Aaron Judge Milestone Homer Odds Update: When Will He Hit No. 60?

Another series, another bundle of home runs for Aaron Judge. The Yankees’ superstar has set a scorching pace this September, and on Sunday, he hit his 58th and 59th home runs in a victory over the Brewers. As is customary, I’ve updated our game-by-game odds of him reaching his 60th, 61st, and 62nd home runs in a given game the rest of the season. If you want to see Judge tying Babe Ruth, tying Roger Maris, or leaving every previous Yankees (and American Leaguer) in the dust with 62, you can see our predictions below.
One note: I’ve added a few bells and whistles to this projection to handle Judge’s rest situation. The Yankees have been more aggressive than I expected in terms of getting him into games this September. To reflect that, I’ve changed the way I handle an off day. Previously, I set a specific day and simply gave Judge no plate appearances that day. As we’re getting closer to that scheduled off day, and closer to some milestones, that deterministic way of handling a day off feels wrong to me.
Instead, I’ve created a stochastic Aaron Boone in my simulation. Starting with the second game of the Boston series, the fourth game in a run of nine games in nine days, Boone will consider giving Judge a rest. More specifically, there’s a 10% chance he’ll give him a rest in each game of the Boston series and each game of the subsequent Toronto series. After Judge has received one rest day, though, Boone won’t give him another for the remainder of the season. That works out to a 60% chance of a rest day in aggregate: 10% in each of the last three games of the Boston series and 10% in each game in Toronto. There’s no way of knowing if this is exactly right or not, but I think it comes close to reflecting how Boone will handle Judge.
With that in mind, here’s the distribution of when Judge hits his 60th home run, as obtained by simulating the remainder of the season a million times. If you want to see that one, get to the Bronx with haste:
| Day | Opponent | Home/Away | Odds of Hitting 60th HR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9/20 | Pittsburgh | Home | 29.6% |
| 9/21 | Pittsburgh | Home | 20.9% |
| 9/22 | Boston | Home | 15.3% |
| 9/23 | Boston | Home | 9.6% |
| 9/24 | Boston | Home | 7.0% |
| 9/25 | Boston | Home | 5.1% |
| 9/26 | Toronto | Away | 4.0% |
| 9/27 | Toronto | Away | 2.7% |
| 9/28 | Toronto | Away | 1.9% |
| 9/30 | Baltimore | Home | 1.2% |
| 10/1 | Baltimore | Home | 0.9% |
| 10/2 | Baltimore | Home | 0.6% |
| 10/3 | Texas | Away | 0.3% |
| 10/4 | Texas | Away | 0.2% |
| 10/4 (DH) | Texas | Away | 0.2% |
| 10/5 | Texas | Away | 0.1% |
Reaching 60 is now more a formality than a question. In fact, Judge’s odds of hitting 60, 61, and 62 are all extremely high, even compared to the already-elevated chances of hitting those milestones that I calculated last week:
| Feat | Odds on 9/14 | Odds on 9/19 |
|---|---|---|
| 60+ Homers | 96.8% | 99.6% |
| 61+ Homers | 90.9% | 97.3% |
| 62+ Homers | 80.8% | 90.9% |
Onward, then, to 61. In aggregate, there’s nearly a 50% chance that he’ll hit that one against the rival Red Sox:
| Day | Opponent | Home/Away | Odds of Hitting 61st HR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9/20 | Pittsburgh | Home | 4.0% |
| 9/21 | Pittsburgh | Home | 10.4% |
| 9/22 | Boston | Home | 13.4% |
| 9/23 | Boston | Home | 11.9% |
| 9/24 | Boston | Home | 11.0% |
| 9/25 | Boston | Home | 9.7% |
| 9/26 | Toronto | Away | 9.2% |
| 9/27 | Toronto | Away | 7.4% |
| 9/28 | Toronto | Away | 5.8% |
| 9/30 | Baltimore | Home | 4.1% |
| 10/1 | Baltimore | Home | 3.3% |
| 10/2 | Baltimore | Home | 2.5% |
| 10/3 | Texas | Away | 1.6% |
| 10/4 | Texas | Away | 1.2% |
| 10/4 (DH) | Texas | Away | 1.0% |
| 10/5 | Texas | Away | 0.8% |
In fact, Judge has set such a blistering pace in the past week that the Toronto series, once the best bet of seeing all three of his 60th, 61st, and 62nd home runs, is barely hanging on to its status as the series with the highest chance of seeing the Maris-beating 62nd. Barely hanging on is still hanging on, though; if you can only attend one game or one series, you should book a ticket for Toronto:
| Day | Opponent | Home/Away | Odds of Hitting 62nd HR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9/20 | Pittsburgh | Home | 0.3% |
| 9/21 | Pittsburgh | Home | 2.3% |
| 9/22 | Boston | Home | 5.4% |
| 9/23 | Boston | Home | 7.2% |
| 9/24 | Boston | Home | 8.5% |
| 9/25 | Boston | Home | 9.1% |
| 9/26 | Toronto | Away | 10.1% |
| 9/27 | Toronto | Away | 9.7% |
| 9/28 | Toronto | Away | 8.7% |
| 9/30 | Baltimore | Home | 6.9% |
| 10/1 | Baltimore | Home | 6.2% |
| 10/2 | Baltimore | Home | 5.2% |
| 10/3 | Texas | Away | 3.6% |
| 10/4 | Texas | Away | 3.0% |
| 10/4 (DH) | Texas | Away | 2.6% |
| 10/5 | Texas | Away | 2.1% |
This is all subject to change, obviously. The Yankees have an off day tomorrow, but that’s been the only sure way to keep Judge off the board recently. Just for fun, I ran a few versions of higher numbers that Judge could theoretically reach. Per my numbers, he has a 45% chance of reaching the 65-homer plateau, a monumental tally. He has a 1.7% chance of reaching 70, which seemed unthinkable even at the start of the month. And I had to see how likely it was that he’d match Barry Bonds’ all-time record of 73 homers. It’s not likely, obviously; in fact, it only happened 780 times out of a million simulations — .08%, in other words. That rounds to never, but it’s notably not zero.
