Mets Lose Scherzer and, Momentarily, Their NL East Lead

Last week, the Mets flexed their muscles by taking two out of three from the Dodgers — the majors’ top team by won-loss record, run differential, and most other measures — at Citi Field. On Wednesday morning they awoke to a new reality. Not only were they tied for first place in the National League East with the Braves, but they had to place Max Scherzer on the injured list due to an oblique injury on his left side for the second time this season; later that day, they announced that Starling Marte had suffered a non-displaced fracture of his right middle finger as well. The confluence may not rate as a crisis in Queens, but playoff races have certainly turned on less.
The Braves’ claim on a share of first place marked the first time since April 11 — and just the second time all season — that the Mets did not have sole possession of the division lead. By the day’s end, however, the Mets again had the top spot to themselves thanks to 5-1 and 10-0 poundings of the Pirates in Pittsburgh, running their record to 87-51, while the Braves beat the A’s to improve to 86-51.
As for Scherzer, with a chance to notch his 200th career win, the 38-year-old righty left Saturday’s start against the Nationals after just five innings, 67 pitches, and one run allowed. Following the final out of the inning — during which he got an assist on a routine groundout by Ildemaro Vargas — Scherzer motioned to pitching coach Jeremy Hefner to follow him into the dugout tunnel, then gave way to reliever Tommy Hunter to start the sixth.
Max Scherzer is out after 5 innings and 67 pitches. pic.twitter.com/rfc94ISI3u
— SNY (@SNYtv) September 4, 2022
Afterwards, both the pitcher and the Mets characterized the early exit as a precautionary move. Via MLB.com’s Joe Trezza:
“I don’t have any strains,” Scherzer said. “The left side was just getting more tired than usual. This was a precautionary move, considering the history of the oblique. Was there a scenario where I could go out there and pitch the sixth and be OK? Yeah. That could’ve happened. But if I went out for the sixth and got hurt, I could never come in here and look the guys in the face and say I made the right decision. It was better to be safe than sorry in this scenario.”
Said manager Buck Showalter: “He didn’t ask to come out. We didn’t think it was a good idea to push it, and we’re hopeful he can make his next start.”
An MRI taken on Tuesday revealed continued inflammation on Scherzer’s left side, so the Mets decided to put him on the IL retroactive to Sunday, meaning that he’s eligible to return on September 19. “This is days not weeks,” said the pitcher before Wednesday’s doubleheader. “This is not a significant injury… It’s not a strain.”
In what I might enshrine as Jaffe’s First Law, there are no insignificant injuries for 38-year-old pitchers who are being counting on to make multiple postseason starts in the following month, because even a minor setback can derail those plans. Old guys, even Cooperstown-bound superstars, don’t heal as quickly as they used to no matter how stiff they keep their upper lips, and if you need a reminder, recall that last fall, Scherzer struggled to rebound from a similar kind of postseason relief cameo that he’d done just two years earlier (against the Dodgers, no less). That’s why a pitcher who was on five days of rest after throwing 112 pitches against the Rockies at home — as Scherzer did on August 28 — is reporting fatigue in the first place: his body can’t do quite everything it could a few years ago. Welcome to the club, buddy.
The Mets, who had to live without Scherzer for nearly seven weeks after he landed on the IL with a left oblique strain in late May, recognize this. Given the team’s Wilpon-era penchant for mismanaging injuries, that recognition counts as good news. It’s certainly better than letting Scherzer linger on the roster for several more days without pitching, or exacerbate the situation with a short start or a more severe injury. As it is, he’ll miss two starts, and better it’s two in early-to-mid September, when the Mets are facing a soft patch of schedule — they’ll face the Marlins, Cubs, and Pirates before Scherzer becomes eligible to return — than October.
