New York Yankees Top 36 Prospects

Below is an analysis of the prospects in the farm system of the New York Yankees. Scouting reports were compiled with information provided by industry sources as well as my own observations. This is the fourth year we’re delineating between two anticipated relief roles, the abbreviations for which you’ll see in the “position” column below: MIRP for multi-inning relief pitchers, and SIRP for single-inning relief pitchers. The ETAs listed generally correspond to the year a player has to be added to the 40-man roster to avoid being made eligible for the Rule 5 draft. Manual adjustments are made where they seem appropriate, but we use that as a rule of thumb.
A quick overview of what FV (Future Value) means can be found here. A much deeper overview can be found here.
All of the ranked prospects below also appear on The Board, a resource the site offers featuring sortable scouting information for every organization. It has more details (and updated TrackMan data from various sources) than this article and integrates every team’s list so readers can compare prospects across farm systems. It can be found here.
| Rk | Name | Age | Highest Level | Position | ETA | FV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Spencer Jones | 22.6 | AA | CF | 2026 | 55 |
| 2 | Austin Wells | 24.4 | MLB | C | 2024 | 50 |
| 3 | Jasson Domínguez | 20.9 | MLB | CF | 2025 | 50 |
| 4 | Roderick Arias | 19.3 | R | SS | 2027 | 50 |
| 5 | Chase Hampton | 22.4 | AA | SP | 2024 | 50 |
| 6 | Will Warren | 24.5 | AAA | SP | 2024 | 50 |
| 7 | George Lombard Jr. | 18.1 | A | SS | 2027 | 45+ |
| 8 | Henry Lalane | 19.6 | R | SP | 2026 | 45 |
| 9 | Brando Mayea | 18.3 | R | CF | 2028 | 45 |
| 10 | Jorbit Vivas | 22.8 | AAA | 2B | 2024 | 45 |
| 11 | Carlos Lagrange | 20.6 | R | SP | 2027 | 40+ |
| 12 | Agustin Ramirez | 22.3 | AA | C | 2025 | 40+ |
| 13 | Jared Serna | 21.6 | A+ | 2B | 2026 | 40+ |
| 14 | Edgleen Perez | 17.6 | R | C | 2028 | 40+ |
| 15 | Chalniel Arias | 19.9 | R | SP | 2028 | 40+ |
| 16 | Sabier Marte | 19.4 | R | SP | 2028 | 40+ |
| 17 | Everson Pereira | 22.7 | MLB | LF | 2024 | 40 |
| 18 | Brock Selvidge | 21.3 | A+ | SP | 2026 | 40 |
| 19 | Clayton Beeter | 25.2 | AAA | SIRP | 2024 | 40 |
| 20 | Luis Gil | 25.5 | MLB | SIRP | 2024 | 40 |
| 21 | Yoendrys Gómez | 24.2 | MLB | MIRP | 2024 | 40 |
| 22 | Keiner Delgado | 19.5 | R | 2B | 2027 | 40 |
| 23 | Roc Riggio | 21.1 | A | 2B | 2026 | 40 |
| 24 | Kyle Carr | 21.2 | R | SP | 2026 | 40 |
| 25 | Antonio Gomez | 22.1 | A+ | C | 2026 | 40 |
| 26 | Brendan Beck | 25.2 | A+ | SP | 2025 | 35+ |
| 27 | Luis Serna | 19.4 | R | SP | 2027 | 35+ |
| 28 | Gabriel Terrero | 18.2 | R | 2B | 2029 | 35+ |
| 29 | Ben Rice | 24.4 | AA | DH | 2026 | 35+ |
| 30 | Angel Benitez | 20.3 | R | SP | 2028 | 35+ |
| 31 | Jordarlin Mendoza | 20.1 | R | SIRP | 2026 | 35+ |
| 32 | Carlos Narvaez | 25.1 | AAA | C | 2024 | 35+ |
| 33 | Alexander Vargas | 22.1 | A+ | SS | 2026 | 35+ |
| 34 | Rafael Flores | 22.7 | A+ | C | 2027 | 35+ |
| 35 | Jerson Alejandro | 17.4 | R | SP | 2028 | 35+ |
| 36 | Matt Krook | 29.2 | MLB | MIRP | 2024 | 35+ |
Other Prospects of Note
Grouped by type and listed in order of preference within each category.
DSL Pitching
Joshawn Lampson, RHP
Mariano Salomon, RHP
Allen Facundo, LHP
Franyer Herrera, LHP
Stanly Alcantara, RHP
The Yankees’ two DSL teams were full of interesting young Latin American prospects in 2023. Lampson, 18, only sits 87-91 mph, but he’s a ridiculous on-mound athlete with a very explosive delivery. He also has a shapely breaking ball. I think he’ll throw harder over time despite lacking typical physical projection. Salomon is a 21-year-old pitchability righty with a low-90s fastball that plays up and a really good changeup. Facundo and Herrera have uphill angle fastballs from the left side and throw fairly hard. Alcantara is like a lot of the other teenage pitchers in the system; he’s a lanky 6-foot-6, but he’s much more raw than a lot of his same-aged teammates.