If you’d told me at the start of the year that someone stood any chance at all of matching Bonds, I wouldn’t have believed you. Judge’s 2022 season has been so good that he’s waking up the echoes of Bonds at his best. I don’t think there’s any better way to describe Judge’s season than to say that he’s bringing back the home run chase era of the early 2000s, all on his own.
Ben is a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @benclemens.


With the record now highly in reach, I’m now wondering what the odds are that Judge finishes the year with an fWAR over 10.
Based on ZiPs, he’s probably got a 99% shot of finishing above 10. He’s already at 10.4.
Looking at Judge’s player page, his 2022 fWAR totals right around what he racked up for the 2.37 seasons from 2019 through 2021. The Yankees rate to be fools if they go to the $320 million-plus Judge is rumored to be asking for. Paying through the nose for career years especially when you owe Stanton and Cole an average of $65m for each of 2025, 2026, and 2027, is asking for trouble.
It’ll be interesting, anyway.
Eh, he’s their best player by a mile. Who are they going to replace him with? A not as good Carlos Correa who would command ~30M per year anyways? Just pay him. You’re the Yankees. If you’re going to let your homegrown player who’s a top 5 player in baseball, what are you doing?
Good question for the Red Sox on Mookie Betts…
If we’re going to knock him for only being an 11 war player over a 270 game stretch, shouldn’t we at least acknowledge the historic seasons that occurred just before and after this cherry picked time frame? He’s been a 35+ million dollar player ever since his sophomore campaign and that should continue for at least a few more seasons.
Nearly 100%?
The leaderboard on the fangraphs app has him at 10.4 currently
a player can produce negative WAR. if he went into a massive slump to end the season he could finish under 10.
Right. Hence nearly 100%.
i’m silly, i read your comment as a reply to sadtrombone and thought you were questioning why it was only 99% /facepalm
Are we really talking about “the AL record,” as if that’s a thing after interleague play?
Think of it as a polite way of saying “non-PED” record.
We have AL MVPs, CY Award winners, batting champions, and triple crown winners, so I don’t see why not.
All of FG’s projection systems have Judge finishing with 11+ WAR.
As far as fWAR goes I think the real question is going to be whether he can top Mickey Mantle’s 56-57 seasons for the best post-integration season of all time, non-steroids Barry Bonds division. That would be 11.4 and 11.5 fWAR.
This is pretty much my standard for evaluating the greats as well–post-integration, non-steroids division.
I will, however, nominate Pedro Martinez as the guy to beat. He has an 11.6 fWAR season (and if you are against fWAR for pitchers for whatever reason you so desire, he also has an 11.7 bWAR season too). Absolutely savage.
As to whether Judge could beat that? I’m sure if I had the formula in an Excel spreadsheet I could calculate that out, but if he merely keeps going in every game doing what he has this season, he’ll wind up at 11.6 fWAR. So he really only needs to play slightly above his current level to get to 11.7.
What’s the ceiling? Well, consider that yesterday he put up somewhere in the neighborhood of 0.5 fWAR in just one game. Let’s just say he puts up roughly that same value across two games instead of one (so, half that value per game). Seems pretty close to impossible, but if he does that over the remaining 16 games left he’ll add another 4 wins and 14.4 fWAR (!!!!), giving him literally the second highest fWAR of all time behind Babe Ruth’s 1923. And if he hits 16 homers over 16 games, then he’ll hit 75 homers, breaking the all-time home run record as well.
Sticking with Pedro we could also use his 12.2 RA9-WAR instead of the 11.7 bWAR. I think the major difference is a lack of a defensive adjustment, and I’d be hesitant on the accuracy of a defensive adjustment using modern defensive stats. Whatever kind of adjustment is being applied to a pitcher from 1999 would be even less reliable.
Martinez played in the steroids era
And Pedro wasn’t a saint…. there was more than just steroids available.
I love the Pedro comment. In my view he is the only pitcher to have a five year period equal to or better than Koufax and he did it in a hitter park during the peak of the homer era.
So, just for funsies, I did some quick math to figure out what Judge’s batting line would have to look like for him to get down to 10.0 WAR on the nose to complete the season. FWIW, I used the 66 PA he is projected to accumulate on the depth charts and assumed his non-batting runs stay the same, which is not really that huge of an assumption, his batting runs are a much larger magnitude than his other contributors. I also considered him to have 2 IBB and 0 SF for the remainder of the season, which is his current pace. A small assumption, but just for completeness.