Regardless of his age, Scherzer has pitched especially well in his first year with the Mets, posting a 2.26 ERA and 2.53 FIP in 127.2 innings, 10.1 short of what’s needed to qualify for the ERA title. Among NL pitchers with at least 120 innings, his ERA is second only to that of Tony Gonsolin, whose 2.10 mark in 128.1 innings is similarly below the cutoff and will remain there because he’s laid up with his own maybe-not-so-minor forearm strain. That leaves Julio Urías (2.29 ERA in 145.2 innings) as the official leader, with Sandy Alcantara (2.36 ERA in 190.2 innings) and scoreless-streaking Zac Gallen (2.42 in 152.2 innings) within striking distance.
Thanks in part to Carlos Carrasco’s return from an IL stint due to an oblique strain on Sunday, the Mets cycled through six starters (Taijuan Walker, Jacob deGrom, Chris Bassitt, David Peterson, and Scherzer being the others) over a six-game stretch. Most likely, the way forward in Scherzer’s absence is to stick with Peterson, who has pitched to a 3.32 ERA and 3.54 FIP in 95 innings this year, with a 2.53 ERA and 1.85 FIP in four starts totaling 21.1 innings in August and September. Righty Trevor Williams (2.92 ERA, 4.07 FIP) is another option, but he’s started just once in the second half, maxing out at 71 pitches.
Even given the soft schedule, whoever fills in for Scherzer will step into the heat of the NL East race. The Mets went 34-17 in April and May, building a 10.5-game lead over the slow-starting Braves (23-27). Since then, the defending champions have outplayed even the Dodgers:
| Team | W | L | W-L% | GB | RS | RA | pythW-L% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Braves | 63 | 24 | .724 | — | 476 | 300 | .699 |
| Dodgers | 61 | 26 | .701 | 2 | 463 | 281 | .714 |
| Phillies | 54 | 32 | .628 | 8.5 | 412 | 345 | .580 |
| Mets | 53 | 34 | .609 | 10 | 377 | 320 | .574 |
The Mets have played at a 97-win pace since the start of June… and it hasn’t been nearly enough to ward off the Braves, who caught them by playing at a 117-win pace over that span. The Dodgers are the only other team that has played .724 ball over an 87-game span this year, doing so in two overlapping stretches, the more recent of which started on May 16 and ended on August 21. In other words, it took a sustained effort as good as any team has mustered this year in order to catch the Mets, who are still on pace to win 102 games, both based on their overall .630 winning percentage, and via our projections. Our Playoff Odds give them a 62.5% chance of winning the NL East, and a virtually identical chance of clinching a first-round bye, though both of those are down 22.9 points relative to a week ago, when the Mets still had a three-game lead.
Though their three-game losing streak from Saturday to Tuesday matched their longest skid of the season (they also lost three in a row from June 26-29 and July 17-23), the Mets are nonetheless 23-14 (.621) since the start of August, and 40-22 (.645) since the start of July. September aside, they’ve posted a winning percentage of .633 or better in every month except June, when they went 13-12 (.520), a period when, not so coincidentally, they were without both Scherzer and deGrom, and when Francisco Lindor hit .202/.255/.362 (77 wRC+) amid what has nonetheless been an MVP-caliber season. Lindor, as it turns out, fractured the tip of his right middle finger when it got shut in a hotel door on June 1. The injury escaped my memory when I examined his fine season a couple weeks back, in part because he missed just one game, but that may well have contributed to his struggles.
Let’s look at that standings table again, this time since the start of July:
| Team | W | L | W-L% | GB | RS | RA | pythW-L% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dodgers | 47 | 14 | .770 | — | 354 | 187 | .763 |
| Braves | 42 | 18 | .700 | 4.5 | 321 | 200 | .704 |
| Mets | 40 | 22 | .645 | 7.5 | 277 | 205 | .634 |
| Cardinals | 38 | 21 | .644 | 8 | 299 | 233 | .612 |
That’s a lot less separation between the two NL East rivals, who have been playing at 113- and 104-win paces over that 10-week span. Both pitching staffs have been particularly stingy during that stretch, with the Braves allowing 3.33 runs per game, the Mets 3.31. The difference is that Atlanta has scored 5.35 runs per game during that stretch, while New York has scored 4.47 per game.
