FanGraphs Baseball

Rio Ruiz Keeps Raking, but Scouts Still Have Reservations

When our other prospect writers submit scouting reports, I will provide a short background and industry consensus tool grades. There are two reasons for this: 1) giving context to account for the writer seeing a bad outing (never threw his changeup, coming back from injury, etc.) and 2) not making him go on about the player’s background or speculate about what may have happened in other outings.

The writer still grades the tools based on what they saw, I’m just letting the reader know what he would’ve seen in many other games from this season, particularly with young players that may be fatigued late in the season. The grades are presented as present/future on the 20-80 scouting scale and very shortly I’ll publish a series going into more depth explaining these grades. -Kiley

Read the rest of this entry »


The MVP and the DH Adjustment

No designated hitter has ever won the Most Valuable Player award. Barring a surprise, that will not change this season. Victor Martinez has had a amazing year, but he is not going to be the American League MVP. (I have a feeling he does not have much of a shot at being the National League MVP this year, either.) Who knows where he will end up in the balloting, but does outside of some Twitter arguments the day the winner is announced, will anyone really care about the down-ballot voting?

According the metric everyone loves to hate, Wins Above Replacement, that sounds about right. Martinez is not even close to the top. This might really bother some people. After all, one could argue that Martinez has been the best hitter in the American League this season. The problem with WAR, from the Martinez partisans’ perspective, is the positional adjustment for the DH.

This is not a post about where exactly Victor Martinez should be in the MVP discussion this season. The question is whether anyone would really have a shot at being the most valuable player according to WAR if they DHed all season.

Read the rest of this entry »


Ben Lindbergh Dispels Postseason Myths

Grantland’s Ben Lindbergh published a great piece last Friday, going through the laundry list of myths we hear rolled out every October, and showing that there is little or no evidence to support nearly any of them. On his hit-list:

Recent Performance Doesn’t Matter.

I wrote about this a few weeks ago, but it’s maybe the most important thing to remember, as we’re going to hear the word “momentum” about a million times in the next 24 hours. The A’s stumbled into the playoffs, going 29-38 in the second half of the year, the worst second-half record of any team that has made the postseason since 1995, but two of the three prior teams to win fewer than half of their games in the second half of the season went on to meet in the World Series. And as Jay Jaffe showed, even looking at just the final month, or the final few weeks, or even the final week of the season doesn’t really tell us anything about what is going to happen in October.

It’s very tempting to put a strong emphasis on what we’ve seen lately. Don’t do it. Recent performance isn’t predictive of future performance.

Experience Doesn’t Matter.

Lots of people have studied this. Lots of people have reached the same conclusion. Young, old, experienced or not; we can’t find any evidence that any particular group outperforms in the playoffs. I guess this is why the “they don’t know they’re not supposed to win” cliche was invented for times when the “experience is the only thing that matters” cliche is proven wrong.

Pitching Doesn’t Win Championships.

Having a heavily loaded front of the rotation is great. Having really good hitters is great. Having a great bullpen is great. There are lots of ways to win. No single way has proven better than the other.

He goes through a longer list, and provides plenty of good links, so keep the piece handy when you’re being inundated by announcer cliches over the next month. Most of them are total bunk.


The Most Extreme Home Runs of 2014

The regular season is over. While that is sad in many ways, it’s also exciting in a few other ways. One of those ways: We have postseason baseball! That’s the best kind of baseball. Another lame, nerdy way: We have complete data sets! Yes, this is something I actually get excited about. Leading up to the conclusion of a regular season, everything is “projected,” “on pace,” or “so far for the season.” Now, everything is final. While, at the All-Star Break, I could only give you the Most Extreme Home Runs of the First Half, now I can replace “first half” with a definitive “2014.”

Before we begin, I’d like to give a shoutout to both ESPN’s Home Run Tracker and, of course, BaseballSavant, for making this glorious research possible.
Read the rest of this entry »


Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat – 9/29/14

11:58
Dan Szymborski: It’s party time!*

11:58
Dan Szymborski: * Any promises of a party to not indicate that there will be a party

12:00
Dan Szymborski: First up though, our usual business. Presidents fighting for some strange reason!

12:00
:

12:00
:

12:02
Comment From Xolo
The Fangraphs profile last week made it seem like Tomas is going to be a +3ish WAR player. Does that sound right?

Read the rest of this entry »


2014’s King Of Driving In Runners

On Sunday, Adrian Gonzalez had two hits, including his 27th homer of the season, and drove in three runs in the Dodgers’ season-ending 10-5 win over Colorado. Already all but guaranteed to lead the NL in runs batted in, the three he brought in yesterday ensured that he’d top Mike Trout and lead all of baseball for RBI for the first time.

Before you wonder why FanGraphs is suddenly acting as though RBI is a real stat that means anything, worry not. I think it’s useless. You, most likely, do too, and we all already know why, because it’s largely based on opportunity and teammate performance, and that adds far too much noise to consider it useful as an individual stat. If you’re not an everyday player, you won’t have an impressive RBI total. If your teammates don’t get on base ahead of you, you won’t have enough chances to rack up those RBIs. Relying on it as an indicator of talent can cause more harm than good, too, like when Brandon Phillips was seen as having a great 2013 last year in the midst of his decline because the Reds offense was lucky enough to have Shin-Soo Choo leading off rather than Drew Stubbs (2012) or Billy Hamilton (2014).

