So You’re About to Pitch to Pablo Sandoval

Hello there, Royals pitchers! Congratulations on reaching this point — you’ve done many proud. No matter what happens, your 2014 season has been a screaming success. The Royals are back on the baseball map nationally and, more importantly, locally. But of course you’re not done yet, as there’s one remaining step in the staircase: Looming in front of you are the San Francisco Giants. You’ll face many different Giants hitters; among them will be Pablo Sandoval. In case you’ve never seen him before, you’re in for an experience. I’d like to show you something. Actually, I’d like to show you two somethings. Here’s one of them:

  • Pablo Sandoval: 45% out-of-zone swing rate
  • Matt Carpenter: 46.8% in-zone swing rate

You’re going to face Sandoval; it could’ve been you would’ve faced Carpenter. Sandoval swings at about as many balls as Carpenter does strikes. For the sake of some perspective:

  • Pablo Sandoval: 45% out-of-zone swing rate
  • Salvador Perez: 44.1% out-of-zone swing rate

So that’s how aggressive this Sandoval character is. Now, you might be wondering, “Does that mean he’s as easy to get out sometimes as Salvy?” No, this Sandoval guy is a unique sort of challenge. To prepare you for the challenge to come, I’m going to provide you with some strategy tips. How should you pitch to Pablo Sandoval, if you want to get him out? Pay careful attention to my advice.

Be careful with pitches in the zone

This should be pretty obvious. You should always be careful with pitches in the zone, to everyone. Sandoval likes to swing at balls, so that means he also likes to swing at strikes. When he does that, he makes contact 86% of the time. As Baseball Savant tells us, Sandoval has slugged .564 against pitches within the PITCHf/x strike zone during his career. That’s a very good slugging percentage, so this isn’t a guy to groove many pitches against. The Giants like to hit him in the middle. Careful with strikes against guys who hit in the middle.

Be careful with pitches out of the zone

So Sandoval likes to chase. For him, it’s not really chasing — he just operates with a big personal strike zone. When Sandoval’s gone out of the PITCHf/x strike zone, he’s made contact nearly 80% of the time, which is more often than a guy like Chris Davis hits strikes. And it’s not just weak, empty contact. During the PITCHf/x era, Sandoval’s slugged .425 against pitches out of the zone, which is the highest mark in baseball. You know how most of you are right-handed? Sandoval’s a switch-hitter, too, and he’s better from the left side. From the left side, he’s slugged .452 against pitches out of the zone. On contact, that goes up to .544. The strike zone’s supposed to capture the hittable area. It doesn’t quite capture Sandoval’s.

Be careful with pitches down

We can break this into more detailed areas. It’s not like all pitches out of the zone or near the border are created alike. Want to pitch Sandoval down? Be careful. He will swing, often, but he’s slugged .439 against pitches down as a lefty, which is fourth-best in baseball. He can punish pitches that aren’t far off the ground:

SandovalDown

According to Brooks Baseball, Sandoval’s made contact 80% of the time he’s gone below the zone. He can stretch those arms.

Be careful with pitches in the middle

Duh. Sandoval swings at these pitches. He doesn’t miss these pitches. Against these pitches as a lefty he’s slugged .554. Other batters have slugged better, but any slugging percentage that begins with the number five indicates that it’s a tricky area for pitchers to navigate. Lots of normal guys are dangerous thigh-high. Sandoval is abnormal, but not in that way.

Be careful with pitches up

Some guys who excel at hitting the low ball can be exposed up top. Sandoval’s not really one of them. As a lefty, against pitches up, he’s slugged .495, which is the 10th-best mark in baseball. I mean:

SandovalUp

There’s an area up there where Sandoval becomes likely to swing and miss. Out of the zone, up, Sandoval’s missed with one out of every three attempts. But he still packs a wallop, and to get him to miss you have to really climb the ladder. If you miss at all below the target you could be whipping around in a hurry. The safe spot is surrounded by dangerous spots, which makes the whole area a dangerous spot.

Be careful with pitches in

Not a lot of pitchers work Sandoval inside when he bats as a lefty, and there’s a good reason for that.