For reference, his current triple slash is .316/.419/.701 with a wOBA of .461. He would have to lose nearly four batting runs to adequately reduce his WAR to 10.0, which works out to a wOBA of .233, somewhere in the Tucker Barnhart range this year. I simply took the ratio of this wOBA to his current wOBA and the number of PA to his current PA, and this produced a line of four singles, one double, three HR, and four unintentional walks over his remaining 66 PA. This is a slash line of .145/.230/.327 and a .233 wOBA. If you look at Judge’s 15 game rolling average (his projected number of remaining games) over the last six seasons, his lowest wOBA is .245 for a 15 game stretch.
So yes, it is highly unlikely that he finishes the season with less than 10 WAR.
And still hits 62
Ha, yeah, I noticed that too. The guy is having a ridiculous season.
Also, he’s doing all this while being a roughly average outfielder, playing more than half of his innings in CF. This season is an all-timer.
The idea of a visual plot came up in the comments of the previous update.
Here’s an update to the stacked chart that I posted there with the new odds:
https://imgur.com/0mScXvo
Sorry, link broke when I updated, try here instead:
https://imgur.com/a/iiQfTye
Thank you Ben! Given the blistering pace he’s setting I wouldn’t be surprised if he doesn’t make it to Toronto, but the cost for Yankees tickets is pretty high for anything other than a not-so-great ticket, plus the general costs of NY. Still tickets available, but I’d guess that Boston series is going to sell out, no?
So I’m headed to the SkyDome! (errr, Rogers Centre?). Couldn’t get there in time for the beginning of the series and had to talk to a bunch of my coworkers and family members to make it work (with some of them coming with me!). But I’ll get at least one game, maaaybe two.
Anyone else going to any games? Would love to have eyes on the ground at other games so I can live vicariously through you if he breaks it somewhere else.
I wonder how much ticket prices for left field and left center field have spiked in the last couple of weeks.
The secondary market for the upcoming home games are off the charts.
A complete list of players who’ve finished a season (since 1900) with a higher wRC+ than Judge’s current mark: Bonds, Hornsby, Mantle, Ruth, Williams.
That’s absolutely insane. According to fangraphs depth charts, Judge is expected to finish with the 9th best batting season since 1947:
https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=all&stats=bat&lg=all&qual=y&type=6&season=2022&month=0&season1=1947&ind=1&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0&startdate=1947-01-01&enddate=2022-12-31&sort=4,d
Only Mickey Mantle, Ted Williams, Stan Musial, Mark Mcguire, and Barry Bonds will have put up better seasons.
It’s possible that Judge does even better than his projection though.
Ever see one of the bored, big kids wander into a sandlot game of nine-year olds, insist on playing, insist on getting pitched to, then watch him knock the ball over a distant stand of trees, past the highway, so high and so far that no one even bothers to look for the ball?
That’s what Judge’s 2022 season feels like.
Last year, I think it was, T-Mobile ran an ad with Judge and Stanton, where Judge is giving Stanton advice on the phone but on a “bad” network. So he interprets it as going to a little league game and crushing the pitchers there to get his confidence up.
So yeah, Judge is doing that with major league pitchers right now.
Judge is already at 10.4 fWAR, and is projected to finish the year by ZiPs at 11.2, which would be a top-20 season for a position player for all time no matter how you slice it. The only players who have ever put up an 11.2 fWAR season or higher are Babe Ruth, Ted Williams, Barry Bonds, Rogers Hornsby, Ty Cobb, Jimmie Fox, Mickey Mantle, and Pedro Martinez. And there are asterisks on basically all of them (either due to competition being excluded or steroid use) except for Mantle and Pedro. If Judge actually finishes this year at 11.2, there’s an argument to be made that this should be one of the top 3-5 most celebrated individual seasons in major league history. We are watching something truly crazy unfold.
You missed Gehrig and Honus Wagner.
Ah nuts, I knew I left someone off!
You also missed Steve Carlton in 1972 (.5 oWAR) and Bob Gibson in 1970 (1.4 oWAR!!!) and Fergie Jenkins in 1971 (1.6 oWAR!!!!).
Clearly what we need is for the combined WAR leaderboards to be able to display all years at once.
I wouldn’t mind if we stopped using asterisks.
it’s noteworthy that Judge has now led off the last 8 games for the Yankees. I’m willing to bet this will continue until both the HR record and the Yankees’ playoff position have been clinched. It doesn’t hurt that Judge has hit ridiculously well hitting from the top spot.
Judge has basically not stopped hitting all season, but this September stretch is ridiculous. Even when he’s not hitting HR, he’s bashing singles and doubles all over the place.
Sept thus far: 15 G, 5 2B, 8 HR, 14 RBI, 18 R, .491/.586/1.018 for a 1.604 OPS with a downright hilarious .594 BAbip.
He was also the first player in the statcast era to hit 5 barrels in one game. Also the only player with 5 batted balls >110mph exit velocity.
I also do feel a little bit for Shohei Ohtani. Not only is he playing on yet another bad team, he’s put up 8.7 fWAR so far this year and ZiPs thinks he’ll finish at about 9.4, which would give him an MVP in basically any year. But not this year.