Speaking of Lindor and broken fingers, Marte was hit on the right hand by a 96-mph Mitch Keller fastball on Tuesday night and was diagnosed with a partial non-displaced fracture of his right middle finger on Wednesday. For the moment he’s considered day-to-day, though he could wind up serving an IL stint and would indeed be missed. The 33-year-old right fielder has matched last year’s career-best 134 wRC+ by hitting .292/.347/.468 with 16 homers and stealing a team-high 18 bases.
If he’s not able to play, Tyler Naquin is the likely fill-in. Naquin has hit .248/.302/.465 (107 wRC+) overall and a more lopsided .254/.293/.521 (129 wRC+) since being acquired from the Reds on July 28. The 30-year-old lefty does need a platoon partner, but right now the only righty-swinging outfielders on the roster are pinch-running specialist Terrance Gore, who has just one plate appearance since 2019, and Darin Ruf, who has just four innings in the outfield since being acquired on August 2; additionally, he’s hit just .163/.208/.233 in 48 PA as a Met. The closest thing the team have to a credible righty-swinging outfield option at Triple-A Syracuse is Mark Vientos, their eighth-ranked prospect, but he’s actually a corner infielder with all of 13 games of experience in left field, in 2021. Particularly given rookie third baseman Brett Baty’s right thumb surgery, Vientos has been considered for a call-up, but with Luis Guillorme on the IL as well, the team opted to go with the shortstop-capable (if 27 major league innings in the past six seasons can be counted as capable) Deven Marrero instead. After straining his groin in mid-August, Guillorme went on a rehab assignment on Tuesday, and could be activated soon.
Who mans the short half of a platoon during an absence that may prove hypothetical is a comparatively minor concern relative to the Scherzer injury, which itself may prove to be as minor as the pitcher and team are suggesting. The good news is that the Mets have played exceptionally well for most of the season, and while the Braves have caught up, Atlanta has a much rougher schedule the rest of the way, with three against the Mariners and seven against the Phillies before they face New York in Atlanta from September 30 to October 2. The Mets’ only other games against teams .500 or better are the three they’ll play in Milwaukee from September 19–21. All of this is already baked into the odds. By being cautious with Scherzer, the Mets are doing their best to make sure they remain in their favor.
Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.


The Mets are up to +7 in Baseruns, largest in the league. Wonder how that stacks up to previous seasons.
But with the advantage in schedule (and the likely tiebreaker over the Braves), they have a clear shot to the division.
it’s tough because the Braves get the Mets at home second to last series. If it’s within a game, I’d favor the Braves at that point. I don’t think it will be- my bet is for the Braves to drop this coming series to the Mariners and regress a bit.
The 2015 Cardinals were +11 of I remember correctly.
I do think the thought that the narrative on the Mets beneficiaries of good fortune has a funny framing. They’re more or less a ~98 win team playing at a 100+ win pace while being 9th in xwOBA this season and having a top 5 pitching staff. This season they’re just…. good.
Oh yeah definitely. I wasn’t trying to suggest they aren’t a really good team. Pre-Scherzer IL stint, I think Fangraphs had them tied with the Dodgers for second best team (assuming I’m reading Depth Charts correctly) and they’re still third
A pretty simple partial explanation for the braves success is that, although playing really well since June, they also have had one of the easier schedules in baseball (19th hardest, .498 SOS), meanwhile everyone else in the NL east has been in the top 10 for hardest schedules, including the Mets being tied for the hardest schedule in baseball (.512 SOS). It’s incredibly confusing as to why one NL East team got a significantly easier schedule than the other 4, and this isn’t a case of “bad teams obviously have harder schedules,” since the Mets and Phillies are playoff teams well over .500.
