How Optimistic Are You that the Season Will Be Played? (Round 2)
Two weeks ago, I asked our readers a series of questions about what the season might look like as a means of showing our relative optimism (or pessimism) about the state of things in our country and in baseball. We are now a few more weeks down the line, so I’d like to see if your perceptions have changed. Feel free to answer the questions even if you did not participate in Round 1. The questions below mirror those asked two weeks ago. Thanks for your time.
Once I get your answers in, I will report back on how everyone is feeling, and what has or hasn’t changed since I asked in March.
Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.


Empty stadiums, earlier start, more games, please!!
I think it’s painfully obvious empty stadiums are the only way we get baseball and there’s no way we’ll get games in Cali or NY this year I don’t think. Verducci on high heat suggested mlb may start in August and have teams playing fifty games, which to me is not a real season though I’d watch anyway. I am still pessimistic we’ll get a season and no season and no work makes me a dull boy.
Ugh…50 games? That isn’t worth doing
I’d much rather Mike Trout get 50 games in his prime than zero…
Why? College and high school sports, plus both professional football and soccer play shorter seasons. Many feel the NBA/NHL seasons are too long.
7 games against each team in your division is 28 games. Play 2 game series against each other team in your league and that’s 48 games. Works for me to get to postseason.
It wouldn’t be “real” but I’d be very happy to see it. And I’d view the winners more legitimately than, oh, anything pre-integration and the Trash Cans.
as for NY and CA…. it’s a lot of cases but the peaks are now or earlier. They are likely to have antibody testing before some other places. I could see an empty-stadium series or a few in both places. Not large crowds at all though.
Who are the trolls downvoting this?
There seem to be many, many trolls on this comment page. It’s rife all the way down the line.
Surprised that Arizona and Florida are in the running here, and not some complex of fields. The key is to be playing a ton of games simultaneously. One or two games at a time won’t cut it. Maybe that’s possible at spring training complexes? I confess I haven’t been.
I’m confused. Arizona and Florida are the places with complexes of fields because those are the location of Spring Training…
yeah, I am mostly fine with Arizona except for very fair weather concerns. Florida, though…. it’s going to be a while before they’re even ok enough to host a baseball tournament.
The baseless optimism around here is so stereotypically American.
There is no way a season is going to happen.
Seems like the optimists have gone negative in downvoting you.
Come to think of it… the negative of a negative is positive, so they’ve actually remained positive. Wow!
FWIW I feel some guilt trying to crack a joke that’s ultimately related to grave subject matter. Pardon my nonsense.
quantum optimism- the ability to be optimistic and pessimistic at the same time
There’s some weird brigading going on, the nutbar upthread who thinks Covid is a hoax is getting a bunch of upvotes. I have no idea why anyone would want to comment brigade on Fangraphs of all places.
I blame the Wilpons, or whoever goes through every night around 5PM eastern downvoting comments critical of the mets.
The nutbar upthread has about 150 burner accounts he uses to proxy-vote his own posts up and everyone else down. He’s the guy who got thrown in jail for spamming the Phillies by spoofing other people’s email addresses. Which frankly seemed a bit much for me at the time, but his citizenship in other areas was extremely, uh, spotty, so there wasn’t much of a character defense for him.
take your meds
Dispensaries are not “essential businesses” in @Baron’s home state.
they BRIEFLY weren’t in one of mine (the one I’m stuck in actually) and the lines went around the block before final closing. People were behaving themselves, though.
“home state” You’re not too bright, are you?
*ahem* simmer down, impossibly delicate white male(s)
I really think the comments sections at FanGraphs have been brutally pessimistic since this started.
Given the course of the virus in Germany, and that Bundesliga plans on a May first start date, you could argue that MLB is being overly cautious (I’m not gonna argue that- the BL seems nuts to be proposing that, but they’re practicing right now so who knows)
The BL’s options are less constrained than MLB’s because 1) Germany approached the initial public health situation more aggressively than the US did and 2) the league season is winding down, rather than just getting started. A few weeks of games followed by another shutdown, followed by a few more weeks of games is totally feasible, even if they have to shut it down 2-3 times. (Euro 2020 has already been postponed until 2021 so summer is wide open for scheduling.)
I wonder what they’re gonna do with release clauses- Will RBL have to end the season without werner?
This is a particularly funny part of the situation. If the season runs into late July/early August, you could have a situation where transfers have already happened but UEFA institutes a rule that all players who transfer after July 1 must be loaned back to their previous club until the end of competitive games for the prior season.
