Michael Taylor Retired, But Don’t Feel Bad for Him
“How many individuals are in the top 1% of anything? If you’re a Stanford graduate and you made it to the major leagues, who’s complaining about that?” Michael Taylor told me in 2013. He retired yesterday.
Taylor was once the darling of prospect hounds. He ranked as high as 29th overall on Baseball America’s top 100, and was the third-best prospect on the Phillies before he was traded to Oakland. He was only given 114 plate appearances in the big leagues and is only 29 years old. We might not really know what Michael Taylor’s true talents look like.
The player agreed, even when we talked two years ago. “It’s a tough thing to quantify — how many of my at-bats came pinch-hitting against the closer or an ace after not getting many at-bats or not being in the big leagues period. I don’t think I’ve ever played two games in a row, maybe in 2011 once,” he said. “16 plate appearances in three years.”
Maybe things would be different if he’d been given more chances. “I’m not the only guy who’s ever been that up and down guy. Had Alex Gordon not gotten the opportunity he got, we would never have figured out how good a player he was, since the first couple of years he struggled,” Taylor pointed out. Steamer still thinks Taylor’s bat could be just about league average, and the former center fielder is no slouch on defense. Maybe he could be someone’s fourth outfielder, right now.
But if you think that’s a woe is me attitude coming from the former Stanford graduate, you’re wrong. “Really all you can do is deal with the circumstances you have and try to play as long as you can and hope that something that will come out that allows to get more time. It’s hard, there’s only 750 spots in the world,” he said the day before a start in late 2013.
As a Stanford graduate that is comfortable talking in analytics and has a player’s feel for the game, he has options. But in late 2012, he wanted to point out that having options doesn’t mean he “loves the game any less” than a graduate from another school.
And he wasn’t looking beyond the game, even as the game allowed him precious few major league chances. “I don’t think I have a set time in mind, I’m going to do this for this long. I just try to enjoy every day. Life is short — that’s a cliche — but life in this game is short. Even the guys that are stars and play, they play for 15 years,” he said in Spring Training in 2013.
What’s next? Over the years, we’ve talked about broadcasting, management, and coaching. “I’ve spent a lot of my life in this game, and I have a pretty good base of knowledge about it. It would be something I would investigate, but getting into a front office is also something that’s very difficult to do, and options are limited. My goal is to cross that bridge when I get to it,” he said in 2013.
Now it’s time to cross that bridge. Taylor said on the phone that he began the process of “reconnecting with the Stanford network” by going back to finish his degree last fall. Now he’s finding that some of the things he did to be a baseball player — “getting ready to play every day, developing skills and talents, and dealing with failure” — are actually transferrable to a new career. He’s excited for an opportunity in sales and marketing, most likely, wherever the job takes him. He once got paid $800 a month to play in Pennsylvania, he joked. His (expecting) wife will be ready to move once again, particularly since the paycheck will be be bigger.
Maybe Michael Taylor didn’t get as long a look as his talents suggested he should. Or maybe Michael Taylor was just one of the 800 best players in the world, and not the top 750. Either way, he’s not bummed about it, so don’t feel bad for him.
“As long as I can have an opportunity to play and have a uniform, and have an opportunity, a chance to play in the big leagues, you can’t really beat that lifestyle and that accomplishment,” he said back in 2013. “I don’t know if I’ll ever be as good at anything else as I am at this, and that’s okay.”
With a phone full of pictures of pitchers' fingers, strange beers, and his two toddler sons, Eno Sarris can be found at the ballpark or a brewery most days. Read him here, writing about the A's or Giants at The Athletic, or about beer at October. Follow him on Twitter @enosarris if you can handle the sandwiches and inanity.
Can we please have two Eno articles a day every day?
Just love reading pieces like this that humanise what we watch without losing sight of the cold hard numbers.
This is a guy who, in the steroid era, would have made it. His OBPs in AAA were good, but he never developed into a power hitter. He also had the bad timing to have what was probably his peak year in the Oakland organization in 2013, when Stephen Vogt and Daric Barton had better years at AAA. That said, he did go 1-for-23, and not many teams would have waited much longer.
I’m glad he has a sense of perspective and didn’t do like Adrian Cardenas and tell The New Yorker he retired despite being “young and strong” and once hitting a single.
Good luck, Michael Taylor!
I still remember when Taylor was so highly touted in Philadelphia. A lot of trade talks at the time involved whether it would be worth moving either Taylor or Domonic Brown, as they were each considered the top prospects in the Phillies system. Taylor, of course, went to Toronto as part of the Roy Halladay trade, and Toronto immediately spun him to Oakland for Brett Wallace. He had a lot of promise, once upon a time.
I wish him well for the future.
Wow, I can’t believe he never got a real shot on a major league team. I guess he was just OK for years in AAA and didn’t do anything in his very limited appearances in the majors.
I guess if you can’t crack a Billy Beane roster you have to be worse than Daric Barton, Travis Buck, or Jack Cust (don’t get me wrong, I love Jack Cust — I wore his jersey in Arizona this weekend).
After seeing him numerous times while he was with Reading in the EL, I certainly thought he would get more MLB opportunities than he did. Good luck to he and his family in the future. With the outlook he has/had,I am sure success will come his way.
It’s so weird to me that he just never got a real chance. I guess he just had the bad luck of being in the farm system of good teams that couldn’t afford to just let him play. His career AAA line was .278/.369/.441 which would seem good enough for at least a 4th outfielder job.
Hey, remember the Brett Wallace – Michael Taylor challenge trade? Yeah, neither do I.
Great attitude from Taylor – there’s gotta be some truth about guys who just never quite get that shot. It’s a tough game.
Wallace might never play in the MLB again, in which case he’ll win. In the saddest way possible.
Wallace: -1 career WAR
Taylor: -1.2 career WAR
Brett still has time, though. Might be able to cost some team, somewhere, a few more runs.
Thank you very much for this article. I saw his retirement notice and i was very disappointed to see a 29 year old retire so early in his career. But its nice to know he is okay with his decision, and has a bright future ahead of him.
If anything, he can be proud of the fact that he was traded for Roy MF Halladay.
I never really gave him a second thought. He was just a former prospect that I knew about in the back of my mind. But after reading this article, I like the guy and hope for a comeback!
Excellent article and perspective. His numbers in aa/aaa certainly back his prospect ranking: .320/.395/.549, 14.5% k rate, 9.8% walk rate, roughly. A lot of teams could have used him as a 4th OF.
Those were his 2009 combined numbers.