In Which Mike Leake Uses a Paper Cup
I’ve touched on it before, but I don’t think we talk nearly enough about how weird it must be to be a major-league baseball player. Sure, they’re wealthy and get annoyed with their boss like anyone else, but they’re also frequently naked around their work friends. Their workplace is so strange. People spit in the office, and those spitters don’t always aim well, which means flecks of spit on their shoes. We watch them be bad at their jobs, but they never get to see us botch a sale or split an infinitive.
Sometimes, their pants rip just a little bit, near the butt.

This happens to the literal best players. They continue to wear those pants for several hours. They then get new pants. They don’t have to pay for them.
And they litter. Gum wrappers, seeds, the sticky leftovers of athletic tape. They use a bunch of paper cups — seemingly a different one every inning! — and then just throw those cups on the floor of the dugout. It’s a move that must strike your average desk-job worker as odd; insurance adjusters are generally expected to recycle.
Perhaps Mike Leake secretly aspires to more traditional office work. In the top of the fifth inning of his July 4th tilt against the Angels, Leake was pulled in favor of Nick Rumbelow. He looked hot and frustrated. The camera finds him as he takes a long, grumpy drink of water. Here we are, watching him after he just failed. He gives the cup an angry little flick. Runners on the corners. Might be time to litter. He stares into the middle distance. Grumble, grumble, bad day. But then…
He puts the cup back! He drinks from the cup, puts his lips full on it, and then puts it back on top of the stack. Presented with this less typical baseball workplace weirdness, we are left to conclude that Leake either has a stack of cups for his own personal use throughout the game — the result of considered cup tastes — or cares deeply about the environment, or else is thoroughly untroubled by the idea of a teammate grabbing his previously full-lipped cup off the top of the stack. It might be an act of care, but it could also be sort of awful.
I suppose, in that respect, Mike Leake has shown that the dugout is actually just like every other workplace, defined as they often are by drudgery, and grumpy types, and small bits of heedlessness borne of opaque personal agenda or indifference to washing the mug you just used before putting it back in the break room dish drainer.
Maybe being a baseball player isn’t so weird after all. Except for when you’re naked with your fellows. That remains strange.
Meg is the editor-in-chief of FanGraphs and the co-host of Effectively Wild. Prior to joining FanGraphs, her work appeared at Baseball Prospectus, Lookout Landing, and Just A Bit Outside. You can follow her on Bluesky @megrowler.fangraphs.com.
What a wonderful Friday gift!
Watching that game kinda sucked. Reading this article, didn’t.
He then proceeded to put his jock strap into the clean laundry pile.
#KeepNotGraphs
Maybe that’s the discard pile? After all, we never saw Leake actually grab the cup from that stack…
That’s what I thought. Still unusual as normal process is to just throw it on the ground.
Well, it was a home game, and Mariners fans know (thanks to unending Eco-Products commercials during radio game broadcasts) Safeco field diverts over 90% of its waste away from landfills, making it the “greenest park” in baseball. Maybe the players — or at least Leake — have taken that to heart and are now re-use and recycle instead of just littering?
“Did you just double-dip that chip?”
“Excuse me?”
“You double-dipped the chip.”
“Double-dipped? What are you talking about?”
“You dipped the chip, you took a bite, and you dipped again.”
“So?”
“That’s like putting your whole mouth right in the dip. Look, from now on when you take a chip, just take one dip and end it.”
“Well, I’m sorry Timmy, but I don’t dip that way.”
“Oh, you don’t, huh?”
“No. You dip the way you want to dip, I’ll dip the way I want to dip.”
Other ways their work-life differs from ours: nobody is watching my hygiene practices on live TV and then writing chuckle-inducing articles about them on the internet. (Though if they were, I might start doing strange and cryptic things just to provoke confusion and more articles).
Have you checked the whole internet?
Perhaps, paranoid and overcompensating for his surname, Mr. Leake has an obsession with fluid containers and maintaining their integrity.
And here I thought he was going to take a Leake in the cup.
I take a random middle cup out of any stack of disposable cups I come across for exactly this reason. This is how I live my life.
There are so many stories out there on the disgusting or at least unsanitary behavior of athletes that I think this doesn’t even register. Greg Maddux, who somehow had this image of being a “nerd” or a “professor,” was famous for frequently peeing on his teammates in the shower.
I don’t care what your FIP is, if you pee on me in the shower we’re gonna have a problem.
Unless I’m part of the Alou family and you’re peeing on my hands.
Rogers Hornsby too. As a manager, and it was one reason among many his players loathed him.
this video is being played backwards. only explanation
Haha! I’ll be sure next time I tour safeco field that I don’t use any paper cups I find. I’m curious to know your thoughts on the Dipoto extension. Is he worth it? We realistically aren’t head and shoulders above TB, LAA, OAK for the second WC (base runs, run differential) and have traded away lots of prospects in the process . I can’t lead myself to giving Dipoto credit for the clutch performances when it appears to be nothing more than random luck
Imo, he’s pulled off the GM trick of mortgaging the future for the present (and as you said, this isn’t a juggernaut team) in order to achieve job security. It works with owners who don’t have a long-term strategy in place, and is maybe the only option for GMs who haven’t earned a good reputation yet.
It will buy him some goodwill, but the M’s farm is barren, and the team could be horrible in 2 yrs.
its a cup
Looks like he’s just being eco-friendly, which is a good thing. Also, these guys go to war together 162 days a year. I doubt any of them fucking cares if they drink water out of someone else’s cup.
perhaps the same malady causing him to steal t-shirts drives this? Could simple frugality be the reason?
Mike Leake shoplifts t-shirts, but returns paper cups. What an odd duck!
#Awesome
Mike Leake’s player page is super trippy. Are we sure the Mike Leake we see every year is really the same Mike Leake, or every year do they just make a new clone of 25-year-old Mike Leake and recycle the old one?