Except that won’t work in all situations. Players who are out of contract on June 30 are simply out of contract, period. No way does a forced extension hold up under European labor law. They can sign anywhere. And players transferring in from outside of Europe … you can make them ineligible to play until the subsequent season, but teams would still be paying them. And because the current season is still going, they can’t sell all the players they ordinarily would to finance those incoming transfers. They’d have to pay both at once.
I saw one writer suggest wrapping two seasons together: the last few games of this year are also the first few games of next year, just cancel promotion and relegation for a year so the leagues all stay the same. This would let both seasons be played out completely with fewer total games. And he’s right about that and I love the solution. It has two problems. First, the TV revenue clawbacks would be awful, that’s 10-12 games lost from that contract. Second, it would make transfers almost impossible to figure out.
the funniest thing was karen brady immediately walking back her “void the season” comments when it was made clear that west ham would be owing a LOT of money
Apparently UEFA has a solution to contracts that no one’s seen or can talk about /rolls eyes
To be clear I don’t actually think the BL is going to get back for May 1, dukewinslow seems right about that. But they have a chance of getting *something* in, and I don’t buy that about any US sports that start before fall (I’m skeptical about those, too).
I don’t get it. There’s nothing wrong with optimism. We need that right now. If the optimists are wrong, so be it, but mentally we need something to look forward to. I’m really tired of the optimist shaming going on in all corners of the web.
Yes, there is.
holy crap lol you kids
I think an increasingly reasonable scenario involves a June start date with games being played in a centralized location (likely AZ) until a late July All Star Game, with that event being the kick off for having fans in the seats. As far as the playoff format, I expect MLB to test the format it floated earlier, but a 1981-style format might work the best (55 games in two self contained halves).
I don’t see fans in the seats until there’s a vaccine. Even if they relax the full on quarantine, social distancing is here to stay.
Yeah, its hard to see fans in seats anytime soon. The reality is that enough money comes from TV rights to make the season worth playing, and if you even assume attendance is down by half (which it will be due to virus fears), it won’t make sense to keep stadiums open.
If government stepped back, I’d guess there’s a sizable minority that would go to games. Especially if teams offered discounted seats. Attendance would be down across board but fans would go tomorrow if they scheduled games and allowed it.
Before an Opening Day in any form can be contemplated, the following question must be answered: What happens in the event of a positive test for one of the participants?
I suspect the answer to that question at the moment when there’s neither immunity nor vaccination on our side, is that, at a minimum, the team needs to be quarantined for 14 days and essentially removed from the competition and at maximum, the whole thing is shut down. If that’s the answer, you can’t start the season. Until a positive test can be dealt with without shutting down a team or league, there really no hope for team sports.
I imagine all teams will be required to proactively quarantine to avoid contact with the non-baseball world as much as possible and which would be easier will centralized games. Put everyone in the same W hotel and keep that baby clean. At some point this summer the populace will likely become more comfortable with the risks of the disease (even death) as we have more information, particularly in respect of how many asymptomatic cases there may be. The players are going to want to make some money eventually.
I’d like more choices on the very last question. I’d expect shorter series.
It was no games two weeks ago, and it’s still no games. No games! I’m sorry, it sucks, but they are not going to find a way to make this work.
You’re right, they won’t find a way to make this work. But they’ll try anyway and be forced to abort.
This is my guess. I think they will play games, but not sure they will get to a postseason.
I voted no season and then stopped voting because I don’t see the point of speculating on the rest. But hypothetically for there to be a season, I think a few things have to be true.
1. Games have to be played without fans and with minimal travel. No fans means stadium size doesn’t matter and spring training complexes are perfect for minimizing travel.
2. Everyone involved has to be quarantined together. Players, coaches, scouts, medical and training staff, food service, TV production crews, transportation, etc. Probably need 40-man rosters from the beginning with no minor league involvement.
3. The season needs to be short enough that it basically provides no real reflection of player value at all (40-50 games) *or* it needs to start in the middle of summer. If they’re using spring training facilities, that means playing outdoors in Arizona and/or Florida in July if we’re lucky. Could work, but would offer its own dangers.
4. The reason it would need to start that early if it goes to 75-80 games is the very first positive test would mean shutting down the whole league for a couple weeks.
5. With such a short season, you can’t just shut down 1-2 teams; there wouldn’t be time to make up the games lost. So games would have to run until mid-winter. This really squeezes winter ball, winter meetings, and spring training into a tiny little window.
