Dallas Keuchel Heads to Atlanta

The Atlanta Braves and Dallas Keuchel agreed to terms on a contract Thursday night, thus ending baseball’s short free agency burst following the conclusion of the MLB Draft. Keuchel’s one-year, $13 million deal will enable him to enter the free agent market after the 2019 season with a clean slate, without any qualifying offer compensation pick baggage to reduce his value to a new team (or offer an excuse not to sign him).

We’ve seen this short-term playbook before from the Braves before, so it’s unsurprising to see them commit to a one-year (in reality, four-month) contract for Keuchel. The offseason in Atlanta was quieter than expected, with the team — or more accurately Liberty Media, the ownership group — choosing not to try to splash cash in the direction of Manny Machado or Bryce Harper like some of the other Johnny-come-soonlys in baseball. The only significant signing the team made was a one-year deal with Josh Donaldson for $23 million.

The $13 million is $13 million straight-up, something that shouldn’t necessarily be taken for granted as these types of midseason contracts tend to be a bit strange. For example, when Roger Clemens signed a one-year contract worth $28,000,022 (the beer money at the end to match his uniform number), that figure represented what it would’ve been over an entire season; Clemens only made a little under $20 million, with the money starting to flow when he made his season debut for the Yankees in June.

The reasons the Braves signed Keuchel to a short-term contract are similar to those behind their Donaldson deal: the team has a very deep stable of prospects and doesn’t necessarily want to commit to Keuchel long-term any more than they wanted to with Donaldson.The long-term solution at third base was always Austin Riley, but with the team coming off an NL East crown and still very likely to be just as competitive in 2019, they wanted a safer short-term option. Enter Donaldson The exact pitcher for whom Keuchel is keeping a seat warm is unclear, but the Braves have enough interesting candidates that the assumption is the question will work itself out over time.

The issue for Atlanta was that that question was not working itself out as quickly as the team hoped. The Braves starters have combined for a 4.38 ERA (19th in MLB) and 3.6 WAR (also 19th) and while those numbers aren’t the worst among 2019’s contenders, the rotation clearly has not been enough of a positive asset. And obviously, this matters quite a bit, with the Braves looking up at the Phillies in the NL East by a two-game margin. Atlanta’s rotation as of this moment has more question marks than they did at the start of the season.

Kyle Wright, Sean Newcomb, Bryse Wilson, and Touki Toussaint have all had brief stints in the rotation, with all four losing those jobs quickly (the latter two after their first starts). You can make a pretty good argument that the Braves have perhaps been a bit impatient with some of these pitchers, but it’s hard to blame the team for their urgency.

Perhaps more rope would have been given if Mike Foltynewicz and Kevin Gasuman were meeting expectations.

Folty’s spring was marred by elbow problems and while his health doesn’t appear to be a question, his velocity and his slider have been. His velocity has recovered, with his fastball in recent starts in the 95-96 mph range, much closer to the 96-97 mph he showed throughout 2018 than the 93-95 he initially came back with in late April. But the slider is still missing bite and that’s a crucial pitch in his repertoire. The former Astro’s breakout 2018 was mostly due to his slider, which ranked fourth in our pitch values, behind only those of Patrick Corbin, Jhoulys Chacin, and Miles Mikolas. Batters only hit .106 against his sliders last year and only mustered a .183 slugging percentage. In just over a month of pitching, he’s allowed almost as many extra-base hits on sliders (9) as he did in all of 2018 (11). And looking at his Statcast data, he’s lost three inches of vertical movement and two inches of horizontal movement from last season.

Kevin Gausman’s ERA remains above six, a disturbingly high number considering that we’re now in June. Given that his FIP is a much better 4.03, Gausman’s poor bottom-line run prevention has some mitigating factors, including a .331 BABIP and a bullpen that hasn’t had his back (58% LOB compared to 72% league-average). But as with the Braves’ lack of patience with the young pitchers hitting roadblocks, Atlanta just doesn’t have the time to hang around and hope that Gausman turns his theoretical run-prevention back into actual run-prevention. Gausman’s done himself no favors by narrowing of his repertoire; he’s essentially been a fastball/splitter-only pitcher in 2019, with his slurve largely abandoned. He’ll likely end up in the bullpen for now, which may be a better fit for a two-pitch hurler still missing his former high-end heat.