Fun, Young Position Players
Enmanuel Tejeda, 3B
Jose Castro, CF
Hans Montero, SS
Josue Gonzalez, C
Richard Meran, CF
John Cruz, CF
Tejeda is a small-ish infielder who stopped playing shortstop in 2023. I still really like the way his hands work in the box, but it’s tough to project third base-worthy raw power here. Castro and Montero both have monster bat speed and power potential. Castro’s swing has huge lift and he has room for another 20 pounds or so on his frame, but he struck out 33% of the time in 2023. Montero’s ability to create big bat speed in a short distance is impressive, but it comes at the expense of his head flying all over the place. He has a real chance to play shortstop. Gonzalez is a medium-framed Venezuelan catcher who has among the best Statcast/Trackman metrics in the entire org. He’s an impressive rotational athlete, but the way his hands load is kind of cheating and I’m not sure it will work at the upper levels. Meran and Cruz are tooled up athletes with big body projection and hit tool risk.
Tough Defensive Profiles
Tyler Hardman, 1B
T.J. Rumfield, 1B
Christopher Familia, LF
Elijah Dunham, LF
Readers are likely to be familiar with this group, as it’s full of upper-level hitters with a track record of good performance. It’s very difficult to profile at the positions they can play. Hardman easily has the most power of this group, but he’s also the most strikeout prone. Rumfield and Familia are more balanced, and Familia’s underlying data is especially impressive. Dunham is more contact and OBP-oriented. Any of these guys would make for a fine emergency replacement in the event of an injury.
Depth Relievers
Alex Mauricio, RHP
Luis Velasquez, RHP
Edgar Barclay, LHP
Danny Watson, RHP
Jack Neely, RHP
Justin Wilson, RHP
Mauricio sits 95 but uses a slider-first approach. He’s a fine replacement-level reliever. Velasquez, 22, is among the harder throwers in the system with a fastball parked in the 95-97 mph range, but he’s also very erratic. Barclay is a soft-tossing changeup specialist who moved from a long relief role into a mid-minors rotation spot during the second half of 2023. Watson is a funky sidearm righty with 30-grade fastball velo. Neely has a plus slider and sits 93-94; that’s a little less velo than is ideal given his lack of command. Wilson missed 2022 with injury but came back sitting 95-97 in a walk-prone 28 innings this season.
Swingman Types
Zach Messinger, RHP
Christian Zazueta, RHP
Messinger has a five-pitch mix led by a 92-mph fastball that plays up and a plus-breaking slider. His command isn’t great and he’s run walk rates around 12.5% the last two years. Zazueta led the DSL Yankees in innings pitched with 52. He has the pitch movement foundation to break out if he can throw harder as he matures. He currently has a rise-and-run upper-80s fastball, a shapely mid-70s curveball, and a precocious changeup, all of which have bat-missing promise.
System Overview
The Yankees farm system has dealt with a number of body blows this offseason via both trades that have helped the big league club and the Rule 5 draft. Those departures (most significantly Drew Thorpe, who would have ranked sixth here) have left New York pretty thin on viable upper-level starters. It’s still early in the offseason and more will likely be done to add to the Yankees’ rotation before the spring, but right now their depth chart has three guys who I resolutely have projected as relievers (Luis Gil, Yoendrys Gómez, and Clayton Beeter) penciled in as starters five through seven. That puts an emphasis on Will Warren (who I think could snare a rotation spot during the spring) and Chase Hampton to be ready soon.
This system is healthy (that’s a formidable group of 50s up top) and exciting, but it’s volatile. There are a lot of teenage arms and hitters with hit tool risk scattered up and down the list. Even most of the very top of the farm system has a wide range of outcomes. Part of why the system has this flavor is because the Yankees just traded a way a bunch of upper-level prospects. It’s also a signal the international scouting program is doing well. It’s one thing for the Mayea and Arias types to sustain their prospect stock, and it’s another to spend most of your bonus pool on those guys and still add other interesting players in that signing class. The Yankees’ penchant for guys built like Freicer Perez and Dellin Betances in this market is clear, which makes sense given their consistent ability to develop pitching.
I have talked to scouts who cover the Yankees system who think they aren’t quite developing pitchers at the same rate as they have in the recent past, and who think the org’s tendency to ask young hitters to sell out for power is detrimental to their development. Some of what pro scouts don’t see is how prospects looked before they were drafted. Especially when the developmental leap occurs behind closed doors, they only see late-round college arms like Hampton after they’ve already been touched and improved. The Yankees have had 20 players selected in the last eight Rule 5 Drafts, which I think is a pretty good indication that the org still knows how to pick and develop players.
Eric Longenhagen is from Catasauqua, PA and currently lives in Tempe, AZ. He spent four years working for the Phillies Triple-A affiliate, two with Baseball Info Solutions and two contributing to prospect coverage at ESPN.com. Previous work can also be found at Sports On Earth, CrashburnAlley and Prospect Insider.