6. The league would have to do the math and conclude that the revenue gained from playing and airing these games would be greater than the operational costs of repeated startups/shutdowns, increased medical costs and security, figuring out new ways to handle TV coverage and media availabilities, etc. And the media revenue would be clawed back in a lot of cases by companies who feel like they’re not getting bang for their buck because they also can’t plan around the shutdowns that will come at a couple points.
7. The states in question don’t themselves reach a state of emergency severe enough to make trying to manage this impossible. That’s not any kind of guarantee yet.
Maybe I’m wrong about some of that. But that’s my starting point for a season to exist. I don’t see it.
This sounds about right. There are so many things that need to go right for a season to happen.
Good, realistic summation.
The down voting is absurd. This is a very well constructed presentation of the situation and deserves to be judged on its merits and not ridiculed.
There’s a guy who has 150 burner accounts and proxy-voted everything he didn’t like into oblivion. His original comment was that “coronavirus is a hoax” and is gone now, but the downvotes from his account remains. You may remember him…he’s a very, very disgruntled Phillies fan who has had a few different usernames here.
I would love to see baseball played, but I suspect that we probably won’t see a season this year. Even playing an isolation schedule in a couple of locations with teams quarantined is going to be a logistic nightmare. Neither Florida or AZ are really hospitable in the heat of summer (especially AZ which routinely is in the triple digits heat wise), and that’s just the weather. (I’d expect any schedule to be 100% night games starting 8pm local to make it tolerable at all)
On the medical side you’re going to have protocols in place to test everybody involved, and it’s only meaningful if the testing is happening weekly or bi-weekly. That’s going to amount to thousands of C19 tests over the course of a season and try selling that to the public while the media is hammering the message that we don’t have enough test kits to go around. Any positive tests will trigger new testing for anybody they were in contact with… and then there’s the additional isolation of players, etc. When all is said and done, it would not surprise me if all amateur/collegiate/pro sports were curbed until there’s a viable C19 vaccine available.
The real answer is that even health experts don’t know. There is so much mis-information and poor understanding of the health risks involved in this pandemic. Makes it very hard to form an educated opinion.
I’m curious as to how 29% of people think that there won’t be baseball this year, yet only 23% think that 0 games will be played. #incongruity
Folks stopped answering after the first question.
I’ve been of the mind that we were going to get baseball in June or July but I’m now incredibly pessimistic about that happening. I used to be optimistic because I thought that COVID-19 wouldn’t transmit well in warm, humid weather, yet it still seem to be doing that even in places that do have warm, humid weather. I thought we’d get a break in the summer and it would come back in September. But now that’s out the window.
The fact is, we have no way to control this thing aside from shutting everything down. Too many states clamped down way too late (most of the states not on the west coast, actually–including New York) and now it’s out there and the genie is never going back in the bottle.
The only way this nightmare ends (1) if we have a test-and-trace program or (2) an effective anti-viral treatment, and they have to be on the scale of a 300-million person country.
Do you think those things happen in time to rescue baseball? I’m just not seeing it. Manufacturing the right number of antivirals is going to take a herculean effort, one that states cannot compel manufacturers to do. In terms of testing, MA will be ready to go. at some point soon. Maybe New York and Washington. But there are other states like Florida, Missouri, and Georgia which literally just got around to the cancel-everything stage, and it’s going to be a while before their tests are up and running. When large chunks of the country are going to be either in lockdown or violently ill, it’s going to be hard to do much.
If the Covid-19 is present in Singapore then heat and humidity is no deterrent to the virus being viable in what is usually the most inhospitable of climates for similar diseases. While I want to see baseball and golf return it appears very difficult to see that happening before a vaccine is available universally and the disease is manageable. What level of control is going to be acceptable to renew life as we knew it is a question that nobody can even venture a guess on.
So it’s funny, right after I posted this an article came out showing that humidity and heat *does* slow the rate of transmission. So maybe it does…but who knows if that was “enough.”
There is a possibility of it coming back if an antiviral already cleared by the FDA is shown to have strong effects on COVID-19, and can be mass-produced so we have millions and millions of doses available. So imagine that Tamiflu magically worked on COVID-19 (it doesn’t, but pretend for the moment it does); if you can ramp up production of Tamiflu enough you don’t have to hide from the virus anymore. The key is that it has to be a medicine already proven to be safe by the FDA, and it has to be widely available. New vaccines and antivirals are going to take too long to determine if they’re safe.
Given that our pathways to having a season are (1) we have a magical breakthrough where an existing medication has an antiviral effect on this virus, (2) we somehow are able to expand our testing capacity dramatically (current is 100K, we may need 20 million or more COVID-19 tests a day), or (3) we have to enforce a quarantine on thousands of workers, I’m thinking that #1 is a lot more likely than #2, which is about a thousand times more likely than #3.
