St. Louis Cardinals Top 34 Prospects

Below is an analysis of the prospects in the farm system of the St. Louis Cardinals. Scouting reports were compiled with information provided by industry sources as well as my own observations. This is the second year we’re delineating between two anticipated relief roles, the abbreviations for which you’ll see in the “position” column below: MIRP for multi-inning relief pitchers, and SIRP for single-inning relief pitchers.
A quick overview of what FV (Future Value) means can be found here. A much deeper overview can be found here.
All of the numbered prospects below also appear on The Board, a resource the site offers featuring sortable scouting information for every organization. It has more details than this article and integrates every team’s list so readers can compare prospects across farm systems. It can be found here.
| Rk | Name | Age | Highest Level | Position | ETA | FV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jordan Walker | 20.1 | AA | 3B | 2024 | 60 |
| 2 | Iván Herrera | 22.1 | MLB | C | 2023 | 50 |
| 3 | Nolan Gorman | 22.1 | MLB | 3B | 2022 | 50 |
| 4 | Matthew Liberatore | 22.7 | MLB | SP | 2022 | 50 |
| 5 | Masyn Winn | 20.3 | AA | SS | 2025 | 50 |
| 6 | Gordon Graceffo | 22.3 | AA | SP | 2023 | 50 |
| 7 | Brendan Donovan | 25.5 | MLB | 2B | 2022 | 45 |
| 8 | Tink Hence | 19.9 | A | SP | 2025 | 40+ |
| 9 | Zack Thompson | 24.7 | MLB | SP | 2022 | 40+ |
| 10 | Alec Burleson | 23.6 | AAA | RF | 2024 | 40+ |
| 11 | Andre Pallante | 23.8 | MLB | MIRP | 2023 | 40+ |
| 12 | Michael McGreevy | 22.0 | AA | SP | 2025 | 40+ |
| 13 | Jonathan Mejia | 17.2 | R | SS | 2027 | 40+ |
| 14 | Juan Yepez | 24.4 | MLB | LF | 2022 | 40 |
| 15 | Austin Love | 23.4 | A+ | SP | 2025 | 40 |
| 16 | Ian Bedell | 22.8 | A+ | SP | 2023 | 40 |
| 17 | Leonardo Bernal | 18.4 | A | C | 2025 | 40 |
| 18 | Freddy Pacheco | 24.2 | AAA | SIRP | 2023 | 40 |
| 19 | Lizandro Espinoza | 19.6 | R | SS | 2025 | 40 |
| 20 | Malcom Nunez | 21.3 | AA | DH | 2024 | 40 |
| 21 | Joshua Baez | 19.0 | A | RF | 2026 | 40 |
| 22 | Packy Naughton | 26.2 | MLB | MIRP | 2022 | 40 |
| 23 | Inohan Paniagua | 22.4 | A | SP | 2024 | 40 |
| 24 | Jake Walsh | 26.9 | MLB | SIRP | 2022 | 35+ |
| 25 | Gustavo J. Rodriguez | 21.5 | A | SIRP | 2024 | 35+ |
| 26 | Won-Bin Cho | 18.9 | R | LF | 2027 | 35+ |
| 27 | Ryan Loutos | 23.4 | AA | SIRP | 2023 | 35+ |
| 28 | Cory Thompson | 27.8 | AA | SIRP | 2023 | 35+ |
| 29 | Moisés Gómez | 23.8 | AAA | RF | 2023 | 35+ |
| 30 | Chandler Redmond | 25.5 | AA | 1B | 2023 | 35+ |
| 31 | Nathanael Heredia | 21.8 | A+ | SIRP | 2024 | 35+ |
| 32 | Edwin Nunez | 20.7 | A | SIRP | 2025 | 35+ |
| 33 | Randel Clemente | 20.6 | R | SIRP | 2026 | 35+ |
| 34 | Alec Willis | 19.3 | R | SP | 2026 | 35+ |
- All
- C
- 1B
- 2B
- SS
- 3B
- LF
- RF
- SP
- SIRP
- MIRP
60 FV Prospects
1. Jordan Walker, 3B
| Age | 20.1 | Height | 6′ 5″ | Weight | 220 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 60 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40/50 | 70/80 | 50/80 | 50/40 | 50/55 | 55 |
Walker worked out as a pitcher, shortstop, and third baseman in high school, then had a rough draft spring amid some weight gain, which is part of why he fell deep into the first round. To say he looks like a steal is at this point a drastic understatement, as he is one of the most exciting young hitters in the minors, with elite power potential and superlative on-paper performance at Double-A while he’s still not old enough to have a beer. Any discussion of Walker begins with his exit velocities, which are nearly unheard of for a player this young. He has a simple, well-leveraged swing that takes advantage of his strength, and the long levers that come with his 6-foot-5, 220 pound frame produce jaw-dropping home runs when he really squares one up. His approach is solid, though there are some issues chasing breaking balls, and his in-zone swing-and-miss has been a fair bit below average in 2022 (he swings inside a lot of sliders), but we’re talking about a 20-year-old at Double-A here. If you’re looking for the prospect most likely to hit 40 home runs in a season down the line, this is your player. On defense, Walker’s ability to bend and get deep into his legs, as well as his lateral agility and range, is incredible for a player his