So Ohtani really does have a decent shot of putting up the greatest second-best season of all time. If I were a voter there I think it’s I’d vote for Ohtani even though I think Verlander has a better statistical case, since I don’t think the case is overwhelming. It’s truly nuts that Ohtani is doing this and he’s probably not winning the MVP.
I continue to curse the Angels for wasting generational talents in Ohtani and Trout. It is frustrating watching them produced elite performances year after year for a team that cannot surround them with complementary talent.
But, I wouldn’t feel too bad for Ohtani missing out on his second consecutive MVP. This is what we want as fans, several worthy contenders pushing the limits of what we projected as possible in a chase for the crown. It is so much more enjoyable than watching a single player lap the field, or having to settle for a candidate that manages to distinguish themselves from a field of good, but not truly elite seasons.
Why curse the Angels for ‘wasting’ Trout? It was Trout who chose to stay with the Angels, wasting (if that’s your measure) the last 5 seasons of his career, iirc.
Two players had over 10 fWAR in 1961: Mickey Mantle, and… Norm Cash, who hit .361/.487/.662 over 672 plate appearances. Cash later admitted to using a corked bat that season.
I didn’t know that about Cash! That explains why he never came close to that again.
Like Sosa and his corked bat, he was just trying to Cash in on the power craze of the early 60s…
It’s not clear corked bats help.
Years on, people may look at the near unbroken streak of MVP awards Ohtani won beginning in 2021 and wonder what happened in 2022, and then realize, oh, that was Judge’s year. Seriously, the fact that Ohtani is still in the conversation with a year like Judge is having is a credit to Ohtani and a reminder of what it’s probably going to take to beat him in future MVP votes. Ohtani is in his peak years now, so if he stays healthy, he’ll be tough to beat.
Honestly don’t think it’s close with Ohtani tbh. Judge leads by 1.7 WAR. If we’re giving Ohtani serious consideration just rename it to the Ohtani award and be done with it.
Perhaps, but there’s a good chance we’ve seen Ohtani’s peak. He’ll be 28 next season, and his ability to pitch and hit like this and do both as often as he does—which is what puts him in the MVP conversation—has everything to do with his recovery time, which is not likely to be increasing year to year.
I don’t think you can take him out of the lineup right now; not at least until you’ve clinched the division.
It’s gonna go: 62, clinch, serious load management.
Hope it’s not that serious on the load management. Yanks will have the bye and plenty of rest upcoming. Give me maximum Judge!
So, whats his contract gonna be and for who??
I would guess it would be for the Yankees. There will be a lot of pressure to retain him after this season and no one else will be willing to spend the kind of money the Yankees will give him. It will probably be a massive overpay. Maybe $370 million for 10 yrs.
I don’t know. Maybe that’s way over what they’ll offer. It’s going to be fun watching the contract talks though!
$370 Million for 10 yrs would contain a lot of risk for the signing team, but I would hesitate to call it a massive overpay. Also, the Yankees are not the only team that would be willing to throw that dollar amount (at least on an AAV level) around to sign Judge long-term.
Personally, I do think it breaks down to about a 60% chance that the Yankees extend him, and a 40% for the rest of the field to sign him. I do think that due to his age, getting 10 years may be a tough ask. I think the offers may cap out at 8, with club options.
You’re right. $370 mil for 10 years could be a steal! Whichever team signs him will have to take on a large amount of risk, probably. Risk is a more appropriate term.
Understanding full well the age gap and the differences in expectations based on that, I would rather owe $370 million to Aaron Judge than $340 million to Fernando Tatis Jr.
Hear, hear!
Yeah, I think it’ll be the Yankees. Though I do think if some team offers like 10/400, he probably walks. But there’s no fits in the AL for him, I don’t think. In the NL.. Maybe CHC? I don’t see it with them letting their old core go plus they’ve got Happ and Suzuki. SF possibly but that’s not Zaidi’s style. He sticks to short term deals typically.
It seems like it’s Yankees or bust, but it takes just one team and it definitely could be another Robinson Cano situation.
The team across town, the Cohen-led Mets, have the money and perhaps the will to steal the Yankees star player. Then again, they have a lot of players to sign too, led by deGrom, and their goal is to build a sustainable winning model. They probably don’t want put that much into one player. The Yankees don’t either, but they may not have a choice. The Yankees offer was very good, yet Judge is now going to blow it away with the greatest walk season ever.
Even signing deGrom, never mind Judge, for a team with a payroll already in the mid-200s, that’s missing a CFer, half of a rotation, and most of a bullpen, that’s already old and getting older, would be a mistake unless Cohen is simply indifferent to a $350m payroll.
It would be one thing if deGrom wanted a huge but incentive laden deal in order to stay in NYC, given how superb he is when he’s able to pitch—but guaranteed money at the rumored $3/135m or 4/180m?
Scherzer won’t get to 150 innings this year. The Mets needed to spend his AAV on the likes of Ray and Rodon, instead, and now they have the Braves running them down. How much sense does it make to add another brilliant, old pitcher at $43-plus million to an extremely iffy rotation for 2023 and 2024?
To be clear, Cohen does seem indifferent to payroll, period.
He did say that he’d like to build a sustainable winner (like Dodgers/Yankees/Astros), implying that he’s not going to run a 300M payroll in perpetuity.
“…and no one else will be willing to spend the kind of money the Yankees will give him.”
