Snake Me Home Tonight: Carroll Breakout Sends Arizona to World Series

PHILADELPHIA – “A lot of people don’t believe in us,” Diamondbacks infielder Geraldo Perdomo said before Game 7 of the NLCS. “I think that’s why we play with the patience we’re playing with right now, to prove to everyone we can do it.”
“Nobody believed in us” is such a hackneyed trope in sports motivation, one that’s been co-opted over and over by teams that everyone believed in. But Perdomo was absolutely right to invoke it; the Diamondbacks were the lowest seed in this year’s playoffs, and before that a dark horse to make the postseason at all. They were under .500 in August, for goodness’ sake. Manager Torey Lovullo was asked after Game 7 if, in mid-August, he thought he’d be in this situation now. “To be totally honest, no,” he said.
But here they are. They took two must-win games against the defending National League champions in one of the most hostile environments in baseball, the latest by a score of 4-2. And now the Diamondbacks, pennant in hand, are off for Texas and a shot at the second World Series title in club history.
Before the season, I thought the Diamondbacks would be a team to watch going forward, but more with an eye toward a playoff run in 2024 or 2025. This group was young, a little underbaked.
Turns out that’s not the case. In Game 7, it was a trio of rookies who lifted the team over the final hurdle. Starter Brandon Pfaadt threw four innings that were more gutty than domineering, as his gem in Game 3 was. Gabriel Moreno, who got decleated by Bryce Harper in Game 5, chipped in two hits and an RBI.
But the hero of Game 7 was Corbin Carroll, the most important player to pull on an Arizona uniform since at least Paul Goldschmidt. This is the guy Arizona is building a team around, and through six NLCS games he’d been terrible: 3-for-23, all singles, to go with one walk and zero stolen bases.
“I talked about this with someone earlier just after the game,” Carroll said. “Six games ago you would have said that I was the hottest hitter on the planet, right? I think it’s easy to get caught up in the day and get caught up in just the minute. But just realizing that that’s all it is, right? It’s just a little hitch of things not going your way. … In the end, I think everything evens out eventually.”
Carroll finished the NLCS without an extra-base hit, but in the Diamondbacks’ biggest game since the 2001 World Series, he put the team on his back and ran. Carroll went 3-for-4 with a sacrifice fly and two stolen bases. He either drove in or scored every single Diamondbacks run. There will be volumes written in the next 24 hours about the Phillies’ inability to close this series out, and deservedly so. But had Carroll contributed any less than he did in Game 7, it would be the Diamondbacks headed for the offseason.
The second man up in the top of the first, Carroll pulled a sinker from Ranger Suárez over to the right of Phillies second baseman Bryson Stott. The second-year infielder made a nice stop, and with a normal runner coming out of the box, he might have arrested his momentum, popped up, and attempted to throw him out. With Carroll and his 80-grade speed on the way to first, Stott didn’t bother.
The next batter, Moreno, lined a single the other way with Carroll in motion; Carroll had time to pause briefly at second, assess the situation, and make it to third base with time to spare. Two pitches later, he was home on a Christian Walker fielder’s choice.
His next time up, Carroll fought off a curveball on his hands for a single the other way. There had been much discussion early in this series about how the Diamondbacks, one of the fastest teams in the league, had abandoned the running game against the Phillies. The reasons were obvious, and twofold: First, the Diamondbacks weren’t getting many runners on base. And second, the Phillies are good at controlling the running game, particularly Suárez and Zack Wheeler. The Diamondbacks are fast, but they’re not stupid. But this time, Carroll ran; Suárez had him picked off, but Carroll is so fast he was able to beat the throw.
Carroll’s first two at-bats put the Diamondbacks in the driver’s seat. His third would make their whole season. The Phillies had just taken their first lead of the game — their first lead since Game 5, in fact — in the bottom of the fourth. The crowd, loud but nervous up to that point, was back in it.
Suárez opened the fifth by allowing a single, but with two quick outs was all but out of the inning. Carroll was getting a third look at the Phillies’ starter, but it was a left-on-left matchup, so manager Rob Thomson let it ride. On his last pitch of the night, Suárez reached back for a sinker, and left it down and over the plate. Carroll lanced it up the middle at the best part of 110 mph, scoring the tying run.