The Yankees are a fun system to read about because they take huge swings on toolsy Latin American kids and so you can daydream all day about what they will look like if it clicks. A lot of them don’t pan out though, so you get to find out who the new guys are you can dream on (Mayea, Lalane, Lagrange…Arias is sort of new to this, sort of not) while watching the bubble burst on the guys who aren’t going to put it together (Pereira, Gil).
I got a chance to go to a couple games in Scranton for the first time ever this year. I had a hard time recognizing Warren, Wells, and Pereira from their prior scouting reports, although Pereira’s new scouting reports are similar to what I saw. Warren’s stuff was not fooling the Mets’ org guys at all, and the Quad-A types and Ronny Mauricio took him apart. I would put Thorpe at least a half-grade ahead of Warren, although Eric has them effectively tied. Wells looked really unathletic at the plate, behind the plate, when running, etc. Maybe he was sick or something when I saw him, but if I was a Yankees fan I’d temper my expectations a bit.
Love your takes ST, though I think you’re wrong on Gil. I think he’s a back end of the bullpen guy, potentially a closer. Elite FB metrics and a really good slider. Pereira may not hit enough though but it’s been 27 games and he’s 22. I’m willing to give him a little more time. Or at least platoon him against lefties with Verdugo. I’m not all the way out on Pereira, but the hit tool has me willing to move on him for sure. He’s probably a trade chip.
I like Hampton plenty, but my guy is Will Warren. He was 1st in stuff+ and pitching+ in AAA (minimum 1000 pitches), doesn’t give up many HRs (though the AAA ball and environment didn’t help), tons of groundballs, insane stuff. He’s a Mike King variant. I’m a big Thorpe fan as well, but I wonder how much that low 90s FB plays against big leaguers.
I am definitely getting strong Mike King vibes off of Warren, too. And that’s a really good thing.
Maybe I caught Warren on a bad day. I was really confused by Eric’s scouting report after I saw him in person. I’m looking at his game log, and it looks like he went through a stretch near the end of July and beginning of August where he was quite bad. And that’s when I saw him.
Did you see him at the tail end of the season? He definitely settled in, so i think he can be good.
No, I saw him in early August. From looking at the game log, it looks like he went through a rough stretch a week or two before that. So whatever I was looking for in Eric’s report, I didn’t see it, and that’s probably because he didn’t have it at that time and straightened it out later.
There’s quite a bit of high-end and breakout potential in the Yankees lower minors right now, more than usual, but that also means there’s a higher bust potential too. It wouldn’t surprise me at all if in year’s time the Yankees system was top 10, even top 5, or in the bottom third! They have to show me they can finish off their hitters. That’s been a weakness for whatever reason.
The guy I’m a lot more excited about now is Agustin Ramirez. He sounds like he could have gotten an FV50 grade from the writeup and statistical performance. I think I’m higher on him and Jasson Dominguez than Eric is. Dominguez is still somehow not yet 21, and his skills are still a work in progress. I think there’s a chance his hitting stalls out due to lousy bat control like Yoan Moncada, but I think there’s a chance he puts it together enough to be an elite hitter for a few years (like, Darryl Strawberry-level good).
I think I’ve learned enough from Aaron Judge to never completely write off raw power like Spencer Jones has, but he sure doesn’t seem like a guy you would play everyday in center field to me and he’s not exactly hitting for a ton of power now. I am very skeptical of him being higher than a 50, and I find it hard to understand how he would ever be ahead of Dominguez who is younger, is probably better defensively, further ahead of him in terms of proximity to the majors, etc.
Yeah, I was shocked to see Jones as #1 and with a 55 grade. That’s a very aggressive ranking for someone with some obvious issues. Sure there’s upside as well but the downside is huge (pun intended).
These two are obviously very different, but I get Elly De La Cruz vibes here. As in, the potential pitfalls with the contact were obvious and they show up in the performance, but the tools are so outrageous and the baseball skills aren’t so far off that there’s a lot of potential positive outcomes. They’re both big, tall guys who have some extra reasons to give them some development slack (Elly switch hitting and Jones limited reps due to injury/focusing on hitting).
Like, Elly was almost a 2 win player in 100 games while still running having terrible k/bb rates and smashing the ball into the ground. I think Jones can similarly improve some and be useful like that. Of course, like Elly, the blow up into elite territory is on the table, too.
I guess my issue is this. The 55 rating – which would put him around #15-#40 on the top 100 list – seems to be based off of potential rather than production. Cause while Jones was okay last year, he didn’t exactly set the world on fire (114 wRC+ in A+, 104 in AA).
I’d prefer to see more actual production before rating him that highly. Particularly for someone who, based off of Eric’s writeup, may need several more years before he’s ready.
Eric certainly has a type, haha!
Yeah, I do feel like I’m taking crazy pills any time I read one of Eric’s writeups of Dominguez.
He’s a switch hitter who doesn’t hit legal drinking age for another 6 weeks…and he had fewer than 800 career PA, entering the season.
Of course his hit tool isn’t a finished product, haha!
Oh, and he went on an absolute rampage in the upper minors in over the second half of the season.
If he were a $500k bonus guy named Dasson Jominguez, he’d be a 60.
