Dallas Keuchel’s Wait Is Over, and the White Sox Are Going for It

After the last couple of winters in which seemingly fine candidates for substantial multi-year deals were forced to settle for one-year contracts, this offseason has seen those same players finally land the kind of commitments they always seemed deserving of. Mike Moustakas signed a four-year, $64-million deal with the Reds after signing back-to-back one-year deals in Kansas City and Milwaukee. Yasmani Grandal signed a four-year, $73-million contract with the White Sox after taking just a one-year deal with the Brewers the previous season. And after health concerns limited Josh Donaldson to a one-year deal a year ago, he seems poised to collect a hefty payday as the best remaining bat available on the market this winter.

On Saturday, another player previously abandoned by the market finally landed his own multi-year deal. The White Sox signed former Braves and Astros left-hander Dallas Keuchel, as first reported by ESPN’s Jeff Passan. MLB Network’s Jon Heyman was first to report the terms of the deal:

Keuchel, 31, was one of the longest hold-outs in free agency last year, as he and formidable closer Craig Kimbrel each waited until June 7 — two days after the conclusion of the amateur draft, when draft pick compensation was no longer attached to them — to sign a contract. While Kimbrel received three years and $43 million in his deal with the Cubs, Keuchel signed just a one-year, $13-million deal with the Braves. In Atlanta, he was part of a starting rotation that finished sixth in the National League in WAR while guiding the team to a second-straight NL East title before bowing out to the St. Louis Cardinals in the NLDS.

In Chicago, Keuchel will join a pitching staff that found some star potential at the top of the rotation in 2019, and has spent the offseason on the hunt for depth. Lucas Giolito was worth 5.1 WAR in 29 starts in a breakout season where he emerged as the staff ace, but the rest of the starting group was rather weak. Reynaldo López carried a FIP- of 108 for the second-straight year, while No. 3 starter Iván Nova wasn’t much better, with a FIP- of 107. Nova is a free agent now, while Tommy John surgeries have made Carlos Rodón and top prospect Michael Kopech’s 2020 seasons fairly unpredictable, so Chicago entered this offseason in serious need of arms.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

The White Sox took their first step toward addressing that need with a signing of Gio Gonzalez on Thursday for one year and $5 million, and waded back into the pool of left-handers to pick up Keuchel two days later. It will be interesting to see what effect — if any — a normal offseason has on Keuchel, who had a rather up-and-down 2019 after waiting until June 21 to make his first start of the season. As I wrote back on September 13, Keuchel settled into one of the best runs of his career down the stretch for Atlanta, thanks in part to getting tons of groundballs again. By the end of the year, he led all pitchers with at least 100 innings in groundball rate at 60.1%, his highest mark since 2015.

But that six-game stretch of brilliance late in the summer was bookended by more troublesome outings. The five starts before it saw Keuchel carry an ERA of 6.83, and over the three starts that followed it, he had an ERA of 6.19. Put everything together, and he finished with his worst FIP- (108) since his rookie year in 2012, a direct result of him allowing his highest percentage of walks and homers over that span without any real change in strikeout rate.

The natural question here, then, is what made Keuchel more appealing this year than last year, if he was a year older and coming off a statistically worse season? There wasn’t any velocity spike or tantalizing new spin rate to his stuff when he got to Atlanta, and while he was perfectly serviceable in two playoff appearances, he didn’t perform in a way that would have left any real impression. If a 30-year-old Keuchel coming off a 3.3-WAR season couldn’t secure a multi-year deal, why could a 31-year-old Keuchel get one after a 0.8-WAR season? Could entering this winter without a qualifying offer attached to him really make this much of a difference?

It is possible that Keuchel may have received a similar offer last year around this time, and was simply unwilling to take it. Back in February, it was reported that the southpaw approached teams at the start of last winter with an asking price of $25-$30 million per year for six to seven years. The fact that he had to wait until June to actually sign with a team suggests that no front office believed that to be a reasonable proposition, but whether Keuchel was offered something in the mid-to-high eight-figure range we don’t know. Grandal, for example, was reportedly offered a four-year, $60-million deal by the Mets last year, and turned it down, only to receive a four-year, $73-million contract this year. It’s possible Keuchel similarly put off committing long-term for a year, and increased his total guarantees in the process.

The contract he ultimately secured fell right around what was expected for him this winter. On our Top 50 Free Agents list — Keuchel ranked 12th — Kiley McDaniel anticipated he’d land a deal in the three year, $45-million range. The median crowdsource was closer to the AAV Keuchel landed, estimating a four-year, $70.4-million deal. And Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS was nearly perfect, spitting out a projected $53.4 million value on Keuchel over the next three seasons:

ZiPS Projection – Dallas Keuchel
Year W L ERA G GS IP H HR BB SO ERA+ WAR
2020 11 10 4.20 27 27 162.7 160 22 53 135 105 2.5
2021 10 8 4.25 24 24 144.0 148 19 47 115 104 2.1
2022 9 8 4.32 24 24 141.7 147 20 48 112 102 2.0

What makes Keuchel interesting here is that he is the kind of pitcher whose numbers could vary significantly depending on the players around him. With such high groundball rates, fielding a strong defensive infield behind him is important. Chicago is a bit of feast-or-famine in that regard — its third basemen were third-best in baseball on defense, while its second basemen were eighth-best. It’s shortstops, meanwhile, were second-worst in baseball, and its first basemen were sixth-worst. Yoán Moncada will be back to hold down third base in 2020, but Yolmer Sánchez was relieved of his duties at second thanks to a poor showing with the bat, thrusting Danny Mendick into the projected starting spot at the keystone position until top prospect Nick Madrigal arrives. The way things look at the moment, infield defense could be more of a weakness than a strength for the White Sox in 2020.

The biggest help to Keuchel in Chicago might not be the players behind him, though — it could be the one in front of him. Grandal, the newest catcher for the White Sox, is not only one of baseball’s best offensive backstops, but also one of its best pitch framers. He finished second in the majors in our framing runs (17.0), as well as Statcast’s Runs Extra Strikes (13) and Baseball Prospectus’ framing runs (19.4). Dating back to 2015, no other catcher is even close to Grandal’s 137.2 defensive runs above average. A catcher of Grandal’s caliber undeniably boosts his pitching staff, and a finesse pitcher like Keuchel, who relies on excellent location over swing-and-miss stuff, could benefit more than anyone. In fact, no pitcher in baseball threw a lower percentage of pitches in the strike zone in 2019 than Keuchel’s 33.6%. A catcher who steals more strikes could be enormously helpful to him.

How helpful? Well, last season’s Braves provided us with a good reference. Keuchel’s 112.2 innings in Atlanta were split close to evenly between two catchers: Tyler Flowers and Brian McCann. Flowers, like Grandal, is one of baseball’s very best defensive catchers – he was tied with Grandal in Runs Extra Strikes, and was third in framing runs despite catching hundreds of innings fewer than the other catchers in the top four. McCann, meanwhile, was closer to an average framing catcher in his age-35 season, finishing eighth in Runs Extra Strikes and 19th in framing runs. The sample size isn’t huge, and this sort of comparison is an admittedly crude measure, but the contrast in Keuchel’s numbers when pitching to the two was stark.