Under the set of circumstances Atlanta is facing, not only is Keuchel a good signing, but the terms make it one of the best potential buys this year. It’s still strange to call $13 million nothing, but in terms of major league free agency, these are nanoscopic potatoes. You can’t spend as much as you want on amateur free agents or draft picks. You don’t have an unlimited supply of prospects to trade for short-term gains. But you can spend all you want on free agents, with the only limitation being the luxury tax threshold, which is still a softer roadblock than the severe penalties for overspending on other avenues of talent acquisition. That’s not a problem for the Braves, who could sign James Shields to a one-year, $50 million deal and still be short of the Danger Zone. (Warning: You should probably not sign James Shields for one year and $50 million.)

Having the opportunity to sign a legitimate free agent in midseason is pretty rare, but Keuchel’s unusual market afforded the Braves the chance to add a player who might not have seemed necessary for the team in January, but who addresses an obvious need now. One remaining question, perhaps one left unanswered and lost in time: did the Braves need to wait this long to sign Keuchel? After all, given how quickly they cycled through the pitching prospects, the team certainly understood how urgent the rotation issue was. It may not have been obvious in March, but the weakness was apparent certainly by mid-April. In terms of free-agent compensation, Craig Edwards estimated that signing Keuchel would have an additional cost of $4.7 million for Atlanta, hardly a crippling loss. What part of this late signing was the draft pick value (or a more general reluctance to spend on free agents) and what part was Keuchel and his agent preferring to have more teams in the bidding such as the Yankees ($10.6 million loss), Cardinals ($7.4 million), or the Cubs ($6.8 million)? If only houseflies on walls had tape recorders, or whatever the kids are calling those today.

ZiPS has been more of a fan of Keuchel, at least in 2019, than the other projection systems, so it’s unsurprising it gave a digital thumbs-up to this signing to go along with my analog one. The penalty used for his missing time is relatively tame as there’s no injury involved, and most players out voluntarily don’t return in as brutally an inept fashion as Kendrys Morales did after ending his 2014 hiatus. That history doesn’t suggest a huge penalty is hardly surprising, as most players don’t use that time sitting around eating cookies, playing video games, and watching reruns of Press Your Luck. Even I don’t eat that many cookies working at home in a decidedly non-athletic capacity.

ZiPS projects a 116 ERA+ and 1.6 WAR for Keuchel with the assumption that he needs a few weeks to be ready to pitch in a major league game. Atlanta will take that and honestly, probably be happy with less. Because if you’re not using money to sign Keuchel, your other options for signing pitchers using just money are Shields or Yovani Gallardo or Miguel Gonzalez, and so on. Keuchel adds just a hair over a win compared to the likely other options and in the NL East, that win might actually matter.

ZiPS Projected Standings, 6/7/19 (Pre-Keuchel)
Team W L GB PCT Div% WC% Playoff % WS Win% No. 1 Pick Avg Draft Pos.
Atlanta Braves 88 74 — .543 51.1% 21.7% 72.8% 4.2% 0.0% 21.2
Washington Nationals 85 77 3 .525 22.9% 24.4% 47.3% 2.1% 0.0% 18.7
Philadelphia Phillies 85 77 3 .525 20.8% 23.6% 44.3% 1.9% 0.0% 18.4
New York Mets 80 82 8 .494 5.2% 10.1% 15.3% 0.5% 0.0% 14.9
Miami Marlins 59 103 29 .364 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 22.8% 2.3

ZiPS Projected Standings, 6/7/19 (Post-Keuchel)
Team W L GB PCT Div% WC% Playoff % WS Win% No. 1 Pick Avg Draft Pos.
Atlanta Braves 89 73 — .549 60.1% 20.4% 80.6% 5.1% 0.0% 22.1
Washington Nationals 85 77 4 .525 18.8% 26.6% 45.3% 1.9% 0.0% 18.6
Philadelphia Phillies 85 77 4 .525 17.0% 25.5% 42.6% 1.7% 0.0% 18.3
New York Mets 80 82 9 .494 4.1% 10.2% 14.2% 0.5% 0.0% 14.8
Miami Marlins 58 104 31 .358 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 23.6% 2.3

Is adding a Keuchel a giant, season-changing move? Of course not, but those are more or less unicorns; situations like the Giants picking up Randy Winn midseason and getting 3.6 WAR in 58 games are highly unusual. From the projections, the Braves have turned about 20% of the scenarios in which they don’t win the NL East into NL East titles, and erased about 30% of their non-playoff finishes from the timeline. Without trading prospects or developing time travel technology, the Braves made as good an acquisition as you realistically can make in June. Of course, we could have said the same thing in May.





