Goodbye and Thank You
More than 10 years ago, my first piece of published baseball writing appeared on the Community Blog at FanGraphs. It was on Adam Wainwright’s curveball. About five years later, I joined FanGraphs as a part-time contributor. I read the offer email in line at Costco of all places. A few years after that, I joined the staff full-time. For nearly six years, I’ve written almost every day, doing work I love focused on a sport I care deeply about. It is a privilege to work at FanGraphs, and while I’m not tired of the work, I’m moving on. I’m leaving the site to join the Major League Baseball Players Association as their Senior Analyst for Economics and Collective Bargaining.
As I was writing this piece, I thought about the others staff members who have moved on and read through the many farewell posts to grace this site since I joined (remember correlation doesn’t equal causation). Managing editors and writers like Dave Cameron, Carson Cistulli, August Fagerstrom, Corinne Landrey, Kiley McDaniel, Chris Mitchell, and Jeff Sullivan went to work for teams. Writers like Mike Petriello, Travis Sawchik, Eno Sarris, and Kiley McDaniel (again) pursued other jobs in media. Some, like Paul Swydan, pursued other dreams. While every post represented the individual writing it, the goodbyes generally contained three themes: the people here, the work, and the opportunity.
David Appelman created a site for people who love baseball. FanGraphs helped me to appreciate baseball more than I did as a kid growing up on baseball cards,
Sports Illustrated, and a playing career that peaked at the age of nine. As a writer at FanGraphs, I’ve gotten the opportunity to work for and with some amazing people in a welcoming environment fostered by David and all those he’s hired over the years.
I’ve had three Managing Editors, all uniquely brilliant. Dave Cameron interviewed me, sent the email hiring me, and helped shape many of my early posts as I was getting my footing. Carson Cistulli spent considerable time editing my words, and to this day, uses the Socratic method if I ask him a question about baseball. Meg Rowley takes great care in her work and encouraged me to use my own voice. Many others have edited my words, their work is mostly unsung. Hopefully I’m not missing anyone, but I owe a debt to Robert Sanchez, Paul Swydan, Dylan Higgins, Brendan Gawlowski, Rachael McDaniel, and Jon Tayler, as well as Christina Kahrl at ESPN.
And while I don’t expect them to be strangers, I will miss working with the current staff at FanGraphs. Eric Longenhagen is serious about his craft, honest in his work, provides evaluations you can trust, and has always been willing to pass along information to help make a piece of mine better. Jay Jaffe is the foremost expert on baseball’s Hall of Fame, but continues to do the work that got him there rather than coasting. Dan Szymborski is well-known for his ZiPS projections, but he has long been one of the most eager to welcome and support new voices in the sabermetric community. Ben Clemens has a great mind for analysis and more humility than he should. I was reading and listening to Paul Sporer’s work long before I met him, and his enthusiasm for life is worth emulating. Jason Martinez’s work tracking the league’s rosters and maintaining our Depth Charts makes the lives of everyone who follows baseball a little easier.
Many people aren’t aware of the work Sean Dolinar does for the site, but he and I were hired at the same time back in 2015, and he’s now the last person standing from that cohort. His work is invaluable to FanGraphs, and he has made countless articles of mine better due to his help on the back end. His love of arcades, a shared enjoyment, has caused me to own and proudly wear what my wife calls, “the nerdiest shirt I’ve ever seen.” And I’d be remiss if I didn’t also mention David Laurila, whose Sunday Notes columns have been a must-read for me for as long as I have been visiting FanGraphs.
To be able to wake up in the morning (or sometimes the middle of the night), ask myself a question about baseball, and then spend my day (or days) trying to answer it might not be everyone’s idea of a dream job, but it is mine. I’ve been incredibly privileged and amazingly lucky to work at FanGraphs. When I wrote that Community Blog post more than a decade ago, I was 29 years old and working full-time as a lawyer. I didn’t write about baseball more than once a week until I was 32, and didn’t start writing about baseball full-time until I was 34. I’m not about to tell you that anything is possible, but for me, this didn’t seem possible when I was 20, and it was more imagination than reality even after I turned 30. And I didn’t do this alone. I wouldn’t be here without the love and support of my wife, Natasha, as well as our two children, who inspire and tire me.