I mean a lot of the gap is just that… the season isn’t over.
In interleague, the Mets got 4 against the Yankees rather than Boston but of course, Boston was projected to be only a bit worse than the Yankees at the start of the year. And Boston adds on far more travel for the Braves obviously so that narrows the gap a bit more. Then one extra game versus Houston compared to Oakland.
Mets: 3 SEA, 4 NYY, 3 OAK, 4 HOU, 3 TEX, 3 LAA
Braves: 3 SEA, 4 BOS, 4 OAK, 3 HOU, 3 TEX, 3 LAA
Then against the other NL contenders, the Braves get one extra against the Padres and one fewer against the Dodgers.
Mets: 6 SD, 7 LAD, 6 MIL, 7 STL
Braves: 7 SD, 6 LAD, 6 MIL, 7 STL
So the Mets got +5 games vs the top 2 teams in the AL and +1 game vs the top team in the NL? And the braves schedule had those replaced with +5 games of last place baseball and +1 game of Padres.
Which doesn’t sound like much, but the Mets are already one of the best teams in baseball vs. winning teams (39-30 vs teams over .500), meanwhile the Braves are very middle of the pack (27-30), feasting on the inferior competition (55-29 vs teams below .500). The Mets certainly have the easier September, but the schedule imbalance is still glaring this year. That’s a 5 game swing in a division that’s going down to the last days of the season.
And again, this leaves the Phillies out of this entirely. They’ve had a very tough schedule as well, and it doesn’t let up in September (7 vs Braves, 3 vs Houston, 2 vs Toronto).
Fangraphs projected the Yankees as a .563 team (on a .498 schedule) and the Red Sox as a .532 team (on a .502 schedule). So the four games were projected to amount to a maximum of .124 wins more difficult of a schedule on average for the Mets from NYY vs BOS. The Yankees overachieved and the Red Sox underachieved but it still isn’t too meaningful.
And if we’re really nitpicking here, the Mets had to travel, what, 4 miles to get to the Bronx? 1000 miles from Atlanta to Boston.
If we’re really, REALLY nitpicking, the travel thing kind of falls apart: the Braves played the Mets at Citi Field before they went to Fenway, with a travel day in between. In contrast, the Mets went to Yankee Stadium at the end of a 10 games-in-nine-days road trip that began with four games in Atlanta, followed by four games in three days in Philly, with no travel days before or during the trip. The Mets played 13 games in 12 days (no off days) from August 12-23, with the final two games at Yankee Stadium. Oh, and Atlanta went to Boston after a day game (and had that travel day), while the Mets played a Saturday SPLIT doubleheader (makeup game from a May rainout) and a Sunday night game in Philly, before playing in Yankee Stadium the following night. They got to sleep in their own beds, but it was obvious that they were exhausted. The schedule makers didn’t know the Mets would get rained out in May and have to play a doubleheader in the middle of that August road trip, or that the Red Sox would suck this year (and it wouldn’t matter to them anyway), but that’s what actually happened.
(Sorry, I’m not articulating myself well today.)
I stand corrected on the travel point!
The Braves do not have a “significantly easier” schedule than the Mets, what are you even talking about? Their schedules are 97% the same.
I’m citing ESPN’s basic SOS metric, which is based on opponent win%. Use BRef’s if you want to see the mets with the 4th hardest schedule (avg opp is 0.1 runs per game above average) and the braves with the 23rd hardest (avg opp is -0.1 runs per game above average). Sounds like a slim margin, but over 100+ games, the difference adds up. The mets number will decrease over the next month, but that doesn’t make my initial point any less valid.
you want to say significant, put a p value in there (or your quantification of uncertainty of choice)
Yes the Mets will get easier and the Braves will get harder as well, making up most of the gap.
The Braves still get 12 games vs the lowly giants/marlins/nationals. The mets get a lot easier, but the Braves are kind of a wash (15 vs phillies/mets/mariners). The phillies have a rough go of it.