Dan Szymborski is a senior writer for FanGraphs and the developer of the ZiPS projection system. He was a writer for ESPN.com from 2010-2018, a regular guest on a number of radio shows and podcasts, and a voting BBWAA member. He also maintains a terrible Twitter account at @DSzymborski.

46 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
YRueyYen
7 years ago

I see this deal working out much better than the $12.5 million to an old Bartolo Colon few years ago (yeah, the Braves weren’t competitive then AND the free agent market was friendlier to old pitchers as well).

Original Greaser Bob
7 years ago

This is great, unlike the excrement Edwards smeared all over the pages yesterday. Reminds me of when Fangraphs was about analysis not narrative (and whatever Ring is getting paid to do).

Cave Dameron
7 years ago

Okay but tell us how you really feel.

Charles Bengal TigerMember since 2017
7 years ago

I can remember when I never would see comments by you. That for me was my favorite Fangraphs epoch. I’m sure there are plenty of Yahoo! comment sections where you can post about “How things used to be” and rail against wokeness.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

I am not sure I would be so quick to send Gausman to the bullpen. Aside from Gasuman’s FIP being well below his ERA, Foltynewicz still looks awful; I would at least consider optioning him to see if he can figure out his slider, or give him a break, or something.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

And as far as the Braves needing another starter, even if Keuchel was willing to negotiate earlier rather than wait (something which is potentially untrue, as Dan alludes to), I don’t know that they thought they needed him a month ago. Gio Gonzalez was available starting on April 22nd, and they didn’t seem to show much interest there, so it is pretty clear they didn’t think they needed help then. You can make the argument that as of May 10th or so they should have known they needed help, since Rian wrote an article about them needing help on May 13th, but at that point it is hard to argue they should have given up a draft pick for an extra four starts. It seems to me that part of their problem was that they weren’t suitors for Gio and they absolutely should have been, but if you think the decision on Gio was reasonable then you have to argue that something changed in the next 2-3 weeks to make it obvious they needed Keuchel.

Richie
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

This. Thisthisthis. Absolutely nuts to give up the draft choice and the extra cash for a handful of starts. Once you decide against giving Keuchel massive money for his desired multi-year contract, the only other non-idiotic option is to wait till this point.

Jetsy Extrano
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Can we see the playoff% estimates for the hypothetical of signing him back then? And see if the delta from this signing is worth the value of the draft pick. My gut says it can’t possibly be, but we can do better than my gut.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Jetsy Extrano

Dan can obviously give a more accurate breakdown than that, including how it actually impacts his simulations.

But if Dan is projecting that Keuchel adds a bit more than a full win in half a season in his projections, we could just calculate out how much 4 starts (or about 1/8th of the season, or 1/4 of half the season) would add. That starts looking a bit like 0.3 wins, which, when benchmarked to Craig’s $9M figure (which is what he uses to calculate Atlanta would lose $4.7M) that’s something like $3M.

In other words, Keuchel adds literally costs more in value for those four starts than the value of the pick the Braves lose ($4.7M), even before you calculate what you’re paying him.

DDMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Even if they wanted Keuchel in May, they should have (and maybe did) make offers to him for LESS than he got now, since there was less competition for his services. Of course, he was likely holding out for what he felt he was worth, and was only going to get close to that after the draft.

emh1969
7 years ago

I realize the Indians don’t have a great chance of catching the Twins. But there are still 100 games left and the two Wild Card spots. So making the playoffs is still a possibility for them.

Meanwhile 3 of their 5 starters are on the DL. And one of the guys who stepped in to replace Kluber/Carrasco/Clevinger is on the DL. Which leaves them with a rotation of Bauer, Bueber, and Zach Plesac (who started the year at AA and has 2 career ML starts). Clevinger did make a rehab start last night but did not look good so hard to say when he’ll be back.

So you’re telling me the Indians couldn’t/wouldn’t outbid the Braves for Keuchel? I honestly feel like management has given up at this point…

MikeMember since 2018
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

At this point? Cleveland didn’t even extend a qualifying offer to Michael Brantley. The same Michael Brantley projected to accumulate almost 4.0 WAR this year and over 2.0 WAR next year. Cleveland’s management gave up months and months ago.

emh1969
7 years ago
Reply to  Mike

Perhaps but there is a difference between giving a multi-year deal to a guy with an extensive injury history and giving a one-year deal to a guy with very little injury history.