I mean, I HATE the Yankees. I’ve been wanting Dominguez to turn out to be a complete bust. But even I have to admit that seems less and less likely.
What are the chances Mayer and Bleis stay 55s, haha?
Mayer has a case since he is basically the same guy from a year ago except one level higher. I would hope Bleis is not.
He was repeating Hi-A, then got rocked at AA before hitting the IL.
For me, Mayer was a 50 before and he is a 50 now. He’s still young and has tools and plays a premium position (probably) and he did fine at a level appropriate for his age. That’s basically the same thing as last year. So if you’re higher on the tools than I am then I see why someone would give him a 55.
I also think it’s justified to give Domínguez a 50 because he’s not going to play for a year and that injects a lot of uncertainty. But he’s so much further ahead of Mayer and Jones that it does seem like it would make much more sense for him to be the 55 and those two to be 50’s.
Now if you want me to really, really disagree with Eric, wait until the Dodgers list and we can talk about Diego Cartaya.
Yeah, I do feel like “55 base, knocking him down to 50 until we see how he comes back from TJ” is eminently reasonable.
At this point, I feel like Justin Upton is a better comp than Zion – so insanely (and unfairly) hyped early on that mere excellence is looked at as disappointing.
You’ve been wanting someone you dont even know to fail? Cornball
I dunno…5’9″ and 220 at his age coming off of major surgery after losing key development years? Body type compared to a guy who can’t stay healthy and has no work ethic? I think it’s fair to question whether he’s a future CF or DH (it certainly was with, say, Mike Stanton and Aaron Judge)
…where on Earth are you getting “220,” haha?
He’s listed at 190, and has actually cut weight since his age-18 season.
He’s also expected back before the ASB.
I definitely agree that he’s missed important developmental time, though!
Given the cancellation of the 2020 MiLB season, the 2019 international signing class should be treated as roughly akin to the 2020 crew when judging rapidity of progression, rather than defaulting to ARL.
…I’m not sure if that’s quite the point you were trying to make, though.
Mike Stanton pitched for the Yankees 20+ years ago. Smiling politely while spewing garbage is passive aggressive cowardly crap.
I’m sure you know this, but Giancarlo Stanton went by Mike Stanton as a prospect and for his first couple of years in MLB.
There are so so many problems here.
Why would the comparison of body types have anything to do with work ethic?
Why would one mention two dudes (assuming you mean Giancarlo Stanton there) who are almost a full foot taller when talking about body types?
Aaron Judge, at 31, played a perfectly cromulent CF. Stanton was still fairly playable in the OF into his early 30’s.
That having been said, I do think Dominguez ultimately settles in as a plus corner OF — he doesn’t seem to get the best reads in CF, but I’ve only watched a dozen or so of his games.
Last year Dominguez ran a 15.2% walk rate in AA, and 16.2% in AAA.
While there are questions on his defense, the guy is not yet 21 and if he weren’t coming back from Tommy John surgery I think it would be perfectly reasonable to expect him to hit .250/.350/.450 with 40 SB potential as a 21 year old center fielder… like, what am I missing here?
I don’t know that that slashline (even excluding the baserunning) is “reasonable to expect” out of any rookie 21 year old. That’s about equivalent to what Adley Rutschman and Gunnar Henderson have put up in the big leagues. Those guys were both #1 overall prospects who became instant 125 wRC+, 5 WAR players as rookies. If Dominguez put those #s up as a CF, he’d probably be ranked in the top 20 (if not top 10) in next year’s trade value ranking. Even if you view Dominguez as more of a 55 FV prospect, I think expectations like these are setting yourself up for disappointment.
I might not bet on an .800 OPS…but most “rookie 21 year olds” haven’t just put up a .365 wOBA across AA and AAA in a pair of pitchers’ parks…with a .62 K/BB, to boot.
For example: Gunnar’s age-21 season came off a year where he actually put up a lower wRC+ across A/A+ than Dominguez did across AA/AAA last year…to say nothing of the gap in their peripherals.
Hence the cognitive dissonance from reading Eric’s Dominguez takes – guys who debut at 20 tend to be pretty damn special, unless they have a hideous approach…in part because they have so much time to improve stuff like their “feel to hit.”
Maybe an .800 OPS is on the high side, but if it weren’t for the TJ surgery, he would be the Yankees’ opening day centerfielder, and Dominguez would be comfortably within the top 10 prospects in baseball, as a 21 year old MLB starting high-OBP CF with plus-plus speed and power, even with a developing hit tool.
It seems like Eric has a bias against guys with “physically mature” body types as prospects. This is causing him to treat it as a done deal that Dominguez will slow down soon and doesn’t have much more room to improve. His job is evaluating and tracking these prospects so maybe he’s seen this happen often in the past but I think it’s slightly unfair to underrate him just because he was already big and strong as a teenager.
Jasson Dominguez only dominated the high-Minors as a 20 year old switch hitter who’s still getting a feel for hitting, then looked like he belonged in his MLB cup of coffee!
Miguel Bleis might have been overwhelmed by Low-A pitching as a 19 year old, but he could be *anything*! Even a 20 year old who dominates the high minors and looks like he belongs in a MLB cup of coffee!