Seems to fracture from contradiction, no? What will Judge do if the Yankees aren’t will to go much higher than the second-highest bidder—sit out the year?
10/$370m (in contrast to the 7/$213.5m the Yankees asserted they were offering, for 2023-2029) is lunacy. Imagine your average payroll just for Stanton, Cole, and Judge—all very, very much post-peak by then—is $103 million for each of 2025-2027. The Yankees were already willing to saddle themselves with Judge in those years for $30.5 per, but by going to 10 years and a $37m AAV, they’re also knocking $37m off the payroll they’re willing and able to spend in 2030-32.
That’s a helluva handicap to take on in return for a player who has a pretty good chance of not being able to put 25 WAR on the field over the life of his next and last deal.
The Yankees have a money-printing machine in their 49% interest in the YES Network; they really do not care about payroll except in the most abstract way. They don’t want another Jacoby Ellsbury, but they also really don’t want another Robinson Cano (who, remember, looked extremely worth that contract halfway through it). Judge is the face of the franchise and if they let the best player they’ve developed since Jeter (or arguably Mantle) walk over $10 or $20 million in total value, it will not go over well with the fan base.
The Yankees YES Network this year not only have the highest ratings of any RSN, which isn’t unusual, but they also have their highest ratings in more than a decade. And that doesn’t even include the remaining games, including this week at Yankee Stadium when Judge goes for 60+. The Yankees print money, but Judge makes them print even more. He knows that. He’ll want to get paid not just for his on-field production, but for his business value. He will get paid.
The Yankees are going to have no choice but to overspend on him. He’s going to want to be the highest paid player in baseball… I’m thinking 9 years, $360 million.
Yeah. I think at this point he’s going to get, at least, the highest AAV.
40million AAV isn’t a huge overspend, IMO. Personally, I’d rather give him higher AAV over a shorter time period, just because the Luxury Tax number is going to be insane anyway and I’d prefer to avoid another Miguel Cabrera or A-Rod situation where we are paying a guy 30 mil+ in his 40s.
It’s the Yankees, they can afford it. Especially in 2030 or something when they’re making like 1B a year or something.
Seriously. I’ve been rooting for the Yankees since the 1960s. If Judge is gone, so am I. That man has brought me much happiness during a summer of profound personal loss. It’s silly, I know, but he has helped me to keep going when I didn’t want to.
I am glad he was helpful to you
Thank you, David.
I think the question is: Is there any other team that’s willing to top $300M for a guy whose body type and injury history does not exactly imply he will be a model of health going forward?
Let’s start: There are probably only about 15 teams would be willing to go for a $300M contract for anyone, period. The obvious cases are the Dodgers, Yankees, Mets, Cubs, Giants, Phillies, Rangers, and Padres are the only teams that seem willing to do anything like that, for any player. You could see the Mariners, Astros, Blue Jays, Cardinals, or Rockies if a truly transcendent talent was available at a younger age but otherwise probably not.
In the past we could add the Angels, Tigers, and Nationals, but with ownership changes either in the recent past or coming up I don’t think they will (definitely not the Angels or Nationals, maaaaaybe the Tigers). The Red Sox weren’t willing to give a deal like this to their own star outfielder, hard to see them doing this for someone else’s. Maybe they’d do it for Ohtani. It doesn’t fit the Braves’ or White Sox’s M.O. at all to do this. The Marlins, D-Backs, Brewers, Rays, Twins, Guardians, Pirates, Reds, A’s, or Royals will never give out a contract like this. The Orioles are a bit unknown but they seem a bit unlikely too.
Then you have to have a team that is willing to say, forget about the risk, we need a guy like Judge. Remember, he’s a huge guy with some injuries in his past and he’s not particularly young for a free agent either. So that probably knocks out the Mariners through Rockies group, who would only splurge for a $300M guy if it was the “right” guy. The Cubs aren’t really near contention, so I doubt they’ll do it either. The Dodgers and Giants are pretty actuarial in their approach, so I don’t think they’ll be in for an older FA either. The Padres already have a ton of huge contracts on the books and would be more interested in giving $450M to Soto than $300M to Judge.
That leaves the Yankees, Mets, Phillies, and Rangers, all of whom have massive contracts on the books but tons of revenues and a possible compelling reason to spend. What kind of limits do you think each of those owners will greenlight?
The Rangers just spent a half billion dollars on their middle infield to finish 35 games out of first; I doubt they’re going to be willing to pony up the kind of money it’ll take to sign Judge the very next offseason. The Phillies insanely already have $65 million a year for the next 3 years tied up in outfielders with Harper, Castellanos, and Schwarber (with Castellanos signed for 4 more years and Harper a bunch more than that), so I can’t see them adding $40 million a year more for Judge.
At the end of the day I think it comes down to San Francisco, Boston, the Yankees, and the Mets. As you say, if Boston was going to sign a big-time outfielder it seems like they would have signed Betts, but they’ll be coming off a last-place finish this season for the second time in the 3 years since they traded Betts, so their priorities might be different. San Francisco has the money and it’s at least theoretically possible that Judge might give a Northern California team a hometown discount. But then it really comes back to the Mets and the Yankees.
I see people are taking into account the injury risk, but no one seems to be considering that Judge may not perform at this level ever again. We see this every year, someone having a fantastic year, and we assume they will continue that performance going forward barring injury.