Then he conjured the game-winner. Carroll once again stole second. Jeff Hoffman quickly got ahead on Moreno 0-2, but just in case, Carroll was in scoring position. The 0-2 slider was up and in on Moreno’s hands, and the rookie catcher fought it off and into right field. Carroll scored easily, and the Phillies never answered.
The Phillies, with their lineup full of power hitters, are never out of a one-run game. Carroll’s fourth plate appearance was his least productive of the night to that point, but it provided the Diamondbacks with insurance: A one-out sacrifice fly off José Alvarado to put Arizona out of reach of the Phillies’ greatest weapon, the solo home run.
Once Carroll had done his job, the Phillies put up one last rally, as back-to-back walks by Andrew Saalfrank put the tying run on first base with one out in the seventh inning and the most dangerous sector of the Phillies’ lineup coming to the plate: Trea Turner and Bryce Harper.
Turner was the hottest hitter on the planet when the Phillies and Diamondbacks decamped for Phoenix last week; since then, he suffered a season-ending 2-for-19 run, including 0-for-12 in the Phillies final three games. The last of those at-bats was a tame flyout to center field.
But that brought Harper to the plate, and he came closer than most people probably realized at the time to duplicating his NLCS-winning home run from a year ago. Kevin Ginkel threw Harper not one but two dead-red fastballs. The first he took for a strike. The second he smashed into left center at 107.6 mph. Again, Zac Gallen’s post-Game 1 comments sprung to mind: The difference between a tape measure home run and a flyout is a couple inches. This time, Harper just got under the ball, knocking it into the air at a 44 degree launch angle; instead of troubling the wall, it fell into Alek Thomas’ glove.
The Phillies went down in order in the eighth and ninth. When pinch-hitter Jake Cave put the game’s final pitch in play, it was Carroll (Who else?) who tracked it down to seal the pennant.
“‘Better squeeze it,'” is what Carroll said he thought in that moment. “They fought us hard all series, and so to be able to finally put it away and run towards that dogpile, man… just a hell of a feeling.”
“I allowed myself to go there,” Lovullo said. “I tried not to. It’s a dangerous thought because you can be let down emotionally. But when it finally happened and I saw the fly ball go up, it was a pretty euphoric feeling.”
This was a starmaking performance by one of the most talented young players in the game, and it underscores the most remarkable thing about Arizona’s series victory.
This was an upset, and a fairly big one; don’t let anyone tell you differently. But no upset in a short series should be that surprising. Playoff baseball isn’t a random exercise, but it is chaotic enough to throw up plenty of surprises.
There was a pretty obvious path to Arizona winning this series; it involved Carroll pestering Phillies pitchers all week long, and probably at least one game stolen by Gallen. Instead, the Diamondbacks won despite getting bupkis from their two best players for the first six games of the series; more than that, the Phillies were able to throw fastballs straight by Walker, who went 2-for-22 with seven walks.
Arizona went down 2-0 in the series, the second loss a crushing 10-0 rout. They were two and a half innings from going down 3-0, and one inning from going down 3-1. Nevertheless, when they needed one walk to stay alive, or one seeing-eye single, or one audacious strikeout, they got it. And when they needed their franchise player to have the game of his life, they got that too.
Michael is a writer at FanGraphs. Previously, he was a staff writer at The Ringer and D1Baseball, and his work has appeared at Grantland, Baseball Prospectus, The Atlantic, ESPN.com, and various ill-remembered Phillies blogs. Follow him on Twitter, if you must, @MichaelBaumann.


AHHHHHH I get to see my team play World Series games in person!
AHHHHHH
Corbin Carroll finally doing something in the LCS leads the Diamondbacks to the promised land.
Carroll’s swing reminds me a bit of a young Darin Erstad’s.
And stolen bases were huge the last 2 games. 8 vs 1.
This is subjective, but I love the fact that we are going to reward an awesome, unspoiled, desperately loyal fan base with a ring.