He’s not entirely wrong about this, but I think this is probably something to worry about a little later. He’s such a premium athlete that even if there some regression he has a decent chance to stay in CF at first unless his routes are bad.
I think you can justify sticking Dominguez at FV50 because the TJ is going to interrupt his development again but I have a very hard time seeing him as being a half grade behind Spencer Jones. If I had to pick, I’d pick Dominguez being a half grade ahead instead of behind.
I’m personally more perplexed about Wells being ahead of Dominguez than Jones. I guess the case is that if everything breaks right for wells, he’s an average/slightly above average bat who is playable at catcher, but neither of those seem like locks. If he can’t catch he’s basically just a Quad-A guy whose bat doesn’t quite justify starting in a corner. I think most teams would take Dominguez over Wells.
He literally tied Corbin Carroll for fastest time home to 3rd in all of organized baseball last year, so the speed should bring up the baseline a bit.
Am I getting the wrong impression if I think the Yankees are distinctly very bad at coaching hit tool? It’s like clockwork that their top prospects show up on these lists with something like a 50-55 FV hit tool that never materializes, to where they’re in AAA with a 40 FV ceiling.
I get the sense that they are the barrel-rate-above-all system, and secondarily not chasing — which I guess there are worse things to be, but there seem to be tradeoffs there. When I look at graphs of where major league pitchers give up barrels, it’s overwhelmingly middle-middle. The MLB yankees lineup got diced up by any starter who could locate at even an average level. Volpe in particular looked totally helpless and has to have lowered his ceiling from a 60-grade prospect to like a 40 or lower, let alone Pereira or Peraza.
Again, I’m not a scout, but I’m just puzzled at how this system that has a reputation as good at development in advanced-stats-focused circles has produced hitters who consistently underperform every projection for half a decade now. Is there an element of putting the cart before the horse in focusing so much on power before zone and pitch coverage?
Like just for instance, Pereira debuted on Fangraphs’ prospect lists in 2018 with a 20/55 hit. 2019 it dropped to 25/50, then 2022 to 30/40, and now 30/30. And he’s the most drastic example, but not the only one. Dominguez has had a similar trajectory, just on a smaller bandwidth. What, did no one notice? Do they not think that’s important? Like, I half expect Jorbit Vivas to be on the updated report next year as a guy with now a 40 hit tool ceiling but who just might pop a dozen homers over a full season with 600 PA.
Volpe just wasn’t ready for MLB. He played a month in AAA. To say he’s a 40 or lower prospect after a rookie year in which he put up a 1.9 fWAR season is insane. A 40 or lower prospect is the last guy on an MLB roster, not one putting up an average WAR.
He was the worst rookie hitter by wRC+ with that many PA in like 6 years. PECOTA has even his 80th-percentile projection for 2024 at a sub-.700 OPS. And for what it’s worth, the decision-makers in the org were undoubtedly expecting more from him. They had him up all year because they wanted him to place in the voting for ROTY, which would net them a bonus draft pick per the new CBA, and so they clearly thought he was capable of it. Which tells me they do not know their own system and its flaws and have been lapped in hitting development by other smarter orgs.
Oh so you just hate the Yankees? Lol you could’ve just said that and saved all the typing.
How is that at all a summary of what I’ve said? I presented a statistic that indicates he was a really bad hitter even for a rookie, a projection system indicating that even his ceiling is a well below-average hitter, and context that is admittedly conjecture but not exactly a reach that the Yankees wanted an extra draft pick.
Well the Volpe stat isn’t a good faith argument for one. How many rookies play 159 games? That stat is absurd. It means nothing. How many rookies have had more PA in the last ten years than Volpe? It’s got to be a low number. He was a 22 year old with a month in AAA thrown into the big leagues before he was ready. If he has the same type of year next year with no improvement, then maybe you’re right on Volpe. But even a small improvement to 90 wRC+ will make him a 3 WAR guy.
And saying the Yankees don’t know their own system is a bit absurd. When’s the last time they traded away anyone they’ve missed? Sure their hitting development isn’t great, but they draft consistently at the end of the first round and don’t have access to elite level talents like Witt, Adley, etc. They also don’t get large bonus pools to pay overslot bonuses to guys that fall.
It’s a lot more complex than “they don’t know their system and their hitting dev sucks”. Also other scouts and teams love the Yankees’ system. They’ve pulled off several big trades over the last 5 years.
When was the last time they kept a guy off-limits in all discussions and he turned into a star? Because they eventually DFA’d Andujar and Frazier and they’re about to DFA Florial.
Speaking of which–Am I misremembering, or did the Yankees trade Jordan Montgomery for the remains of Harrison Bader? If I were a member of the 2023 Yankees, I certainly would have missed him.
The problem is their system has clearly “hit” on only 1 position player they signed as a IFA or drafted, whether with the Yankees or otherwise, in the last decade+.
