Addison Reed Might Be First Victim of New Year’s Effect

When FanGraphs conducted its annual free-agent crowdsourcing project just after the end of the 2017 season, the results suggested that Addison Reed would receive the third-richest deal among relievers this winter.

Top Relievers per Free-Agent Crowdsourcing
Rank Player Med. Years Med AAV Med Total
12 Wade Davis 4 $15 $60
18 Greg Holland 3 $12 $36
20 Addison Reed 3 $9 $27
24 Mike Minor 3 $9 $27
29 Jake McGee 3 $8 $24
32 Bryan Shaw 3 $7 $21
37 Brandon Morrow 2 $9 $18
“Rank” denotes rank among all free agents per crowdsourced results.

If the crowd were correct, Reed was in line for something remarkably similar to Mike Minor this offseason. So when Minor landed a guaranteed three years and $28 million at the beginning of December — that is, almost precisely the same figure for which he’d been projected by the masses — it seemed that, in theory, the crowd’s estimate represented a reasonable target for Reed.

In practice, however, that appears not to be the case. Ken Rosenthal reports this afternoon that Reed has signed with the Minnesota Twins for two years and “slightly less” than $17 million.

Jon Heyman has the precise terms:

In what has otherwise been a remarkably slow offseason, a number of relievers have already found homes — many of them, as Craig Edwards noted in mid-December, for two years and roughly $15 million. But that standard reliever deal has typically been reserved for standard-type relievers — not the sort, in other words, projected to receive the third-richest contract of the winter.

Relative to best free-agent relievers, the terms for which Reed’s services have been secured are rather modest. Let’s revisit the table from above, but now with the actual contract terms added to the mix:

Top Relievers, Crowdsourced vs. Actual Deals
Rank Player cYrs cTot aYrs aTot Diff %Diff
12 Wade Davis 4 $60 3 $52.0 -$8 -13.3%
18 Greg Holland 3 $36 — — — —
20 Addison Reed 3 $27 2 $16.8 -$10 -38.0%
24 Mike Minor 3 $27 3 $28.0 $1 3.7%
29 Jake McGee 3 $24 3 $27.0 $3 12.5%
32 Bryan Shaw 3 $21 3 $27.0 $6 28.6%
37 Brandon Morrow 2 $18 2 $21.0 $3 16.7%
-c- denotes crowdsourced contract figures.
-a- denotes actual contract figures.

Wade Davis technically received less than the $60 million projected by the crowd; however, he also elicited $2-plus million more in average annual value than was expected and the highest per-year salary ever for a reliever.

As for the other free-agent relievers comparable to Reed, they’ve all exceeded the crowd’s expectations. As a group, the combination of Jake McGee, Brandon Morrow, Bryan Shaw, and Minor have secured $13 million more in guaranteed salary this offseason than anticipated. Roughly 15%, in other words. Reed, meanwhile, has agreed to an amount roughly 40% less.

It’s possible that this is the product merely of a miscalculation of the market for Reed — or, alternatively, just a random outcome.

It’s also possibly due, however, to what might be called the New Year’s Effect. In a piece for Royals Review — and cited for the first time at FanGraphs by Travis Sawchik — Max Rieper found that free agents who signed before January 1st signed contracts for about 4% more than the crowd’s estimated figure. After January 1st, however, free agents received about 25% less. While the difference between Reed’s guarantee and others secured by comparable free agents is even more pronounced in terms of degree, it’s similar with respect to type.

The reasons for the New Year’s discount aren’t known, but some logical hypotheses exist. It might be a product, again, of a systemic misunderstanding of a certain player’s market. It might also be the result of anxiety: the prospect of entering February with a deal, watching as pitchers and catchers report — it might be sufficiently uncomfortable for a player to just take a more modest deal. Finally, as might be the case with Reed, it might be due to some specific constraint placed by the player himself on negotiations. Whatever the cause, it exists and teams have maybe looked to capitalize upon it or exploit it, depending on one’s point of view. And Reed might be its first victim of the offseason.





Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.

