I Don’t Mean to Alarm You But Melvin Upton Jr. Is Back
It’s always dangerous to assume everyone else is the same as you are. Just because you don’t give a shit about poems doesn’t mean other people don’t give a shit about poems. You want to be careful not to assume too much of your own preferences and experiences. That being said, I’m pretty comfortable with one assumption — I’ve barely paid attention to the Padres, and I feel like most people have barely paid attention to the Padres. That’s not to say no one has paid attention to the Padres, but those who have are probably few and far between. You know how it goes. Apparently Austin Hedges is leading all Triple-A hitters in slugging percentage by like a million points. I learned this Tuesday morning. Austin Hedges? Whatever.
About a certain Padres player, then. Apologies to those of you for whom this isn’t new news, but something has quietly been taking place. Remember when the Padres picked up Melvin Upton Jr.? They did it in the Craig Kimbrel trade, and they took him on as a salary dump. The Braves just wanted to be rid of him, and right away, the Padres put Upton on the DL. He did come back and play, eventually. He played well. And he hasn’t…stopped…playing well. Away from the spotlight, away from the pressure, Upton has rediscovered his talent. It sure looks to me like Melvin Upton Jr. is back.
The Braves signed Upton after the 2012 season. In the table below, you’ll see three lines of numbers. You see the three years of Upton leading up to free agency. You see his two catastrophic years with the Braves. And you see his past year as a Padre.
| Split | PA | BB% | K% | ISO | wRC+ | BsR/600 | Def/600 | WAR/600 |
| 2010 – 2012 | 1883 | 10% | 26% | 0.194 | 109 | 4.6 | 2.0 | 3.5 |
| 2013 – 2014 | 1028 | 10% | 32% | 0.116 | 66 | 1.8 | 1.7 | -0.1 |
| Past 1 Year | 509 | 7% | 27% | 0.177 | 110 | 5.7 | 3.5 | 3.7 |
I’ll be damned. Recent Upton isn’t the exact same as earlier Upton, but the profile is awfully close. Strikeout-prone power hitter with athletic, all-around skills. Upton, back then, looked like a borderline star. For the past year or so, he’s played like a borderline star. You can never forget about a dip like the dip he had, and it’s not like Upton would forgive himself for that or anything, but the player Upton looks like now is the player the Braves wanted to sign. He didn’t hit the ground running, but Upton is working to salvage the contract he agreed to. He lived through a professional nightmare, and he didn’t let it destroy him.
Over the weekend, Upton mashed a walk-off dinger against the impossible Andrew Miller. In the past year, Upton has clocked in with a 36% hard-hit rate, matching Jay Bruce and Andrew McCutchen. The Braves got burned. You do have to wonder how much another team would trust Upton, at this point. But he’s made himself appealing again, at least to some extent, and his contract extends through next year, when he’ll earn around $17 million. What’s crazy now is it’s not too hard to imagine Upton actually being worth that salary. All he’d have to be is something like an average outfielder, and lately he’s been clearing that bar. Clearing it easily! Melvin Upton Jr. could be a legitimate trade target. The Padres might not have to eat too much money. They got a bad break with the Jon Jay injury, but this career reversal is working out.
Upton’s back. If he’s not all the way back, he’s seemingly most of the way back. That’s astonishing in and of itself, and you could write a book about all this. Hell of a story, Melvin Upton Jr.’s. Another time, we can celebrate how Upton has found himself. For now, it’s July, and Upton is a talented veteran on a go-nowhere team. Front offices are going to call about Upton. Front offices are going to want Upton. Upton, once again, ought to be wanted. What a game this is.
Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.


I expected better than 101 wrc+ however the fact he resembles a MLB CF again is a feat.
110, not 101. More than respectable for a good defensive centerfielder who also runs well.
101 in 2016. 110 in 2015
But over the past year–comprising 509 PA–110. Seems more meaningful than splitting into 228/330 PA samples.
I was skeptical of the large HR/FB% increase, but the distance numbers appear to back it up.
Good! I’m glad that he was able to right the ship. I suppose it’s silly that there’s some part of my brain that feels bad for a guy who, all things considered, probably has a perfectly fine life.
Maybe it’s something about the dignity and self esteem that comes from knowing your work matches your pay. In any case, I definitely like the world where Melvin Upton is producing over the world where he isn’t.
At the time, I thought Upton was a excellent signing by the Braves. Turns out I was right, kinda sorta.
Love him. Favorite player on Padres you can see he has fun out there now. Solarte similar.
Sadly Padres need to deal him, Padres have 4 legimate prospects/young players options in OF between Margot, Renfroe, Alex Dickerson, and Travis Jankowski. Getting all these 4 players the PA’s and defensive innings they can should be a priority.
No need to put Renfroe/Margot up this year, both tho are clearly close to ready and need to be up next year at latest. Getting Jankowski and Dickerson all the playing time currently has to be a priority.
I’ll root for Melvin wherever he ends up.
Don’t mind me, I am a biased Detroit Tiger fan, but I liked the world the other way around – when Justin Upton was good to great and his older brother BJ, sucked. Now Justin is really really bad and the Tigers need him to be really good because JD is out. Justin is making his brother look better. I didn’t think that could be possible.
I live in Orange County and can see Mike Trout whenever I want. On top of that, it’s just a 50 minute drive to go see Clayton Kershaw and Corey Seager. As fascinated as I am by all 3 of these guys, I find MUJ just as fascinating this year. Glad someone gave him some props.
Here was something I tweeted on April 16th:
“Comparing 2 LF through last 502 PA;
A – .218/.277/.358, 72 wRC+, 15 HR, 13 SB
B – .239/.325/.393, 100 wRC+, 12 HR, 19 SB”
“A – Ian Desmond. B – Melvin Upton Jr”
Desmond has been loud in his comeback this year while Upton has quietly strung together a very nice campaign; quietly because Desmond is on pace for a 7+ WAR season and is playing on a contender, while Upton is on pace for right around 3 WAR and plays in San Diego. But still, I hope you appreciate him, San Diego!
Good heavens, you have to watch the Angels all the time?
I’m sorry.
I said Mike Trout. That or the cubs or Mariners coming up town would be the only reason for me to go.
What? The biggest change is in defense, which is notoriously unreliable for any 160-game stretch, much less for one that followed a change in park and teammates.
As for hitting, he looks an awful lot like the Braves version, with an extra 60 points of BABIP. Yes, you read that right: 60 points. Guess what happens when balls fall into play: many become doubles and triples, leading to increased ISO. Not sure how that escaped your analysis.
So we’re primarily left with an improved HR rate plus defense and baserunning over a whopping 550 PA. None of those are particularly predictive at that sample size. So no, MUJ is not back. He’s still a .220 hitter with a sub-10% BB rate who happens to be renting a luxurious .335 BABIP tuxedo.
Look closer and you’ll see his infield pop up rate has gone way down, from as high as 19.3% in 2013 to 6.3% this year. So an improvement in BABIP seems to make a degree of sense.