My love of baseball is what brought me to FanGraphs, and it is also what has motivated me to leave. I will still be able to wake up in the morning and try to solve some of the sport’s more vexing issues. The opportunity to spend time thinking about some of the biggest concerns facing the game — competition, fairness, pace of play, and the best way forward for generations of players to come — is a great one. To be able to think through those issues and potentially help address them was simply too enticing a chance to pass up. It’s going to be a lot of work, but it’s work I love. I’m grateful I had the chance to work at FanGraphs, to meet and count as colleagues some incredible people, and to interact with a great baseball community. I look forward to continuing my work with the Major League Baseball Players Association. Thank you for reading.
Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.
NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Congratulations Craig!
Happy Trails, Craig! I have thoroughly enjoyed your work over the years, especially your always honest and sometimes irreverent chats. It’s nice to know that the MLBPA’s days of getting hosed by the owners are numbered!
Best of luck craig! Loved reading you here and you will be missed. Give the owners hell!
This is incredible news, and as we have come to expect, an incredibly-well written piece. Thanks for everything you’ve done here, Craig, and good luck at the MLBPA. I know I feel better about their chances in the upcoming labor war already.
Congrats!!!!
Congrats and thanks for everything, Craig. Best of luck to you in your new position.
Wow this is huge. Go get ‘em, Craig. Best hire the Union’s made recently.
100% agree – go get ‘em Craig! I’m rooting for you.
Good luck!
Man I’m gonna miss your articles but knowing you’ll work where the game can really be changed for the better is a relief. You’ll have a fight on your hand in the next CBA, stay strong!
Great news for the players association!
Now I feel better about the players union’s chances to not lose their shirts in the next CBA negotiations!
Lose their shirts? Its the strongest union in professional sports.
Low bar.
Or in Shirtless Bartolo’s case, not be forced to wear a shirt…
Fucking A, you’ll be missed.
But I gotta agree with everyone else here: Go get ’em, Craig.
Craig, congratulations on this amazing opportunity with the MLBPA! Thank you for helping me, and so many others, learn to think more and more critically about the game we all love.
Congrats on the job, you will be missed here at Fangraphs. I am glad the MLBPA is making smart moves to help them. (Lawyer, Baseball Sabermatrician; economic analyst). Good luck in your future endeavors.
Congrats Craig! Wonderful opportunity. I have enjoying your work and wish you the best in your new venture.
I get so tired of billionaires screaming poverty for the sole purpose of paying the talent/workers less. Best wishes and go get em Craig!
Congratulations, Craig! Thanks for all of your great work.
Also, tell them to stop worrying so much about the effing luxury tax and get back to basics, with Min salaries, arbitration moving earlier, etc. I know it won’t work because of which player reps have the loudest voice, but it’s time the MLBPA stopped getting owned because they’re focusing all of their efforts on rewarding players that require the another assent of the owners and GMs. It doesn’t matter how high you raise the luxury tax, you cannot convince front offices to pay big dollars for declining players when many of the top players are so cheap.
NO! Bye, Craig, good luck in the future!
Goodbye and best of luck Craig. The Players Association makes a lot of sense with your past work.
My heart drops every time I see one of these stories hit the site.
Congratulations Craig, you will be be missed here! Best of luck in your new role; when I see how much the PA was able to get in the next CBA I’ll know you were the braintrust behind it!
Congratulations Craig. Will miss your writing but if you can help the game move forward in your new position, all the better for all of us.
Didn’t think you could top your previous Handy headline, but you have.
Thank you Craig :’-)
Happy trails Craig — I’ll miss your heavily researched & thoughtful articles here.
ALSO — “the nerdiest shirt I’ve ever seen.”
You had to know FanGraphs readers would take this as a personal challenge… I hope the shirts sell out!
(my favorite nerd shirt says “There are 10 kinds of people, those who understand binary and those who don’t.”)
Fangraphs’ loss is the MLBPA’s gain. I have no doubt that in the end it will be a gain for all of us who love baseball and want to see some of the… developing economic issues that threaten the game worked on by the best. Thanks Mr. Edwards. You will be missed.
Sorry to see you go. I really enjoyed your stuff.
