Javier Baez, the Chicago Cubs, and the Value of Versatility
Javier Baez is the Chicago Cubs’ current starting second baseman. It’s a new role for him. In four postseason games, he’s made four starts at the position. By contrast, he’d already played 38 regular-season games before he made his fourth start at second, on June 2. It’s not a role he took over at the All-Star break or even later in the season, like teammate Addison Russell did at shortstop last year. Baez made just 38 starts at the position all year long, and as the team prepped for playoffs in September, Baez received just six starts at second base in the final month. Baez’s versatile regular season — as well as the versatility of other Cubs teammates like Kris Bryant and Ben Zobrist — prepared for any role in the postseason, and that versatility enabled by Joe Maddon has played an important role in the team’s success.
Baez is the most shining example of that versatility on the Cubs. He’s played more than 25 games at each of second base, third base, and shortstop — one of only 68 players in history to accomplish that feat, per the Baseball Reference Play Index. While it isn’t so unique that Jedd Gyorko and Darwin Barney weren’t able to also do it this season, Baez’s age is a differentiating factor. Turning 24 years old in December, only Joe Dugan and Rogers Hornsby nearly a century ago accomplished the feat at a younger age (both by just a few months). Baez is also one of only 66 players in history to record at least 50 games at both second and third base. Given that he’s the only name on both lists, it appears safe to say he’s the only player in baseball history with at least 25 games at shortstop, 50 games at second base and 50 games at third base.
While Baez might have most diverse position profile on the Cubs, and perhaps in baseball, he isn’t the only Cubs player to play multiple positions this season. Of the seven Cubs who played in at least half of the team’s games, the only players who didn’t log at least 150 innings at multiple positions were Dexter Fowler (center field), Anthony Rizzo (first base), and Addison Russell (shortstop) — and even Russell split his time between second base and shortstop last season. Having a utility player or two on a team is commonplace, but the Cubs are functioning at another level.
Back in August, Ken Rosenthal noted that Kris Bryant could become the first player since Stan Musial to win an MVP award while receiving at least 30 starts in both the infield and the outfield. How many other teams or managers would ask their MVP-caliber third baseman to split time in the outfield? The most recent example of such a thing is probably Tony LaRussa’s use of Albert Pujols during the latter’s first few years in the majors, before arm injuries and Scott Rolen permanently moved Pujols to first.
Here’s another relevant fact: the Cubs have gone the entire season without a regular left fielder. Willson Contreras has gotten time in the outfield and behind the plate. Before the season, if the Cubs had gotten a .259/.370/.463 line with a 122 wRC+ and 5.0 WAR that ranked second in MLB, it would be fair to assume Kyle Schwarber had just produced a really good year. However, no Cubs player recorded more than 200 plate appearances from left field this season and only Bryant and Jorge Soler had more than 100 PA. Their current left fielder, Ben Zobrist, had just 59 plate appearances from the position all year.
In MLB this year, 71 players logged at least 150 innings at multiple positions. The Cubs had five of those players (Baez, Bryant, Contreras, Zobrist, and Jason Heyward), the most of any team. If you take out players whose multiple positions include only outfield positions, there are only 38 such players. The Cubs have four of them (the list above without Heyward), tied with the St. Louis Cardinals for the most in baseball. No other team had more than two multiple-position players. The Cubs tend to have fairly unique combinations, as well.
| Positions | Other Players with that Combo | |
| Javier Baez | 2B-3B-SS | Jedd Gyorko and Darwin Barney |
| Ben Zobrist | 2B-RF | None |
| Kris Bryant | 3B-LF | Jose Ramirez and Brandon Drury |
| Willson Contreras | C-LF | None |
| Jason Heyward | RF-CF | 10 |
The other benefit for the Cubs is that these players are generally good defenders. Compare the group of Cubs to the group of Cardinals (the aforementioned Gyorko plus Matt Carpenter, Greg Garcia, and Brandon Moss) and we see fielders who are natural fits for their various positions on the Cubs, while the various Cardinals are less well suited for their various defensive responsibilities.
Baez was certainly the hero of the Division Series against the Giants, with game-winning hits in two of the three wins, and his versatility gave him the opportunity to receive regular playing time this year. However, Baez wouldn’t even be playing absent the versatility of Joe Maddon’s proto-Baez in Ben Zobrist. As well as Baez has played in the Division Series — both with the glove and the bat — at all three of his best positions (2B, 3B, SS), he’s still second-best on the Cubs. Baez is no Kris Bryant and Addison Russell with his glove has cemented himself as the Cubs shortstop. Even at second base, where Baez is playing now, he is not near the quality of Ben Zobrist.