Dallas Keuchel Splits by Battery Mate
Catcher IP ERA K/9 BB/9 HR/9
Tyler Flowers 61.1 2.93 8.7 3.7 0.7
Brian McCann 51.1 4.73 5.6 2.5 1.9

McCann caught eight of Keuchel’s first 10 starts, and Flowers caught eight of his final nine. There are a couple of different ways to look at that. Keuchel might have improved as the season went on, and Flowers happened to transition into catching him just as he was settling in. Throwing to Flowers might have also been what triggered Keuchel’s late-summer turnaround, helping him improve enough to make him worth an offer like the one the White Sox extended him.

In a vacuum, I’d probably believe the second option first, and that explanation is further supported by considering where exactly Flowers is best at framing pitches. For a sinkerballer like Keuchel, the best areas of the zone to buy strikes are going to be below the knees, low and in and low and away — areas Statcast identifies as Zones 18, 17 and 19. Turns out, Flowers performed pretty well in those zones in 2019, as did Grandal.

Statcast Framing by Shadow Zone, 2019
Catcher Runs Extra Strikes Strike Rate Zone 11 Zone 12 Zone 13 Zone 14 Zone 16 Zone 17 Zone 18 Zone 19
Tyler Flowers 13 52.8% 22.1% 53.6% 11.7% 64.5% 67.4% 35.7% 62.1% 35.9%
Brian McCann 8 49.7% 21.1% 41.4% 17.0% 74.4% 64.2% 41.8% 49.1% 24.2%
Yasmani Grandal 13 51.1% 19.3% 51.5% 30.9% 58.4% 72.4% 32.1% 56.2% 31.4%

Whatever led Chicago and other teams to be more aggressive in pursuing Keuchel this time around, they’re irrelevant now. The White Sox have him, and that fact alone is a signal that the team is serious about its intentions to chase down the AL Central this year. They indicated their desire to accelerate their rebuild last year when they got involved in the Manny Machado sweepstakes, and they were one of the first teams to spend serious money this winter when they signed Grandal. Two starting pitcher signings and a trade for outfielder Nomar Mazara later, they’re still hard at work improving the team. It would be a stretch at this juncture to say they’re a real contender to topple the Twins for the division crown — our Depth Charts project them to have the 16th-most WAR in baseball — but with two AL Central rivals planning to be punching bags in 2020 and a third apparently working hard to join them, who knows how easy it could be to stack up wins in this division and bolster a Wild Card chase. While Keuchel was waiting to sign last winter, he said it was important to him that he went to a contender. With some more action this winter and the graduation of a couple of key prospects, the White Sox could end up closer to that status than they were when the winter began.





Tony is a contributor for FanGraphs. He began writing for Red Reporter in 2016, and has also covered prep sports for the Times West Virginian and college sports for Ohio University's The Post. He can be found on Twitter at @_TonyWolfe_.

115 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Theo Epstein
6 years ago

I hate my boss.

Anthony Princeton
6 years ago
Reply to  Theo Epstein

Theo, you guaranteed Darvish, Lester, Chatwood, Hendricks and Kimbrel almost $420m and traded Cease and Eloy because in large part you can’t develop a single pitcher of note. That isn’t your owners fault big guy.

baubo
6 years ago

Quite surprising that this is the same front office that once got Hendricks and Arrieta for nearly nothing. In retrospect those feel like they just got lucky instead of being smarter than everyone else like we felt at the time

Original Greaser Bob
6 years ago
Reply to  baubo

Arm chair GM. Yeah!

shadowmoses
6 years ago
Reply to  baubo

Reading an in-depth profile on Epstein years ago, I had gotten the impression that he was one of those guys who was ahead of the curve compared to the rest of the league. I figured he was going to be one of the better GMs in the game for years to come.

Oops. Lol.

scotch pilgrim
6 years ago

There’s no complaints about the Lester deal, IMO. Hendricks’s deal might be an absolute steal. Darvish was much better last year than his injury filled first year, but still a lot of time/money left on that one before we know where it sits. The Chatwood and Kimbrel deals – the 2 cheapest of the bunch – have been bad (though Kimbrel could rebound).

Long story short, I have no idea why the Cubs would/should have been in a Keuchel or what the other deals have to do with why they shouldn’t/weren’t in on this deal.

Anthony Princeton
6 years ago
Reply to  scotch pilgrim

The Cubs have not replaced Hamels and their window is closing primarily due to the lack of young, quality pitching and the fact most of the young core are approaching free agency at the same time. The relief pitching is thin plus Quintana is a free agent after 2020. So is Chatwood but that is a good thing.

Another interesting note is that the Cubs were the only team in MLB that didn’t have a starting pitcher under the age of 29 record a win in 2019.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  scotch pilgrim

Do you really think the jury is still out on the Darvish deal? He’s 33 years old and his stuff is already diminished. He might provide value this year, but there are still 3 more years left after that.

Garys of OldeMember since 2016
6 years ago
Reply to  scotch pilgrim

There cannot be a White Sox story without mention of the Cubs. Unwritten rule of the South Side.

Theo Epstein
6 years ago

Hey there, the Lester deal worked out great. Hendricks seems to be on pace to work out too. The jury will be out on Darvish this year. Kimbrel was a hall of famer and best pitcher of the decade until he became a Cubs. And Chatwood… Well, cant win ’em all…

Brad
6 years ago
Reply to  Theo Epstein

I love Cubs/Red Sox commentary on a White Sox signing. Oh wait no I don’t

Original Greaser Bob
6 years ago
Reply to  Brad

Second team. Dems da breaks

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  Brad

Unsurprising to see related items get discussed when important dominos move in the market, and the Red Sox (w/ Price to TOR rumors) were an important part of the discussion prior to Keuchel/Ryu signing within a few hours of each other; it isn’t that surprising for them to come up.

Garys of OldeMember since 2016
6 years ago
Reply to  Brad

Considering that White Sox fans chant about the Cubs whenever they go deep in the playoffs, it isn’t surprising they came up.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago

In regards to the infield defense piece, I don’t think the Sox would be worse off this year than last. By all accounts, Anderson has the talent to be better than what he was last year – he has very good defensive stretches and a very good season in the past. He’s still young and was always raw at the position. Moncada was excellent in his first season at third, and while Sanchez was a gold glover I think it’s safe to say that Madrigal is not any worse defensively than Sanchez.

With continued growth and comfort from Moncada, and faith in Madrigal, it really all comes down to TA. If he showed baseball anything last year it’s that you shouldn’t count the guy out. It wouldn’t be shocking to see him return to his 2018 defensive production – if not better.

scotch pilgrim
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

I think it’s far from safe to say that a prospect isn’t any worse than a guy who’s already demonstrated he’s a plus there in the bigs.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  scotch pilgrim

Madrigal is regarded as one of the best defenders in the minor leagues. His Steamer projections are better than Yolmers so I don’t think it’s crazy to assume that at all.

FrancoLuvHateMets
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

I used to think that way too until the last 3-4 years seeing Mets prospects who field nothing like their scouting reports said they would.

Connor Grey
6 years ago

@FrancoLuvHateMets I couldn’t agree more. Seeing just how incredibly wrong the scouts were about Conforto, Rosario, and Alonso’s defense has made me take defensive scouting reports with a grain of salt.