Remember when Stanton went on a tear to hit 59 homeruns, seemingly one every day at the end of September, and how it felt for the Yankees to get him? That has never happened again, and I imagine that would be so even if he were healthy.
Judge is 30, and he has never had a season like this. Chances are, he will never have another season like it again–he is much more likely to have a 5 win season next year than 10 win. The numbers bear it out time after time.
He’ll almost certainly never perform at this level again. Who has? But over the course of his career, parts of 7 seasons, Judge has averaged 8.1 fWAR/ 162 games. As long as he can stay healthy enough to play 120 games a year, and performs like his 2017-2021 self, he’s worth $40 million / year.
Right, so close to a 5 win season. No doubt 40 million per year, but for how many years? Judge will want that for eight to ten years. You’ve seen projections, they drop off rapidly into the thirties.
Yeah I wouldn’t worry about him returning to his previous level but f performance. If I’m the Yankees I am not worried that Judge returns to being a 5 win player over 400 or 500 PAs because he’s dinged up. That will happen sometimes, no doubt. I’m worried his back or his legs completely crumble and he can’t swing without hurting himself. I think that will probably happen at some point and is the reason why there is no way I’d give him the deal he’s looking for. But the Yankees I think are going to feel a ton of pressure to keep them and maybe in their unique situation it is the right call, even though the chances it will work out are here pretty low.
In any case I’m less interested in whether it’s a good idea and more interested in if teams think it’s a good idea.
“…and would be more interested in giving $450M to Soto…”
A strange business model where a player has a career year and we’re talking about going from $213.5m to $300m-370m, but when a player has an anti-career year there’s little in the way of a deduction.
Soto has proven he’s capable of a very weak year, for him, without apparent injury as the cause. Even before his last 50 games I’ve been wondering why would anyone pay a 5-6 WAR DH close to half a billion dollars.
Soto’s not a free agent until after the 2024 season. Soto has certainly dropped his total earnings potential this year, but if he bounces back and puts up 7-8 WAR next year and the year after, people will forget 2022. If his 2024 looks like his 2022, he’ll be lucky to top $25 million in AAV.
Soto is 7 or 8 years younger than Judge. The chances he outperforms Judge over the next 9 years is very high.
Scherzer has the AAV record at $43.5M. Judge at 8/352 is a $44M AAV. Will the Yankees, or any team, go there? Will they have to? He’ll be 31 next season.
Interesting thing I’m throwing out there and taking no position on one way or another: other than Mookie Betts and Barry Bonds, every single position player who’s ever had a season as good as the season Judge has already put up by fWAR is in the Hall of Fame.
Yeah. I’ve been thinking about Judge and the Hall of Fame recently, also. If he puts up two more All Star seasons (more than 5 WAR), he’ll be comfortably over the 7 year peak JAWS standard.
I have no expertise in this area, but I bet the voters will give him a break on the career standards because of this historical season.
He’ll also got a pretty good shot of passing Mookie Betts too.
I’m a peak over longevity guy for the hall and this is about as ridiculous a season as I’ve ever seen. If he puts up another 8+ win season at some point in the next couple of years (or if his decline is more gentle than I expect, I think he’s going to break at some point soon) in addition to what he’s doing now, he’s a lock for me. And I’d listen even if he doesn’t.
Who are players who had seasons in the last 70 years even close to this who aren’t in the Hall and who don’t have major steroid suspicions / aren’t yet eligible? Norm Cash (1961), Darrell Evans (1973), and Rico Petrocelli (1969) came close, but never reached anything close to that ever again. Jacoby Ellsbury had that one crazy year in 2011 that was way out of his line with everything else he ever did. Al Rosen had a few good years before back injuries ended his career. Even Roger Maris’s year where he hit 61 wasn’t close to this.
But if Judge finishes where his projections say he will (just north off 11 wins) and he puts up another 8+ win next year (just a hypothetical, I don’t care when he does it), he’ll have a three-year peak where he’ll have 30 overall wins via fWAR out of 45 total. And then let’s say injuries sap all his strength and he basically is a barely passable DH, playing just long enough to reach the minimum number of seasons for the HoF before his body totally gives out, leaving him with something like 50 fWAR. Who would vote against that case? Maybe 20% of voters?
It’s really too bad he was robbed of the MVP in 2017 (like seriously, how did he lose lol), with 2 MVPs he’d absolutely be a lock for the HOF even with just 50 total WAR. But at this rate he’ll finish with ~36 this year, then another 20 over the next 6-7 years should be easy with an incremental decline (especially using an ~11 WAR season as his baseline).
>like seriously, how did he lose lol
While a wRC+ 174 fwar 8.8 player losing against wRC+ 160 fwar 7.5 player is baffling,
so would a good baserunning 2B with WPA 3.51 losing against a corner outfielder with WPA 2.10.
2017 Judge had the 3rd most unclutch season since 1974.
I would have voted for Judge even in the absence of the knowledge of Astros cheating and I believe Judge would have had a much better shot if he were not a rookie, but voting for Altuve back then wasn’t as ridiculous as people make it out to be in hindsight.
Also at the time the fWAR numbers were closer, subsequent adjustments have dinged Altuve and helped Judge.
