Rangers Romp to World Series Behind Adolis García’s Dominant Performance

Baseball games don’t have a single protagonist. Baseball series don’t have a single protagonist either. The vagaries of a nine-man lineup, four-man rotation, and eight-man bullpen mean that the most important moments of a series feature semi-random matchups. Bryce Harper doesn’t get to bring the ball up, call for an isolation, and try to hit a game-tying home run. You can’t game plan a high-leverage at-bat for your star. It’s just probability; the big moments can’t possibly find the same guy every time, which is what makes baseball such a team sport.
Okay, now that I’ve said that: This game was Adolis García’s game, and this series was his series. He’s been at the center of everything ever since the start of the ALCS, but particularly for the past three games. First, Bryan Abreu hit him with a pitch that emptied the benches in Game 5 and eventually led to a memorable Astros comeback from García’s own three-run homer. He came back on Sunday determined to extract vengeance, and eventually succeeded. He took 16 swings at 22 pitches, first racking up four strikeouts but then hitting a majestic, game-breaking grand slam. On Monday, he was right in the middle of things again.
In the first inning, García stepped into Cristian Javier’s nightmare: Corey Seager demolished a high fastball for a 1-0 lead, Evan Carter walked and stole second, and García was at the plate threatening to break the game open before the Astros even batted. Javier threw him a fastball roughly six inches above the top of the strike zone. But García was up there to swing, not take, and he smashed a single off the face of the left field wall to score Carter. It was more of a double and a running error if I’m being honest; García, intent on celebrating his success against the Astros to the fullest, took a leisurely look at the rapidly receding baseball before he realized it wouldn’t leave the park. He scurried to first at half speed, chagrined, before stealing second immediately.
By the time García stepped to the plate again, a new pitcher was in the game. Javier didn’t last the first inning; he allowed five baserunners out of six batters faced and then hit the showers early. That meant García had a new opponent in Hunter Brown. A new pitcher meant a new plan: García took the first five pitches he saw, getting to a 3-2 count and noting that Brown was either throwing a fastball up and away or a curveball off the plate. The 3-2 pitch was another fastball up and away, and García decided he’d had enough of waiting. He muscled it just fair over the right field wall for a 4-1 lead.
At that point, the game was hardly over. The Astros weren’t about to go quietly into the night; they chased Max Scherzer from the game in the third inning and narrowed the gap to 4-2. They brought in J.P. France to replace Brown, and France immediately gave García another chance for a memorable moment. France got bitten by the BABIP gods; he gave up a walk and three soft line drives, the last a looped Carter double, to bring García to the plate with a 6-2 lead and two runners on base. García was locked in by now. He took a slider low, took a curveball high, and then smacked one that was juuuuuuust right for a two-run single.
Things kept going from there. With the game well in hand at 10-3 in the eighth, García got one last chance at the plate. He was in swing mode, ready to unload on whatever he saw. He’d already made an out, his first of the game, with two wild swings at sliders in his last at-bat. But José Urquidy might not have gotten the memo, because he dialed up a first pitch curveball right down the middle. García took a mighty hack – and hit the ball preposterously high in the air, a moonshot that barely cleared the left field wall. It would have been a home run in just two of the 30 parks in the majors, but come on, this was his night – of course it was going out.
This will forever be remembered as García’s series. He drove in a ludicrous 15 runs across the seven games, an all time single series record. He was at the center of a benches-clearing fracas, and he made sure the Astros remembered it by burying them under nine RBI over the next two games. He was named series MVP after the game and roundly deserved it. But this being baseball, plenty of other characters also figured into Game 7’s outcome.
Jordan Montgomery might have had a case for MVP if it weren’t for García’s late-series outburst. He threw 11.2 solid innings across starts in Games 1 and 5, then returned on two days of rest to stymie the Astros for another two-plus innings on Monday. Josh Sborz faced six batters and retired five of them. Seager was locked in right from the first pitch he saw, finishing 3-for-5 with a walk and a home run. Carter and Jonah Heim reached base multiple times. Nathaniel Lowe cracked a two-run homer. When all was said and done, eight of the nine Texas starters reached base at least once, wearing down eight Houston pitchers.