This post is sort of about Javier Baez’s versatility, but it’s also about how Ben Zobrist’s versatility helped make Baez’s performance possible. Ben Zobrist just recorded a batting mark of 114 wRC+ or higher for the sixth straight season, recording a 124 wRC+ mark that was roughly 30 points ahead of Baez’s. He’s put up average defensive numbers this year consistent with his age and a standard decline from his formerly elite numbers. With his offense, that has been good for a 4.0-WAR season, the fifth time he’s reached that number in the last six seasons.
While I spent some time questioning Joe Maddon’s strategic decisions yesterday, he is due some praise for utilizing the team’s versatility all season long and trusting that his players could handle the difficulty in moving around. All series are filled with what-ifs, but you have to wonder how this series would look if Baez had not started every game. By moving Ben Zobrist to left field, where he has played some, but not a lot, this season, Maddon has enabled playing time for Javier Baez and allowed Baez to shine in the NLDS.
Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.


> Even at second base, where Baez is playing now, he is not near the quality of Ben Zobrist.
This seems like a questionable assumption, especially given the line later in the article saying Zobrist has “put up average defensive numbers this year”. Did we just watch the same NLDS?
fixed. thanks.
Nice piece Craig!
Also certainly helps for double switch possibilities. To pinch hit his catcher for his SS in the 9th and be able to keep him in the game without really losing a ton on defense is certainly a nice luxury.
I love Bryant. I’d take Baez over him at third. How ever, I don’t think anyone is going to prefer Zobrist over Baez at second. That’s not even mentioning his ‘tag’ game that’s been getting so much pub recently. Zobrist is steady, he’ll make all the expected plays, and none of the tougher ones.
I think it’s pretty clear that those comments were about the player overall, not just the defense at that position. Baez is clearly a better defender than Bryant or Zobrist.
As good as Baez is at 2B, I think he may shine even greater at 3B, where he can put his plus arm on display from long range (although he gets less fielding opportunities when he plays there).
The question that comes to mind is how much better defensively (and maybe offensively) Baez might be if allowed to settle into a routine at second or third.
Or worse… Shifting him around might help with focusing, nerves etc. Who knows the meta mental game aspect of that definitively.
Do you know of many players whose defense was worse as one position regulars?
The only one I can think of was Tony Philips and he went the other way, from regular to supersub mostly because he wasn’t so hot at second.
Not off the top of my head. I have heard it suggested by people familiar with the team though. Sometimes just letting the athletism play is better than becoming robotic was their take.
Another great thing about the versatility, in addition to the ability to strategically rest players by shuffling positions, is that it acts as great depth in case of injury. No matter the position of the injured player, the Cubs can look for any position in trades or signings. If Zobrist gets hurt, you could get another secondbasemen or move Baez there and get an outfielder. If Heyward gets hurt, you can find an outfielder or move Zobrist there and find an infielder.
Also, I’m surprised that we didn’t get a gif in here of the pickoff at first base when Baez and Rizzo switched positions. As soon as they switched, I knew it was for the purpose of Ross throwing behind the runner to first, and sure enough, Baez applied his tag, and they had a pick off!
You mentioned possible injuries but forgot to mention schwarber who did get hurt. Huge bat to lose for most teams and yet you still have 103 win team.
how much of a loss was schwarber really? he is not as bad defensively after some people call him after his miscues the last postseason but he is certainly no more than plus defender.
he is a good hitter but the Cubs strung together a LF platoon with a 122 wRC+ this season. do schwarber couldn’t have done that much better (maybe a little) and with worse defense.
still if course it hurt the Cubs some especially for the postseason when an extra big bat is nice but in regular season games I don’t think it cost them much.
What line did the cubs rightfielders put up? You don’t think bryant is capable of playing right?
I believe all of bryant, zobrist, baez, and contreras got time at first base as well.
Just to make some fanbases mad.
Bryant-5 more years of control
Russell-5 more years of control
Rizzo-5 more years of control
Schwarber-5 more years of control
Contreras-6 more years of control
Baez- 5 more years of control
Soler- 4 more years of control
Almora- 6 more years of control
Rizzo is the grandfather of the group at 27. Everyone else is under 25. These are just the position players.