Eh. Still had him beat by almost 1 WAR at the time and had him beat in almost every offensive category except batting average. I just feel if they reversed teams, Judge would’ve won. I mean he hit 52 homers and still lost. There’s a Yankee tax.
“How”? There was guy name of Trout who was still in his prime, taking the luster off of Judge’s OBP and SLG. For WAR there was Altuve before the, you know, and Simba, if you preferred glove gazelles up the middle to corner guys.
You might prefer Judge–it’s certainly understandable. But “robbed”? I wonder if Judge not winning was due to fangraphs’ fWAR either not being available on the site, or not yet considered as or more reliable than rWAR…
More like 80% of the voters. 50 fWAR is extremely low for a HOFer, and the only guys to get in with a number like that are usually considered the mistakes. On the other hand, the number of guys with great years but only 50 fWAR career and who end up on the outside, is far, far larger.
If Judge follows your scenario he’s much more likely imho to follow the Dale Murphy HOF trajectory than whomever it is you think is closest to the specifics and details of the career you’re hypothesizing for Judge and who got in with David Wright’s career WAR total.
There is nobody who’s hit the highs that Judge has, multiple times, and ended up with 50 fWAR. Maybe some deadball pitchers, Joe Wood or whoever. The closest I can think of for a player who played at a superstar level for multiple seasons but had a career too short for HoF consideration is King Kong Keller, and he used to get some support. And at his best he wasn’t as good as Judge.
Just for the purpose of this exercise, I went through and looked up every single player since 1901 who put up at least two seasons of 8.8 fWAR — as Judge does, in 2017 and 2022 — and are not in the Hall of Fame. Here’s the complete list:
Barry Bonds
Roger Clemens
Alex Rodriguez
Joe Jackson
Mike Trout
Snuffy Stirnweiss
That’s it. Mike Trout will go in to the Hall of Fame the moment he is eligible; we all know the deal with Bonds, Clemens, and ARod. Joe Jackson is ineligible because of the Black Sox scandal.
That leaves Snuffy Stirnweiss as the only baseball player in history with two 8.8 fWAR seasons who is not in the Hall of Fame without a very good reason for not being in the Hall of Fame. Stirnweiss is barely eligible for the Hall of Fame; without a single game for the 1952 Cleveland Indians he wouldn’t have played in 10 MLB seasons. His two great seasons were indeed great — he always played all-time-great defense at 2B throughout his career, and in his two seasons over 8.8 fWAR he led the American League both years in runs, hits, 3B, and SB. The problem is that those great seasons came in 1944 and 1945, when most of the best players in baseball were away fighting in World War II. When he won a batting title and led the American League in slugging and OPS in 1945, he hit .309/.385/.476. Immediately after the war ended, Stirnweiss reverted to being what he actually was — a great middle infield glove and not much of a hitter. His third-best season was a 3.4 fWAR season in 1947, on the back of great defense and a .256/.358/.342 line. After 1948 he was never a regular again, and he was out of baseball by age 33. His career fWAR total is 27.8, with 17.9 of that coming in 1944-45 and less than 10 total coming during the other 8 years he played in the majors. He later tragically died in a train accident at age 39 that killed 48 people in New Jersey.
So there simply is no precedent for a player with a peak as great as Judge’s peak not making the Hall of Fame. Not to say that he’s a lock for the Hall or anything, far from it. But you can’t really look to comparable players because he doesn’t have any.
* – I’ll give a shoutout to the player who came closest to joining this group, Sam McDowell, who put up 9.4 fWAR in 1968 and 8.7 fWAR in 1965. McDowell was a legitimately great pitcher, a true ace, who reached the majors at 18 and was one of the best pitchers in baseball from 1965 through 1970, leading the American League in strikeouts in 5 of those 6 years (he also had control problems, leading the AL in walks 5 times). But that would be the end of the line for him as a productive pitcher; at age 27 back and neck injuries, combined with severe alcoholism and contract disputes, led to him bouncing around the league for a couple of years before being bounced out of it at age 32. Notably, he was the basis for the character of Sam Malone in the tv show “Cheers.” He’s probably the closest to the high-peak, 50 career fWAR non-Hall of Famer that you’re thinking of. He’s probably got the dubious distinction of being the best player to never get a single vote for the Hall of Fame.
Excellent overview. Peak will certainly count heavily in Judge’s favor. I believe 70 WAR is generally viewed as pretty much as an automatic entry point, but 50 WAR with very high peak seasons can lead to enshrinement. I don’t believe the OP’s Murphy or Wright comparisons are apt. Neither had years like Judge’s 2017 or 2022. Context is critical; total WAR necessarily is not. BBWAA members can easily see the differences between Judge’s case and Wright’s.
Another item. Let’s say Judge wins the Triple Crown. There has never been a MLB player in the past 100+ years who won the triple crown — live-ball era forward — who wasn’t inducted into the HOF. Joe Medwick might be questionable to some, but not really. He’s even a decent comparison getting back to the 50+ WAR group of HOFers. Medwick’s 54.5 rWAR is on the lower end, but he had a lot of black ink early in his career, including the triple crown, an MVP and several finishes in the top 5. Add in a career 134 OPS+, and he feels quite a home in the HOF once context is provided to the total WAR number. Chuck Klein is another. Didn’t even reach 50 WAR. High peak early, lot of black ink similar to Medwick. When I see a guy winning a triple crown and leading the league in total bases for four straight years, with three straight MVP finishes in first or second, he has my attention. Context. I’m about the history and the peak for the HOF. I could actually make an argument for every single player who won a triple crown going back to the 1800s having a case.