Not by much. Don’t the Braves have the fifth-easiest schedule the rest of the way? (I could be wrong about that, sorry if I am.)
Fangraphs says the Braves have the 11th hardest schedule the rest of the way.
Blaming schedules is pretty absurd. Schedules of teams in the same division are 95%+ the same.
The reasonable version of this comment is:
“The Braves have caught up some because they’ve played an easier schedule over this stretch, but now it’s going to turn around and the Mets are going to be the ones playing an easier schedule, since the schedules are more or less the same over the entire season.”
I might disagree with that take, but it would be a defensible one.
For those old enough to get the reference, the Braves have been like The Nothing in Neverending Story (for Mets fans, at least).
Regarding Ruf, I’m starting to wonder whether the team giving up FOUR players for the short side of a platoon is playing into their thinking about his playing time. Vientos seems ready for a shot….
Peterson’s been an unsung hero for the Mets all year. I hope he’s got a few more innings in that left arm. And with Smith and Megill nearly coming back, the bullpen can get stronger.
But those Braves. They are a hell of a team.
Yup people were suggesting they were on the decline in May after letting Freeman go, and while they’d be better with Freeman than Olson they’re in even better shape not only this year but going forward thanks to Harris and Strider. I believe the Braves are playing something like .700 baseball since Harris came up and Grissom has been great since they gave up on the Cano experiment and Arcia got hurt.
The Mets have played very well since June but the Braves have been on a Mariners of ‘01 win pace since June.
The Mets offense has struggled the last few weeks as Alonso has had a power outage and Nimmo has stopped walking since June and Vogelbach has turned back into a pumpkin.
Hopefully Escobar’s hot streak is something and Alonso and Lindor get red hot again. That said, Scherzer is a big loss and Walker I’d having a bad second half for a second year in a row. I don’t think 100 wins is enough to win the division it’ll take 103-104 wins.
Maybe Walker “finds” an injury after Scherzer’s back and they keep Peterson in the rotation for a few more turns, or perhaps they bullpen a few games. I worry about him and Carrasco considering their injury histories. But you could also do worse for a #4 and #5.
Yes, it’s going to take more than 100 wins. Been fun but also terrifying, considering the times the Mets have lost first place in the 2nd half.
Does last year even count? The 2021 Mets were a mediocre-to-bad team, propped up by deGrom’s right arm for three months, Weekend at Bernie’s-style. They had a negative run differential for long stretches in the first half; for a while, they had the division’s worst RD (weirdly, the Marlins had the best). Meanwhile, the Braves underperformed their RD all season, and several players (notably Freddie Freeman) underperformed their expected stats in the first half. The Mets’ “collapse” was really just regression, and it was obvious that it would begin on that infamous 13-game August stretch against the Dodgers and Giants. Before that, you have to go back to 2007-08 for a “collapse,” which is hardly relevant to this year (and which have their own similar issues).
(I still think the Mets should have sold at the deadline last year; they could have gotten a prospect or two for Marcus Stroman, for example—but I digress.)
They should have sold at the deadline last year despite being in first place? Mirage of not nobody would do that.
Yeah, if you think the Mets should have sold, then pretty much by definition you must also think the then future World Series Champions should have sold, after losing their best player for the season.
Last year it was reasonable to expect that Lindor, Conforto, McNeil, and even guys like Dom Smith, JD Davis and James McCann would pick up the slack in the second half, evening out the regression to the mean otherwise – they all had career worst or close to it seasons. I knew their record was better than their performance first half, but was still optimistic about winning the division because I didn’t think 2/3 of our lineup really would have the worst seasons of their careers at the same time.
Agreed. Considering how incredibly good the numbers of the 2020 team was & the terrible sequencing, you’d hope that the sequencing would balance out & the quality hitting would remain. Instead they all just sucked.
