Ichiro Is Back Home

Seventeen years ago, a man named Ichiro Suzuki came east over the ocean to play baseball in Seattle. He was 27 years old then, and very good at what he did. Today, multiple reports indicate that Suzuki, now aged 44, will return to the Mariners. And it doesn’t matter, really, how good at baseball he is or isn’t anymore.
It matters a little, of course. The Mariners announced today that Ben Gamel will be out for four-to-six weeks with a strained oblique, and although that injury does not necessarily prohibit him from serving as the team’s unofficial hair model/Adonis, it does probably preclude him from playing the outfield, because Opening Day is about three-and-a-half weeks away. Suzuki, for all of his recent decline in offensive skills, can still play the outfield with reasonable competence — and certainly well enough to cover for Gamel where Guillermo Heredia and Taylor Motter cannot while also coming off the bench when needed.
I’m guessing that had a little to do with the timing of the deal, but it probably wasn’t everything.
In another sense, though, Ichiro’s performance on the field won’t matter a whole lot. Suzuki is a shadow of the player he once was, but the player he once was was one of the greatest to ever play the game, and he did most of it in a Mariners uniform. Only Ken Griffey Jr. and Edgar Martinez generated more wins in teal than did Suzuki, and both of them will be in the Hall of Fame eventually. So will Ichiro. This year may well be his last on a big-league field — there was talk that he’d retire, or head to Japan, if not offered a big-league contract — and there’d be no better way to go out than in Seattle, no matter what form that exit takes.
Maybe Ichiro will make contact with the ball 90% of the time again, like he last did in 2015. Maybe he’ll strike out less than 10% of the time again, like he last did in 2012. Or maybe he’ll hit .300 again, like he last did in 2010. I doubt any of those things will happen. What will happen, I’d hazard to guess, is that he’ll play at about replacement level for the first few months of the season, run out of opportunities in the late spring, and make a dignified exit from a legendary career during some sunny Seattle homestand this summer. If that’s how it goes, there are worse ways to end a career. Ichiro is back home, heading west into the sunset.
Rian Watt is a contributor to FanGraphs based in Seattle. His work has appeared at Vice, Baseball Prospectus, The Athletic, FiveThirtyEight, and some other places too. By day, he works with communities around the world to end homelessness.
Always gotta give a listen when I read about Ichiro
Benjamin Gibbard – Ichiro’s Theme
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hk7wk01rwHE
I could not support this move any more. Hope he can tack on some more milestones while given a chance to take the field.
Maybe for his last hurrah he finally starts hitting all those homers we’re told he’s got in his back pocket.
He’s 14th on the Mariners’ all-time HR list. Another 16 and he’ll make it into the top 10!
“I could not support this move any more.”
I share your words but with a different meaning.
By this point I’d rather remember Ichiro how he used to be.
Less than 100 AB to hit 30th all time, 80 GP to tie for 30th all time, 1 SB to take sole control of 35th all time SB, 35 hits to tie for 20th all time, 15 put outs from RF to tie for 6th all time.
I know those aren’t the sexiest things, but I want him as high in the books as possible to make up for the fact that his Japan stats don’t count (even though he clearly would have been beating the shit out of American pitching in his prime).
“… [T]here’d be no better way to go out than in Seattle, no matter what form that exit takes.”
As long as Ichiro doesn’t fall asleep while sitting on the bench during a game, anyway.
It’s great that he will retire a Mariner but I hope he gets to go out on top and on his terms and that seems less clear. Playing at replacement level for a few months followed by a “dignified exit” do not necessarily seem compatible. The actual end could be awkward and possibly acrimonious unless there is a plan drawn down to the day/date or tied to specific milestones.
Ichiro said a year ago that he wants to play until he’s 50, so I don’t think that he’ll simply decide to retire gracefully a few months from now. https://www.mlb.com/cut4/ichiro-suzuki-baseball-wizard-wants-to-play-until-hes-50-years-old/c-221485082
I therefore agree with you that this situation could turn awkward and acrimonious.
I like the way you write. Thanks for this.
For what it’s worth, he was much better in the second half last season. It’s possible he’ll stick around in a bench role even when Gamel’s back if he’s at least somewhat productive. Seattle could stick with one of Healy/Ford, rather than both.
“Hey, look, the Mariners have an opening in right field. This would be a perfect chance to give Top-100 prospect (who ended the year in AAA) Tyler O’Neill a chance to shine…wait, no this can’t be right, you say he was traded to the Cards for an obvious AAAA arm who can’t stay healthy? What horrible timeline are we living in?!”
Epilogue:
“It’s okay, you can just re-sign Jarrod Dyson, who hasn’t gotten any real offers…what’s that?! You say he just signed last week!? Argh.”
(for a team that says they want to win now, the Mariners sure have a funny way of showing it)
I guess you didn’t notice that O’Neill is out with an oblique strain right now, or that Gonzales has been sharp in his first 2 outings…
Yeah, you know who was killing it in Spring Training last year? Tony Wolters.
To be fair, Gonzales does have a new pitch (a cutter) so maybe that will make the difference, because man he has been the living definition of mediocrity so far.
I can’t wait to see his homecoming reception. Just generally I could spend hours at a time watching people cheer for Ichiro.
I love this and can’t wait for all the standing o’s at Safeco. It will give us a chance to say a proper goodbye. The first time he left, as was so often the case, the Mariners were terrible, and as is so often the case, the star player took the brunt of the blame from talk radio and ignorant fans. It was embarrassing and made me ashamed of my fellow Mariner fans. I always wondered if Ichiro looked back fondly on his Seattle years or if he saw them like I came to – as a black hole of enduring failure and disappointment that sucked away the best years of his Hall-of-Fame career for a fanbase that didn’t deserve them. I’m glad he WANTS to come back.
And Carlos Beltran breathes a sigh of relief that he will not share his first HoF ballot with Ichiro…
Maybe I read it incorrectly, but this article seems to say that Ken Griffey, Jr. is not in the Hall of Fame. He is.