In case you haven’t heard, the new Baseball Hall of Fame ballot was announced today. Fifteen newcomers — players who retired in 2010 — join 17 holdovers. As usual, the list is a mix of token candidates, interesting players and slam dunks. Here is a custom leaderboard for position players and pitchers for just the newcomers. And here’s a table for them, in case you don’t want to play around with the leaderboard.

2016 Hall of Fame Ballot – Newcomers

Name	G	IP	ERA	FIP	xFIP	PA	wOBA	wRC+	BsR	Off	Def	WPA	RE24	WAR
Ken Griffey Jr.	2671					11304	0.384	131	-7.3	444.1	-39.6	45.2	529.0	77.7
Jim Edmonds	2011					7980	0.385	132	-8	317.7	73.3	31.5	352.0	64.5
Jason Kendall	2085					8702	0.334	99	0.7	-6.8	130.8	11.1	92.8	39.8
Mike Hampton	425	2268.1	4.06	4.27	4.57	845	0.289	67	-1.2	-36.9	91.2	0.4	-5.3	35.9
Troy Glaus	1537					6355	0.365	120	-2.4	157.7	-20.4	12.1	159.1	34.4
Luis Castillo	1720					7471	0.327	97	33.4	7.1	37.9	1.4	18.3	28.4
Randy Winn	1717					6878	0.333	100	28.2	28.8	23.5	9.7	70.1	28.1
Mike Lowell	1601					6500	0.346	108	-39.7	25.8	22.7	1.8	77.9	26.0
Trevor Hoffman	1034	1089.1	2.87	3.08	3.78							32.2	174.8	26.0
Billy Wagner	853	903	2.31	2.73	2.76							28.5	196.6	24.1
Garret Anderson	2228					9177	0.334	100	-7.2	-12.6	-59.6	5.5	101.6	24.0
Mark Grudzielanek	1802					7603	0.32	91	4.1	-80	69.4	-8.2	-60.1	23.2
Mike Sweeney	1454					5848	0.366	117	-2.7	121.2	-106.5	15.0	206.1	21.1
Brad Ausmus	1971					7102	0.299	76	-23.2	-244.9	183.7	-22.5	-219.2	17.2
David Eckstein	1311					5705	0.316	92	10.6	-49.7	28.6	-2.7	-40.7	16.8

Note that for the pitchers, I included their position player WAR, as well as their RE24 and WPA. For Mike Hampton, that’s a bump of 7.9 WAR. For the two relievers, it’s a demerit of 0.1 WAR.

The most interesting questions are what you think of Jim Edmonds and Trevor Hoffman. Edmonds makes for a fascinating debate. I’m not sure Hoffman does. Honestly, looking at these dashboard numbers, it’s hard to make the case that Hoffman deserves inclusion. Or, if he does, then Wagner definitely deserves inclusion as well.

Here’s the same leaderboards (position players, pitchers) and table for the entire ballot.

2016 Hall of Fame Ballot – Everyone

Name	G	PA	wOBA	wRC+	BsR	Off	Def	RE24	WPA	WAR
Barry Bonds	2986	12606	0.435	173	30.4	1173.8	67.6	1348.3	127.0	164.4
Roger Clemens	360	213	0.207	15	0	-23.8	23.2	736.4	74.3	134.4
Mike Mussina	376	54	0.172	5	0	-7.1	5.9	400.4	39.2	82.3
Jeff Bagwell	2150	9431	0.405	149	6.5	594.6	-82.1	698.7	59.6	80.2
Curt Schilling	495	901	0.161	-16	-0.3	-132.8	94.6	277.5	25.0	78.8
Ken Griffey Jr.	2671	11304	0.384	131	-7.3	444.1	-39.6	529.0	45.2	77.7
Larry Walker	1988	8030	0.412	140	21.5	427.9	3.5	534.1	48.9	68.7
Tim Raines	2502	10359	0.361	125	100.4	408.2	-109.6	503.5	50.4	66.4
Mark McGwire	1874	7660	0.415	157	-2.5	555	-138.5	581.3	53.5	66.3
Edgar Martinez	2055	8678	0.405	147	-21	500.5	-133.5	514.9	45.2	65.5
Jim Edmonds	2011	7980	0.385	132	-8	317.7	73.3	352.0	31.5	64.5
Alan Trammell	2293	9376	0.343	111	2.3	124.1	184.4	124.9	13.0	63.7
Mike Piazza	1912	7745	0.39	140	-31.6	370.1	20.7	497.4	43.5	62.5
Gary Sheffield	2576	10947	0.391	141	9.7	575.7	-300.9	625.2	60.2	62.1
Sammy Sosa	2354	9896	0.37	124	-7.9	300.4	-8.1	383.0	24.9	60.1
Fred McGriff	2460	10174	0.383	134	-8.6	409.1	-186.3	527.6	47.5	56.9
Jeff Kent	2298	9537	0.367	123	-19.8	259.7	1.2	346.5	24.3	56.1
Nomar Garciaparra	1434	6116	0.376	124	4.8	199.9	18.8	239.2	17.1	41.4
Jason Kendall	2085	8702	0.334	99	0.7	-6.8	130.8	92.8	11.1	39.8
Mike Hampton	425	845	0.289	67	-1.2	-36.9	91.2	-5.3	0.4	35.9
Troy Glaus	1537	6355	0.365	120	-2.4	157.7	-20.4	159.1	12.1	34.4
Luis Castillo	1720	7471	0.327	97	33.4	7.1	37.9	18.3	1.4	28.4
Randy Winn	1717	6878	0.333	100	28.2	28.8	23.5	70.1	9.7	28.1
Lee Smith	549	71	0.09	-55	0	-13	6.1	156.4	22.9	26.1
Mike Lowell	1601	6500	0.346	108	-39.7	25.8	22.7	77.9	1.8	26.0
Trevor Hoffman	551	36	0.127	-28	0	-6.3	3.8	174.8	32.2	26.0
Billy Wagner	452	21	0.119	-30	0	-3.8	2.2	196.6	28.5	24.1
Garret Anderson	2228	9177	0.334	100	-7.2	-12.6	-59.6	101.6	5.5	24.0
Mark Grudzielanek	1802	7603	0.32	91	4.1	-80	69.4	-60.1	-8.2	23.2
Mike Sweeney	1454	5848	0.366	117	-2.7	121.2	-106.5	206.1	15.0	21.1
Brad Ausmus	1971	7102	0.299	76	-23.2	-244.9	183.7	-219.2	-22.5	17.2
David Eckstein	1311	5705	0.316	92	10.6	-49.7	28.6	-40.7	-2.7	16.8

Again, the RE24, WPA and WAR numbers are combined for the pitchers.

So, who would you vote for? I made a survey so you can vote. You’re on the honor system here — don’t pick more than 10 players, please. If you’re looking for my two cents, here’s how I’d vote:

• No Doubters: Bonds, Clemens, Griffey, Mussina, Piazza, Raines
• Don’t Want To See Fall Off Ballot: Sheffield, Walker
• Last Chance: McGwire, Trammell

Because I would want to give McGwire and Trammell their best shot in their final year on the ballot, I’d leave off Bagwell and Schilling, and cross my fingers that Edmonds gets enough votes to stay. Either way, it’s a tough puzzle. Rock your vote below!