I blame the fans for running J.D. out of town. The fact that they had to give up so much for Ruf makes clear how inflated the asking prices were at the trade deadline, but fans were so mad at J.D., and so insistent that the FO do SOMETHING, that I feel like they made that move because they figured it would cause the least harm to their farm system, while hoping it would be neutral as far as the major-league roster. But I could certainly be wrong.
The fans didn’t run anyone out of town. The Ruf trade is 100% on the Mets front office, no one else.
Agreed. Most of the Mets chatter I heard was sad when J.D. was dealt. Bottom line, it was a terrible trade, even if Szap never pitches an inning in the pros again. Davis for Ruf itself is bad.
Blame the Eppler-Alderson FO for the silly Ruf 4 for 1 deal. Prices weren’t inflated, the Mets FO just crumbled.
For whatever reason I’m reminded that the Braves lost like a dozen top(ish) prospects a few years ago due to their bonus scandal… and they’re still doing this. They *are* a hell of a team.
This is basically the only interesting playoff race this year.
Does the Braves win projection include the potential return of Soroka & Albies? Conversely, the Mets may get a pen push with the additions of Megill and Drew Smith back to the pen, although not the same, but clearly potential to push guys like Givens or ‘insert AAA RP here’. I think one of the important things to consider is that Grissom (.389 BAbip) & Harris II (.381 BAbip on season) have sustained such a great run that there may be a regression coming at some point as the league adjusts? For the Mets, it’s more about guys like Escobar (.962 OPS last 28 days) and (.843 OPS last 14 days) showing any kind of value at all to lengthen the line up and take heat off of the core offense when they have off days or mini slumps.
Albies is projected for 70 PA the rest of the way, Soroka for 7 IP. I don’t really expect them to bring Soroka back to the major league team this year after all his time out.
I think the article misses the key difference. The Braves have pitching depth that the Mets do not, especially in the bullpen. The Mets don’t have a lefty in the pen that is even serviceable, and are one more starter injury away from spiraling out of control. Meanwhile, the lack of faith in the bullpen has led to overuse of Scherzer, Walker and Carrasco, all of whom hit the IL. It’s incredibly frustrating for a team’s most glaring weakness in spring training to be the team’s most glaring weakness at the trade deadline, and go unaddressed beyond Givens.
The Braves have better starting pitching depth than the Mets?
That wasn’t what he said, so it’s not fair to ask this question in this way.
The Braves pitching is set up very well for the playoffs, compared to last year and especially compared to 2020 when they would have perhaps asked for volunteers from the stands except nobody was allowed in. The Braves have 4 guys that their fans feel comfortable as playoff starters and if any of them get hurt then they have options in Anderson and Odorizzi that are way better than what they actually used the last two years to fill out the rotation. Or, with a bullpen that is legitimately stacked from top to bottom, they could rely on a bullpen game that could be very effective.
This late in the season, I think the quality of your depth is more important the the quantity as it isn’t that likely that you will lose several players in a matter of weeks.
The Mets will add David Peterson (lefty), Tylor Megill, and probably Taijuan Walker to their playoff bullpen. Diaz and Ottavino are studs and Lugo is solid. If Degrom, Scherzer and Bassitt are starting most playoff games, that bullpen easily plays.
Ottavino is…fine. Tied for 60th in fWAR among relievers, 61st in FIP, 22nd in ERA. Whatever way you slice it, he’s having a good year but is not among the top relievers in the game.
He’s nails when he starts an inning. So is Diaz. And Lugo is better in those situations. But the Mets don’t have anyone that can put out a fire. Megill will be asked to fill that role….
Exactly. Right now, the Mets have three healthy starters – DeGrom, Bassit and Peterson. Hopefully Scherzer can come back. But the plan was for Peterson to pitch out of the pen in the playoffs and he hasn’t taken well to that role thus far. The only reliable arms in the bullpen are Ottavino and Diaz and BOTH do really bad work with inherited runners. Lugo is hit or miss and can’t throw on back to back days which is going to be a problem with the new postseason schedule.
