Has Anyone Seen Second Base?

Pardon me, but have you by any chance seen second base? It can usually be found over in that large patch of dirt, but I seem to have mislaid it. Second base. It’s the second of the bases. I could have sworn I left it right there. Amid the dirt. You turn your back for one second. Maybe I should retrace my steps. Here’s what happened.

It was the bottom of the ninth. One out, runners on first and second. Fernando Tatis Jr. came to the plate. That’s the white pentagon in the ground over there. When a strapping slugger comes to the plate, I have to take a walk. Out of respect for his prodigious power, I bid farewell to my traditional post alongside third base and I sojourn a half dozen steps in a northerly direction, toward the outfield. Sometimes I carry a generous scoop of trail mix in my back pocket for such journeys. Tonight I went without, and maybe that’s what did me in. Low blood sugar can wreak havoc on your sense of direction.

Anyhow, I traveled north-northeast toward the left fielder. That’s my colleague, Randy. When he wants to show you that he’s happy, he crosses his arms and scowls as if he’s angry. When he’s angry, he scowls but doesn’t cross his arms. It’s confusing until you get used to it. I traipsed all the way over toward Randy, and then wouldn’t you know it, that pesky Tatis hit a nice soft chopper back to my right. I had been standing in the right place all along! I swiveled with the quickness of a cat. Crouching like a tiger on the prowl, I crept in and toward the third base line. Gracefully as a lynx, I secured the bouncing ball. Ferociously as a panther, I pivoted and heaved it to second base. Or so I thought. Second base had vanished like an elusive snow leopard. My throw sailed into the night.

I suppose you could argue that I only threw to where I thought second base to be, that all the twisty-turnies had a deleterious effect on my internal compass, causing me to throw wildly into the night, that the base is around here somewhere and I’ve just been looking in the wrong direction this whole time. But that strikes me as unlikely. More importantly, it would be unprofessional to entertain such a thought. A good infielder always trusts their internal compass. It’s just one of the tools you have to keep honed to a fine point in order to play at this level.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed.
We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member.
1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other.
2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off.
3. Dark mode and Classic mode!
4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them.
5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects.
6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.)
7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only.
8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO.
9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members.
10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features!
We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it.

You need a clock in your head so you know how much time you have to catch the runner, a compass in your head to know where all the bases are, a barometer in your head to know how the dew point of the grass will affect a bouncing ball, a calorimeter in your head to make sure you don’t overdo it on the trail mix, and an alethiometer in your head to ask the Dust what’s really going on. I suppose these days, you could just get rid of all the clutter and keep a smartphone in your head, but the point remains. It’s less likely that I completely lost second base and threw the ball directly to the middle of nowhere than it is that second base simply disappeared entirely.

With no destination to speak of, my throw skipped joyously across the springy grass for what felt like an eternity. What I wouldn’t give to feel that free for even a moment.

I looked down at my hand. “Do you have any idea where second base went?” I asked it. It said nothing. That about brings us up to the present. I queried my hand just a moment ago. Still no reply. Here I stand, wondering what happened to second base. Maybe you can help me find it.

Would it help if I were to describe it? Physical characteristics: It’s a big white square on the ground. I guess technically it’s a cuboid, say, two inches tall and 18 inches to a side. Slightly domed. Cryptic markings on the top. It’s composed of a tough rubbery composite. Very sturdy. It would honestly make a great murder weapon, should things take a turn. It’d be a bit unwieldy, but that’s how it goes when things take a turn. You can’t always be a Picky Ricky about your bludgeons.

Metaphysical characteristics: I suppose you could argue that second base is the axis around which the game revolves. The beating heart of the playing field. A minor fortress standing resolute against outfield encroachment and the unrelenting waves of time that seek to smooth our sharp edges. Second base is the cusp. The launchpad for the flanking run from scoring position to scoring. The rally point at which the numbers really start to count, especially if you need to complain about Juan Soto. Have you seen anything that matches that description? White, cuboid, beating-axis-fortress-cusp-heart?

A man spray-paints it eggshell white and then stabs it into a big hole in the ground before the game. Another man takes it away after the top of the fourth inning and stabs a fresh replacement into the ground. Actually, it may well be the same man. I’m just now realizing how little I know about the person or persons who paint and stab the bases. Wait, could that be it? Did the man forget to replace the base? That’s a strong working theory. I certainly wouldn’t have noticed if it disappeared for five innings or so. When was the last time I saw it?

You know what? I was standing right on it, and it can’t have been more than an hour ago. I took a walk, and then my friend Josh hit a single that allowed me to jog over and stand directly on the base. Josh and I were working out of Arizona before this. He was transferred out here to Seattle a week before I was. “I guess you’ll have to trade your parasol for an umbrella,” I kidded him. He laughed, but I could tell he was only being polite. Umbrella humor isn’t for everyone. Anyway, Josh moved me over to second. I was right there. I think I even have a picture.

Hmm. It’s a little blurrier than I remember it, but that’s definitely me standing on second base.