In Conforto’s case, I saw him play a really good left field multiple times when he was in Double A back in 2015, so it’s not even like he made changes once he got to the majors that made the scouts look bad.

carterMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

What do you mean on the Conforto part? That his defense is good, or that it is bad? He has been a positive in the field over the years as long as he is not in CF. Obviously he cannot play CF. Alonso still isn’t a good defender. I think minor league scouting reports inherently are stupid/racist. I doubt they intentionally do that, just that a lot of the scouts are often the old guard. Read what Marcus Stroman said his comps were coming up. It is the same for defense, latinos are often said to “look the part”. White guys are always given a “filled out, might have to move to a corner”. It is lazy, and often inaccurate. Think about the speed grades on guys like Zimmer (fastest runner in MLB 2 years ago) where he is said to likely have to move to a corner.

Connor Grey
6 years ago
Reply to  carter

@carter I meant that Conforto is a good defender. Scouts were saying he was a liability in the outfield when he was drafted and continued to say he was a terrible defender while he was coming up in the minors. My untrained eye saw him make some impressive plays as a left fielder in the minor leagues and he looked exactly the same playing the outfield in the majors.

oozyalbies1
6 years ago
Reply to  Connor Grey

He’s reckless

shadowmoses
6 years ago
Reply to  scotch pilgrim

Amed Rosario nods in agreement (granted, he was much better defensively down the stretch).

carterMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

When Madrigal is ready where does Tim Anderson move to? -3.7 for SS certainly isn’t good, but it isn’t like he needs to be moved off the position. Could he bump Garcia if his bat doesn’t get going?

carterMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  carter

I’m an idiot

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago

The White Sox: Now clearly projected to win more games than they lose!

There’s more than a trace of a winner’s curse about this one as well, and I do have some concerns about Anderson’s defense as the author states, but I will hand it to the White Sox: Despite me disagreeing with the entire motivating principle of their offseason, they have been awfully consistent in their goals. They gave a four-year deal to that starts in Yasmani Grandal’s age-31 season, a 3-year deal that starts in Jose Abreu’s age-33 season, and a 3-year deal with a vesting option for year four that starts in Dallas Keuchel’s age-32 season. This is a team that either does not give a damn about what the payroll is going to look like in 2022, or is so desperate to win some games that they don’t care. And they’ll almost certainly win some more games, so, they’ll probably get what they want.

Also, I’ll change my sad-trombone-tune if Cleveland does the unthinkable and deals Lindor and/or Clevinger, which would suddenly blow the division wide open if the Twins have even a slight run of bad luck. And at the minimum, this deal makes more sense than the Blue Jays giving Ryu that four-year deal.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Or, they signed veteran FA’s to contracts that are set to expire when their young and talented core starts getting expensive? This isn’t really rocket science.

The Twins, as of today, have 2 starting pitchers for opening day.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

They signed veteran FA’s who will likely be bad (and the very least, overpaid clogging up the payroll giving them an excuse to not spend money) when their young and talented core is good enough to contend. This also isn’t really rocket science.

And somehow, despite the Twins only have 3 starting pitchers (which also gives them an avenue to improve!) they are still likely about 4-5 games better than the White Sox. I mean, it’s possible to overtake them, because there’s certainly that much variance in the projections, so it’s worth a shot if Cleveland sells and they only have to rely on one team underperforming.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Most every free agent that is signed to a long term deal in this market will be less than good at the end of contracts. The White Sox limited that risk by signing a 3 and 4 year deal only.

Abreu really doesn’t matter for this conversation; but if you think Grandal/Keuchels salary in 2022 is somehow going to prevent this team from adding more IDK what to say. Their payroll is still only sitting around 110 million – they were running around 130 nearly 15 years ago. Expecting them to approach 150-170 during their years of contention isn’t crazy…. meaning that giving 18 million to keuchel and grandal for one year shouldn’t impact their future investments in years 3 and 4.

At some point, the Twins don’t have a lot of options to add – that point may be now. The Sox look like they’re signing EE as well; which should net them another win or two. When you get to a 3 win gap, really anything can happen.

You were saying the Sox had no chance a week ago; now they’re 5 games from divisional favoritism.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

Well, 4-5 games from having a 50/50 shot at the division if Cleveland sells, and 33/67 if they don’t. And that is worth something. So, enjoy it! I disagree with the entire logic of their offseason, but at least it’s consistent and the games will be more fun.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

You’ve disagreed with the entire rebuild, and I’m not sure how anyone can disagree with a roster filling massive holes with steady veteran presence and a high upside RF’er.

I’m not sure what logic you would agree with; Giolito and Moncada aren’t getting any years of control back. The time is now to begin the ascension towards competitiveness.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

Doing your best to extend Giolito and Moncada and splurging on free agents in 2020-2021 and 2021-2022. And since you brought up Mazara, you’re right, I don’t think he’s going to be anything. But he’s pretty much guaranteed to be replacement level unless he faces an army of left-handed pitchers, so, again, at least there will be some better baseball.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

So you can say with certainty what Mazara will be?

That’s interesting, because there are a lot of smart people around baseball who seem to think that he’s still got untapped potential. It’s no guarantee he gets there, but he wouldn’t be the first 25 year old in baseball history to take significant steps forward. Development happens.

The White Sox have no use for extending Giolito or Moncada if they aren’t going to fill their glaring black holes with legitimate MLB players.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

Sad is maybe a little pessimistic but I think there is some truth that the White Sox have the potential risk to end up like the Rockies where they invest their money in mediocrity and end up paying a lot for team whose upside is a few games over .500 unless they are extremely lucky.

It’s far to say that’s what will happen, but it’s definitely within the realm of possibility, and that’s just about the worst place a franchise can end up.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

Yeah, I don’t think that they’ll ever wind up quite like the Rockies. The White Sox have too much high-end talent for them to wind up 15 games below .500. Moncada can and will probably regress a bit; Anderson could turn into a pumpkin; Giolito could tear everything in his arm; and Madrigal, Vaughn, Eloy, Cease, Kopech, and Robert could all bust. The chances that all of those things happen, though? Almost zero.

The more likely scenario is that some of these guys bust or suffer serious injuries, others turn out to be really good, and the arbitration costs for guys like Moncada and Giolito get really high very fast as the old guys fade, leaving them unable to reel in the reinforcements they need to get past the Yankees, Rays, Twins, Astros, etc, topping out as a 90-win team that wins the division a couple of times but can’t get into the ALCS before Giolito and Moncada hit free agency. I don’t know that there’s a perfect analogy among the current crop of teams.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

The Rockies have multiple MVP candidates and still look like that. Would you rather have Robert+Eloy or Arenado+Story? Because Arenado+Story represents a high-end outcome for the Robert/Eloy pairing

But that Rockies contention was built entirely around having no important injuries, and as soon as they stopped having extremely good luck with no one important being injured, they collapsed.

Its a downside case because the prospect base for CWS is stronger than COL, but honestly, I would not be surprised if the 2 best CWS players out of this rebuild never have combined 2-man seasons like 18-19 Story/Arenado (or 17 Arenado+Blackmon).

The Rockies built a stars and scrubs roster with expensive scrubs. That’s probably going to be a good description of age 35 Dallas Keuchel and Jose Abreu, but neither of those contracts alone is crippling. The Rockies have 6 or 7 of them to be in their situation.

carterMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

I agree with both. I like having teams try and be competitive, even when it might not make a ton of sense. There is certainly a lot of risk here with what the White Sox are doing, but if the reports are true this division looks wide open.