The winners didn’t have the only impressive performances of the night. As you might have heard, Yordan Alvarez had a pretty good series. He batted five times in Game 7 and went 3-for-4 with a walk and a triple, his sixth straight game in the series with multiple hits. Alvarez’s masterful ALCS deserves some mention, even as his team got absolutely buried at the end. He’s one of the best hitters in baseball, and he hit another gear this October. He finishes the postseason with a 297 wRC+ on a .465/.510/.968 batting line. It’s nearly impossible to win MVP when your team loses, and Garcia was a deserving winner as I said, but Alvarez put his mark on the series anyway thanks to an unending stream of hits.
For the Astros, this ALCS loss will sting for quite a while. They lost a close series to a big rival, and did so in heartbreaking fashion. Even worse, Dusty Baker made some strange decisions that left runs on the table in this one, at a time when the team absolutely couldn’t afford to do so. Brown looked solid in his two innings of work and spent the year as a starter, so I’m not quite sure why he got pulled. France, on the other hand, went eight batters and only recorded two outs; by the time Baker pulled him, the game was essentially over. And coming back is harder when Martín Maldonado has to take key at-bats; he batted twice with a runner in scoring position, with Houston trailing by multiple runs both times. Yainer Diaz is clearly a better option here, and Baker eventually did go to him, but the Astros skipper let valuable run scoring opportunities slip away first.
Getting back to the victors, Texas’ postseason work isn’t done. The World Series starts on Friday in Arlington, and regardless of who the Rangers face, they’ll have their work cut out for them. But for now, it’s a celebration. More than that, it’s Adolis’ celebration. You can’t control who comes up in the biggest spots, it’s true. But every time he had a chance to deliver in Game 7, he did, until his own success made his subsequent successes less important. This is the kind of playoff series we’ll remember years from now. Not because it went seven or because the road team won every game, and not because of late lead changes or a comeback from a 3-2 series deficit, but because it’s the series where Adolis García drove in all the runs and stared the Astros down while he did.
Ben is a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @benclemens.
Evan Carter has been phenomenal since they arrived in Arlington. They were amazing in the pennant race, and they have been fantastic in the playoffs. They cannot possibly maintain their .435 BABIP up long term, but they surely could keep it up another 4 to 7 games. If they do that, they will be a hero in Texas even if they regress to a more reasonable BABIP next year.
We assume Carter is more akin to James Outman or Brandon Marsh than Mickey Mantle. But so far in 2023, they are playing much more like Mantle than Marsh.
Trolling attempt?
The poster’s entire existence on this site is a trolling attempt.
We aren’t “trolling” at all. We just think Carter, while they are a very good ball player, will have a career more similar to Outman or Marsh than Mantle. They have hit like Mantle so far, but their BABIP is sky high. We don’t think they can keep that up long term.
Gotcha, trolling attempt, moving on
Is it really necessary to clarify that Carter isn’t the next coming of Mantle? I think it can be assumed that any player isn’t the next Mantle until they play like Mantle for multiple seasons. Even Trout isn’t the next Mantle. Carter’s unsustainable wOBA so far wouldn’t even make Mantle’s top 8 seasons.
Necessary? Clearly not. But was it necessary to ask if our comment was necessary? Also clearly not. None of our comments or your comments on this or any website are necessary.
Carter might wind up being a star, but they have their work cut out for them if they aspire to be like Mantle. That’s for sure.
I’m more just baffled that you’re comparing him to guys that strikeout over 30% of the time, that’s just fundamentally not who Carter is. Also there is a very wide margin between Mantle and those two.
El Bombi isn’t just a great player but an amazing story and human being. Seeing him succeed makes me happy
Hate to beat up on Dusty given that he’s likely to step down after the season per the athletic, but where was his urgency tonight? It was 4-2 and he just twiddled his thumbs while JP France burned it down. He probably shouldn’t have even brought him in but allowing him to face so many batters was malpractice. Bochy otoh went to Montgomery from the third inning through the fifth inning very smartly.
Was Dusty this bad when he was working with Click? I remember when the Astros first hired him someone said that it was a great fit because Dusty would benefit from the work the front office and it would keep him away from some of his worst tendencies while fixing the culture. But Click and Putila are gone now.
Honestly he seemed like he just gave up in this one. The pitching decisions were almost all baffling and Maldanado batting with runners in scoring position twice down like he was was malpractice
I love Dusty, but I think he is now 0-8 in game 7’s he’s managed – or maybe series deciding games.