Joely Rodriguez is not rosterable; Peterson starting means no lefties in the bullpen.
The cascading effect of the injuries to Walker and Carrasco and the lack of bullpen depth is Scherzer throwing an unnecessary amount of pitches against the Rockies… and look what happens next.
Put all that together and this was a team that needed a whole lot more than just Mychal Givens and the promotion of Ricky Vaughan, ahem, sorry, Bryce Montez de Oca.
But as someone who watches way too ouch Mets baseball, some of you are looking at the stats but not the current roster construction or what’s actually happened over the last 39 days.
By FIP, the Mets have seven starting pitchers among the top 45 in the NL. The Braves have four. The Braves have a better bullpen. They don’t have much starting depth.
By FIP, the Mets have five starting pitchers projected as top-45 in FIP by depth chart ROS, and the Braves have seven. This doesn’t include the possibility that Scherzer is done-zo. So this could be the literal opposite of what you say.
I’m not saying this definitively means anything, but neither does your thing.
…. which tells me what Taijuan Walker did before he was hurt. And Carrasco. And now Scherzer. How the Mets have pitched this season to date doesn’t tell me what they have right now.
So your position is that how pitchers have performed over 80% of the season has no bearing on what they are likely to do going forward? This makes about as much sense as your assertion that Edwin Diaz does “really bad work with inherited runners.” (Diaz has stranded 90% of runners this year.) Or your assertion that the Mets are one pitcher injury away from “spiraling out of control.”
Diaz has stranded 90% of runners this year. But the Mets are using him almost exclusively in clean innings because of his history of struggling with inherited runners. He’s succeeding at a higher rate but with lower incidences. The front office and manager have openly discussed this – putting him in the best position for success. So I stand by that comment.
And I never said that how pitchers perform over 80% of the season has no bearing going forward. But where the pitching staff is today has to be considered. To take an extreme hypothetical, if the Mets had the best FIP but every starter has already thrown 200 innings, Diaz had over 100 appearances, etc., there would be massive flags about their ability to sustain through October based on their usage.
What I’m saying is that it is statistically unlikely that Carrasco or Walker will be the same pitchers going forward as they were for the first 60% of the season based on what has developed over the last 20% of the season. And I’m saying that the fact that the Mets continue to run Joely Rodriguez out there in the 8th inning shows how thin they are. And Tommy Hunter in one run games. And so forth and so on.
TL;dr this team is in more trouble than the stats suggest because of the risk that certain starters are already maxed out which will ripple through the already-thin bullpen.
Care to revise your assessment of Carrasco’s and Walker’s prospects, given their performances this weekend? Didn’t exactly looked “maxed out.”
No, I don’t given the fact that it was the Marlins. The articles today about Walker are almost exclusively about how amazing last nights starts was in light of his 2nd half performance.
But no, I’m not changing my assessment based on one start. Pretty small sample size compared to the body of work in the 2nd half of the season.
Fascinating, that the successful attempt to buy legitimacy by wildly overpaying Scherzer is now, predictably, biting the arse of a team that didn’t need his 130 innings so much as they needed 300 strong starter innings from the likes of Rodon and Ray (or your preferred 2 top starters here) for the cost of Scherzer’s $43m AAV.
Bassitt had passed 90 innings in all of 2 seasons, while of Carrasco and Walker neither could be sensibly projected to be effective past 90 innings. Megill had been highly effective for about five starts in 2021, and Peterson’s FIP promised no likely success in 2022. DeGrom wasn’t coming back until June, if then. With $43m to spend, adding an old, brilliant starter who had faltered at the end of the previous season wasn’t the way to go with it—much as I love watching Max pitch for the Mets.
Tbf they tried to sign Gausman in addition to Scherzer and he took less money to go to Toronto.