Anything can happen in a 162 game season. If the Indians trade either Lindor or Clevinger (looks more likely than not that one, or both is traded this offseason) then the White Sox get to play vs the Tigers and the Royals. The other two teams in their division might not even be much better. Twins are going to mash, but they are going to have to outscore teams to beat them. They have Berrios, Odorozzi and a whole lot of wishing in one hand. With Ryu going to the Blue Jays, signing Keuchel had extra value to them, as they took him away directly from a team in their own division that they are going to be competing with as soon as 2020.

Outside of that I am of the camp that catching might be underrated. A guy who touches the ball on every single play to me is likely the most valuable non pitcher on the field at all times. It doesn’t seem coincidental that teams perform great when Grandal is on the field.

I think the AL Central is wide open, if you get rid of Clevinger the White Sox rotation might not be worse, and that is if you expect anything out of Carrasco (I don’t). The bottom of the White Sox starting line up is a bit weak (Garcia, Mendick) but that isn’t any worse than Bauers and Allen. The Twins obviously have a better offense, but their pitching is piss poor. The White Sox are an Eloy Jimenez (or Mazara being what they thought he was going to be) breakout from winning that division.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  carter

It isn’t clear how any of these contracts hurt them much going forward. Sure, nobody other than Trout is guaranteed production, but Grandal is projected to be well worth the contract, Keuchel is close enough, and unless his option vests will be off the books before the big money years of extensions to current players kick in. And if the option does vest, then it means he was probably a good signing. Gio is signed for 1 year. Abreu for 3 years. None of this has long term cost. Sure, they might extend Moncada or Giolito soon, but the big raises won’t be for 3-4 years. What was the Sox other option? Hope their 8 prospects who had TJ surgery all rebound?

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

Thing is…the Rockies sank a ton more years into guys like Desmond.

The Sox are out on all but one of these guys before they hit 35…and that one is the heart and soul of their team, who can been hidden at DH.

oozyalbies1
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

Won’t say it’s likely, but it’s definitely POSSIBLE that these commitments prevent them from adding more, or at least limit who they add. Two years ago this was widely and vocally regarded as one of the cheapest organizations in baseball.

Their fans should be happy that they’re spending, but they’re certainly going about it in a “dipping their toe in” kind of way. I guess this is progress at least, but would they ever make an actual splash?

I for one will be interested to see how this plays out. In the short term. We’ve been reading the opines of the underpaid veteran for years. The White Sox are sure gonna provide some useful test cases toward identifying if all the hypothesizing and posturing was valid.

gettwobrute79Member since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Keuchel and Yas aren’t bad. Grandal is quite good actually. Also none of the deals they signed are long term. The money on those deals in 2022 isn’t going to prevent them from trying to extend guys like Yoán, Gio, or any of the other guys (Robert, Madrigal, Kopech) who have a decent chance of breaking out. I don’t understand your beef here at all.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  gettwobrute79

Grandal I think is a very good signing because good catching is very rarely available.

I am not entirely sure about Keuchel as it seems like equivalent pitching is easier to find closer to their contention window, however, there is a good case for DK benefitting particularly from the pairing with Yas.

Trotter76Member since 2018
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

“clogging up the payroll giving them an excuse to not spend money”

Are you bemoaning that the Sox opening their wallets is really a ploy to NOT spend money on different free agents in the future? There are many reasons to downvote but this may be the funniest bit of satire.

MikeSMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

They no longer have huge, gaping, holes (once Madrigal and Robert are on the team) except maybe DH, where they should be able to patch things together with Abreu, Jimenez, Collins, Grandal, and others. What they do have are a lot of young players who could bust, but have high upside, and a lack of depth if they have a few injuries.

They are currently projected to be about 5 wins behind the Twins in the division and the A’s for the second wild card and 5 wins is probably within their upside variance, which could allow them to leapfrog all the teams between them and the postseason.

I still don’t think they are quite a playoff team and a lot of things need to break right for them to be one, but they are a lot closer to being one than they were this time last year and if those young players develop then they look like they could be a legitimate contender come 2021. If nothing else, there will be fewer starting pitchers and fewer hitters that I just don’t want to watch because I know they aren’t real MLB ballplayers.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  MikeS

I think this is the crux of it. They’re very clearly no longer “bad.” And that has some value, at least until Reinsdorf cries poor because they’ve committed all kinds of money to veterans who aren’t pulling their weight. Until then? At least there will be some competitive baseball in there.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

When it comes to you, the Sox are damned if they do and damned if they don’t.

That has been the common theme with you, which is fine; you are entitled to your opinion.

At some point though the overly negative outlook you have on the organization should probably expire. You have been hating on the rebuild since the acquisition of Moncada – whom you deemed a sure fire bust whose bat to ball skills would prevent him from stardom. Even throughout last year you were reciting BABIP inflation among others as an excuse for Moncada’s breakout. In general, the White Sox have more variance in their projections than the rest of the teams in the division given the youthful nature of their roster. While that could be a bad thing, it could also mean a universal step forward as an organization towards competitiveness and progress.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

I don’t get called sadtrombone for nothing! Yeah, he was a ridiculously scary prospect. And no, I didn’t call him a surefire bust, just someone who was unlikely to be a star. And I liked Kopech better than him, and by a lot. I still like Kopech, FWIW.

It’s just not worth it for teams to try to spend that much money on players who will immediately get worse when what it does it put them from being five games below .500 to five games above it, and when they actually have a reasonable case of spending that money later. Dan put it well in one of his recaps:
“You also need tempo, to find the best point to punch through the enemy’s defensive line or push your chips or capture a white pawn in a risky fashion… or any other relevant analogy.”

The problem is that unless Reinsdorf is still around and goes full Mike Ilitch–which would be a welcome change of pace–these guys are going to be used as excuses why they shouldn’t spend in 2021, when the team really needs it. The Grandal deal is good enough that it probably doesn’t matter, but the rest of it? It’s only worth it if it’s more important to win 86 games now than 95 games later.

And it might be worth it! But I’d much rather they be in on Paxton, Andrelton Simmons, Marcus Semien, Robbie Ray, George Springer, and (if they can swing it) Mookie Betts next offseason. Or Noah Syndergaard, Michael Conforto, Freddie Freeman, Anthony Rizzo, Javier Baez, Francisco Lindor, Carlos Correa, or Corey Seager the year after that. You can try and argue that this offseason shows that not everyone will take your money, but I’m drawing the opposite lesson here: Guys in their prime don’t want to sign with teams that are this far from competing when the money is similar elsewhere. In 2020 and 2021, all that changes.

The whole point isn’t that I hate the White Sox because it’s something about the White Sox. It’s that I object to the idea that the White Sox are an exception to a larger philosophy about where on the win curve it makes sense to spend.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Well, there’s a massive different between 5 games under and 5 games over; in regards to playoff prospects, that’s a massive swing.

The White Sox, in theory, have spent less total money on these acquisitions than they offered Machado. Unless you thought Machado was the only signing they’d make for a 5 year period, it’s safe to say there’s still money in the bank for another marquee signing if it’s needed. If they think Mazara isn’t good and want to go after Springer, they certainly have the flexibility to do so.

And again, it makes sense to improve your team all the time; regardless of the tank-ladened narrative that has saturated the sports world in the past decade.

