In-Game Update: Pujols and the Value of a Foul Ball
Just minutes ago, during the Cardinals-Mets game currently unfolding in Queens, Albert Pujols hit a home run off of Jonathon Niese. The home run is notable because (a) it came at the end of a nine-pitch at-bat and (b) SNY’s Gary Cohen noted after the foul ball you see GIF’d and expertly embedded above that good hitters are good at fouling off two-strike pitches.
In fact, Cohen’s words were prescient, as, two pitches later, Pujols did this to the baseball:
You needn’t see the rest of the video to get a sense of where that ball landed, but I’ll tell you anyway: really far from home plate.
Though this one instance is obviously isolated, it serves as an entree for some interesting reading — specifically of a piece that Pizza Cutter (Russell A. Carleton) did for MVN back in the mist-covered days of sabermetrics (i.e. 2008). In it, Carleton looks at what does and does not denote skill in foul-balling.
The basic results? Poorer hitters hit more foul balls in 0- and 1-strike counts; better hitters hit more fouls in 2-strike counts. But there’s plenty more there, too.
Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.




I’ve been asking this question in chats for like two weeks. Thank you for this post.
Why does Jonathon Niese keep throwing Albert that low breaking ball? He’s fouled it off like 30 times now, and I’m starting to believe that he’ll never miss it.
Better than the high breaking ball. By my count Pujols has hit 47 home runs today. Wow. Guy’s good.
I think that’s a cutter. Hard to make out the velocity, but it looks like 88.
When this baby hits 88 MPH, you’re going to see some serious $#!+
Couldn’t resist the temptation to respond with the “Back to the Future” reference, which seems somewhat appropriate here.
“The basic results? Poorer hitters hit more foul balls in 0- and 1-strike counts; better hitters hit more fouls in 2-strike counts.”
I read the article and it doesn’t say that at all. It says more fouls in 2-strike counts usually means a higher contact percentage, more singles and fewer strikeouts, but it also has a negative correlation with walks and home runs. Fouls in 0 or 1 strike counts is correlated with more home runs.
Yes, this. A better summary would be: “The basic results? High-risk, high-reward players hit more foul balls in 0- and 1-strike counts; low-risk, low-reward players hit more fouls balls in 2-strike counts.”
The article is really just a different way of looking at another fact we’ve known for a long time, which is that strikeouts correlate with plus power.
This is sheer awesomeness for the simple fact that that is me in the front row right above the Citi sign.