JediHoyer, I’m sure I’d be just as giddy if I were a Cubs fan. But don’t forget that paper dynasties have funny ways of fizzling. You list 8 players; I count 2 or 3 stars, which is great, but 4 who are way more promise than proof so far. Not long ago, Starlin Castro was a future superstar; so were Yasiel Puig, Elvis Andrus, Brett Lawrie, Wil Myers, Jurickson Profar, Hosmer & Moustakas, etc.
I remember when the ’90s Indians were the model franchise, churning out talent and signing them long-term. Somehow, they never got to the mountaintop.
There’ll be time enough for counting when the championships are won. Or at least, y’know, when you get TO a World Series. 🙂
“Somehow, they never got to the mountaintop.”
They got there, the Braves and Marlins just pushed them off.
You said you count 2 Or 3 stars already… I wasn’t implying they will all be stars, however they are all average or better players. I also didn’t include zobrist and heyward who are above average in what like 13 out of the last 14 years? That’s 10 average or better position players in the league without a dh. Top 25 prospects Jimenez and happ are also position players. That allows them to trade from this depth. The 90s indians lacked pitching (nagy was great before injuries and old hercheiser was steady if unspectacular) and still managed to make it to 2 world series.
All average or better players? Soler? Almora?
Soler is -1.4 WAA through 765 PAs so far (B-R figures). His minor-league record is mostly A and below, less than 70 games at the high levels. He just finished age 24. The power he’s shown so far is no great shakes by current standards. Odds are against him ever being an average MLB player.
Almora did fine in 117 PAs this year. He looks like a good glove to me, but nothing is proven. What will he hit? Minors shows solid BA, but no walks or power, no base-stealing. Yeah, he’s just 22 and a #6 overall pick — that does not make him even an average MLB player now, or ever.
Schwarber can mash and draw walks. His MiLB stats were kick-ass, but we’re still talking 900 PAs as a pro. He’s quite likely above average, but we’ll see how the year off affects him, and what position he settles at. If he has a Matt Stairs career, meh.
Contreras had a good half-year — hitting stats kinda like Michael Conforto last year. Nothing is proven until they do it consistently.
Don’t get me wrong, it’s a huge pile of talent. But we tend to endow such group members with reflected glory. To me, Soler is just a guy; Almora reminds me of Juan Lagares a couple years ago. A rising tide doesn’t float all boats.
Lol, that’s what happens when you scout the star line. Soler keeps getting hurt and isn’t getting everyday at bats. He will be a 120 Wrc+ guy with above average running and bad d. Solid average with upside for more with the bat.
Almora is basically kevin pillar with above average running instead of plus-plus plus and young enough there is hope for the bat. Basically 2.5 war-3.5 war guy.
Schwarbers power is real.
Contreras is a catcher who hit most of his homers straight away or oppo. Stud.
Juan lagares was a well above average player until he couldn’t use his throwing arm…
Baez was also working as a centerfielder in the Caribbean Winter League last off-season, and saw time there this spring as well.
And Maddon has mentioned that he is the emergency catcher, in the event that one is needed.
Kris Bryant also longed an inning in CF and at SS this season. And he played full games in CF last season.
Good post. I thought I knew the Cubs were versatile, but I didn’t know half of it.
I’m not a Cubs or Rays fan, but I think Maddon is brilliant. It’s especially interesting that, while most modern managers fixate on enabling their players’ routines, keeping them in their comfort zones, Maddon keeps his guys “on their toes” — and has more wins in the last 9 years than any one team. That’s not all on him, of course, but he helps.
It is hard for me to believe that Baez is not a better SS than Russell. If that is the case, then the Cubs are screwing this up. If you want to miscast your best defensive player as a role player, then you are doing it wrong.
If Baez is their best defensive player, then the versatility argument is just a rationalization. Should Andrelton, B Crawford and Lindor be bouncing all over the field or should they be playing the highest impact position all the time? I am not sure that this is really a space for non-Maddon thoughts or traditional baseball values but I tried.
They are both great fielding shortstops. Baez has more talent, but Russell is steadier. Russell is good enough to allow Maddon to play Baez whereever the best matchup is.
Russell is probably winning the gold glove this year… Him or Crawford. I have doubts about Baez consistency if given the every day job.