The White Sox haven’t had a winning season since 2012! It’s about to be 2020. Do you know how difficult it is for a fanbase to watch and support a team that has lost more than 84 games for 7 straight years? This implication that teams should only spend when they are already great is a terrible narrative.

gettwobrute79Member since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

As a Bucs fan, prior to the Mazara deal, I was wondering why Chicago wasn’t more active for Marte. Maybe the teams don’t line up well; they’re clearly not getting any of Chicago’s top four (Robert, Madrigal, Kopech, Vaughn), but I think Marte is probably worth a lower 50 and a couple of 40’s and the Sox system thins out quickly after those four. They could use josh bell while they’re at it.

Shalesh
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Totally agree with sadTrombone. I think 2020 is a year early for the WSox but there were some talents in the WSox price range such as Grandal and Wheeler that are difficult to obtain outside of FA. Keuchel is more of an easily obtainable commodity and not one with a power arm like Morton or Lynn who can raise their K%, lower their BB% and HR/FB rate to have great years.

They’ve now tied up $35M/yr to sub-2.5 fwar players like Abreu & Keuchel for the next 3 years. That’s almost enough to get a legitimately great player like Betts on an AAV basis! And the White Sox are a team that needs great players to compete with the superteams since they’re still only a low 80s-win team. MLB seems to have decided to raise payrolls league-wide in advance of CBA negotiations next year based on the lavish FA we’ve seen so far, so maybe the White Sox are planning on jumping to a $160M payroll next year rather than the $130M max we’ve expected.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

The Sox have the high end, elite talent. This team didn’t need to go through another period of stars and scrubs. Robert, Giolito and Moncada – arguably even Kopech – have that elite player ceiling.

I also don’t know why anyone expects this team to cap their payroll at a level they were at in 2006-2007.

Shalesh
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

WSox have potential talent. Superteams have more 4+ win players than the WSox have POTENTIAL 4+ win players. That’s why player acquisition should focus on getting those.

WSox have run payrolls of $91M, $71M, and $86M the last three years. They had a payroll of $129M in 2016, so I don’t think you know what you’re talking about.

You and scotttt ignore the risk that wasting money on mediocrities like Abreu and Keuchel prevents the WSox from ever growing more than an 84-win team. I’d rather have a shorter window of 90+ win teams by waiting to get 4+ win players than have a longer window of 84-win teams by devoting large amounts of payroll to mediocre players.

Having good intentions of “going for it” and “trying to win” is far less important than using cost-benefit analysis and scouting probabilities of these players.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

Based on what?

Grandal, Moncada, Anderson, Giolito, Kopech and Robert could all be realitic 4 WAR players. The Astros had 5 4+ WAR players last year. 7 with Greinke/Altuve who are safe assumptions. The Nationals had 6 – giving Turner 4 despite his injury.

The White Sox? Have 3 on their current roster (Moncada, Grandal and Giolito) who have actually achieved that threshold. With Anderson, Kopech and Robert capable of ascending their with reason – Anderson getting there on a rate basis last year, but he didn’t play enough games.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

If you could just guarantee 4 win players sure, but there aren’t many of them and lots of teams are competing for those players. The Sox have made offers for those players (Machado) and didn’t get them. And in that case it looks like a lucky break they didn’t.

scotttttttttttt
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

The arguments against waiting another year are

1) The team hasn’t had a winning record in 7 years.
2) The clock is ticking on breakout stars Moncada and Giolito. If you’re waiting a year you’re wasting another year of these guys under team control.

synco
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

I think you’ve hit exactly the point re: the $35m/year bit. Taken as individual pieces, these moves are all defensible-ish (though the Keuchel and Abreu deals probably have a ceiling of blah and a floor that is significantly worse).

As part of a larger picture, they don’t make a ton of sense. If the prospects develop, $35m is right about where you need to be for a legit elite FA who wants to join an up and coming team. If they don’t develop, it’s $35m thrown away on declining vets who take up none of the slack. I think they would have been far better served by waiting one more year, seeing what they’ve got, and then throwing a ton of money at a stud if the prospects start to pan out.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  synco

The White Sox had more than 1 hole post-rebuild, so filling one hole with elite talent and the rest with garbage is exactly the thing that got them in this mess in the first place.

Shalesh
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

What got them in this hole is terrible amateur & J2 scouting and player development. A lot of traditional, non-SABR fans like you and scottt are putting way too much faith in the FA well. FA is mostly garbage. You want to sign one of the few elite players that FA offers not stock up on declining mediocrities to “fill holes.” This is how the WSox will be trading Moncada, Giolito, Eloy, and Robert in a couple years to rebuild since this stocking up on expensive, declining veterans didn’t work out. And they still have more than 1 hole (closer, #2 Starter, RF, DH are all ???) and are counting on 4 rookies for other positions. Playoff contention counts on ALL of these things working out, which means a very low probability.

Kevin Gausman signed a 1 yr, $9M contract and his Steamer projection is 2.4 WAR for next year. It’s not too difficult to replicate the production of mediocre FA’s like Keuchel and Abreu with the Gausman’s and Cron’s who are DFA’d every year. A DFA can’t replicate Betts’ projection and would have a very difficult time replicating Bauer’s or Ray’s.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

Very clearly baseball doesn’t agree with Kevin Gausman’s steamer projection but if you want to cite it, go right ahead.

Stating that I’m a non-SABR fan is comical. I can be a fan while also realizing that things like Gausman’s projection are horribly wrong – as baseball also seems to believe.

In the Sabr world, following these signing, the Sox have a better than “slim” chance of competing int he AL Central.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

The super teams are not in their division. A lot can happen in a best of 7 series. And if the only time you should spend is when you can on paper be as good as the Yankees and Dodgers right now then you should basically never spend.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

The Sox don’t have much chance at all for players like Betts. Saving your money for something that will never happen doesn’t do much. Robbie Ray? He doesn’t project any better than Keuchel. And they can’t actually sign him now. A decent player now will often be worth more than simply the possibility of a player in the future.

carterMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Damn Sad Trombone the most downvoted comments on both the major articles (Ryu, Keuchel) today. Impressive.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  carter

I definitely did not get in the holiday spirit. These are times for optimism, apparently.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I got pretty wrecked on the other one but fairly upvoted here, go figure.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

FWIW, I thought your points on the other article were fine. I don’t exactly agree with the details of them, but I think the bigger news is that people are not in the mood to hear the message of “spending huge sums of money on free agency is not a sound strategy unless you have a really strong foundation.” That’s the common aspect of both of our comments.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Yeah, people don’t like being told that their team has no interest in making moves just to entertain them in the offseason. I have had a lot of similar discussions with Dodger fans, and it’s even worse with them when its like guys .. there are …maybe 5 players you could potentially acquire who improve the team at all, and one of them basically told us to go fly a kite!

The conviction among the online Dodger fanbase that they MUST make a major move this offseason to make up for their playoff disappointment is perplexing. It’s like people don’t pay attention to how modern teams are constructed.