Fun-Hating DorkMember since 2019
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

A qualifying offer is only a one-year deal.

emh1969
7 years ago

Yeah, I didn’t read Mike’s comment closely enough. But since Brantley wasn’t going to sign a qualifying offer I’m not sure it’s really relevant to what they could or should have done relative to Keuchel.

Richie
7 years ago
Reply to  emh1969

I agree that it was a no-brainer to extend the qualifying offer. Which if they were fully certain Brantley wasn’t going to accept they then would’ve done so. But yes, there was some risk of Brantley getting no multi-year offers, and then accepting it. And Cleveland management clearly has gotten an order from ownership “here’s your budget, and Do NOT! Go Over It Or ELSE!!!”

Mike NMN
7 years ago

Good presentation. What no one knows, of course, is what type of offers were actually made to Keuchel in either the offseason or early Spring. Presumably, it took the reality of not having one’s price even approached before Keuchel was willing to consider (or had no choice to consider) this offer. Braves may only have been able to get him because things approached this stage. You really are shooting at a moving target–teams’s overall budgets, whether they fill needs differently, CBT, how much reserves they need for last minute trades. No one just waits for a Keuchel to drop into their laps.

TheGarrettCooperFanClub
7 years ago
Reply to  Mike NMN

well, the reported astros offer of one year for the qualifying amount before the season started is really all thats known, and i think its obvious that would have been the better move for DK but he might have been holding out for a multi year deal still at that point.

baubo
7 years ago

The Astros were reported to have offered 3/45 at the beginning of the offseason and 1/15 later. The asking price (yes I know asking price is always inflated) was 6-7 years at 20-30mil per year.

It’s pretty clear there was a big gap here between teams and Keuchel. It’s not like there weren’t other big money starter signings. Corbin, Morton, Evaldi, Happ all constitutes kind of a range of pitchers you can group Keuchel with. And other than Corbin everyone else had roughly 16mil/yr type contract.

Mike NMN
7 years ago
Reply to  baubo

I suspect that Boras was trying to sell a Cy Young winner, when the teams were seeing a solid #3.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  baubo

I am pretty sure that if Eovaldi got $68M guaranteed, that Keuchel could have too. Pretty much everyone thought Eovaldi was the third best option on the market, with Keuchel being #2.

So, somewhere between that and the $100M which was the lowest part of the 5-6 years at $20M/$30M range that was mentioned? $65M to $100M?

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago

This is nitpicky, but Bryce Wilson didn’t lose his spot in the rotation. His was a spot start and he wasn’t intended to stay in the rotation. Wilson has never performed well at AAA, and his promotion to that level was aggressive considering his AA tenure (short, good not great).

This has nothing to do with the article, I realize. The Braves more mature pitching prospects have been predictably disappointing if that is possible. You’re just not going to normally find 3-4 guys ready to break into starting big league roles all at once.

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago
Reply to  Dan Szymborski

That’s fair, and I agree, but still a bit different than the other three. And it was very unlikely that he would pitch really well because he’s clearly not ready for the big leagues if he can’t handle AAA.

mookie monster
7 years ago

So what lessons should Keuchel take away from this? He held out for a big contract and clearly didn’t get it. Does he try again next year? Did he overvalue himself? Is this outcome ok with him?

cowdiscipleMember since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  mookie monster

It definitely seems from what was reported that he overvalued himself and didn’t back off his demand before teams had moved on. Neither he nor Kimbrel were ever going to get both the years and AAV they reportedly were asking for. I mean, no harm in asking, but they should’ve dialed back their asks in January instead of at the end of spring training.

Richie
7 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

If you figure a pitcher only has so many arm bullets, if you will, maybe they figure time missed now simply means an extra 3 months now added on at the end.

mookie monster
7 years ago
Reply to  Richie

This is interesting, and I keep coming back to something similar… maybe they’re looking at it not as $$/year but more like $$/pitch thrown.