I’ll be cheering on the Rangers because everyone deserves one banner, but if it goes the way of the Snakes, no one (other than rangers fans) can be too upset.
Who are the spoiled fanbases?
The two obvious are the Astros who for the past seven years but they were the worst team in baseball for a solid decade prior going back to the berkman, biggio, and bagwell days of the early 2000’s. Dodgers are but they have spent the past decade watching their team choke every postseason except for 2020.
I think there is a gap and the braves are in the next tier of “in the process of being spoiled” As they have 1 WS win in the past 25 years(only 2 years ago but still) but are in the midst of an active run that should see at least 3-4 more legit shots at winning one with this core of players.
Next are teams that are “spoiled” maybe moreso on their history than their recent play. The red sox, yankees, giants, and cardinals all have multiple rings won in the past 25-30 years but the past 4-5 years havent been that entertaining outside of single event or two(red sox have the most recent success with a championship in 2018 but have bad for 4 of the 5 seasons since. None have played in a world series besides the red sox in 2018 since the giants won in 2014.
Also, is there an unloyal fanbase(outside of the florida teams but a whole article can be written on how its not the fans fault for not supporting those teams)
I agree these are two fun teams to watch and should make for a good series and i am also so happy the phillies lost as the hype the media was giving them was very annoying and we can hopefully never hear about the fortress that is their stadium as losing back to back clinching games at home cant happen if its such an advantage.
Gotta agree that this narrative of spoiled fan bases is purely justification for why a team shouldn’t win over another team. Claiming one fan base is more loyal than another is just absurd at this point. If you don’t like a team just say it, you don’t have to justify it by saying their fans don’t deserve it. All fans of every team deserve to win, that doesn’t mean the team itself deserves to win.
Probably getting too far afield from anything quantifiable to be worth it here, but I think there’s a clear difference between generalizing about a given team’s “fan base” and its hard-core loyal fans. I’ve been to enough ballparks to see that every team has hard-core fans that live and die with every pitch (okay, I haven’t been to any games in Florida). And with those “true,” hard-core, loyal fans I feel a close bond no matter what team they root for, even if it’s one of my team’s rivals. But it seems foolhardy to deny that — leaving those fans aside — there’s a big difference between the attitudes of the bulk of people at the park in one city or another.
Like, yes, there are Dodgers die-hards who keep a scorecard and would never dream of leaving before the last out, and I feel a deep kinship with them even though I’m not a Dodgers fan, but still — I would never deny that “the Dodgers’ fan base” contains a lot of people who leave early to beat the traffic. The generalizations are mostly about that kind of fan, not the serious ones.
I’ve long ago stopped judging fans for what type of fan they choose to be. Leave early to beat traffic? Some people have kids to put to bed and early meetings to attend. And now some great seats are open for the die hards to maybe upgrade! I really only dislike the obnoxious hateful fans, those who ruin it for others while forgetting it’s a game. Fights, personal insults…though fun banter is terrific and should be encouraged. Otherwise let fans be who they wanna be. So long as they cheer and make some effort to watch some of the game. Not everyone appreciates the deep dive stuff like we Fangraphs subscribers. That’s ok. And also, I leave games early. Haha
Congratulations to Arizona, but really, I have always thought that the World Series should feature the best teams in baseball. Arizona was barely over .500 and had a negative run differential. It’s a farce. MLB has clearly expanded the playoffs too much. But of course they won’t cut back because of the $$$$$$$$.
Yes. An all-wild card world’s series is a disappointment in our view. 162 games of a gruelling regular season and the best teams over that stretch get knocked out in short series. The more you expand playoffs, the less the summer matters.
Let’s have all the teams make the playoffs…. The regular season can just be a seeding round.
i mean the phillies were something like the 10-12th best team in the league. they were hardly among the best teams by regular season record or run differential
The difference was the Phillies were built for the playoffs, so people expected that if they made it they’d compete. Just like last year.
Not sure if you mean this as a joke, but if it’s not a joke, Philly is definitely not built for the playoffs as compared to the competition. In fact, they’re perfectly average when compared to the teams that did make the playoffs (7th out of 12) when you look at what drives playoff success and the impact on each team’s chances.
