The expanded playoff format might have put an end to Game 163 tiebreakers, but this postseason still promises to deliver some great matchups, featuring division rivals, electric starters, fearsome bats, and multiple teams that finally put an end to long playoff droughts. And though the field boasts four 100-plus-win clubs that seem poised for deep runs, a lot can happen in a short series. That makes it difficult to predict how October will unfold, but 30 of our writers from FanGraphs and RotoGraphs did their best.
Below are our predictions by league and round, as well as each writer’s full forecast (those tables are sortable). Happy playoffs!
American League
Wild Card Series
Blue Jays vs. Mariners Wild Card Series
Winner
Votes
Toronto Blue Jays
19
Seattle Mariners
11
Guardians vs. Rays Wild Card Series
Winner
Votes
Cleveland Guardians
19
Tampa Bay Rays
11
Division Series
Astros vs. Blue Jays/Mariners Wild Card Winner Division Series
Winner
Votes
Houston Astros
24
Seattle Mariners
3
Toronto Blue Jays
3
Yankees vs. Guardians/Rays Wild Card Winner Division Series
Winner
Votes
New York Yankees
23
Cleveland Guardians
6
Tampa Bay Rays
1
Championship Series
American League Championship Series Matchups
Matchup
Votes
Houston Astros vs. New York Yankees
19
Houston Astros vs. Cleveland Guardians
5
New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays
2
New York Yankees vs. Seattle Mariners
2
Seattle Mariners vs. Tampa Bay Rays
1
Cleveland Guardians vs. Toronto Blue Jays
1
American League Championship Series
Winner
Votes
Houston Astros
20
Cleveland Guardians
3
New York Yankees
3
Seattle Mariners
3
Toronto Blue Jays
1
National League
Wild Card Series
Mets vs. Padres Wild Card Series
Winner
Votes
New York Mets
24
San Diego Padres
6
Cardinals vs. Phillies Wild Card Series
Winner
Votes
Philadelphia Phillies
20
St. Louis Cardinals
10
Division Series
Dodgers vs. Mets/Padres Wild Card Winner Division Series
Winner
Votes
Los Angeles Dodgers
21
New York Mets
9
Braves vs. Cardinals/Phillies Wild Card Winner Division Series
Winner
Votes
Atlanta Braves
27
Philadelphia Phillies
2
St. Louis Cardinals
1
Championship Series
National League Championship Series Matchups
Matchup
Votes
Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Atlanta Braves
20
Atlanta Braves vs. New York Mets
7
St. Louis Cardinals vs. New York Mets
1
New York Mets vs. Philadelphia Phillies
1
Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Philadelphia Phillies
1
National League Championship Series
Winner
Votes
Los Angeles Dodgers
13
Atlanta Braves
10
New York Mets
7
World Series
World Series Matchups
Matchup
Votes
Houston Astros vs. Los Angeles Dodgers
7
Houston Astros vs. Atlanta Braves
7
Houston Astros vs. New York Mets
6
New York Yankees vs. Los Angeles Dodgers
2
Cleveland Guardians vs. Los Angeles Dodgers
2
Toronto Blue Jays vs. Los Angeles Dodgers
1
Seattle Mariners vs. New York Mets
1
Seattle Mariners vs. Los Angeles Dodgers
1
Seattle Mariners vs. Atlanta Braves
1
New York Yankees vs. Atlanta Braves
1
Cleveland Guardians vs. Atlanta Braves
1
World Series Champion
Winner
Votes
Houston Astros
12
Los Angeles Dodgers
6
New York Mets
5
Atlanta Braves
2
Cleveland Guardians
2
New York Yankees
2
Seattle Mariners
1
Writer Predictions
2022 FanGraphs Staff Playoff Predictions: AL
Writer
CLE/TBR WC
TOR/SEA WC
NYY/WC DS
HOU/WC DS
Alex Chamberlain
CLE
TOR
CLE
HOU
Alex Eisert
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
Alex Sonty
CLE
TOR
NYY
HOU
Ariel Cohen
TBR
SEA
NYY
HOU
Ben Clemens
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
Chad Young
CLE
SEA
NYY
HOU
Chris Gilligan
CLE
TOR
NYY
HOU
Dan Szymborski
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
David Laurila
CLE
SEA
CLE
HOU
Davy Andrews
CLE
TOR
CLE
TOR
Dylan Higgins
TBR
SEA
TBR
SEA
Eric Longenhagen
CLE
TOR
CLE
HOU
Esteban Rivera
CLE
TOR
NYY
TOR
Jake Mailhot
CLE
SEA
NYY
SEA
Jason Martinez
CLE
SEA
NYY
SEA
Jay Jaffe
CLE
TOR
NYY
HOU
Jeff Zimmerman
TBR
SEA
NYY
HOU
Jon Becker
CLE
SEA
NYY
HOU
Jon Tayler
CLE
SEA
CLE
HOU
Justin Choi
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
Justin Mason
CLE
TOR
NYY
HOU
Kyle Kishimoto
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
Leo Morgenstern
TBR
TOR
NYY
TOR
Lucas Kelly
CLE
SEA
NYY
HOU
Meg Rowley
CLE
TOR
NYY
HOU
Michael Baumann
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
Mike Podhorzer
TBR
TOR
NYY
HOU
Nicklaus Gaut
CLE
SEA
NYY
HOU
Paul Sporer
CLE
TOR
CLE
HOU
Tess Taruskin
CLE
TOR
NYY
HOU
2022 FanGraphs Staff Playoff Predictions: NL
Writer
STL/PHI WC
NYM/SDP WC
ATL/WC DS
LAD/WC DS
Alex Chamberlain
PHI
SDP
ATL
LAD
Alex Eisert
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Alex Sonty
STL
NYM
ATL
LAD
Ariel Cohen
PHI
NYM
ATL
NYM
Ben Clemens
PHI
NYM
PHI
NYM
Chad Young
PHI
SDP
ATL
LAD
Chris Gilligan
PHI
SDP
ATL
LAD
Dan Szymborski
PHI
NYM
ATL
NYM
David Laurila
STL
SDP
ATL
LAD
Davy Andrews
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Dylan Higgins
PHI
SDP
ATL
LAD
Eric Longenhagen
PHI
SDP
ATL
LAD
Esteban Rivera
STL
NYM
ATL
LAD
Jake Mailhot
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Jason Martinez
PHI
NYM
ATL
NYM
Jay Jaffe
STL
NYM
ATL
LAD
Jeff Zimmerman
PHI
NYM
PHI
LAD
Jon Becker
PHI
NYM
ATL
NYM
Jon Tayler
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Justin Choi
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Justin Mason
STL
NYM
STL
NYM
Kyle Kishimoto
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Leo Morgenstern
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Lucas Kelly
STL
NYM
ATL
LAD
Meg Rowley
STL
NYM
ATL
LAD
Michael Baumann
PHI
NYM
ATL
LAD
Mike Podhorzer
STL
NYM
ATL
LAD
Nicklaus Gaut
PHI
NYM
ATL
NYM
Paul Sporer
STL
NYM
ATL
NYM
Tess Taruskin
STL
NYM
ATL
NYM
2022 FanGraphs Staff Playoff Predictions: CS and World Series
Meg is the editor-in-chief of FanGraphs and the co-host of Effectively Wild. Prior to joining FanGraphs, her work appeared at Baseball Prospectus, Lookout Landing, and Just A Bit Outside. You can follow her on Bluesky @megrowler.fangraphs.com.
Why do you all hate my favorite team??