As laid back as he normally is, he seems to make his teams uptight and to make weird decisions or non-decisions in these games.
On the other hand, maybe it’s all postseason vagaries and nothing he did or didn’t do would have changed the outcomes.
I still think he’s deserving of the Hall of Fame. His overall body of work is outstanding.
Hot take: his body of work has been with great GMs.
Losing 4 home games in 2 different series is a very strange achievement.
Worth noting that Dusty was not there for the first occurence. That was Hinch
It wasn’t just this game. It was the weird benching of McCormick, the existence of Singleton, the refusal to remove Maldonado even when the starter was out.
This was what Dusty has done the entire season. He sticks with his perception of roles, statistics be damned. It’s why team leader Maldonado remained the starter despite Diaz outplaying him in every metric. It’s why Chas McCormick played like a rotating 3rd-4th outfielder despite breaking out as a 130ops+
It’s why Maton, despite finish among the leaders in allowing inherited runners to score, remained the Astros go-to guy in such situations. Luckily for the Astros he pulled through.
It’s also why Singelton, a big lefty who can’t hit anyone, let alone righties, remained the go-to pinch hitter despite having 0 success.
Could somebody explain Baker’s fascination with playing Maldonado? He can’t hit. He doesn’t throw out runners, he leads the league in passed balls. Anyone?
“Something something veteran presence blah blah blah leadership”
Brown is probably better than Javier and ridiculously better than Urquidy or France so it could be that underutilizing him was the difference in this series. Javier has done well in postseasons up to now of course.
The loathsome cheaters get thumped. Maybe there is a tiny modicum of justice in this sad universe.
How many players on this current Astros roster were on the “cheating” team?
I feel like these sentiments will still follow them even after there isn’t a single member of the 2017 Astros still there. FWIW, Altuve, Bregman, Verlander, and McCullers (if he counts) are the only members of the 2017 Astros still with the team.
Oh, it will. That taint is attached permanently to the franchise, as well as to the particular players and personnel involved.
There will always be the haters but what team hasn’t attempted to steal signs at some point?
I think once this generation of players retires there will be plenty who are willing to talk about the electronic sign stealing era.
The Astros, Red Sox, and Yankees weren’t the only ones and there were plenty of accusations against other clubs, including the Rangers
Accusations, but no proof and no punishment. “Everybody was doing it” is a pretty lame excuse regardless.
Ya but that’s because MLB didn’t have any interest or financial incentive to investigate other teams.
They sell baseball. Why ruin the integrity of your league when you can instead sacrifice the Astros and make an example of them? Then market the Astros as the villain in an otherwise honorable league.
That sounds way better than: expose all the cheaters making MLB look unethical, pathetic and incompetent at running a business. Good luck selling that product.
That’s why I’m curious to hear from this generation of players when they retire.
I do agree that “everybody was doing it” is a lame excuse but in a competition with so much at stake…If MLB isn’t enforcing the rules, the rules will be broken routinely. And not just by the Astros, Red Sox, and Yankees.
If MLB is not trying to look unethical, pathetic, and incompetent at running a business, that train left the station a LONG time ago
MLB didn’t enforce the rules against the Astros. They lost a few million bucks and Jeff LOLuhnow, effectively zero punishment.
Altuve and Bregman, who are the faces of the franchise.
Altuve, maybe. Bregman is not the face of the franchise. I would argue Yordan and even Verlander are higher up on that metric.
They didn’t stop cheating until AT THE EARLIEST 2020, if ever (since they weren’t punished in any real way, there was not reason to stop). Watch the 2019 World Series and tell me they don’t know what pitches are coming.
The Rangers were also accused of stealing signs back then but enjoy your victory lap in make believe land
I will, don’t you fret. I made a stiff drink in honor of the Rangers.
I totally get it, if I was an Astros fan I would not back down an inch. Flags fly forever, Astros fans are completely fine in insisting that no crime was committed.
But the rest of us, living in reality, know that the 2017 title is tainted.
It’s not that “no crime was committed”. It’s that only one lawbreaker got charged and the others got let go and got to keep a clean reputation.
How tainted is a title if many of the contending teams were up to similar schemes?