It would be more realistic to move the league to South Korea.
I anticipate games starting, but there being a very high chance of everything coming to a screeching halt as a second wave hits.
That perspective doesn’t seem to be able to get across by answering the questions here. I’d guess we get 26-50 games in July and August, but no playoffs and no resolution to the season. I hope I’m wrong!
Your poll didn’t provide an option for the scenario I envision.
Games will get underway either the end of June or in July. However, in relatively short order, under one month, someone will test positive and then another and the season will be cancelled. No playoffs.
Golf already went through that scenario. The Players Championship completed one round then abandoned the tournament. In chess, the Challenger’s Tournament, played in Russia under rigorous safety controls, was scheduled for 14 rounds to be played in a three week time frame in March but was abandoned at the half-way point
Here’s my looney tunes, high-risk idea. All players (at least 40 per team), coaches, umpires, staff, etc. (and maybe even their immediate family members) who are in low-risk groups gathers in AZ at the beginning of May and are kept in isolation — but they all get exposed to the ‘rona when they get there. For the next several weeks, they can get treatment as needed if they experience any symptoms (which many of them won’t) and do spring training activities if their breathing is not impaired. They don’t have to worry about social distancing or washing their hands or wearing masks because they will all already have been exposed.
Given that only low-risk populations would be involved, this intentional exposure would be unlikely to result in any significant excess strain on the health care system in AZ, especially since MLB will have the resources to provide additional supplies/equipment to augment what is already available in AZ.
After 6 weeks or so, enough people will have worked through any symptoms and be recovered, that regular season games can start by early June, with everyone involved hopefully being immune from re-infection so that games can be played without weird distancing rules. I have no idea if a 6-week time frame is realistic for recovery, but you wouldn’t need 100% recovery, especially if you started with 40+ rosters at the beginning of the exposure period, in which case you’d have some cushion if a few players did not fully recover during that time frame.
You still couldn’t have fans in the stands, but games could be played without worrying about having to shut everything down if one person got infected, since everyone would have already been exposed.
This plan would obviously never be implemented. There are plenty of players, coaches,umpires, staff, etc., who are older and/or have underlying health issues. And not everyone in low-risk groups will want to take that risk. And if someone who was intentionally exposed died as a result, the loss of life would not easily be forgiven and there would be huge liability issues.
I know it’s as crazy as those chicken pox parties that some people have to intentionally expose their kids to the chicken pox so they’ll be immune later. But if we’re thinking outside the box ….
Enough is enough. These polls and articles of what if scenarios are just plain dumb. Don’t get me wrong I love America’s Pastime but I think everyone needs to be realistic here. It’s a Virus that spreads by just about any human function. breathing, talking, coughing.. touch. It’s the largest Deadly Virus in our lifetime ( not flu doesn’t count Trumpsters) but yet people can’t put there heads around or open there eyes about it. Oh yes, Sports must go on, the economy must go on, voting must go on… Its a FN Pandemic people lets just beat the curve, do our part on staying at home and social distancing, than when all said and done we can talk about non essential things like sports!
I thought there’d be no baseball this year, but it was more of a gut thing. After reading your excellent analysis about the Arizona situation, I’m now certain there will be no baseball this year. It’s a huge shame, since baseball is the only thing left in life I enjoy, but time and logistics are not on baseball’s side here. Thousands of people are needed to put on a MLB season, and once a few of the guys get the virus, everything will grind to a halt. Virus carriers being asymptomatic for so long means by the time a player starts to get sick, he has already spread it throughout the clubhouse.
Unless the models are overestimating the virus’ longevity, or a vaccine is fast-tracked at a speed greater than anything before it, baseball in 2020 is an impossibility.
Though I’m not a disease related scientist, I work at a major gov lab and the sense I get is that people are bullish on things improving in May, taking June to remain cautious, and resuming some activities in July. Based on that I’m all in on the half-season idea as the most common scenario for a realistic optimist.
We just need y’all to use some damn masks and gloves and be careful now, k? Most importantly, convince your stubborn friends and family to do the same.
Until there is the ability to continual testing of both the players and fans, you can forget it. And you can bet the Governors in Ca., NY and Washington will never go along with anything less. I want to see baseball as often as anybody, but thats the way it will go as long as there aren’t enough tests in the US. Right now, less than 1% of Americans have been tested. And, MiLB is not happening no matter what MLB is able to do.