Matt Klaassen Fangraphs Chat – 7/21/11





Matt Klaassen reads and writes obituaries in the Greater Toronto Area. If you can't get enough of him, follow him on Twitter.

7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
James
15 years ago

If the Rays deal Kotchman, who might play first base for them? Damon?…DanJo?…Joyce?

BipMember since 2016
15 years ago

Ok, seriously guys, how do I ask a question in one of these chats?

noseeum
15 years ago
Reply to  Bip

They usually start around noon. If you’re here at that time, than the interface if different. If you come at 2, it’s done and the replay is here to read.

BipMember since 2016
15 years ago
Reply to  noseeum

That’s what I assumed. And you mean noon ET right? Damn, I have to wake up at 9 AM.

noseeum
15 years ago

When evaluating VOSCAR+, I think you really have to change the “positions”. So Jeter’s replacement should be “other team captain” or “most famous guy on team”. You have to compare him to people like Pujols and so forth. Jeter should get some bonus points for being fairly unattractive and still getting seriously play, but he’s got a high bar to clear being captain of the most famous franchise in sports.

Along these lines, crappy pitchers shouldn’t be compared to team aces. They should only be compared to other crappy pitchers.

And ugly crappy pitchers. Now they have a low floor, giving them huge upside VOSCAR+ potential.

This all leads to Brad Penny having to be a clear cut VOSCAR+ stud. Alyssa Milano? Eliza Dushku? Now marrying Karina Smirnoff? I don’t even know how you do it, but hats off to you, Brad Penny.

Matt
15 years ago
Reply to  noseeum

Brad Penny is an excellent call. He definitely gets my nod. I also think VOSCAR should adjust for the market/team you play for. If you’re in LA you have a better chance at hooking up with a celeb(Like Penny did when he was there and recently Kemp with Rihanna), same thing in NY, so if you can pull off a hot celeb while playing for a smaller market team that should be worth major bonus points.

TheGrandslamwichMember since 2020
15 years ago

The chat needed more Sweet Chen Music, and I agree that Penny is the VOSCAR+ front runner.

Good stuff!