JABO: Trying to Make an MVP Case for Mark Teixeira
Unless he changes his name to Mike Trout and has some pretty impressive plastic surgery, there’s not a strong argument to be made for Mark Teixeira as the AL MVP this season. Teixeira currently leads the Yankees in FanGraphs WAR at 3.3 but he’s only 14th in WAR among AL batters, behind the likes of Logan Forsythe, Kevin Kiermaier, and, well, 11 others. Throw in pitchers and there are seven more above Teixeira. So despite having quite a comeback season and despite being the best hitter on a first place team, Teixeira isn’t in the AL MVP conversation.
But what if we try hard to put him there? Maybe we can find something we’re missing, some way that, even if things stay as they are through the rest of the season, Teixeira deserves to carry the mantle of best player in the American League. It’s probably a stretch, but what the heck! What else is a guy to do on a Sunday night? (Please, please don’t answer that.)
Right off the bat, and you know this is going to be good because I’m already resorting to baseball-themed cliche, I should acknowledge that leading the league in WAR doesn’t necessitate winning the MVP, but for our purposes here, it’s an easy way to sort players, especially since the presumed leader in the race also happens to be the leader in WAR. So convenient!
Including pitchers, there are 21 players with a higher WAR than Teixeira so far this season. Moving a guy from 22nd to first without him actually doing anything is a lot to ask, but here we go! We can start off by saying this: pitchers shouldn’t win the MVP. Pitching is a completely different position and necessitates different skills and should be judged independently. That’s why pitchers have the Cy Young award. Do I believe this? No! But it works here and we press onward! So drop the seven pitchers from the list and Teixeira moves up to 14th. That’s progress! I wish all my housing projects were this easily accomplished.


The argument is a peace of cake. Most RBI’s by a position player on a first place team.
http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=all&stats=bat&lg=al&qual=0&type=8&season=2015&month=0&season1=2015&ind=0&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0&sort=7,d
Why do you nerds always make things so complicated?
“Position player”? Why are you trying to steal Kendrys Morales’s rightful award?
Kendry is a DH so he’s only half a player. And if you divide the 80 RBI’s by 2, it’s obvious he’s not #1.
You’ve changed, skipper. You’ve changed. #RBIFORLIFE
no dh should win mvp. it devalues the award. you cant make an argument to bolster a particular players credentials based on defensive ability. the DH (maybe usually a defensive liability) is allowed to ignore that part of his game and concentrate on offense only (what is this Football?).
Don’t forget the criteria of not clogging up the bases!
I know the article approaches this a bit tongue-and-check and then dismisses the whole premise in its conclusion, but I still don’t see the angle. It almost devalues what Teixeira has done to try to squint and see an MVP case. Lots of players deserve kudos for having good seasons, and it isn’t fair to try and make Teixeira’s season into something it clearly isn’t.
(There’s also no real argument that Teixiera is more deserving than Nelson Cruz, who now actually leads the AL in wRC by a hair, and who maybe would have been a better subject for the article. Cruz’s defense is a mess, but if that’s the starting point for the argument between Tex and Cruz, you’ve trapped yourself into saying Teixeira’s below average 1B defense and winning team are factors that put him over Cruz, which also don’t make much sense.)
This was just dumb. I understand what you’re trying to do – but either go full hog tongue and cheek or dont attempt.
We all know there s literally nothing you can say that would make Tex a top 5 MVP candidate. UNless you can come up with something logical, then dont write it — or just go crazy like Dusty said….
really a waste of time.
Mmmm…full hog tongue…
Yes, this was the fangraphs version of click bait. SHould’ve called it “Top 20 reasons why Mark Teixeira should be MVP; #8 will SHOCK you…”
Far more interesting would be to compare Josh Donaldson to Mike Trout.