Folks don’t seem to recognize that the most likely outcome of these aggressive offseasons is like, the 2019 Reds, aka you forget that they happened by May 1st.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

The Dodgers are in this extremely weird spot where (a) all of their best hitters are lefties except Justin Turner, and (b) the only way to really move the needle is to acquire a 5-win position player, a 4-win pitcher, or an elite reliever. Funny thing is that this is exactly where they were last offseason before they signed Joe Kelly and AJ Pollock, and now there’s a bit of sunk cost fallacy going on here. That’s probably why aside from Ryu, the smoke around the Dodgers has been with Rendon, Clevinger, Lindor, and Hader. I’m of the mind the Dodgers should absolutely be willing to make a bold move but in the given free agency/trade market, it’s not easy to identify what that move should be; the options are not very appealing.

gettwobrute79Member since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

I agree with you up to a point. Making moves for the sake of making moves (like what your dodger brethren are suggesting) is foolhardy. But I think that’s always the knee jerk response by fans of playoff teams who lose.
However, by using the 2019 reds as an example, are you implying that teams with some solid pieces (Reds and White Sox) but aren’t quite contenders simply shouldn’t try at all? I don’t think that’s a good policy, because that’s how you slowly kill fanbases, as I’m seeing it here in Pgh.
In short, it’s rare that you’re going to time everything right, so waiting for everything to fall into place at one moment is a fool’s errand. How realistic is it to have young regulars break out, prospects come up and be immediate contributors, guys have bounce back seasons from injury AND sign the perfect FA to make the cherry on the sundae?
So the White Sox signed the best catcher on the market and overpaid a bit on short contracts to Keuchel and Abreu. They’re still likely to contribute and with Cleveland selling their big guys at Big Lots prices, there may only be Minnesota to worry about. It’s important to take in the landscape of their division as well.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  gettwobrute79

Nah, I think CWS is coming along (though I would guess that 2020 is not the first year they are competitive in a serious way; they’re a year behind the Padres, probably), and some of the moves teams are making are good ones (I like Grandal to CWS for example)

What I don’t like is making moves for league average or barely above league average pitching when your most important competitive years are gonna be the back half of the contract when they’re less good than they are now. There’s a big difference between guys like Cole and Wheeler who you expect to be good for several seasons and dudes who are 2 win pitchers at 31 and you just agreed to pay them when they’re 35.

Maybe at some point you gotta pay for that kind of pitching, but it makes more sense to do it when you’re closer, not for that first year when you’re trying to be respectable. If you can’t find that kind of talent for less than 18m per year, you’ll never succeed anyway.

Regardless of whether they should, in practice we know every team has an upper bound on what they’re willing to spend even if we don’t know what that number is, and committing a chunk of it to 34 year old Dallas Keuchel in what you intend to be the middle of your competitive window is likely to be detrimental to filling your needs when you really need to fill them because you’re battling for a division. (in 22 or 23).

A team like CWS should be investing in players who you expect to be reasonably productive for the next several years. I don’t think Dallas Keuchel meets that standard and you can see what his ZIPS look like right in this article for some evidence to that effect.

The one thing I have come to appreciate the most as a Dodger fan is that that team will absolutely not ever do something that they don’t think will help them in the long run, even if it is potentially helpful in the short run. It means they don’t do a lot of stuff fans would like them to do, but you can have nearly complete confidence they will not do something that can have an impactful backfire. There’s a lesson there in discipline, and I think too many teams get caught up in ‘we want to do these 2-3 things this offseason’, and then when only 1 of them comes together they feel like they still have to be doing stuff, but the available talent is no longer up to the task. Wheeler would have been a good signing for this team, Keuchel is .. I don’t think that contract is gonna look good in 2022 when they’re trying to compete.

gettwobrute79Member since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

While I think Keuchel may be a little overpaid with this contract, I think you’re making it out to be more of a detriment in 2-3 years then it really is. And he’s only signed for 3 years to begin with! This isn’t a Pujols length of time we’re talking about here. I’m curious to see what Keuchel does with a normal type season and pitching to Grandal.
I do agree that signing this type of pitcher probably makes more sense a year from now when they know more about where the Injured Wing club (Rodón, Dunning, Kopech) sits. Not to mention, the upper middle class of pitchers (Stroman, Bauer, Q, Ray, and Paxton) makes it seem like they could sign one of them, just because there are so many of them.
But they also just tried that when they made a play for Wheeler; they offered him more cash than Philly did I believe, and it didn’t work. I don’t think the alternative when they struck out in that deal should just be “do nothing and wait till next year’s class.” While you mention the “discipline” in not chasing needs as the Dodgers do, that’s not the world the rest of the league is living in. The Dodgers, because of their money and insane player development history, can afford to be incredibly choosy. The Sox, by basically punting on the rotation this year, may waste another cheap year of Gio and Yoán.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  gettwobrute79

I don’t think the White Sox are serious candidates to contend for the AL wildcard given how incredibly good you have to be to do that (it might be another story in the NLWC race), and they should be realistic about their timetable: if they want to spend 18m a year for mediocre pitching in 2022 when all their players are ready (and they clearly aren’t all ready yet), they’re better off acquiring someone then, who is younger, instead of 34 year old Dallas Keuchel in his walk year.

It’s just a premature version of this expense because of what Keuchel’s aging curve is likely to look like, unless they are really betting on making a huge surge this year. That, however, is not likely, as teams rarely jump in one year from sub-500 to WC contention: there is usually a season that looks like the 2019 Phillies in the middle, where the team is alright but a lot of players are still maturing. That is what’s most likely gonna happen for the CWS in 2020, and if that’s the case they’re better off giving those innings to nearly any unknown quantity rather than the quite known Keuchel quantity, which has limited upside.

gettwobrute79Member since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

I agree on the WC contending; frankly they have a better shot at the division, because Cleveland is giving every indication of tearing down a bit, which may give the Pale Hose one team to beat. And I don’t think signing Keuchel prevents them from getting someone like Ray next season either. This year seems like an in between year but also a guy like Keuchel (and Gonzalez to a much lesser extent) gives them some protection with those injured guys coming back as well. I don’t think an in between year is a bad thing anyway because as it stands, they’re very volatile now with prospects coming up and young arms coming back.
Anyway, good baseball talk! Happy holidays to you and yours!

fredsbankMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

You’re racking up the downvotes lately, my dude. Might want to rethink your takes since they’re very bad.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago

I’ll also throw one other idea out there, one that is so crazy it might actually work: What if the White Sox traded for Yelich?

This sounds totally crazy, because it is totally crazy. But the White Sox are probably the only team with both the motivation and assets to actually trade for him. The Rays could do it, but it would run counter to everything they do to trade Wander Franco in a deal for Yelich. Same with the Dodgers; they’re allergic to trading any prospects they haven’t already given up on. The Padres could do it, and Preller has shown he’s willing to put less-than-ideal defenders in center field, but it’s not a great fit. Atlanta could blow them away with depth but they seem much more interested in keeping their guys; they’re probably the next most logical suitor behind the White Sox.

Meanwhile, the White Sox are obviously going for it, could use another fantastic big lefty bat, and have an enormous amount of team control over players with huge ceilings between Robert, Kopech, Madrigal, Vaughn, and Eloy (I’m assuming that Moncada is completely off-limits for a team that wants to win now, since he’s their best position player by quite a bit). They could easily deal from that surplus and bring back Yelich, the megastar they’ve been looking for. I mean, it’s not *likely*, but with the Brewers looking like a .500 team and the White Sox going for it, it sure seems like a good outcome for everyone.

Eminor3rdMember since 2019
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

That would make one of the worst defensive outfields in MLB history, and their best prospect is a CF on the cusp of the MLB.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Eminor3rd

So play him in left or right field? I don’t see the problem with that.

Eminor3rdMember since 2019
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

The guy who WAS their best prospect, but just graduated, is already in left, and they guy they JUST traded for, a former top prospect that they think (correctly or not) has tremendous upside they can unlock, is already in right. Yelich is better, sure, but it makes no sense to trade elite prospects to fill a position you’ve already filled; the net improvement is less than the talent they would acquire.