I did this exercise for a previous discussion of the utter failure of the Yankees hitting development program — there were 3 or 4 players league wide in ’23 who cracked 100 wRC+ as a batting title qualifier that were developed by the Yankees – Judge, Ezequiel Duran, Thairo Estrada, and, depending on which organization you give credit for him, Gleyber Torres. If you slide the PA marker down low enough, you can include Gary Sanchez.
I will say that I think injuries definitely derailed Frazier — concussions are no joke — and certainly contributed to Andujar not repeating his fantastic rookie year.
And if you think the Volpe stat is cherry-picked, fine, let’s lower the bar. 250 PA sound reasonable? Volpe ranks 244th out of 337 rookies in the past 10 seasons at that threshold. Fantastic, from a consensus top 10-ish prospect. 28th-percentile given a full season to figure it out with assurances he’d never be demoted or lose the job.
Hey, maybe I’m wrong. Maybe all the projection systems are wrong too, and maybe so are all the pitchers who had him thoroughly figured out by September, when he cratered and was the worst hitter in the AL. I don’t see it. I see a guy who can be exposed up, down, away, and in, and whose vault lead baserunning gimmick lost its effectiveness by June. I see yet another guy they should’ve flipped when his value was sky-high whom they’ll wind up DFAing in two years.
lol
2 WAR as a rookie
Wow, the 19th-best WAR of any rookie position player in 2023. I take it all back
But now you’re going overboard.
To assert that Volpe was anything but a disappointment is simply erong. His defense was better than expected (hardly GG level) which greatly helped his WAR value.
I think you’re right. Hopefully dumping Lawson (signed by the Red Sox) is a signal they’ve realized that their philosophy has to change.
Eric touches on this a little bit:
That said, I have no idea why anyone thought Pereira was going to have an average hit tool.
That was after he signed as an IFA and there was no stats or data for him lol. After he started playing the games, he was projected around a 40 hit tool IIRC.
He had a 50 FV rating on his hit tool as recently as the 2021 Updated list. Obviously his minor league playing time is a little disjointed because of 2020, but I definitely wouldn’t say “there was no stats or data”
Just eat your popcorn and enjoy the battle between a pair of massive Yankees homers?
The next time the Yankees make a mistake will be the first in steveo’s eyes…while Mac is fully convinced that every prospect is Hall of Fame bound until the Yankees RUIN THEM.
I don’t get NY sports radio in Ireland, so I’m enjoying this!
I openly criticize the Yankees all the time. Hal is cheap, the Yankees lineup is (was?) feeble (Soto and Verdugo help), the rotation is iffy, the bullpen could use another back end guy. I am a Yankees homer but they’ve been a deeply flawed team these past few years. Juan Soto helps, but they’ve got a long way to go. The farm is solid but the Yankees have an issue finishing off their development in MLB. If they don’t accomplish it with this round of prospects, they’ve got some internal questions that need to be asked.
The questions have needed to be asked for years, specifically on the position player side of dev. Hitting on Judge counts for quite a bit, but not being able to build out any depth, whatsoever, is a huge problem. They’ve needed to use their pitching development to paper over that with trades.
A) If you think a 2 fWAR/3 rWAR rookie season lowers Volpe’s “ceiling” to a “40 or lower,” you first need to turn off WFAN, then you need to look at what “40 FV” means, haha.
B) There’s definitely something iffy with their position player development, and I agree that the “EV Uber Alles” approach isn’t a fit for every hitter.
If you think Anthony Volpe – who just posted 1.9 fWAR and 3.3 bWAR as a 22 year old MLB shortstop – is a “40 or lower” grade prospect, you don’t understand what prospect ratings mean. If Volpe never gets any better at all and puts up years exactly like the year he put up, that’s what a 55 grade MLB player looks like.
Not to mention – all the kvetching about how “No rookie with so many PA has ever had so a low wRC+” is hilariously wide of the mark.
Every team has a lower threshold at the plate for a plus runner who plays a good defensive SS!
Love the list. Thanks Eric. Some thoughts:
I’m disappointed the FCL crew John Cruz, Enmanuel Tejada, Willy Montero, and Hans Montero didn’t make the top 36. I was also hoping to see Engelth Urena not on here as well, but he missed the entire season so it’s understandable. I also would’ve liked to see Cam Schlittler listed but he’s a swingman/back end type so it’s not crazy. One guy I’m high on who isn’t listed is Jackson Fristoe. He has an elite FB with great metrics and velocity. I expect the Yankees will teach him the sweeper and he’ll take off next year in A+. I think he’s the next Chase Hampton. Also kind of shocked Caleb Durbin didn’t make the list. Hit really well this year and all the other small MIF are included.
I think more of Dominguez’s and Serna’s hit tool, but for the most part I agree with the grades given. I’m also higher on Rumfield. I think he can really hit. Low babip this year tanked his BA, but he’s a huge human and with his hit tool, if he can tap into some more raw power, I think he can be a Casas light with less raw power but a little better hit tool. I also think I’d 45 Brock Selvidge. Big lefty, 3 solid pitches, great GB rates, threw a bunch of innings, etc.