19 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
rhswanzey
8 years ago

A LH setup arm – hello, Tony Watson – is a much better fit for them, but consider me a bit surprised the Red Sox didn’t appear to seriously entertain keeping Reed. Two years at a reasonable AAV without the durability concerns of guys like Morrow and Davis would seem like a pretty good idea for a team putting a lot of stock in three RH setup arms coming off major injuries – Smith, Workman and Thornburg.

Alan
8 years ago

It is not hard to imagine that the Rockies must pay a premium to get top quality relievers (and probably get ignored completely by top quality starters).

Feels like the Twins got a good value – Morrow has more “upside” but also has significant durability concerns that the Cubs have the luxury of accomodating, but the Twins probably do not – the lower the payroll, the more the endurance and reliability matters compared to upside.

Matt
8 years ago

Jeff Passan reported that Reed was looking to sign with a team in the Midwest. Given the Twins need for a late inning reliever and their ability to compete for a playoff spot, he likely took less money. (It’s also been reported that he turned down multiple 3 year offers)

phealy48
8 years ago
Reply to  Matt

He is going to a young, pretty good team where he can be The guy in the ‘pen. Not always about money, like you said.

carterMember since 2020
8 years ago
Reply to  Matt

“Looking to sign with a team in the midwest”… Wtf?

Dave TMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  Matt

I’m a bit surprised that the Cardinals, and perhaps the Cubs, weren’t in on Reed for somewhat more money over 2 years as two other Midwest teams looking to add late-inning relievers.

It’s possible, though, that those teams were relatively negative on Reed for some reason. I could also see Reed feeling like he has a more guaranteed path to being the closer in Minnesota, which might appeal to him either due to mindset or as something of a “bet on himself” move. On the latter, I haven’t seen reports of a third-year team option on this deal, and we’ve seen club options (in some cases with vesting based on appearance totals and player health) on a lot of other set-up man contracts this offseason.

So, for the just turned 29-year old Reed, his optimistic scenario is that he closes for two years, getting paid at an AAV that’s more in-line with good set-up man money these days, and then can be back on the market as a 31-year old trying to get a contract with a “proven closer” premium. Looking at it dispassionately from the outside, I don’t know if that’s a great monetary bet given what we know about reliever volatility. I can see, however, a thought process there that makes sense for an optimistic player, especially if his geographic preferences also push him away from the three-year offers that he’s received.

phealy48
8 years ago

It’s entirely possible that the crowd, not Reed, misread the market. Reed ranks 9th by projected 2018 WAR(Swarzak ranks first somehow) among free agent relievers. His .6 projected WAR would give him a projected AAV of roughly 5-6 million.

By that metric, Swarzak was robbed. His 1.2 WAR should give him a 12 mil AAV, instead of his 7 mil.

So Mr. Reed actually did okay for himself.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago
Reply to  phealy48

I think perhaps the crowd was still remembering Reed’s great performance two years ago, but I think most teams understandably see him as more of a solid 1-WAR per yer guy out of the bullpen.

phealy48
8 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Yeah, the projection for .6 WAR seems low since he has had three straight 1 WAR or better season. He does have a knack for limiting the long ball, so maybe the crowd knows better than the computer. Overall, I think this is a fine deal.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago

Signing after Jan 1st is a proxy for market demand since top players theoretically get more teams interested sooner. The date is a spurious effect…something else causes both the signing date and the contract underperformance.

However, Matt’s point about reed’s geographic preference and Alan’s point about the Rockies overpaying seem more applicable here.

John Autin
8 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I upvoted simply for “spurious,” but … I do think there’s a real psychological effect when the year number changes to that of the upcoming season. For the same “lizard-brain” reason that leads retailers to make prices end with “.99” … basketball coaches to call timeout when a deficit hits double-digits … baseball managers to use the closer the moment the save rule is triggered….

Dave TMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

I generally agree with sadtrombone.

I think it’s sequencing more than the calendar date. As teams sign players, logical landing spots go away, along with available dollars that teams have budgeted for payroll.