If they’re going to make a trade, it needs to be for a starting pitcher. Though I don’t think it’s likely they will do that. While their farm still has high-end talent, it no longer has much depth. As the roster is currently constructed, they actually need to use the guys that are still down there.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

The Dodgers have a pretty exceptional record of the prospects they refuse to trade working out, so if they don’t want to trade Lux and May, I believe them.

There’s no world where the Brewers trade Yelich, that contract is one of the best deals in baseball and it’s the crux of the Brewers’ ability to compete with their payroll ranges. This is a fantasy post.

Have you been drinking too much egg nogg? This is unlike you.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

Well, I did say it was a crazy idea…

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I would rather crazy meant unconventional and not deranged, and for the Brewers, trading the Yelich contract is deranged unless they are done contending and actually rebuilding (and they’re not).

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

I suspect the Brewers may have gone into this offseason thinking they were going to try and make another run, but there’s no way forward there and I’d be shocked if the team’s braintrust doesn’t see that. It’s a stars-and-scrubs roster: A top-5 outfielder, a top-5 reliever, a nice #2 pitcher and an explosive guy at 2nd who could go a bunch of different ways (everything from superstar to replacement level), and then a bunch of 1-to1.5 win veteran types, some of whom they might get lucky on.

I think everyone is waiting for the Brewers to execute some deep brilliant plan but the most likely story is that they know they have no path forward without spending a huge amount of money. There has been all kinds of smoke about them trading Josh Hader, and while he’s probably way more likely to go than Yelich/Hiura/Woodruff it’s an indication the team is in some sort of rebuilding phase. I still wouldn’t expect them to trade Yelich because he’s easily the team’s biggest star, but this is a .500 team as currently constituted with a bottom-3 farm system and not much help coming in the immediate future. It’s looking real ugly over there.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

That was also true when the Brewers chose to ‘retool’ instead of rebuild and returned to contention quickly. They might have to do that again, but if they did I wouldn’t bet against them, and that Yelich contract is great for a long time.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

The Brewers never really “retooled”. They traded anyone who would bring back any talent: Lucroy, Gomez, Segura, Khris Davis, and any reliever of note (Francisco Rodriguez, Thornburg, Will Smith, Jeffries)…even Maldonado, Jason Rogers, and Adam Lind. The roster was turned over entirely to pre-arb guys of various stripes and Ryan Braun.

The reason they returned to contention so quickly is because they flipped the prospects they got for Yelich, signed Cain, got Travis Shaw in one of their trades, and then were able to extend that for a year when Cain and Shaw turned into pumpkins with savvy free agent signings. They sold and then they bought.

For what it’s worth, I actually prefer what the Brewers did by bringing in a huge number of guys with question marks over what most rebuilding teams do, which is signing over-the-hill veterans like the Tigers or just not giving a damn about winning like the Astros. The Brewers actually won a few games with guys like Thames and Villar and Broxton when they were riding hot streaks. Makes rebuilds way more fun. But if they’re following that blueprint, Yelich and Hader are goners, Cain and Knebel are gone as soon as they rebuild value, Woodruff is 50/50 once he shows he’s healthy, and they’ll try to get by with the Josh Lindbloms of the world.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

That would be fun at least. And there are a lot worse win now trades that teams make.

Shalesh
6 years ago

Depth Charts currently has the WSox at 84 wins, the Indians at 88, and the Twins at 89. Steamer has the WSox at 80 wins, the Twins at 86 wins, and the Indians at 90. The WSox are reportedly closing in on EE, the Twins are battling the Nats for Donaldson, and the Indians may trade Lindor and Clevinger so these projections pend the end of the winter.

IMO, there were only about 9 guys I think were worthy of winning a bidding war for a multi-year contract over: Cole, Strasburg, Rendon, Wheeler, Donaldson, Grandal, Ryu, Will Smith, and maybe Ozuna. I think the Braves got a steal on a 1-year deal for Hamels since I think he’ll produce roughly the same as Bumgarner, Keuchel (whose 88mph FB is down from his CY2015 90mph), and even Ryu and the Rangers 3/$30M deal for Gibson looks real good now too.

I would have preferred the White Sox sign a 1-year stopgap like Ivan Nova and then make a bid at Bauer or Ray next year. With Robert, Madrigal, Cease, and Kopech, the White Sox must think it a poor idea to let 2020 go by without a shot at positive variance from their rookies. Next year, they’ll have Colome, Herrera, Leury, McCann, EE (or another stopgap DH), and possibly Mazara come off the books. Is that enough for a run at Mookie Betts or George Springer and a closer like Yates or Giles in next year’s FA? I hope so.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

The Sox weren’t going to kick the can down the road for another off-season. They have TOR talent with their young guys already (Kopech, Gio, and Cease) and they needed a stabilizing veteran to fit in with their talented youth. While a TOR arm would obviously be nice, this rebuild was always banking on Gio/Kopech and if they failed this team was going to fail.

I think the Sox are happy to get a reliable arm to fit in the rotation that is in great contrast from their flame throwing power arms.

JediHoyer
6 years ago

I like the grandal signing. Still disappointed, they were in such a good position to be able to take on both Myers and Price’s contracts. More upside with price, higher floor with Myers but still some upside and they could have added more minor league talent on top. I like Steele Walker though and think a lot of other teams do too.

Rational FanMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  JediHoyer

Whose floor is Wil Myers higher than?

The only way you’re trading for Wil Myers is for Dion Waiters.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  Rational Fan

Wil Myers’s floor is located in the 3rd sublevel underneath the sewage settling tank.

JediHoyer
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

Mazara is under 2 career war. Whats the difference? Other than getting a prospect instead of giving up. Hell include Steele Walker, take Myers money and you probably get c.j. Abrams and a lotto ticket.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago
Reply to  JediHoyer

The big difference is that Mazara is a lefty who hits righties at a slightly above-average clip. Giving up a prospect for a defensively-challenged platoon corner outfielder whose main strength appears to be “can be a bit better than league average production if you manage his PAs” is not my cup of tea, but the logic behind acquiring a lefty to balance the lineup isn’t bad by itself.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  JediHoyer

To ad to what ST said, Mazara’s also still 24 years old, whereas Myers is 29, so the odds of Mazara being able to figure it out and have a productive season are substantially higher than Myers. The distribution of outcomes for Mazara have a much higher potential ceiling, even if his reaching it isn’t particularly likely.

Myers is basically all downside risk and also costs a ton of money. He’s a negative value asset at this point that no team would take on without compensation.

Mazara’s a poorly compensated change of scenery candidate.

The exposure involved in taking on Mazara is much lower, and there’s more upside. If he doesn’t work out, it costs nothing to nontender him or DFA him. Myers costs you 8 digits going forward for several years.

NATS FanMember since 2018
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

I disagree on Myers. Given 600 ABs at first base Myers most likely outcome is 1.5 WAR which is the same as Abreu. Abreu is a better hitter, but Myers plays closer to average at 1B. While Abreu should probably DH.

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  NATS Fan

Steamer projects myers to have a wRC+ below 100, 14 points worse than Mazara, and put up 0.5 war in half a season’s PAs

For 40 million over 3 years, that is fuckin’ awful, and a lot worse than Jose Abreu, whose projected wRC+ is 25 points higher than Myers.

Myers is a valueless asset. He’s basically 13.3m of AAV in sunk cost over the next 3 seasons.