I was prepared to say that I’m lower on Pereira but, um, yeah. I think his best profile is a Morel type. Beeter needs to improve his control, but that’s a tall task. I’m also a bit lower on Vivas. The hit tool is solid, but I don’t think he can play the left side of the infield. If he were a good defender or had elite speed, I’d be on him as a starter.
Overall I think it’s a fair assessment. Probably a top 10ish system, maybe even top 7ish, but we’ll see how the rest of the lists shake out.
Excited to see J. Serna and Delgado on the big list — as a big believer in the importance of OBP, I’ve been keeping an eye on them. Thought Tejeda would be on it; there’s a lot to like there.
I tend to agree with the general idea of “let the player convince you he can’t play a premium position”, but I think it might be a good idea to slide Rice to 1B more or less full-time and see where his bat takes him.
I’m out on Pereira. Small sample size and all that, but he looked absolutely unplayably awful in his callup. Wells was trending that way, but he got it together and that swing — it feels like he was made for Yankee Stadium. Very yes on him.
I’m also very much here for Dominguez. I hate to be “that guy” but he definitely has shown a makeup that strongly implies a desire to continue to improve and an ability to make things happen in big spots.
“Makeup” is the flimsiest and most useless thing prospect writers who should know better still talk about. I think as soon as that gets mentioned in a blurb, you can stick a fork in the guy. Good prospects, no one cares enough about their makeup to even mention it. Look back at all those “intangibles” that Volpe was given credit for.
Yeah that Adley Rutschman guy sure was a dud.
Julio Rodriguez too.
Taken from Alex Verdugo’s 2019 Top 100 Prospects “TLDR” blurb from this very website:
Verdugo’s “makeup” surely hasn’t affected his big league career at all, right?
I agree with you that it is very tricky to evaluate personality/work ethic from outside the organization, and that “makeup” often has carried some level of implicit bias (whether about style of play, ethnicity, background, etc.) which generally makes it useless.
That’s why I was reluctant to even mention it, but some players have a certain “it” factor to them that it’s hard to ignore. Two fantastic examples are mentioned in the immediate comments; Aaron Judge is another example. Altuve, Yordan, Verlander, Scherzer, Harper, Soto, Corbin Carroll, Jose Ramirez, Lindor, Cole, Seager — all immensely talented dudes who just seem to bring a little more value than even their impressive stats would indicate.
Yeah, I’ll just admit I went overboard in what I said, but I’m still just skeptical anytime I see it mentioned for a prospect who isn’t already exceptional as per something more measurable. I just think professional scouts and prospect writers completely misread it all the time and write practically the opposite.
I wonder where Thorpe would have listed here if he was still in the system.
“ (most significantly Drew Thorpe, who would have ranked sixth here)”
Wondering if Jared & Luis Serna are related?
Cousins, if I recall correctly.
I guess I’m left wondering why Jones couldn’t be up early in ’25 following Dominguez’s path with a cuppa in ’24 September. The Yankees have been super aggressive on promotions when ‘their guys’ hit production or plate appearance milestones. Following that logic may not be for Jones as Jones may need more time, just as described in the report with long levers of tall prospects requiring longer development paths or the big league not competing quashing late-season development opportunities.
Main thing is that Jones hasn’t had anywhere near the performance that Dominguez did at the same levels, back when he was 19.
It’s closer than you think. Outside of Dominguez’s walks and lowering his K% in A+, they are producing similar stat lines with an advantage to Dominguez for an increased OBP. Granted one is younger, but both are in second seasons.
Don’t forget that Dominguez also hit for quite a bit more power!
So yes…the only reasons JD had a 30 point higher wRC+ in A+ as a 19 year old switch hitter than Jones did as a 22 year old are that his K/BB/ISO was 12.5%/18.5%/.205, while Jones’ was 9.2%/29.0%/.182
Power was marginal at best (.02 ISO). Domiguez’s wRC+ was better due to his OBP, i.e. his walks. Jones has better power, but Dominguez hit more flies.
A) An ISO gap of .020 is absolutely significant.
B) A BABIP gap of .020 is also significant.
The only reason Jones’ wRC+ was only 30 points lower at age-22 than JD’s was at 19 is that .020 advantage in wRC+.
absolutely significant? this is A ball. they had similar seasons in A ball. it doesn’t matter beyond that. otherwise and jones would have a lower fv than dominguez.
I mean…you can keep claiming that a 145 wRC+ with a .343 BABIP and .66 BB/K is “very similar” to a 115 wRC+ with a .363 BABIP and a .31 BB/K, haha.
It just, y’know, won’t be true.
So, again:
The reasons age-19 Dominguez DRAMATICALLY outperformed age-22 Jones in Hi-A, despite a significantly lower BABIP…are that JD walked more, whiffed less, and hit for more power.
But…uh…Jones might reach that level, someday?
I suspect he’s more on a Judge path specifically because it’s about trying to get consistency from Jones and tap into that raw a bit more.
That having been said, I expect Jones gets a full ST invite this year and, if it goes well, slides into AAA — but I wouldn’t be shocked if he’s headed back to Somerset.
Dominguez forced the issue from a performance standpoint. Jones hasn’t exactly been busting the door down.