Even funnier, the team that finished last in “being built for the playoffs”, the Diamondbacks, will be playing in the World Series.
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/which-teams-are-best-built-for-postseason-success/
The Phillies were tied for the 6th best record in baseball w/ the Astros & Rangers and had the 5th best expected run diff by Baseruns, which is better than Pythag:
https://library.fangraphs.com/team-record-pythagorean-record-and-base-runs/
Also tied for the 4th best record in the “projected full season” (which I assume is based on current team composition).
Arizona beat two division winners and the defending NL champs. They’re highly deserving pennant winners.
*Swept* two division winners and rolled into perhaps the most hostile place in October and took two from the defending champs. Pretty f—ing gutsy.
Absolutely! It’s hard to think of anything to dislike about this squad. And Carroll is just electrifying, already one of my favorite players
Wow, they won a few short series. I guess that is better evidence than a full season that they are a better team than they were!
Counterpoint: hey 100-win Dodgers, division-winning Brewers, “built for the playoffs” Phillies with a 2-0 series lead and two deciding games at home: quit whining and win your series against this “inferior” competition.
Not sure that you understand that how random short series are… the better team only wins a little more than half of them.
Oh I understand perfectly how random they are – I’m just not sure how productive moaning about the current playoff format is. Also not saying the Dbacks are “better” or “more deserving” – but they showed up and they mowed down some pretty stiff competition, bottom line. I can recognize and celebrate what they have accomplished.
(Funny too that Braves fans and others weren’t grumbling before the series started; just afterwards when they didn’t go as planned…)
How productive are any of our comments in the long run? That said though if the fanbase complained enough, MLB might listen in that it might affect their revenue!
Given that MLB is currently doing a playoff ad blitz claiming that fans asked them for a shift ban and bigger bases… be careful what you wish for, I guess. Or at least be careful what you’re going to be told that you wished for after the fact, when no one even asked you before.
The last time two wild card teams clashed in the World Series was the 2014 series, AKA an instant classic. The only time before that was 2002, another instant classic. I’m sorry, but this view is both abjectly wrong and very tired. Enjoy baseball for what it is: the closest humanity can get to witnessing true entropy.
A Pirates-A’s World Series could be an “instant classic” also. We do not need to agree about any of this. Clearly MLB will never return to the traditional playoff formats, and more playoffs means more money. But it should not bother you that we don’t like it this way. We used to watch every playoff game, and now we only watch a few. Playoffs have been over-extended and watered down. We just don’t care as much anymore.
Counterpoint: this playoffs has been the most fun in a long time. And I say this even with my team failing to make the postseason.
Abjectly wrong? You are saying my opinion is abjectly wrong because a few good series happen to result from playoffs between wild card teams? Entropy is not the goal in life…
Honest question that is truly coming from a place of not knowing. But this “the best teams in baseball should be in the World Series” thing keeps coming up and I have to wonder: Is there any room to discuss strength of schedule when talking about 100 win teams?
It’s obviously an accomplishment for obvious reasons but take the Dodgers last year. They won 111 games and lost in the first round. 61 of their wins came against teams with losing records. 31 came against teams with winning records. 17 came against teams playing .500.
32 of their wins (against teams with a losing record) were teams 20 games or more below .500.
I don’t know what it means but I keep thinking about it (and I don’t get great answers when I bring it up with my baseball friends). Curious to know what the Fangraphs nerds think!
In the recent past, the 19-games-against-your-division days of yore (maybe it just seems like 2022 was a decade ago?), you have to be careful to exclude the shared games from the pool — IOW, pulling the Dodgers-Rockies games out of the Rockies’ record when talking about strength of schedule. Otherwise, you can get some distortions.
Even in the 13-game intradivision schedule, that’s enough to keep it in mind.
You have a point, the best teams do not always have the absolute best records because of a variety of factors. That is kind of the point of the playoffs in my view, take the teams that arguably are the best in the league and play them off to see who is. Usually that is like 2-4 teams per league (this year in the NL it was 2, and the AL it was 4). But teams in my opinion that you cannot make a plausible case are the best team in the league should not be representing that league in the WS, which crowns the champion of baseball.