But working for MLBPA sounds like an amazing opportunity. Congratulations! They are lucky to have you.
Great news! Congrats and well wishes. Taking on the Lords is fine work for a mind such as yours. Thanks for the hours and hours of awesome reading and discussion.
Congrats, Craig!
As a person that is in their early 20’s, it is sad/exciting to see the people that got me into analytics move on from Fangraphs. Eno, Dave and now Craig.
Appreciate the tremendous articles over the years!
Sad to see that but have fun in your next chapter!
Congratulations and best wishes! Happy to know you will be part of baseball’s problems solvers.
Always love reading your stuff Craig! Sorry to see you go.
Any chance we can get one last article on the value of an Arenado trade to the cardinals??
Sounds like an awesome opportunity. Congrats! From reading your awesome coverage here, it’s not hard to see why the MLB PA was interested.
Good luck, though not a fan of unions at all.
Congratulations and best wishes. You will be missed.
Au revoir, Mr Edwards
Congratulations, Craig! Wishing you the best! You’ll be missed around these parts!
We’ll miss you, but as long as everything gets fixed in the next CBA, all will be forgiven. Good luck!
A sad, teary goodbye to the always reliable Craig Edwards Cardinals Puff Piece
It’s going to feel weird having someone else write up the Arenado trade.
Clemens would be a natural fit, as would Szym. Luckily FG has a Dodgers-level deep bench of talent.
That’s quite the opportunity and well deserved. You will be missed but I’ll also be poking around from time to time in the future to see what/how your contributions have been. Thank you for the hard work and content you’ve put forth over the years and best of luck to you!
Sad to see you go, but really glad you found this new gig, Craig! It seems like a perfect fit. I just wanted to thank you for everything, especially your work during last year’s 2020 labor negotiations. I often referenced your work when discussing these matters with others. There was nobody who covered this with the poise and excellence that you did.
Congratulations and Good Luck from the folks at Viva El Birdos! The big question, of course, is who from VEB is Fangraphs going to poach THIS time?
( ╥﹏╥) ノシ
Is this the start of an exodus? I saw the membership drive goal doible to 40K. Is the website failing?
Possibly, but I think the simpler conclusion here is that Craig thought it would be more interesting to try to produce statistics about player salaries for the union than for the internet. It’s clearly a passion of his.
Also, I saw an ad a couple of days ago that they were hiring a new writer.
The goal was always 60k memberships, I believe. The graph simply changed scales because 20k was eclipsed.
Already a member but I was psyched to donate and try to be lucky #20K on the fateful day. My dreams are crushed — CRUSHED!
Congratulations, and best of luck to ya!
Best of luck, Craig. The players got themselves a good one.
Congratulations Craig!
I am happy for you. Your content will be greatly missed and the public discourse surrounding the game will undoubtedly be poorer without your contributions. However, I think that the Players Association specifically and Major League Baseball generally will ultimately benefit more from your services in you new role. It has become abundantly clear that the Owners and Front Offices are not capable of making decisions that benefit the health of the Game in the long term and that this responsibility will fall on the shoulders of the Players Association. I am certain that your contributions to the Players Association, and the next CBA will be invaluable. Hopefully everyone in the MLBPA realizes the invaluable resource that you represent to forwarding their goals and make appropriate use of your skills.
Best of luck. You will be missed.
Morbo
Congratulations, and dang! I hope you’ll be able to feed Fangraphs some nice inside perspectives on anything that isn’t confidential.
Yours is easily the best name/avatar combo on FG. I need to revisit my collection of Far Side books.
Good news: Fangraphs is hiring!
Bad news: guess why a spot opened up 🙁
We’ll miss you here Craig, but all the best in your future baseball adventures!
I appreciate your work greatly and have enjoyed reading you regularly.
I’ve been an employee of labor unions for about 19 years now and I want to welcome you to the labor movement; I hope you find it as fulfilling as your work as Fangraphs. Your new job is one of my dream jobs.
Nice gig! Congrats!
The MLBPA got a gem. Congrats and best of luck, Craig!
Super sad to see you leaving FanGraphs – every time I came across some bit of CBA- or finance-related baseball news I’d be sure to wait to form my full opinion until I read your piece on it. Your voice here will be missed but congrats on the new job!
