Scherzer’s Max-Effort Relief Work Causes Dodgers to Shuffle NLCS Rotation

The bill for using Max Scherzer to close out Game 5 of the Division Series against the Giants has come due. On Saturday afternoon, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts announced that he would again use Corey Knebel as the opener in Game 1 of the Championship Series against the Braves, presumably to give Scherzer — who threw 13 pitches in closing out the Giants, earned his first career save, and indicated his intent to “party hard” in celebration afterwards — an extra day of rest before his NLCS start, a move that bumps Walker Buehler and Julio Urías back one game as well.

Prior to Game 5, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said of the possibility of using Scherzer, “He’s ready for whatever we need. Obviously the most important thing is to win tonight. But we still have to think about when and if we fire that bullet there is a cost, and we have to weigh other options as far as guys we already have in particular roles who have thrived.”

With Knebel and Brusdar Graterol each pitching scoreless (but hardly adventure-free) innings ahead of Urías on Thursday, the Giants emptied their bench early in order to gain the platoon advantage, but were left with righty Wilmer Flores — who was 0-for-17 with eight strikeouts in his career against Scherzer to that point — batting with two outs in the ninth. He struck out, aided by first base umpire Gabe Morales‘ dubious strike three call on a checked swing. Knebel will again open, and Roberts has indicated that Tony Gonsolin, who has not pitched since September 30, will figure prominently in a bulk role.

From the standpoint of our ZiPS Postseason Game-By-Game Odds, the overall cost is negligible thanks to the quality of the Dodgers’ pitching. The swing in the odds of the individual games appears somewhat steep in spots as the Dodgers reshuffle their rotation, with the Braves’ decision to pitch Ian Anderson in Games 2 and 6 (if necessary) and Charlie Morton in Games 3 and 7 (if necessary) nudging the needle as well:

NL Championship Series Rotation Changes
Game LAD Old LAD New ATL Old ATL New Old Odds (LAD) New Odds (LAD) Change
1 Scherzer Knebel Fried Fried 56.5% 51.3% -5.2%
2 Buehler Scherzer Morton Anderson 54.5% 58.8% 4.3%
3 Urías Buehler Anderson Morton 61.3% 59.3% -2.0%
4 Gonsolin Urías Bullpen Game Bullpen Game 50.8% 60.0% 9.2%
5 Scherzer Gonsolin Fried Fried 61.3% 49.9% -11.4%
6 Buehler Scherzer Morton Anderson 54.5% 58.8% 4.3%
7 Urías Buehler Anderson Morton 56.7% 54.5% -2.2%

Max Fried’s Game 1 assignment and the Braves’ use of some kind of bullpen configuration for Game 4 were thus the only constants for either side. Still, it all comes out in the wash, moving the overall series odds by less than 1%:

NLCS Outcome Projection Change
Outcome Prob Prob Change
Braves win in 4 Games 3.8% 3.3% -0.5%
Braves win in 5 Games 7.5% 8.9% 1.4%
Braves win in 6 Games 11.8% 11.1% -0.7%
Braves win in 7 Games 12.9% 13.6% 0.7%
Braves Total 36.0% 36.8% 0.8%
Dodgers win in 4 Games 9.6% 10.7% 1.1%
Dodgers win in 5 Games 18.8% 16.1% -2.7%
Dodgers win in 6 Games 18.7% 20.1% 1.4%
Dodgers win in 7 Games 16.9% 16.3% -0.6%
Dodgers Total 64.0% 63.2% -0.8%





Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on Twitter @jay_jaffe... and BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.

7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
tomerafan
2 years ago

Baseball in 2021 reminds me of the neutral zone trap era in hockey. It’s legal and acceptable strategy to use openers and bulk pitchers and all of this may be the best way to win games, but it’s a suboptimal and less enjoyable version of the sport itself and really needs to change.

Dmjn53
2 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

I don’t really see where that change is coming from. I’m thoroughly against changing the rules just because a particular strategy is too common or works too well.

I think we just need to accept that the idea of a “starting pitcher” the way it’s traditionally defined is close to defunct, just as the traditional NBA center or between the tackles NFL running back are relics as well

tomerafan
2 years ago
Reply to  Dmjn53

I think the change comes when the MLBPA ultimately (and rightfully) howls over the impact this has in pitcher salaries and contract length in the future. The more fungible that pitching roles are for non-superstars, the less incentive there is to hand out multi-year guaranteed contracts to the pitching middle class.

Dave T
2 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

What would the proposed rule change(s) be, though?

The only sure way that I can see to get back to starting pitchers routinely pitching really deep into games is to have stricter limits on roster size and/or number of pitchers. The limit is currently 13 pitchers (14 post-Sept 1.). Knock that down to about 10 pitchers, and we’d see different usage patterns out of necessity.

Such a move is hardly attractive to the current MLBPA membership, though, because it obviously removes major league jobs for a large number of pitchers.

tomerafan
2 years ago
Reply to  Dave T

I would go to a 27 (25) man roster where yesterday’s starting pitcher and tomorrow’s starting pitcher are ineligible, and a starting pitcher can only pitch once every four days during the regular season. The MLBPA gets an extra 30 roster spots, teams can go back to carrying 13 batters and 12 pitchers every day while actually having 14 pitchers on the roster, and if you choose to use an “opener” then he can’t pitch for another four days.

Dave T
2 years ago
Reply to  tomerafan

That change would make it very difficult to use openers and full-on bullpen games, but I don’t see how it addresses strategies like having a very quick hook and routinely pulling starters in the 4th or 5th inning.