The playoffs were never a good means of isolating the best teams, for the reasons you already mentioned. You’re just contradicting yourself in simultaneously downplaying the results of the current playoffs due to small sample size randomness, & overstating the importance of previous playoffs which had the exact same “issues”.
Some of those teams have a losing record because they have to play the Dodgers so often
Before 1969 the Pennant was considered the important goal for a team, and World Series sort of like a Bowl game. It’s great to win, but your season was still great even if you didn’t. Well unless you lost 10 times in a row or something. It hasn’t been like that since.
Braves – Orioles may or may not have been any more or less entertaining than Rangers – Diamondbacks. It probably would have been more “legitimate”. As long as we view playoffs and WS as entertainment rather than actually proving “bestness” there isn’t much of a problem.
The “best” team is probably the Braves by a pretty good margin — with Morton and Fried. The “best” AL team is probably the Astros at the end of September, or maybe the Rays with their pitching staff intact, or maybe the Rangers with Scherzer and DeGrom. If we want to we can consider that settled independent of playoffs.
If you looked at records and run differential and the eye test of looking at the roster, the best teams in the AL were the O’s and Rays, and you could make a case for the Astros and Rangers. In the NL, the Braves were the best but the Dodgers also won a hundred games so those would be okay. Might be able to make a case for the Brewers and Phils but past that, meh.
And, friend, there is no way to know in advance which matchup would be the most entertaining!
But your line “As long as we view playoffs and WS as entertainment rather than actually proving “bestness” there isn’t much of a problem.” is pretty insightful. I do like to think of there being a measure of “bestness” in there and I think a lot of people do as well.
“I do like to think of there being a measure of “bestness” in there and I think a lot of people do as well.”
Isn’t this the 162 game regular season? A postseason isn’t going to produce this (even a pre-1969 AL winner v NL winner format) unless without absurdly long series. To match the NBA’s best of 7 series probability of better team advancing vs underdog upset, MLB would need to play a best of 75 series just because of variance.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1701.05976.pdf
Yep, they play 162 games to determine which teams are the best. The postseason is a completely separate entity that is mostly disconnected from overall team quality. I wonder if there would still be the concept that the World Series winner is the “best” team if the field hadn’t been limited to the 2-4 teams that were determined the best in the regular season for the first 90 years of it’s existence.
If they included the worst team in the league in the playoffs as the last wild card each year, that team would probably win the pennant about 5% of the time, but because the field has historically been limited to teams that were already determined to be the best, it’s easy to think the best team wins.
the rangers were easily on the same tier as the rays/O’s even ignoring the postseason
They were an excellent team, but they were 11 and 9 games back respectively in their records from those two teams. a few games, okay, but that many games makes it, well, hardly “easily”…
The current playoff system is obviously not designed to elevate the best team as champion. Whether or not that’s a problem depends on your point of view. Some people find the current format entertaining, no doubt. I personally only find it entertaining when my team is winning, and I think probably a lot of serious baseball fans would agree if they’re being honest. If you share that perspective, the fact that this format eliminates 90% of the qualifiers (as opposed to 50% under the pre-1969 system), and does it in pretty random fashion such that fans don’t even know what to expect is a problem for the entertainment value.
If ~90% of fanbases have nothing to cheer for the latter month of two of the regular season because they have no hope finishing 1st in their league, that probably isn’t the answer either.
Right, it probably isn’t. The answer might be a culture shift to something more like the English Premier League (about which I know very little) where as I understand it coming in first over the course of the season is considered the true championship, but there are also in-season or postseason tournaments that are avidly watched but not considered to be as important as the “regular” season.
MLB could do some things to encourage such a culture shift, but the ultimate decisions would rest with the media and fans to prioritize and celebrate different things. The current environment treats having the best record in the league as little more than a playoff seeding story.