SandovalIn

Sandoval doesn’t often whiff when he swings inside. As a lefty, he’s slugged .530 against inside pitches, as he’s blessed with quick wrists that let him get the bat head out in front. This, of course, applies to both inside strikes and inside balls. The pitch you see above was an inside ball. If you’re trying to pitch him right under the hands, good luck. Those hands move around.

Be careful with pitches away

Here’s a fun fact: As a lefty, Sandoval’s slugged .472 against pitches away. That’s 22nd-best in baseball, even with one Prince Fielder. Pitchers routinely target areas away, as they tend to do against mostly opposite-handed hitters. Just as Sandoval can turn on a pitch in, he can smack a pitch away to the opposite field, seemingly without any problem.

SandovalAway

Sandoval’s least likely to swing at pitches out of the zone, away, but he’ll still chase and he’s still made contact with those pitches 80% of the time. If you’re pitching to Sandoval, all your defenders need to be paying attention, because he can cover the entire field.

Be careful with fastballs

Against fastballs and cutters, Sandoval has been 57 runs better than average for his career. To put that in more familiar terms: He’s hit .302 and slugged .502, with both marks even better left-handed. He’s made contact better than 80% of the time. Sandoval can slap fastballs, and he can also turn on them, depending on the location.

Be careful with off-speed pitches

Against off-speed pitches, Sandoval has been 20 runs better than average for his career. To put that in more familiar terms: He’s hit .319 and slugged .473, with both marks similar left-handed. He’s made contact 84% of the time, which is even better than his fastball contact rate. That’s the hallmark of someone who’s able to make an on-the-fly adjustment.

Be careful with breaking balls

Against breaking balls, Sandoval has been four runs better than average for his career. To put that in more familiar terms: He’s hit .272 and slugged .419, with both marks better left-handed. He’s made contact 82% of the time, which is also better than his fastball contact rate. While Sandoval has been worse against breaking balls than against other pitch types, he’s one of the relatively few players to be better than average against all three types. If you’re not careful with your slider or curve, Sandoval’s more than capable of drilling it.

Be careful with two strikes

With some players, when you get them into a two-strike count, you all but already have them beat. With Sandoval, it’s not so. Since he debuted, the average player has hit .182 and slugged .274 with two strikes. Sandoval has hit .221 and slugged .338, and this year he hit six home runs. Players are at their most aggressive when they’re a strike away from a whiff. For some, that’s a departure from their comfort zone, but Sandoval is naturally so aggressive anyway that two strikes don’t seem to bother him, relatively speaking. You could say he’s always hitting like he has a two-strike count.

==========

So what do we have here? Some kind of impossible player to get out? Not really. Sandoval’s career OBP is .346. This year it was .324. Most of the time, Sandoval will not reach base, meaning the pitcher was successful. His true talent as a hitter is probably about 15% to 20% better than the league average. That’s not Barry Bonds. Pablo Sandoval isn’t annoying because he’s unstoppable; he’s annoying because he’s kind of strategy-proof. He doesn’t have a clear weakness.

The best advice I can give is to just pitch him without pitching him stupid, and then whatever happens happens. He’s going to hit pitches he has no business hitting. It’s obnoxious. But there’s nothing you can do about that, so you just have to not let it bother you. You’re pitching to Pablo Sandoval in the World Series? Pitch however you usually pitch. Maybe see if you can pitch left-handed, if you don’t already do that. That’s the one thing, so maybe that’s the key. Pitch to Pablo Sandoval left-handed. If you can’t use that advice, there is no other advice.





Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.

30 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Justin
12 years ago

Teams refusal to flip Sandoval around is stunning. His splits make it clear that he should never be allowed to bat from the left side late in a game, and he showed that yet again this playoffs.

Beau
12 years ago
Reply to  Justin

If you have a choice of burning a lefty against Sandoval or getting an inning using them against the Ishikawa-Crawford-Blanco-Panik left handed block. Most managers will choose the latter.