Congrats! That’s a great opportunity. Go fight the good fight.
Congratulations, and you leave a deep legacy of fine work. The MLBPA’s gain is our loss.
“The nerdiest shirt.” Sorry Craig, but your wife’s got to get out more. Good luck in your new job.
Good on ya’, Craig! I hope you’ll be able to write here, once in a while, to inform us of what you’re working on. It’s been great reading your work, and I’m going to be rooting for your ongoing success.
Good luck!
Guy will make 6 figures to help people making 9 figures get more out of people with 12 figures
And this aggrieves you….why, exactly?
I suppose the part I dislike is that we’ve agreed that these very rich players need help. The players AND owners need to make less. Games are too expensive, advertising is ridiculous, and the game needs to be more accessible to everyone. Why does 25th man making half a million freaking dollars need anyone’s help? Not to mention baseball culture being upset when someone receives 3yr / 30 mil when the consensus said 3 yr / 50 mil. It’s crazy. Lower ticket prices. Lower parking. Make games more watchable with less blackouts. Give back to the freaking fans.
I thought your original post was clever, snarky and more than a little truthful. My only response to your follow up is most people feel most products/services (food, drugs, legal fees, recreation, etc.), that most of us make/deliver are too expensive.
That’s unless a) The government gives them to us for “free” or b) We have a narrative handy to justify the cost.
…& by showing those 12-figure hogs are making so much cabbage that not only can they afford free agents AND to pay minor leaguers a livable wage AND still not need public subsidies for their new stadiums , thereby taking you, me & our tax dollars out of the equation.
If you don’t like the rest of the economics of MLB? Watch amateurs, coach little league or grab your glove & go play. I’d step outside & play catch with you.
The world’s a rough enough beast to tussle with; we create games & chalk the foul lines to create a small, artificial environment where we strive to keep the world fair for 27 outs… each… except for sometimes when we might need a few more, maybe but probably not an infinite number.
Anyway, if not stepping outside to throw then maybe the batting cages to knock the crap out of something but have everyone here be totally cool with it?
We’re here because of a shared love of the game, there’s no need to distract from that.
Did you just find out about hierarchy and capitalism? Rich people usually don’t work for poor people. And remember who invented the cliche about “letting their money work for them” i.e., bragging about not working at all. It wasn’t working stiffs like me that’s for sure.
Congrats and best of luck, Craig. I appreciated your takes and how you made an argument for them.
As others have said, your work here will be missed, but congrats and good luck in your new role with the MLBPA. You’ve certainly got a big challenge before you, but I have confidence that you and Bruce Meyer will help negotiate a new CBA with improvements in the economic structure that foster increased competition and more meaningful free agent opportunities for the players.
A Bummer! And I’m not speaking of the relief pitcher with the White Sox.
I will miss your writing but I am beyond thrilled that you are moving on to a position where you can help make this great sport better. Best of luck!
This is sad news. Sorry to see you go. One of the best writers at FG. Congrats on the new job though.
Wainwright goes back to StL and they look to trade for Arenado; Craig’s watch is done 🙂
I join everyone in how much we’ll miss his voice and perspective, but also in how much better the game will be because of his work. Good luck and happiness!
?
?!
You’ve definitely been value added to the FG family. Best to you on what looks like an exceptional opportunity and exciting challenge.
Dang, this is the second Craig Edwards farewell I’ve had to endure. Will really miss your writing but all good wishes for the future.
Congrats! Hopefully your common sense wisdom will help avoid a strike. It’s past time to get the union and ownership focused on what really drives both their revenue lines, growing the long term popularity of the game!
Thank you, Craig. You will be missed. Godspeed.
Sad to see you go, but what an excellent position to be moving into. Best of luck
Mazel tov! And it’s cool to hear you didn’t really even start writing here until you were 30, gives the rest of us hope that maybe we’ll get our act together someday lol
What a cool opportunity! Their gain is definitely our loss, but I’m really happy for you. Thanks for all the great reads!
Congratulations! What a gracious, warm article.
Great work on this site and a really noble, rewarding job awaits you. I pray your work will help prevent a work stoppage next season!