It’s barely been one paragraph, and I’ve already probably spent far too much time even talking about why this is a flawed stat. You already know this. Unfortunately, we can probably agree that the majority of general baseball fans don’t quite agree with that, if only based on how many references to “RBI” I saw regarding Gonzalez on Twitter. Gonzalez himself, more understandably, took note as well: Read the rest of this entry »


The Most and Least Improved Hitters of 2014, by wRC+

The 2014 MLB regular season is officially something that happened. With its passing comes the need to get our affairs in order, for the lists, they are coming. They will be many, they will be tenacious. You, there! Guard that outpost! Get those archers ready, there’s no time to lose! The first of the lists are coming over the horizon. Brace yourselves, there is no end in sight.

Here are the most-improved (qualified) hitters of 2014, by the metric of wRC+:

Name 2013 wRC+ 2014 wRC+ Diff
Victor Martinez 112 167 54
Michael Brantley 103 155 52
Jose Altuve 85 135 50
Anthony Rizzo 103 153 50
Alcides Escobar 49 95 45
Starlin Castro 72 115 43
Adeiny Hechavarria 53 82 28
Jose Bautista 133 159 26
Adam LaRoche 102 127 25
Giancarlo Stanton 135 159 24
Todd Frazier 100 122 22
Justin Morneau 101 123 21
Denard Span 97 117 20
Trevor Plouffe 92 112 19
Nick Markakis 88 106 18
Alex Gordon 104 122 18
Brian Dozier 100 118 18
Jimmy Rollins 85 102 18
Jonathan Lucroy 117 133 17
Neil Walker 114 130 16

Seeing names like Martinez, Brantley, and Altuve on this list shouldn’t come as too big of a surprise, given the news surrounding their 2014 efforts. Some other interesting names pop up, however. Anthony Rizzo has taken a significant jump. Alcides Escobar has gone from loathesome to respectable, and Jose Bautista got better which doesn’t seem very fair.

In contrast, here are 2014’s least-improved (again, qualified) batters. You could also say these batters got the most worse, but that doesn’t sound either correct or pleasing.

Name 2013 wRC+ 2014 wRC+ Diff
Chris Davis 168 94 -74
Allen Craig 134 69 -65
Shin-Soo Choo 151 100 -51
Domonic Brown 123 75 -48
Miguel Cabrera 192 147 -44
Chris Johnson 127 82 -44
Jason Kipnis 129 86 -43
Jean Segura 105 67 -38
Jay Bruce 117 79 -38
Joe Mauer 143 106 -38
Matt Carpenter 146 117 -29
Marlon Byrd 137 109 -28
Jed Lowrie 120 94 -27
Evan Longoria 133 107 -26
Matt Dominguez 88 63 -25
Zack Cozart 79 56 -23
Austin Jackson 107 85 -22
Chase Utley 127 106 -21
Eric Hosmer 120 100 -21
Billy Butler 117 97 -20

The top three names here offer an interesting juxtaposition of two sluggers falling to around league-average, and a pretty-good hitter falling off like a Clayton Kershaw curveball. The inclusion of Davis and Craig on this list is notable, as if I expand the search to the last 20 years, they also make the cut.

Name Season 1 Yr1 wRC+ Season 2 Yr2 wRC+ Diff
Scott Brosius 1996 131 1997 50 -81
Adam Dunn 2010 136 2011 60 -75
Chris Davis 2013 168 2014 94 -74
Adrian Beltre 2004 161 2005 90 -71
Willie McGee 1985 151 1986 85 -66
Brook Jacoby 1987 144 1988 78 -66
Allen Craig 2013 134 2014 69 -65
Cal Ripken 1991 154 1992 90 -64
Ray Durham 2006 126 2007 62 -63
Jose Hernandez 2002 119 2003 58 -61
Howard Johnson 1989 166 1990 106 -60
Roberto Alomar 2001 151 2002 91 -60
Larry Sheets 1987 141 1988 83 -58
Chipper Jones 2008 174 2009 116 -58
Gary Gaetti 1988 144 1989 86 -58
Edgardo Alfonzo 2000 150 2001 93 -58
Aubrey Huff 2008 134 2009 77 -58
Derek Bell 1998 129 1999 72 -57
Casey Kotchman 2011 127 2012 70 -57
Darin Erstad 2000 140 2001 83 -56

Both Chris Davis and Allen Craig rank in the top seven of worst hitting drop-offs of the last 20 years. The reasons why should warrant some deeper digging. This is neither the time nor place for such digging — with these things typically being left for the cold, dark expanses of winter. For now, let us gaze upon these lists, acknowledge that they are indeed lists, and glean whatever value or joy we desire from them.


FG on Fox: How The Players Would Vote

The end of the season means it’s time for the playoffs, of course. But it also means that it’s time to vote on awards that reward regular season work. The players also vote on awards — and since they’re voting on their peers, they have a unique perspective on the exercise.

The players vote on something called the Player’s Choice award. And since I’m tasked with voting for the Player of the Year at FanGraphs, I thought it would make sense to ask the players for advice.

I asked two questions of a wide variety of players. The first was about their general process in deciding on their vote. I wanted to know what stats they looked at how they made their decision. The second was whether or not they thought a starting pitcher could rival a position player as the best player in baseball.

Let’s take the questions, one at a time, and see what the players said.

Read the rest on Just a Bit Outside.


The Playoff Odds, Now That We’re There

The postseason begins tomorrow, and we have our 10 contenders for the crown: Anaheim, Detroit, Baltimore, Oakland, and Kansas City in the AL, and Los Angeles, St. Louis, Washington, Pittsburgh, and San Francisco in the NL.

Two of these teams will be eliminated by the end of the day on Wednesday. Let’s take a look at the early odds for the Wild Card games, based on our depth charts model and the season-to-date stats model.

Read the rest of this entry »


Effectively Wild Episode 544: Cole, Altuve, and Other Season-Ending Excitement

Ben and Sam discuss the Pirates’ decision to start Gerrit Cole, the Astros’ decision to sit (and then start) Jose Altuve, and other news from the weekend.