Maybe pitchers are coming to view the wear and tear on their bodies like NFL players and Keuchel is taking a page out of the LaVeon Bell playbook… if you’ve only got so many good years/innings/pitches in you, don’t burn them for anything less than your price.

rhdx
7 years ago
Reply to  mookie monster

Maybe, but it seems really clear that Bell cost himself money.

mookie monster
7 years ago
Reply to  cowdisciple

That’s my instinct, too, but they held out for so long, when it was so clear they weren’t going to get the deals, that I feel like I must be missing something. At least Kimbrel got his multiyear deal, but Keuchel is going to be in exactly the same position next winter, only one year older and with a smaller body of work this year to convince teams of his value.

TerryMc
7 years ago
Reply to  mookie monster

There will be no qualifying offer/loss of draft pick attached next year though. Signing teams will only be spending cash.

Antonio BananasMember since 2016
7 years ago

This is a great signing for ATL. Maybe Keuchel provides some leadership the young pitchers need as well. Like an overlapping affect.

I still think they need another SP and RP. What would it take for Hand and/or Bauer if they become available?

Shalesh
7 years ago

In 2014, 1.5 years of Samardzija went for top-5 prospect Addison Russell. In 2016, 2.5 years of Andrew Miller went for top-40 Clint Frazier and top-100 Justus Sheffield. So maybe Cristian Pache for Bauer and Ian Anderson or Kyle Wright plus Joey Wentz for Hand.

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

2014 was a long time ago. I doubt very seriously Pache is on the table for almost any 1.5 year player. The Hand deal presented seems reasonable. No sure things on either side, but big upside.

CC AFCMember since 2016
7 years ago

This is all well and good, but we’re ducking the real issue here: did the Yankees grooming policy play a role in Keuchel going to Atlanta or not?

BMac
7 years ago
Reply to  CC AFC

I hope so!

3cardmontyMember since 2020
7 years ago

An 8% bump in playoff odds from the addition of one player kind of seems like a “giant, season-changing move” to me. Does your system routinely show higher increases for other midseason acquisitions?

Richie
7 years ago
Reply to  Dan Szymborski

I don’t get this. Meaning that the “mass market” thinks a half-season of Keuchel gives them an 8% bump, but it’s really less than that?

rhdx
7 years ago
Reply to  Dan Szymborski

To some people it will depend on the starting point. Some people may view going from 90% to 98% differently than 45% to 53%. Most people view 90% as all but certain already.

Number20
7 years ago

I wonder how many starts ZiPS assumes Keuchel will get? Joe Madden believes Kimbrel should be ready in about three weeks. (Kimbrel thinks more like two) Usually, starters take longer to stretch out and there are more opportunities to ease relievers into pitching roles as well. I’m guessing 15?

Interesting dynamics with free agent starting pitchers, who have long preparation times, that both make them poor pick-ups for immediate needs when a starting pitcher goes down, but also pushes them into competition with mid-season trade alternatives once teams have sorted themselves out btw/ contenders and non-.

DH
7 years ago

Bottom line takeaway from the tables: in August, Keuchel will win a game against the marlins that the Braves would have otherwise lost.

bosoxforlifeMember since 2016
7 years ago

Where in the article is the name of the most important pitcher on the Braves staff mentioned. I am, of course, speaking of their 21 year old wunderkind, Mike Soroka. Hyun-Jin Ryu is getting all the press but Soroka has been even better. Snitker let him go into the 9th tonight after 8 innings of 3 hit, 0 run ball, and for that Snitker will be drummed out of the game for breaking all the rules and allowing a 21 year old to pitch into the 9th. In 10 starts Soroka has given up 10 earned runs. It is not Soroka, individually, that caused Anthopoulos to be so hesitant in trading this winter, it is the very correct fear of dealing the wrong pitcher then being tarred and feathered as he is escorted out of Atlanta. The Braves have to give all of these exciting young pitching prospects a chance to see who else might be ready to step up. Until they can sort them out, signing Keuchel to a short term deal is a smart move.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
7 years ago

Awesome move. Not only does it strengthen our rotation, but it lengthens our bullpen as well. We’ve got guys (Folty, Touki, Gausman, etc.) who are capable of starting but are likely more effective as bullpens arms for now. It’s important that we didn’t give up any prospects to sign Keuchel either. I imagine that this allows us to continue to develop our young arms and then potentially use them to acquire an impact player in July or the off-season. Donaldson and Keuch will be gone after this year, but we can plug in guys and barely lose any value. I’m very happy with the enviable position we’re in as an organization.