Fangraphs is an example of an organization with “good turnover.” The people who leave do so for rewarding opportunities and challenges working here prepared them to do.
All the best in your new endeavor. I’m sure you will accomplish great things and help others to do so as well.
Nooo 😭
That’s a really cool opportunity though, thanks for all the great articles
I’ve been reading Craig’s stuff for so long that I practically know every turn of phrase before I read it. This is a real loss.
Best of luck on your new opportunity!
Forecast 2025… Epstein as MLB commissioner and Edwards as the head of the player union…save the future of baseball.
Hopefully you are able to prevent the strike that seems to coming our way.
As an econ nerd (and former college econ major), I loved your work on labor markets, contracts, etc. There is no equivalent journalism that I have seen covering this or any other sport. At least none that has been so thorough and frank, and available to the internet public for free!
All of your work on labor issues have been a readily available litmus test/thought exercise for the “real world” issues I see around me that affect our working lives and our political lives. As a non professional economist (just someone who loves the subject and thinks about it in my free time), it can be hard finding ready examples of public data on contracts, unionization, and monopsony power (or would it be “oligopsony” in the case of the 30 teams?). Again, I have found your work to be tremendously valuable as thought exercises I can use to help frame my understanding of our broad economy.
I am always sad to read these goodbye pieces. But I appreciate the humanity behind them. I am always shocked by how unique the writing is on FG. But when I hear that folks like yourself had lives outside of baseball journalism, in your case and I believe others, as an attorney, then it all really clicks. It’s so obviously apparent that folks here (and many of the folks in the comments too!) are of a high caliber with a very different set of knowledge and skills than most writers.
May you make the game and the lives of players and the entertainment for the fans all better with your important work for the MLBPA! I for one hope that you will be permitted to write guest columns for FG!
Wow, impressive. Congratulations. It sounds like a fantastic job for someone passionate about baseball. Good luck.
Sounds like a great opportunity. Good luck and I appreciated your work on this site.
Congratulations!
Have fun storming the castle!
Congratulations on the new job, and thanks for many, many great articles.
You’ve been a joy to read. Congratulations on this career advancement! The players are lucky to have you.
Love ya Craig! Good luck on the labor side and I hope you can make some positive changes.
I’m going to miss the heck out of your work, but this is an incredible opportunity for you. Way to go!
Congrats! And thank you.
Good luck! Thanks for your contributions that have deepened my appreciation for this beautiful game.
Congratulations! They are lucky to have you, and I’m looking forward to you fixing baseball.
I’m selfishly disappointed you’re leaving but thrilled for you. Be well, stay safe, and thank you for all your truly amazing work over the years.
Congratulations my friend. You’ll be missed.
Your #1 fan in Mexico.
You will be missed sir. Best wishes on your new position!
Man that is a great job. Good luck with the union.
Just a thought and a question for everyone. MLBPA would be smart to bring stadium workers and other team personnel into the fold somehow, even if just solidarity work. And with the changing relationship between MLB & Milb, is now the time to bring Minor Leaguers into the union?
Craig, congratulations, and best wishes in your new endeavor. I haven’t always agreed with your positions but I’ve respected your approach and apparent willingness to listen.
Good luck with your side and it’s multiple interests- players along the aging/value curve, agents, and don’t forget the MiLB players. Good luck with the owners- small/large market, little RSN revenue/lotta RSN revenue, low valuation/high valuation…
Hopefully the CBA negotiations will be hard on the problems easy on the rhetorical. You get that it’s hard for owners/players to be on the same team without revenue sharing. That’s hard to do with so little revenue coming from a National TV contract. But we’re all rooting for you to be successful!
No more Craig Edwards Cardinal puff pieces…
Congratulations! Enjoy this next journey.
Please take Jay Jaffe with you. He would do an incredible job. It would be challenging, but we would survive here without him. Please take him.
I’d hate to lose you and your writing for anything less than the fantastic new opportunity you’re following. Thanks for the knowledge over the years. You will be missed.
Craig, your work on the site was fantastic. All the best in your next phase! The player’s association gained an excellent teammate, but you will be missed here.
Best of luck. Thanks for all you’ve done. Give em hell…
Sad for me, but happy for Craig. Congrats, give those owners hell.