JD for MVP
I agree with the notion that this was a muddled premise that didn’t really work. It’s hard to see what you were going for, but maybe something like:
1. Mark Teixera’s having a helluva season (+ some stats).
2. Players with numbers like his used to win MVP awards. Here are some examples of that.
3. Teixeira won’t win, but could he possibly be a top-10 candidate?
4. Arguments in favor of his candidacy.
You misspelled “Josh Donaldson.”
Yeah, I’m not one to be critical of free articles (I read Cistulli’s stuff, for god sake) but this piece screams, “Fox overlords demand content now!”
You didn’t even take the time to cross off Cespedes for going to the NL.
Or, in the case of Fox, an article about somebody besides Megyn Kelly.
Truly pointless, and not even because it has nothing to say about Teixera and nothing to say about WAR. Most particularly pointless because it blithely assumes that we all know that Trout will end the seasons with the highest WAR total among American League position players – otherwise what is the point of saying Trout’s name over and over?
Do I consider Trout ending the season at the top fairly likely, you know 60-70%? Sure. But the only reason one would act like it’s a done deal is because one has been pumping Mike Trout far too long.
No one needs to be pumping Mike Trout anymore – he’s doing fine, getting paid and getting credit. Personally I’d like to see Donaldson deserve the award, and get it, for variety’s sake if nothing else. Trout has plenty of time to get five more and his HoF induction.
Eh, if Trout earns it by being the best player he deserves it. But if Donaldson is close, tied, or arguably better than Trout, that’s when things get interesting. Between the walk off hits, the stellar D, and nearly equal production, it’s an intriguing comparison. Trout’s offence is superior, but Donaldson’s defence has allowed him to provide similar value.
Trout has 1 MVP to his name, and you want it to go to someone else for variety’s sake?
I’ve heard this argument made against Trout on more than one broadcast this season (I know, I should have learned to turn the volume off by now). Which is how the best player of his generation by a country mile will probably manage to retire with just that 1 MVP – the media hype cycle is so short these days that people were already tired of celebrating Trout’s greatness before his 24th birthday.
You could also eliminate the teams not currently in a playoff position, since that would take off Kiermaier, Cruz, Kipnis, Dozier, Longoria, Forsythe and some others. That was the angle I expected the article to take. As written, this is a mess in my opinion.
I actually liked this article thanks for the free stuff 🙂
Agreed. I like the combination of logic and insanity.
The article doesn’t quite work. Either fully embrace the humor angle or do a serious approach. It’s a bit muddled. I’d rate it a 40 currently, with 60 future potential with revisions.
Which list did ARod get booted from? This one?
“Right now the list looks like this:
Mike Trout
Josh Donaldson
Manny Machado
Jason Kipnis
Lorenzo Cain
J.D. Martinez
Yoenis Cespedes
Nelson Cruz
Brian Dozier
Evan Longoria
Kevin Kiermaier
Logan Forsythe
Ian Kinsler
Mark Teixeira”
I noticed this as well. I read back through it at least 5 times and just decided to give up. Still wondering how ARod fits in with this…
He who shall not be named.
Yesterday’s list?
Cespedes should win MVP in both leagues
Was this inspired by one of the chats last week? I remember someone asking about this.
Kind of a weird article. I get tired of the MVP/CY Young awards pretty quickly. Watching people passionately argue that pitchers should be able to win the MVP gets old after like…the first sentence.
I hear he shows some real grit during Yankees-team-building-Monopoly night.
Good enough for me.
I keep reading the assumption that Teixeira’s defense has a negative value because of a number based on, what, range? It’s a terrible assumption. Tex at 1B has saved the Yankees min. 10 runs scooping balls that Gregorius, Headley, Drew et al have tossed into the dirt with men on base. Some have been spectacular, as have his picks on hot shots throughout the year. I don’t think he’s the MVP, but most of you don’t have an idea of his actual value at 1B because your stat doesn’t process the most important part of the position. 1B is a power position, and Tex’s massive power numbers speak for themselves. If you want a SS range at first, you have a different player. He’s in top 10 for MVP without question. Now go fix defensive WAR.