Adam
12 years ago
Reply to  Beau

Good point. It’s also tough to use a lefty late in a game against Sandoval because of his position in the batting order relative to Posey and Pence who both mash lefties.

glib
12 years ago

Yes, KC should have three or four lefties in the pen to properly match up. He has become more selective lately, but he will give you DP grounders as well. I would love to see a study of bad ball hitters and their playoff performance.

haishan
12 years ago
Reply to  glib

Is it worth taking out one of the Royals’ Big Three relievers for Brandon Finnegan to get Sandoval out? Finnegan’s not bad, I like him a lot, and he’s plenty capable of getting outs versus RHH (so not a pure LOOGY), but he’s almost certainly a downgrade from Herrera/Davis/Holland overall. That said, Sandoval is so dangerous from the left side it might be worth it.

Avattoir
12 years ago
Reply to  glib

‘Okay now, hold still, you may feel a some mild discomfort … [saws off arms] … that’s just the saw, it’s like that for everyone … just a bit longer now [saw saw saw]… almost there – GOOD! Now for the tricky part: sewing them back on, each on the other side … ‘member to relax, you could feel a pinching sensation … [sews each arm on other side] … okay now, let’s TIGHTEN THESE BABIES UP [yank sew sew] … a bit more [tug sew tug test] … DONE! And now, you’re good to go against the Panda!’

Jose
12 years ago

Just pitch him where he can’t hit a HR and play no dubs defense. What comes, comes.

Deelron
12 years ago
Reply to  Jose

Where’s that location exactly (Justin Verlander would like to know)?

Jose
12 years ago
Reply to  Deelron

The dirt, obviously.

Ron Sullivan
12 years ago
Reply to  Deelron

He is certainly a magician at times. But, “as far as the long ball goes”, down and away is the best way to keep him in the yard. Mechanical speaking, he ‘s not trying to hit a bomb on the pitch away. Does he do it? Yes, maybe once or twice in a season…throw him on the inner half and he could hurt you.

James Shields
12 years ago

So just hit the bastard?

obsessivegiantscompulsive
12 years ago

Great article, loved reading it.

Fun fact on the Panda: he’s a natural left-hander. That’s why he’s better hitting as a lefty. He LEARNED how to throw right-handed because he wanted to play SS like his hero, Omar Vizquel. He’s actually thrown out a hitter lefthanded professionally: in the minors, a hot smash knocked the glove off his left hand, and he just reacted, reaching down with his left and throwing out the hitter. Has to be the only time that’s ever happened in the professional ranks since pro baseball’s earliest days.

Another fun fact: why he hits the way he hits. Or at least I believe this is his secret sauce. When he was young, he and his brother would play this game of “pepper”, where they would use something small (I believe it was a bottle cap) to hit, and they would play this all the time. I believe that is what taught him to be able to swing out of the zone and still make good contact, all that practice hitting a much smaller object.

So yeah, this article pretty much captures the lunacy that happens when he bats, he’s got to frustrate a lot of pitchers.

I would also add that Pence is another hitter made from the same mode, he mashed a very high pitch for a homer earlier this season, and has been one to go outside the zone to get hits as well. So Royals pitchers got two of them to contend with.

joser
12 years ago

Playing pepper with bottlecaps and other tiny bits of junk is hardly secret or unique to Sandoval; it’s the pasttime of virtually every little kid in the Dominican, at least all the ones too small or poor to have any real equipment. If you ever go there (or see any documentary about it, like Rumbo A Las Grandes Ligas or Pelotero or just Youtube), you’ll see stickball played with rocks, balls of tape, almost anything — though it’s usually the larger-than-beercaps caps from water bottles (and which can be spun for a lot more break than any baseball). Interviews with any Dominican player such as David Ortiz or Vladimir Guerrero almost always mention this at some point. It may be one of the reasons “nobody walks off that island”; certainly Guerrero had a bigger zone than even Sandoval.