Not Mantle 56 and 57?
Mantle is in the Hall of Fame.
It seems to me that if Boone is going to give him a day off while he’s still pursuing the record, it will be in Toronto. I would think they want to maximize the chance that he breaks the record at home.
If I were managing the team I wouldn’t rest him against the second place team unless the division were locked up. The Yankees almost certainly won’t have clinched by the time they get to Canada so I’m playing him that series.
Agreed. If anything, DH Judge and sit Stanton.
What does a simulation of Judge in Colorado look like? If he has this year for the Rockies (assuming similar at bats, not getting pitcher around, etc) how much would he have had?
Simulation includes lots of injuries running around the cavernous outfield.
And dingers!!!
Per baseball savant, Judge would already have 67 if all of his batted balls were at Coors. He’d also have 67 in Cincinnati. He’d only have 47 in Detroit.
Note: This tells how many of this player’s home runs would have been out of other stadiums. This accounts for different wall heights, distances and environmental effects.
I noted this in Ben’s chat. The Yankee game on Friday is an Apple TV exclusive. A lot of older people do not have Apple TV, and fans in general have not signed up to Apple TV just to watch baseball games. It’ll be a shame if he sets and/or breaks the record on Friday. If I’m Boone looking to give Judge a day off, maybe I pick Friday! Problem is that’s a home game, so he might wait for one of the games in Toronto for his next off day.
As a MLB.TV subscriber, I’m pretty upset about missing critical stretch run games because of Apple TV already.
As a MLB.TV subscriber, I’m upset I have to miss any games. MLB needs to get with the times and make it as easy as possible to watch every game. Customers will stay loyal and even pay extra for ease of use.
I’m with you. I pay for baseball content as is, so it’s frustrating to lose games, particuarly during pennant/postseason races, and potential record-setting/milestone events like Judge and Pujols.
If I could watch every regular season game with no exceptions, I’d be willing to pay more. If I could also watch every postseason game, I’d be willing to pay substantially more.
Now please excuse me while I work on my “how do I watch the playoffs” spreadsheet. Hopefully enough of my free trials for the 7 different streaming services I’ll need have reset to get me partway there.
And I’ll add my voice to chorus. Bad enough that MLB.TV will never allow me to see the team that plays in my own city, thanks to blackout restrictions (way to build your fanbase, baseball!); increasingly MLB.TV is missing the other games I might be interested in as well. I’m sure the Amazon games will require a Prime subscription soon. I’m so looking forward to the day, not far in the future, when one game every night requires a Hulu subscription, another requires Paramount+, and another Peacock, in addition to the games that are reserved for Apple, Amazon, and Disney. But don’t worry, your MLB.TV subscription will still ensure you have at least two games to choose from — as long as they aren’t in your league or time zone. And it’ll cost twice as much because
supply chain, uh wait,inflation, uh wait, we’re paying minor league players more!It annoyed me having to listen the Brewers’ broadcasters to watch the Yanks’ series over the weekend (let’s just say I am comfortably in MIL’s terrority). They’re pretty homer-y and watching your team blow a game in the ninth with the broadcast team rooting for the other team is aggrivating.
(I watched most of the rest of that series on mute.)
I wouldn’t care about the local blackouts if we could actually watch our local station at a decent price. The problem is we can’t. The only streaming service that carries it would cost us an extra $70/month just for our baseball games, or we’d have to spend a lot more to go back to cable or satellite.
As such, we have to listen to the radio save for the rare national broadcasts on Fox, ESPN, FS1, or yes, Apple TV.
It’s not that hard to sign up to watch the MLB games (and for free) on Apple TV if you take the time to do so.
Can we blend this with the Pujols tracker? I’d like to know the odds of Pujols hitting 700 and Judge hitting 62 on the same day.
Judge will warrant a separate entry in the record book just as Maris did, if he doesn’t hit 61 in the Yankees’ first 154 games. A 162 game season is not a 154 game season (just as a 16 game NFL season is not a 14 game NFL season). This shouldn’t be difficult.
Fwiw, there was never an asterisk. Just a separate entry. Seems fair.
Ruth’s 60 has a HUGE caveat — pre-integration.
The thing with records is that context matters for every record, every entry, so it feels almost superfluous to start putting asterisks/separate entries all over the place.
It’s a good thing the record is 73 so nothing to worry about.
It would still be an American League record.
Ruth also didn’t have to hit as many breaking balls, didn’t have to face as much velocity, and he played his prime years back when ground rule doubles counted as home runs. There are several differences between eras besides just games played per season.
Although, I do like that since 1903 (when the AL adopted the foul strike rule) MLB has remained more consistent than most other sports. For one thing, when the NFL expanded from 14 to 16 games, that was a 14% increase in the schedule length (and is overall a 21% increase with now 17 games compared to 14), while MLB expanding from 154 games to 162 was only a 5% increase.
Settle down, Ghost of Ford Frick.
Looks like that 29% chance of number 60 happening vs. the Pirates was spot on!
based upon available evidence…… 60 seems highly probable