Cleveland Swaps Teenage Athlete for Pitching Depth in Hu
The Cleveland Indians have once again traded away a malleable, athletic member of their talented group of AZL players in exchange for a player who can help them in 2019.
Cleveland gets:
RHP Chih-Wei Hu
Tampa Bay gets:
INF Gionti Turner
Turner was a 27th rounder in the 2018 draft and has already been flipped for a big leaguer. He wasn’t a Division-I commit, and was instead headed from Watson Chapel High School in Pine Bluff, Arkansas to Three Rivers Community College in Poplar Bluff, Missouri (different tree, still lyin’). But Cleveland signed him and he came to Arizona instead, where he managed to stand out amid many talented Cleveland teenagers. He hit .296/.348/.396 as a 17-year-old in the AZL while playing second base, shortstop, and center field.
Indeed, a multi-positional utility role is the most likely positive outcome for Turner. Lean and long-limbed, he struggles to swing the bat with any authority right now and may never have an offensive profile that fits in a lineup every day. Like many Cleveland high school draftees, Turner is extremely young for his graduating class; he didn’t turn 18 until mid-August. It’s possible that he’ll grow into relevant strength, but he’s already quite behind in that regard.
But Turner has plus speed, and a gritty, max-effort style of play, and he’s a plus-plus athlete. A lack of arm strength may limit him to the outfield and second base, but this is exactly the kind of athlete who can become an above-average defender all over the field.
25-year-old Taiwanese righty Chih-Wei Hu was a 2016 Futures Game participant and his stuff that day was as nasty as any pitcher at the event, as he sat 94-97 with a plus-plus, mid-80s changeup that seemed to disappear entirely as it approached the plate.
Hu’s five-pitch repertoire hasn’t truly been on display in his limited big league appearances, all of which have come out of the bullpen. His stuff has ticked down a bit; his fastball now sits in the 91-94 range and will touch 95, and his goofy, upper-80s palmball changeup has screwball action and is his best shot at missing big league bats. Hu also has an upper-80s slider/cutter and a low-80s knuckle curve, both of which he needs to locate in order to be effective because they’re very hittable if left in the strike zone.
Essentially, Hu has backend starter stuff but it’s possible a full-time move to the bullpen will enable his fastball to play up. If armed with a plus fastball and that weirdo changeup, Hu could be a high-leverage reliever. He still has an option year left and will likely open 2019 as a starter at Triple-A.
Eric Longenhagen is from Catasauqua, PA and currently lives in Tempe, AZ. He spent four years working for the Phillies Triple-A affiliate, two with Baseball Info Solutions and two contributing to prospect coverage at ESPN.com. Previous work can also be found at Sports On Earth, CrashburnAlley and Prospect Insider.


I like it. We need RP’s not 17-year old IF’s right now as our window will most likely slam shut after 2020.
Haven’t delved into why Hu hasn’t crossed the border of major league success, but the Indians have found success with RP with less pedigree. Shrewd move at a quick glance. Well-rounded athletes, you say? I say Quinton Holmes. Where is he nowadays? Give me the closer prospect any day, especially if you trust your minor league development dept.
Turner has a bit of a Willy Mays Hayes flourish on his finish
“…and a gritty, max-effort style of play…”
Next you’ll say white guys can be athletic and have good baseball instincts.
What?
Really like the trade for the Indians. The kind of opportunistic 40 roster trade I was hoping for. Maybe they can swing one more for Joe McCarthy.
Surprised that the Rays didn’t get better offers for Hu
I hope they keep McCarthy. No idea why they would want Heredia over McCarthy as the 5th OF. And McCarthy can play 1b too, which Bauers hasn’t locked down yet in my mind.
Surprised the Rays didn’t keep Hu. Since he has an option, he’s exactly the type of up-and-down arm who could start or relieve that they look for
Cleveland wants to deal. I keep looking at the White Sox and thinking about why they don’t just take on e.e and Jason kipnis contracts and buy a really good prospect, incude Nate Jones and/ or Jose abreu. I love rocchio, Jones and McKenzie in the tribes system. If you can get 1 or 2 of those guys and a guy your high on, then take that money on in the last year of your rebuild. You got boegarts, arenado, Cole, sale, and wheeler to throw your money at next year.
With Dave Stewart out of the league, no GM will give up Top 200 prospects to dump a salary. Maybe an out-of-options FV45 like the Royals got in Trevor Oaks from the Dodgers last year, but not guys like Jones and McKenzie. Cleveland could trade those for actual good players on low salaries if they wanted to.
Why does Tampa Bay agree to part with this guy? Did they simply just not have a spot on the 40-man for him?
They do need 5-6 spots unless they plan on letting Joe McCarthy or Kean Wong be drafted.
But they didn’t seem to be very impressed with Hu. They would call him up for a weekend, not use him, and send him back down. They’d give innings to pretty bad relievers while he repeated AAA. They didn’t bring him up in September, while they were still hoping for a wild card. It’s been clear for a year that they didn’t like him. I can’t tell you why.
Chih-Wei needs to play first base, just once…
i’ll settle for him drawing a walk, but even that’ll be tricky in the AL
Longenhagen, the next time you’re up for any kind of blogging award/public office, I will vote for you based entirely on that double-layer joke in the second paragraph.
Can somebody explain that one to me?
Pine and Poplar are both trees.
A bluff is pretending you have something that you don’t.