Jones is almost definitely starting at Somerset – he held his own, but nothing he did there shows he’s ready for Scranton.
I agree he starts in Somerset. Probably gets another ~375PA before moving to Scranton. Gets at least 100PA in AAA before September.
Once Pereira, Cabrera, Peraza, Wells, Volpe, and Dominguez hit AA, they all had a taste of the bigs by the end of the following season. How does being tall stop the Yankees from following this pattern with Jones?
It’s not about Jones “being tall.”
It’s about the fact that, of the players you named, the only one who wasn’t significantly better at A+ and AA in terms of both results and underlying stats is Everson Pereira…who was only called up after the season was over.
None of them struck out 29% of the time in A+, either.
Jones being a step behind those guys developmentally doesn’t make him a bad prospect – it makes sense for all the reasons Eric lists in his glowing writeup.
But he is developing at a slower pace, and ignoring that is unfair to the kid.
After the Soto trade, their farm system is in the lower 1/3. Depth could be a problem for them unless they sign some people to AAA.
They gave up one prospect of substance in the Soto trade and two useful big leaguers on the cusp of free agency, along with a couple of guys who wouldn’t have made this list.
The Yankees currently have 5 x catchers and 10 x outfielders on their 40-man. Having that set in place prior to R5 draft is the reason they lost so many players – it’s complete roster mismanagement and a black eye to their front office who left some of their best pitching depth exposed. How do you not protect Matt Sauer but decide to pick up Oscar Gonzalez on waivers when he clearly won’t have a role with the team? The Yankees are mismanaged. Simple as that. There’s good reason they won’t catch Rays or Orioles again this year, and it starts with Brian Cashman.
It was 6x C up until the Soto trade, which was sort of hilarious. (BTW, when I saw that Higgy didn’t get non-tendered, I was fairly sure he was headed to San Diego…)
Oscar Gonzalez was added after the Rule 5 protection deadline, so he didn’t really affect anything — Sauer was already dangling in the wind. I’m bit more iffier on whether they should have protected him, but I also think there’s a decent chance he doesn’t stick all year and gets returned.
The one move I totally question is Carlos Narvaez. I’m not sure why he had to be added to the 40 — and weirdly, in advance of the deadline by a few days. Leaving 3 or 4 spots open seemed a bit weird unless you’re trying to splurge in the R5 — guys can be DFA’d later if need be, and as it turns out, the Yankees were net negative in 40 man spots since that point. Trading 4 guys from your 40 to receive 2 will do that.
This year wasn’t even that bad from a 40-man management standpoint, although the Verdugo/Soto trades next year’s burden a bit (w/o looking it up, I believe Fitts and Thorpe are both 2024 R5 eligible).
Yankees certainly seem to love very short middle infielders, very tall pitchers, and all the catchers they can get
I mean, there are worse types of players to have a propensity for.
Not saying it’s a bad thing, but it’s amusing/interesting to me that (by my count) 22 out of 36 players ranked here are either middle infielders that are 5’10” or shorter, pitchers that are 6’3″ or taller, or catchers. Especially with all of the short middle infielders, it makes me wonder if the Yankees think they’ve found an undervalued player type.
I think the Yankees’ borderline obsession with collecting short middle infielders like Pokemon is fascinating given the opposing player most single-handedly responsible for keeping them out of the WS these last 7 years.
My ungenerous take about Cashman and co.’s decade in review is that they’ve been copying off the Astros’ homework since 2017. Followers rather than trendsetters, perpetually a step or two behind.
Life-long Yankee fan here, so not a hater. They let Andres Chaparro walk for nothing, then pick up Boston reject Jeter Downs. Thats all i need to know about their current decision-making process.
Won’t someone please think of the 24 year old 1B with a 90 wRC+ at AAA?
99% of Yankee fans have no idea what Andres Chaparro looks like.
A righty 1B, no less.
He might be the next Mike Ford!!!
Ford is better, and Ford is in a constant battle of trying to prove he’s more than a AAAA hitter. Some fans have difficulty putting context around stat lines, hence why MLB talent evaluators know a player like Estevan Florial won’t hit MLB pitching with any consistency, but fans don’t.
I agree with all of this.
Drew Thorpe was higher rated than Hampton or Warren, but I do wonder if the Yankees prefer the latter two more than Thorpe, or they viewed them as roughly equals and told San Diego to pick one of the three.
Lots of guys here leaping multiple levels since the 2023 evaluations– from 45 to 55, 40+ to 50, even 35+ to 50. The numbers don’t really jump off the page in many of these cases, so these reevaluations clearly reflect a lot of effort on the author’s part in terms of watching these players, talking to scouts, etc. It looks like 2023 must have been a good year for the Yankees’ player development system- good for them, I guess .
Is Jace Avina not on this list because he was just acquired, or, because he doesn’t deserve to be ?
I think… the 2024 Yankee Prospect listing also appears EXACTLY for 2023. One is wrong.
i remember when luis medina was a Yankees prospect, he was a 50FV although his walk rates were trash lol. Then he went to the A’s, he was no longer a 50FV. Same thing happened with James Kaprielian and Waldichuk.