European football doesn’t have postseason tournaments. The UEFA Champions League is in season. Teams included in that are determined based on the previous season results so while it’s really important, it doesn’t make anyone forget about the League season. League is only 36-38 games so there aren’t 50 irrelevant games being played by a bad team
I was thinking something like that too. In the English Premier League, there are several things you can win. If you have the best record in the League, you have won the league and get a trophy (no playoffs). Then there are two elimination series where all the teams in English soccer at all the various levels play for I think the Caribou Cup and the FA Cup. Then, the toughest of them is the Champion’s League championship where you play the champions from around Europe in an elimination tourny. Winning all 4 of them is extremely rare and like the ultimate season. Last year Manchester City did just that…
Other prizes include if you finish in the top 4 you get to play in the Champion’s League the next year and the 5th place plays in the lesser but still sought after Europa Tournament. And at the other end there is avoiding relegation to a lower level (the bottom three teams). The A’s might have tried a little harder if they were in danger of being sent to AAA…
The promotion/relegation thing can’t work in MLB without massive changes to structure, since the minor leagues are owned by major league franchises. But even if you don’t have that element, shifting the overall format such that regular-season success is treated like the most important thing and then you’ve also got fun tournaments alongside that, with entrance into them determined by current year or prior year record. You could have like a Champion’s Series between the top two finishers that would be like the old World Series, and you could also try to organize some kind of international component–instead of the WBC, professional teams from different leagues competing in a tournament.
This is obviously all very pie-in-the-sky, but I think it would be better for the sport’s long-term health than the current playoff format or successive expansions of the playoff field.
Very much agreed, excellent thoughts there.
“I think it would be better for the sport’s long-term health than the current playoff format or successive expansions of the playoff field.”
Hard disagree. I will take the “get in and anything can happen” that sustain 75% of fanbases as opposed to the “let’s buy our way to the top!” model that the Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, etc. use year after year (some admittedly showing more recent success than others).
I’ve said before, I will take the “hey, there’s a 10% chance we make the playoffs and then a 10% chance we make something happen!” that gives some fanbases a glimmer of hope (check the preseason playoff odds for the Orioles and heck, the Diamondbacks are playing out that sliver of hope in real time to very real success) to the 0.000% chance that Crystal Palace, Fulham, Bournemouth, and Luton Town have each and every season in the EPL. They will never outspend Man City, Liverpool, Man U, Arsenal, or Tottenham, and thus they will never compete for a league title.
Baseball is pretty different, though. The Rays haven’t had the best record in their league so far (except in 2020), but they’re frequently in the mix and probably will get it at some point in the next 10 seasons. Pittsburgh and Kansas City have both had short stretches of contention in the last 10 years, and they don’t spend at all and don’t even have very good baseball operations teams. The Giants are capable of spending big, but they bounced to a 107-win league-leading season on the backs of many decent players having career years. The 2001 Mariners were middle-tier spenders but had the best season in history, again in large part because lots of solid-to-good players all had career years at the same time.
In general, baseball is just a lot more random, which mitigates to some extent the perennial loser problem you might see in those leagues where the best teams win 70% or more of their games.
Don’t know why this was voted down. Arizona had a negative run differential. Some people don’t care, some people do but there is no doubt the expanded playoffs has massively devalued the regular season. This is also why you aren’t going to be seeing dominant teams anymore. The value of going from a 95 win team to a 100-win team is 0. Dipoto talked about a 10 year plan where the team wins 54% of its games and that’s pretty much the plan of every team now. Make the playoffs, get hot and lucky and win.
Corbin Carroll is a special player. They will be someone to watch moving forward.
They really came through in the clutch last night. They deserve the Rookie of the Year award they will no doubt win.
Did this dude make an alt to talk to himself?
Watching a mental breakdown in real time is fascinating.
Ketel Marte was amazing. They went 12 for 31 to lead their team to the Series. The only thing we would change about Ketel is their uniform number should be “1”. Ketel One has a real marketing opportunity.
So whose roster would you rather have, the Dodgers or the Diamondbacks?