I’ve never been to Venezuela but I’ve seen games with bottlecaps in Cuba and I imagine it’s common anywhere in Latin America where baseball is popular and kids don’t have access to real equipment. (For a taste of ball in the Dominican those two linked documentaries are recommended, btw, along with the realistic fictional movie Sugar)

Gelatinous Cube
12 years ago
Reply to  joser

Eddie Murray and his brothers also used to practice with bottle caps in their garage. (I think I remember him saying that anything which didn’t go out the front of the garage was an out.)

apistat
12 years ago

http://i.imgur.com/pSXAm4D.gif

This is a Pablo Sandoval at bat. This is a home run on a 1-2 count.

jason shureMember since 2017
12 years ago

Wait, he has slugged .564 against pitches in the zone, and .425 against pitches out of the zone. But he hasn’t broken .420 overall for the last two full years. Are we perhaps describing an extinct panda? Or am i reading this wrong?

Steve
12 years ago
Reply to  jason shure

I also have the same question…

Big Daddy V
12 years ago
Reply to  jason shure

I don’t know exactly how the numbers are calculated, but I assume his has to do with strikeouts.

jason shureMember since 2017
12 years ago
Reply to  Jeff Sullivan

Right, so the arguments in the article still hold – he has been an unusual hitter, and it must be frustrating for pitchers overall. But there may be some lag in pitchers fear of him, as he doesn’t seem to be quite the same threat anymore.

ElJimador
12 years ago

Great article. As a Giants fan I was so fascinated with Sandoval’s bad ball hitting ability that after that after the 2009 season I made a project of looking up every one of his ABs on Brooks and found that for the season he hit over .300 and slugged over .500 on pitches outside the strike zone. (His overall line that season was .330/.387/.556). I would love to know how stats like that compare historically to Vlad Guerrero, Yogi Berra and other notorious bad ball hitters, if only we had the PitchFX data at the time to do it. He’s definitely unique in the game today though.

That said, I believe the best way to pitch him as a LHH is to try to get him to chase early then throw fastballs up in the zone to get him out. Yes he’ll get on top of that pitch from time to time and hurt you (especially if you become too predictable where he knows it’s coming) but it’s still a better bet than throwing him anything in the lower half if you need to throw a strike. In or out doesn’t matter but changing his sight line up or down does help, at least usually. If you execute that plan and he still does what he did in his first AB against Verlander in the ’12 WS (homer on a shoulder high 95 mph after falling behind 0-2 on pitches at the knees) then forget everything and just treat him as ’02 Bonds. Panda is streaky and when he’s hot it’s better not to pitch to him at all and just take your chances with the next guy.

Chris
12 years ago

So pitch him with the bases empty and at least a two run lead… got it.

Johnny
12 years ago

Pitch him out of the zone away and play no doubles defense down the 3rd base line. And then hope for the best.

Hurtlockertwo
12 years ago

Pablo’s agent thanks you for putting an extra $20 million on his next contract.

AB
12 years ago

His Righty OPS his 140 points lower than as Lefty. This split differential compares poorly with most other accomplished switch-hitters. Heck, it compares poorly with most accomplished fixed-hitters as well. Thus, you’d think he’d give an attempt at going full-time Lefty. But he’s only batted Lefty vs LHP 4 times in his career.

AB
12 years ago
Reply to  AB

Additionally: since he’s so good at putting the bat on the ball anywhere in/out of the zone, to me that suggests that the L-vs-L disadvantage shouldn’t affect him too much.

Matt
12 years ago

I believe there’s an old baseball adage that you simply feed good ‘bad ball hitters’ pitches down the middle of the plate – it makes them uncomfortable. I’m sure data/heat zone maps don’t back this up, but might as well give it a shot.

Brad JohnsonMember
12 years ago

My strategy for handling Sandoval: don’t let the other Giants on base.

B N
12 years ago

Actually, Panda does have one weakness: that he doesn’t use his tremendous contact abilities to draw walks as much as he might. So his ‘weakness’ is that he tends to swing at the low pitch that gives him a 40% chance of getting on base rather than take a ball that gives him 100% chance of getting on base. This is a guy that makes contact with nearly 85% of pitches in the zone. I bet that if he specialized in it, he could Wade Boggs (see: foul off) his way to hit a 0.375 OBP (i.e., raise his walk rate by 3-4%).

Joshua Duncan5
12 years ago

Love this article. Love pablo, love his freakish ability.