That was only an hour ago, but a lot has happened since then. I scored. Josh scored. My friend Mitch scored. His friend Jorge scored. Mitch and Jorge worked together in Minneapolis before this. Apparently, Mitch’s high school friends call him Garv Sauce. That doesn’t sound very appealing to me. If you served me some fries with a side of Garv Sauce, I think I’d lose my appetite. Wait, that was in the bottom of the fifth, so the man had already come back and put the base back in. There goes that theory.

I suppose it’s possible my aim wasn’t perfectly true. I mean, I really felt like I nailed the throw, but I did have to execute those furious half-turns at high velocity right before I let the ball go. If I’m being perfectly honest, I’m still a little dizzy. I could really use that trail mix. Maybe it’s time to put a gyroscope in my head too. But I don’t think I could have gotten so turned around as to lose sight of second base entirely. It seems much more likely that the base just disappeared.

Maybe it was swallowed by a sinkhole. Or a speeding baserunner trampled it with such force that it was pushed deep into the earth and the surrounding dirt fell into the resulting hole and covered it up. Or they pushed off the corner with so much angular velocity that it spun and spun until it rose off the ground like a gyrocopter and floated out into the bay. The theories are really coming to me now. Perhaps an intense slide showered it with so much dirt that it’s still out there but perfectly camouflaged. That’s got to be it. If you see it, let me know.





Davy Andrews is a Brooklyn-based musician and a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @davyandrewsdavy.bsky.social.

22 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
aglossmanMember since 2016
10 months ago

Love the alethiometer ref

resist1922Member since 2025
10 months ago
Reply to  aglossman

AND a gyrocopter, but not sure that’s Pullman specific.

marzMember since 2017
10 months ago
Reply to  aglossman

Perhaps Suarez has been separated from his daemon? And what even is Suarez’s daemon? This seems important.

bigpizzamanMember since 2024
10 months ago
Reply to  aglossman

I just started my first reread of the Golden Compass yesterday. It’s been 20 years.

I spit out my coffee when I read that line. Very eerie

SportszillaMember since 2017
10 months ago

I was streaming this on my phone at a bar and thought there had been some sort of glitch with how far off that throw was

Smiling PolitelyMember since 2018
10 months ago

well, “Garv Sauce” is going to be lodged in my head for awhile…

BryzMember since 2019
10 months ago

It’s been around since he was a Twin (just so you know).

Mitchell MooreMember since 2020
10 months ago

I’m glad to report that he found second base last night. Second inning, runner on first, Tatis chopped a very similar ball, even a bit further to Suarez’s right, and Eugenio made a Jeteresque jump throw right on target to get the force out.

bookbookMember since 2024
10 months ago
Reply to  Mitchell Moore

Wow. Using “Jeteresque” as an adjective to describe something positive on defense! On Fangraphs! I think I’ve seen it all.

carterMember since 2020
10 months ago
Reply to  bookbook

Hey no one ever said he wasn’t able to go to his right and make a jump throw on a ball most people would be standing in front of. It is funny though that I can’t even picture him going to his left. Like I can’t even picture it in my head.

Jason ScottMember since 2024
10 months ago

2nd base is a point, so it can’t be an axis, which is a line. Maybe that’s the reason you can’t find it.

Blue ShoesMember since 2019
10 months ago

#KeepNotGraphs

DylanMember since 2016
10 months ago

Things like this always make me think of Sam Miller’s article about Mark Reynolds being blind.

I love baseball.

raregokusMember since 2022
10 months ago
Reply to  Dylan
LMOTFOTEMember since 2017
10 months ago
Reply to  raregokus

Thanks for sharing, I loved this article. He and Adam Dunn were ahead of their time, and quite entertaining as well.

GoatHerderMember since 2016
10 months ago
Reply to  raregokus

Thank you for sharing, first time reading it, very entertaining.

Tickled a long forgotten brain cell that remembered reading about Wesley Walker who was an NFL wide receiver and blind in one eye when I was a kid.

raregokusMember since 2022
10 months ago
Reply to  GoatHerder

There are very few things in this world I’ve laughed harder at than that GIF of Reynolds getting picked off without moving a muscle

carterMember since 2020
10 months ago
Reply to  raregokus

Great article. It reminds me a bit of Chris Carter. He was one of the most entertaining hitters to me because you could tell he was just completely lost but so strong he hit home runs anyways *if he hit it*. His at bats were glorious spectacles, it’s like he would guess fastball middle and swing at a fastball middle while a curveball bounced in front of the plate. The thing that he did that was different was he would still swing as if the pitch was coming down the middle and not adjust to location at all, and miss it by 6 feet.

FreshOJMember since 2025
10 months ago
Reply to  raregokus

thank you, thank you, thank you

Tampa Bay Devil WorshippersMember since 2016
10 months ago

This is magnificent writing. Long live #notgraphs!

sandwiches4everMember since 2019
10 months ago

I love the fact that the video is titled “Fielder’s Choice”, as though he decided that he wanted to throw the ball into short RF.

resist1922Member since 2025
10 months ago

Umbrella humor isn’t for everyone.