Betts, Freeman, Smith, Miller vs
Carroll, Gallen, Moreno, Marte
Muncy, Outman, Phillips vs
Walker, Kelly, Pfaadt
Dodgers but it’s not as one sided as the records without Kershaw, Urias, May and Buehler
Agree the two superstars who appear to be aging pretty well tips it to the Dodgers but I think it’s pretty close, especially with uncertainty about Urias and Buehler moving forward. Pfaadt looks like the guy in your list above most poised to make a huge leap forward next year.
With the current salaries and obligations, definitely the D’bags. On pure talent and for only the next couple seasons we would take the Dodgers.
The Suarez-Carroll pickoff play failed because of a mistake by Harper, which Ron Darling pointed out on the broadcast. Harper’s inexperience at first cost them a run there.
Wasn’t that in the 3rd? I think Suarez got through that inning without a run.
What we’re seeing is baseball’s version of March Madness. Most years, a Cinderella team crashes the Final Four by beating a Duke and Kentucky. So it is with the Diamondbacks, baseball’s Loyola Chicago for 2023. Enjoy the spectacle!
All 30 MLB teams are owned by billionaires/half-billionaires and bring in massive amounts of money. It’s hard for me to root for the Diamondbacks in the same way as Fairleigh-Dickinson, Saint Peter’s, or Florida Gulf Coast.
This is nothing like March Madness. Small samples have much less effect basketball teams.
Would actually be curious on the impact of variance for a 40 minute NCAA basketball game vs a best of 7 MLB series. Probably still more variance in the baseball series but it might be fairly close.
There are only 30 mlb teams so it would basically the NCAA basketball equivalent would be top 8 seeds only. Or if we limit it to playoff teams, top 6 seeds only.
#1 seeds have won 24 of the last 37 titles so it would be as though someone used ZiPS to determine the seeds and the top 4 that way won 2/3 of the time
No Fangraphs writer picked either of these teams to make the WS. I think that’s pretty special.
Maybe we’ll see a little less homogeneity in the predictions next year. Sure the safe/easy route to go is to go chalk, but where’s the fun in that? “Gee your picks are just like 28 of the other 29, insightful!”
(It’s like filling out a bracket – usually the safe route is to sprinkle in a few upsets early and then go chalk late, but it’s like, “Ok, you and 98.5% of other brackets correctly picked Kansas to reach the Final Four, do you want a cookie for that?”)
Or, the inherent tension between wanting to be right (in which case folks go safe and chalky) or wanting to be remembered (which one might be if they correctly had the Dbacks in the WS)
Oh yeah, they definitely should incorporate betting odds into that somehow so that there’s more incentive to pick upsets. We already know what the projections say.
Yeah it’s hard to tweak a scoring system to get it “just right” in mixing correct picks while properly valuing (but not overvaluing) upsets – betting odds is probably the single best approach but I don’t know that Fangraphs wants to head down that road
Could use projection odds instead of betting odds and get a similar rewards system without having to venture into the gambling world.
I believe cowdisciple already proposed this in the comments on the writers’ picks,* but it seems like the clear right approach to me rather than just expecting that the contrarian impulse will add up to something quantitatively correct when aggregated across the pool of writers. The game of “Beat the Projections” still requires something that’s conceptually very close to “betting,” but we could call it credibility points, rather than dollars, that the writers were putting up against the computer.
* (Not saying that I did pick or would’ve picked them to go to the Series, but I will claim partial credit, since in that same thread I identified the Rangers and Diamondbacks as the two teams most obviously getting shorted.)
Rangers and DBacks World Series, exactly what we all thought going into the season. I love baseball so much
We love baseball as a sport, but not always MLB as an entity. MLB is not baseball, just one baseball league. We have more fun watching our local varsity baseball team, our local college team, and travel tournaments than we have watching MLB. The playoffs take so long – by this time of the year we are watching college and NFL football, basketball, hockey, formula one, EPL soccer, cricket World Cup, and others. We wish MLB season was shorter, and fewer teams made the playoffs. We would watch every playoff game if MLB went back to an East-West league alignment with just one NLCS round then the WS. We think MLB should be over by the second week of October.
A+ headline, Michael. Kudos.
Looking forward to some more 80-grade ophidian wordplay for the World Series.