Charlie Morton and the Buccos’ Rotation

Prior to yesterday’s games, the Pittsburgh Pirates were the only team in the Majors without a starter who had thrown 100 pitches in a game. Naturally, Paul Maholm replied to my tweet with this nugget by throwing 100 pitches exactly. The Pirates have had four starters removed before topping 80 pitches, which is second in futility only to the Washington Nationals. Here are the Pirates’ six starters this year and their notable numbers:

Brian Burres – 1 GS, 4 IP, 5.03 FIP
Zach Duke – 3 GS, 19 IP, 4.13 FIP
Paul Maholm – 3 GS, 17.2 IP, 4.27 FIP
Daniel McCutchen – 2 GS, 7.1 IP, 9.98 FIP
Charlie Morton – 2 GS, 9.1 IP, 7.31 FIP
Ross Ohlendorf – 1 GS, 5 IP, 7.03 FIP

(Yes, I know the samples are small. The FIP is there just to illustrate how awful some oe the performances have been.)

Generally speaking, when it’s April and Burres is getting starts for you, something has gone wrong. Horribly, horribly wrong. That wrongness is Ohlendorf being hurt. Ohlendorf is more interesting for his off the field accomplishments than his on the field pitching. The real gem of intrigue in the Pirates’ rotation right now is Morton.

Morton was the power arm acquired by the Pirates in the Nate McLouth deal. He has something spectacular growing on his chin in the form of a beard. Check his gamelogs so far:

4/9 @ ARI: 3.1 IP, 1 HR, 6 SO, 1 BB, 4 FB, 2 GB, 8 LD
4/14 @ SF: 6 IP, 3 HR, 3 SO, 0 BB, 7 FB, 10 GB, 4 LD

That Arizona start is incredible to me. He gave up eight earned runs despite posting a 6/1 K/BB ratio and only allowing one home run. I guess there’s no bias in those eight line drives, because, jeez. I actually used the Baseball-Reference Play Index to find comparable starts since 1980. As it turns out, Morton shares some, um, really good company. No, really.

In 1998 Randy Johnson struck out 12 batters while allowing eight earned runs (giving up three homers undoubtedly played into that). Ryan Dempster, Curt Schilling, Mike Mussina, Nolan Ryan, and Floyd Youmans gave up boats of runs while striking out 10 apiece. Kerry Wood, Roger Clemens, Johnson twice, Sidney Ponson, Kevin Gross, and Mike Norris K’d nine through rough starts. And the list goes on. Josh Beckett, Kenny Rogers, John Smoltz, Mark Langston … they all got battered around while fanning at least eight.

Of course there are some stinkers on this list too. But right now, Morton’s name resides next to A.J. Burnett, Jon Lester, Justin Verlander, and Roy Oswalt. That’s not too shabby. Now, before someone takes this the wrong way, I’m not saying good pitchers get hit around super duper hard while striking batters out. It does happen sometimes. But, I’m not saying this is some harbinger to Morton winning the Cy Young. It’s just not a death knell by any means.

Note: I tried including the B-Ref PI link so everyone could view the report. At first and second try this did not work out. I’ll try again later with hopefully more success.

We hoped you liked reading Charlie Morton and the Buccos’ Rotation by R.J. Anderson!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

newest oldest most voted

Did you list a lot of guys who struck out a 8+ batters only? There’s a difference between 8 and 6, I suppose. Especially when the 6 comes against a team with a bunch of “Three true outcomes” guys (Arizona is 4th in K’s in the MLB), and the people he struck out include Mark Reynolds, Connor Jackson, and Miguel Montero (twice).