Eckstein’s Unlikely Bomb

With the game tied at two in the bottom of the tenth, Giants manager Bruce Bochy’s greatest concern was likely Adrian Gonzalez, the man in the on-deck circle at the beginning of the inning. He probably hadn’t even considered the possibility that the game would be over before he even reached the plate.

David Eckstein cared not for improbability on Monday night, as he homered down the left field line off Jeremy Affeldt to win the game for the Padres. It was Eckstein’s first home run of the year and only his 10th since 2006, when he was a member of the World Series champion St. Louis Cardinals.

Eckstein never really had power, but his ability to hit home runs has disappeared since 2005, a season in which he hit 8 home runs and put up a career high .102 ISO. Since then, he’s averaged a home run every 199 plate appearances. A move to PETCO park, where last night’s home run occurred, certainly hasn’t helped the power-starved Eckstein, who saw his HR/FB% fall to a career low 1.3% last season as a Padre.

Not only that, but Jeremy Affeldt is an extreme ground ball pitcher, with a career 48.9% GB rate and a ridiculous 65.0% GB rate to 18.5% FB rate last season, and his GB rate has been above 50% since 2007. Over the last three years, Affeldt has allowed a 26.2% FB rate, and Eckstein has a 29.7% FB rate. Given the league average FB rate of 36.7%, using the crude estimation Expected = (Offense + Defense – Average) – used in The Book – we would expect Affeldt vs. Eckstein matchups to end in a fly ball only 19.2% of the time. Then, given Eckstein’s 1.9% HR/FB over that time frame, we would expect this matchup to end in a home run only .003648% of the time, or roughly 36 out of every 10000 times. With PETCO Park’s .86 HR park factor, that falls to 31 out of every 10000 times.

Of course, you already knew that Eckstein’s home run was unlikely. Still, I think events like these are fascinating. Personally, I think one of the most remarkable things about major league hitters is that even those that we consider not to have any power, such as Eckstein, are capable, on any given pitch, of hitting the ball out of the ballpark. Eckstein just happened to hit his in a clutch situation against remarkable odds.

We hoped you liked reading Eckstein’s Unlikely Bomb by Jack Moore!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs




Jack Moore's work can be seen at VICE Sports and anywhere else you're willing to pay him to write. Buy his e-book.

newest oldest most voted
Wrighteous
Guest
Wrighteous

Eckstein HRed in this spot because he is a clutch hitter who knows how to win. There’s not another ML shortstop who I’d rather have on my team.

Azim
Guest
Azim

Yeah, Eckstein’s grit, leadership, and clutchness outweighs the fact that Hanley Ramirez’s WAR last year was higher than Eckstein’s 4 previous years by 3.4. ZOMGZ EXTINE IZ DA GOAT!?!?!1!!11ONE!11

TomG
Member
TomG

Steroids. Without them Eckstein would be bagging groceries at the local megamart.

Justin
Guest
Justin

He’s so f***in scrappy!!!

Drakos
Guest
Drakos

I have a problem with your statement. You seem to imply that Eckstein is a shortstop. He has been a second baseman since he came to the Padres.

Chris
Guest
Chris

Eckstein is a 2B now, in fact, he hasn’t played SS since ’08 and even then he split time at 2B

joser
Guest
joser

If this statement was made by anyone here other than wrighteous, I’d applaud it as a hilarious and spot-on parody. Coming from him, though, I have to join TomG and blame it on drugs — but not on Eckstein’s part.