Astros beat the Red Sox, Yankees, and Dodgers in the 2017 playoffs. Red Sox and Yankees both got caught that year and the Dodgers faced many accusations but weren’t investigated
As it stands, the Rangers’ trade for Jordan Montgomery is one of the best deadline deals in recent memory. If they win the whole thing, it is probably the best of all time with every other candidate looking at tying it. There is no way they make the playoffs or win this series without him, and he was a big part of the win against the Rays too. He covered up an extremely thin rotation, one that would have cracked for sure otherwise. This is what front offices are dreaming of when they make trades like this.
And I love seeing winning moves like this get rewarded. The Rangers could have sat on their hands given their record but they correctly identified they were going to need more pitching to win.
One of the best, yes.
But the gold standard is still Doyle Alexander: In 11 starts for the Tigers, Alexander went 9-0 with a 1.53 ERA. An All-Star next year, too.
Unfortunately, the price for getting him was either Steve Searcy (ML ready) and a kid named Smoltz.
That’s funny, every time I see the Doyle Alexander trade mentioned the discussion is how lopsided the deal was in favor of the Braves.
The Tigers got exactly what they wanted. That the Braves got more in the end doesn’t change the fact that both teams won the trade. This was certainly not Slocumb for Lowe and Varitek.
I think “best of all time” warrants some analysis and would be a great Fangraphs article. The 1969 Braves picked up Hoyt Wilhelm late in the season and won an ultra-close NL West race….so, lots of material here – good post!!
I think you would have to look at how close a team was to making the playoffs and getting through each series. With how close this series was and making the playoffs, and how good Montgomery has been, he would be very high up there.
Montgomery was flat-out awesome this series, but I was admittedly confused to see him out there in an 8-2 laugher. Dunning or Heaney can’t protect a 6-run lead? If you can’t use them there and save Monty for the World Series, they don’t need to be on the roster.
When Montgomery entered the game it was 4-2 with a man on 3rd base, and only the 3rd inning. It’s game 7 and way too early to worry about lining up a rotation for the World Series.
Sure, the Rangers blew the game open in the top of the 4th, but once you’ve got Monty in the game you may as well use him for a bit. He only threw 32 pitches, so that probably won’t affect his usage plan any differently from if they had used him for a shorter stretch.
I agree with you. Going to Montgomery to eat a few innings was the right thing to do. In game 7, you don’t worry about tomorrow because there might not be a tomorrow.
Now, the worst case scenario for the Rangers is that Montgomery starts game 2 on Saturday on regular rest. That’s not the worst thing in the world.
Exactly. Especially since they can start Eovaldi on full rest in game one.
When up 4-2: absolutely use Montgomery, that’s no sure thing.
When it’s an 8-2 game: hey, probably need to save that prized arm. “There’s no tomorrow” etc. obviously has some common sense limitations, a 6-run lead probably being one of them.
Their teams didn’t quite make it that far in the postseason, But C.C. Sabathia and Manny Ramirez willed their respective teams to a playoff berth in 2008.
Sabathia deal wouldn’t be a deadline deal since he moved in early July . but he was so dominant for Milwaukee.
Ehh. Semantics
IIRC Sabathia was pitching on 3 days rest the last month of that year.
I think it was his fourth consecutive 3 day rest start in the playoffs where he finally got hit (which is insane). He had something like 7 complete games
I don’t want to actually check and spoil my likely inflated memories of that run, but I recall him being an actual good hitter during that stretch too.
He hit .229 with a homer and 6 RBI for the Brewers, not bad at all!
One name that comes to mind, similar to Sabathia, is Randy Johnson to the Astros in 1998. 10-1 in 11 starts, 1.28 ERA. Astros lost in the NLDS but RJ pitched 14 IP with a 1.93 ERA. Would have been better remembered if the Astros had hit in the playoffs. 3 runs scored total across their three losses.
On June 15, 1964 the 28-31 Cardinals traded Ernie Broglio + to the Cubs for Lou Brock +. They proceeded to “go” 65-38 to rise from 8th place to win the pennant over the Short Bunning Phillies and Rose Robinson Reds. “Lou” batted .348/.387/.527 racking up 43 SB and 4.7 fWAR in the remaining 103 games. He then batted .300 with 5 RBI in the World Series victory over the Mantle Berra Ford Yankees who had already won 7 World Series titles, and their 12th Pennant together.