It could be that some post-January 1 signings misread the market and could have gotten bigger contracts earlier in free agency, but I agree that we’re seeing selection effects with most of the later signings. It could be that teams, or at least teams with money to spend and open spots, are more optimistic on performance projections (relative to the public consensus) for players who sign earlier. In some cases it could also be that late signings have selection bias toward the players most impacted by factors that are tough for us to observe from the outside: player decisions more weighted toward geography vs. dollars (as may be the case with Reed), more medical questions than we know, and/or difficult personalities.

tdouglas
8 years ago

I’m shocked STL wasn’t in at that price. There’s still a desperate need for good relievers in STL’s bullpen, and there aren’t many good relievers left. St. Louis is as Midwest as it gets. Maybe they think they are close to a deal for Colome or something, but I don’t think one reliever is enough. Giving up assets to get Ozuna for two years doesn’t make sense if there aren’t a couple more significant moves, because the Cubs still hold a decent lead at the moment.

robbotis
8 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

The Cards are waiting for the right opportunity. And have been since Pujols left. And will be until they get a new owner. With the stadium sold out and that new TV contract, Bill DeWitt is just swimming in money. And they’re payroll is down. Again.

Dave TMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  robbotis

We don’t know what the payroll will be until the season starts. Right now the 2018 Opening Day payroll would be about $4 million under 2017.

The Cardinals’ 2018 payroll would be higher if the team had been successful in acquiring Stanton (who will make $16 million more than Ozuna in 2018). The 2018 payroll would almost certainly be higher if the team acquires Donaldson (due to make $23 million in 2018), about whom the Cardinals have reportedly checked in with the Blue Jays to the point of pestering, depending on the exact trade return. And there are still quite a few unsigned free agents out there. I wouldn’t be shocked to see the Cardinals sign Greg Holland, whatever the wisdom of that move.

There’s fan frustration at seeing the Cardinals miss the playoffs two seasons in a row, which is compounded greatly by seeing a successful and well-run Cubs team at the same time. The Cardinals’ payroll, however, has hovered right around 10th in MLB (per the 40-man end of year rankings at Cot’s), which is roughly in-line with where the team ranks in revenue (per Forbes). And, as for the idea that the Cardinals have done nothing but wait to spend money since Pujols left, the 40-man year end payroll (again per Cot’s) has gone up at least some every year since Pujols left, and during that time the team has been between 8th and 12th in MLB every year in payroll (by that same measure). Last year the Cardinals ranked 10th in payroll.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

I don’t actually think that St. Louis is “as midwestern as it gets” but everything you said about the Cardinals is just as true about the Cubs.

Dave TMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  tdouglas

The Cardinals could use one more quality late-inning reliever, but I don’t think they need to add multiple relievers. The mix of Gregerson, Lyons, Cecil, and Bowman looks like a fairly solid group of 6th through 8th inning relievers.

One of the things about having a good group of high-minors starting pitching prospects is that those players are also potential relief reinforcements, and there have also been indications that Reyes could get some time in the bullpen this year on his way back from Tommy John surgery.

Paul22
8 years ago

So the top 7 relievers got 5 million less in guaranteed money than the crowd projected. -2.5%
And thats the segment of the market said to be doing well.

Meanwhile spending is around 600 million, 800 million less than last year and 1.8 billion less than the year before. Half what it was in 2012 not even adjusting for player payroll inflation

Anyone seen Tony C around. Some reporter might want to ask his thoughts on how players are doing since he took over

Dave TMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  Paul22

Those lower guaranteed dollars are more than accounted for by the $8 million of Davis’ contract (3 / $52 million vs. 4 / $60 million), which as Carson points out has a higher AAV than projected. Another wrinkle is that Davis has a vesting player option for the 4th year (reportedly with 30 games finished in 2020) that would allow Davis the option to push the contract value to 4 / $66 million if it vests.

Adding it all up, I don’t see that Davis’ contract is necessarily less player-friendly than a straight 4 / $60 million contract, which in the latter case might also have a 5th-year team option (key point: team option, not vesting player option) at similar value to the AAV on the first 4 years.