Nomar Mazara’s not a bigtime asset, but considering he costs nothing and is only 24 years old there is some upside there. I don’t think there is any way that Myers puts up enough value to be worth what he’s paid, and he probably won’t finish out his contract on a 40 man roster, he’s going to get released or traded then released within the next year.

Shalesh
6 years ago
Reply to  JediHoyer

You can’t get the #43 prospect in baseball for taking on Wil Myers’ salary liability. The Padres might give you 8 FV40’s. More likely, they’ll do a bad contract swap. Top 200 prospects are too valuable to give away like that.

I’m surprised the WSox or BlueJays didn’t do something like this for David Price. The RedSox must be driving a hard bargain for salary dumps or looking for a bad contract swap themselves. They still have 3 months to find a taker.

Baron Samedi
6 years ago

Can you please clarify what, exactly, is “it”?

MRDXolMember since 2021
6 years ago

This White Sox team is high-variance, extremely SL, and what this signing, and really much of their offseason, is about is raising the floor at various positions. Their roster come May, barring further disastrous injuries, will have current stars Moncada, Giolito, and Grandal, and potential stars Kopech, Robert, Madrigal, Eloy, Cease, and if you believe in swing-changing, Mazara. That’s not to say any of them *will* break out into stars— Eloy‘s probably the surest bet and he’s limited by his defense— but Keuchel brings a steady 3 WAR/200IP in the rotation, a godsend to a staff that gave 44 starts to the likes of Ross Detwiler, Dylan Covey, and Odrasimer Despaigne last year. The high end outcome, the ~80th percentile outcome, is a much better team than anyone expects. The key is to get the 40th percentile outcome closer to that with veteran signings, and this certainly accomplished that.

scotttttttttttt
6 years ago

All of these wait till next year and sign better free agents ideas don’t really take into account that this isn’t a video game where you can pay the player you want the highest amount and guarantee to sign him. The White Sox were reportedly the highest bidder on Wheeler and look what they got them. These moves put them in a better place to win now, and are not so large and long that they block them from signing players in the future. They’re also coincidentally timed to come off the books right around the time when some of the Sox young players are going to be entering free agency and need to be extended. I’m sure the Sox missed out on Machado last year they started thinking about what it would take to sign Arenado this year, but look how that turned out.

You can’t plan for next year by punting on this year. That works to extent, but there are no guarantees for what next year will bring. By signing these players the Sox actually put themselves in a better position to sign top talent in the future by showing, for the first time in a long time, they are serious about contending and are willing to pay to put themselves closer to that goal.

Shalesh
6 years ago

WSox got Grandal, who is the #6 FA. I think they can get 1 or 2 of Betts, Springer, Bauer, Paxton, Ray, Yates, or Giles next year. And certainly would prefer going for that than putting $35M into Abreu and Keuchel, 2 guys whose projections could be replicated by DFA’s.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

Bauer, Paxton, Ray, Yates, and Giles are all reasonably high risk players. Bauer is 28 with only 1 great year in his career. If Paxton is good you think the Sox are going to outbid the Yankees? Ray is 28 and has never even been worth 3.5 wins. Yates will be 33 when next year starts and has generated all of 5 WAR in his career. Sure, give him $15 million a year and see how that works out. Paying closers not named Mariano Rivera has always been a great strategy. Giles’ peak was 2.1 wins. Keuchel should be able to produce that easily enough. Following this blueprint is basically guaranteed failure.

Shalesh
6 years ago
Reply to  rhdx

The White Sox can’t sign anybody good or there is nobody good, so just sign Abreu and Keuchel until the next rebuild? Seriously? Why bother then? Get Reinsdorf to get over turning J2 into a draft and put some resources there like the Rays and Indians and forget FA altogether…like the Rays and Indians.

The point is to acquire All-Stars, not to exhaust the payroll on mediocre players. I think fans are overrating Keuchel based on his accomplishments of 4 years ago rather than on his projections.

You’re comparing Reliever WAR with Starter WAR, seriously? They’re on different scales with GREAT RELIEVERS maxing out around 3 FWAR and GREAT STARTERS maxing out at 8 FWAR. GREAT RELIEVERS make $18M/year and GREAT STARTERS make $35M/year. $6M/WAR for relievers > $4.5M/WAR for starters. (napkin math)

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

No, people think Keuchel can produce 2.5 WAR. He is projected for about 7 WAR over the next 3 years. At $8 million a year that’s $56 million. He signed for $55.5. It may not create large surplus, but free agents rarely do that. Yates has about 1.5 good years in his life at 33 years old. Great starters do not make $35 million a year. 1 starter ever has made that much. You must be trolling because if it was one’s goal in life to make the worst arguments possible they couldn’t even come close to the nonsense you wrote. Again, how many long term contracts given out to 33 year old relievers with almost no track record worked out? Never.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago

Yeah, because players want to sign with teams that have a shot at making a real run. You have to top a deal by a lot more than $3-5M if you’re not in the right spot in the win curve. I get where you’re going with this, and it does sort of help, but that’s also a point in favor of waiting until the young guys are ready to rock it before firing your bullets.

synco
6 years ago

The idea is that if your prospects start to pan out, the team suddenly starts looking a lot more attractive to FAs. Stars want to get paid and to win.

Smiling PolitelyMember since 2018
6 years ago

Am I wrong for thinking the ChiSox did everything the Angels *should* have done this offseason?

Shalesh
6 years ago

Yes. I love Rendon and while Keuchel is better than Bundy or Teheran, I don’t think he’s worth $55M. ChiSox did very well with Grandal though.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
6 years ago

Signing Grandal? Check. Signing Keuchel? Check. Signing Abreu? Only if it means DFA’ing Pujols. Trading for Mazara? Maybe? Probably not? Still, I think you’re onto something here.

JediHoyer
6 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Grandal yes, but I like the teheran signing for them over keuchel. Homer Bailey and betances would be good for them. Together probably cost the same as keuchel too. Except only 1 yr. Or just take j.a Happ off the Yankees hands. Or all 3.

rhdx
6 years ago

I am not a huge Keuchel fan, but he should be able to generate 2 WAR or so per year and I am glad the Sox are going for it. Given that the 5th starter on the Sox would have almost certainly been replacement level, this is a fair upgrade.

NATS FanMember since 2018
6 years ago
Reply to  rhdx

Grandal makes 3 WAR a good possibility. 2 WAR without Grandal. Yep he is that impactful for a guy like Keuchel

mikejuntMember
6 years ago
Reply to  rhdx

I think if you’re paying for Keuchel you are hoping you get better than that, because there’s no reason to pay a premium in AAV for 2 war over 180 innings worth of starting, you should be able to find, or create, that for less.

rhdx
6 years ago
Reply to  mikejunt

I’m hoping for more, but unless he gets seriously hurt I think he can hit his FG projections. If he produces 1 WAR for each $8 million I won’t be dancing in the streets, but I won’t be complaining either. And Grandal seems likely to help a pitcher with his profile.

NATS FanMember since 2018
6 years ago

I’m not sure Keuchel made his best choice cause Anderson is not his ideal SS. But, Grandal may turn him into an Ace. So who knows for sure!

CC AFCMember since 2016
6 years ago

Theo Epstein: breaks curse of the babe and curse of the billy goat and still gets shit for the Tyler chatwood contract…

burning_phoneix
6 years ago

Robert finna come up and hit .330/.390/.620 and drive us to 95 wins and the division