Those Yankees also boasted stars Elston Howard, Mel Stottlemyre and Roger Maris, as well as author Jim Bouton, broadcaster Tony Kubek and home run allower Al Downing.
The talented young Phillies included Dick Allen, Johnny Callison, Alex Johnson and Rick Wise, as well future leaders Pat Corrales, Ruben Amaro, Bobby Wine and Dallas Green. Cookie Rojas went on to play for the Royals but Tony Gonzalez did not play for the Chiefs, nor was Frank Thomas elected to the Hall of Fame.
The 1961 pennant winning Reds featured future stars Vada Pinson, Tony Perez and Tommy Harper, as well as the blind flamethrower Ryne Duren.
A Ken Boyer grand slam in the sixth inning of Game 4 proved decisive in the World Series victory
You think Scherzer is going to be right by Game 3 or 4 of the World Series? They’re going to need him to pitch better.
I thought he looked better tonight and his pitches were sharper but he will need to pitch better for sure. Really tough with no rehab starts. As a Rangers fan I’m hoping for Arizona if for no other reason than a Game 3 in Philly against that lineup seems terrifying.
Ya he’s getting there. Of course there can be setbacks
I don’t think Dunning, Heaney and Gray are terrible though
Great game by Texas.
For Texas. In Texas. According to Texas.
THE STARS AT NIGHT ARE BIG AND BRIGHT…(clap clap clap) DEEP IN THE HEART OF TEXAS…
(Anyone else thinking about Pee Wee’s Big Adventure now?)
So, of course the Rangers and Adolis himself being the ones that performed better after he “woke up the Astros” in game five is going to throw some cold water on those laziest of takes about bulletin boards and Uncle Mo, right?
Of course not, what am I, an idiot!?
Good for the Rangers – ever since they got David Freese’d in the world series I’ve felt a little bad for them, and I always do like to root for one of the six teams that have never won a championship to get a shot. The Astros are the opposite of that, they have officially entered “I’m tired of these guys” territory.
Whoever was in charge of defensive positioning for that team is still kicking himself for not yelling at Nelson Cruz to play 10 feet further back
Its sad because one of the cheating teams hacking the pitch coms this yr made it to the world series. The 3-4 others have been knocked out already.
?
Surely you will provide evidence for this outlandish claim?
Saw it in the comments of a Facebook post once so it’s definitely 100% true!
Garcia’s postseason line is crazy. He’s striking out 30% of the time, and doesn’t have a single walk (he has, famously, been plunked twice).
He’s also homering once every 7.7 PAs, and has 20 RBIs in 12 games. Yowza.
Bochy was awful in this series and has been throughout the entire playoffs. Routinely hits Robbie Grossman 3rd and removes him for a defensive replacement in the fourth inning, has the team’s 2nd best hitter in Garver hitting 7th like half the time, puts Cody Bradford in the series’ biggest situation, throws Leclerc out there literally every single game regardless of score, replaced a lefty with another lefty like 6 times and was about to do it again yesterday…Yikes
Grossman had a 158 wRC+ vs lefties this year and 126 for his career. Tough to find Carter’s minor league splits but he was 0/10 with 1 walk in the reg season against lefties, but mashes righties. Together they make up the ultimate 3 hitter platoon bat
He was hitting Grossman 3rd against RHP. Also would remove him while a LHP was still in the game
he only started vs Valdez
He started 3rd earlier in the playoffs until Garver got in against Baltimore.
This is not an accurate description of any of the lineup construction since the second game against Baltimore.
The defensive replacement for Grossman is Evan Carter (who is a better hitter) when the lefty goes out.
Garver is not the second best hitter and has hit either 3rd or 5th most of the time (I think he was hurt when Grossman was drawing starts).
As a Texas fan, it was sweet, sweet music when the radio guys started thanking the Astro’s staff for the excellent chicken wings provided pregame.
In the seventh inning of game seven while up seven in Houston.
The clearly audible “Lets Go Rangers” chants in the ninth were even better.
Many times you will hear cheers for the Yankees, BoSox, Braves, Astros, Cubs, and Dodgers in Arlington. The reverse is still novel.
While there is no Nap-O-Li or Cruuuuuz noisemaking like in 2011, it is still fun. The fan intensity of October baseball transcends July baseball by an order of magnitude.
Bochy the Rock Goes to the World Series