size. There have been some instances this year where he’s backhanded a grounder deep near the third base line and fired a rocket over to first base, but most of his routine throws are casual lobs over to first. There are some scouts who have seen nothing but this type of throw from Walker for entire series, and leaving them with questions about whether he can play third base, but there are still flashes of a plus arm on occasion. Of course, Nolan Arenado‘s presence through 2027 might dictate a move to first regardless of how Walker looks over there. His 40-man timeline presents the Cardinals with a likely seamless transition from MVP candidate Paul Goldschmidt to Walker if they so choose, with Walker possibly DH’ing most days during Goldy’s contract year. Even if he plays nothing but first base from the jump, Walker will still produce enough power to be a consistent 3 WAR All-Star, and there’s superlative thump here even at that position.
50 FV Prospects
2. Iván Herrera, C
| Age | 22.1 | Height | 6′ 0″ | Weight | 220 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 50 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50/60 | 50/50 | 40/45 | 50/40 | 40/50 | 60 |
Herrera’s bat-to-ball track record would be exciting regardless of what position he played, but it’s rare for a catcher to be as deft with the barrel as he is, and it’s the chief reason that he projects as St. Louis’ heir apparent to Yadier Molina. While Herrera’s hitting posture can get a little too upright and cause him to pull off of sliders away from him, including ones that finish in the zone, he is adept at making contact basically everywhere else, especially at the top of the strike zone. Herrera is also capable of doing all-fields damage when he gets extended on pitches on the outer third, and the hit/power combination here could make him one of the top 10 (or so) hitting catchers in the entire league. He also has uncommon athleticism for a catcher and generates home-to-first times close to 4.3 seconds at his fastest.
Indeed, Herrera would just be a 55 FV prospect were he a better defender. Even as he’s improved his receiving (average) and framing (below-average, at least to my eye, especially at the bottom of the zone), they’re still not great, and his ball-blocking is even further behind and at times is a real problem. Things aren’t so bad back there that Herrera will have to move to first base, but even though he’s kissed the big leagues, he does need polish. He’s only 22 and is now Molina’s squire, so those issues should improve at least a little bit. Very likely to be a good everyday player, the strides Herrera can make on defense will determine just how good.
3. Nolan Gorman, 3B
| Age | 22.1 | Height | 6′ 1″ | Weight | 230 | Bat / Thr | L / R | FV | 50 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 35/40 | 65/70 | 50/60 | 40/40 | 30/40 | 45 |
Gorman had another good season in 2021, slashing .279/.333/.481 combined between Double-A Springfield and Triple-A Memphis, mostly at the latter. It was the first time that he hadn’t experienced a whiff-prone adjustment period upon promotion, and his K% was lower last season than in any year since he was in rookie ball. He began 2022 on an epic heater, clubbing 15 homers in a little over a month at Triple-A Memphis even though his strikeout rate exploded. Up in St. Louis for the last couple of weeks, he has hit for power while producing a lower OBP. Thick and physical, Gorman has comfortably plus raw power at age 22, though his body is maxed out and I’d be surprised if there was another grade left in the tank even though he is so young. While he’s had issues getting on top of fastballs at the top of the zone, there’s enough playable power here that Gorman should produce like a heart-of-the-order thumper.
The presence of Nolan Arenado and Paul Goldschmidt on the infield corners means Gorman is being shoehorned in at second base, where he isn’t very good; his range, hands, and actions around the bag are all below average. He can make routine plays, though, and the Cardinals would be justified in running him out there situationally, even knowing that he’s a 30-grade defender at the position. If he played there every day, he’d produce like a left-handed Dan Uggla. Gorman is a fringe defender at third and would probably be an average defender at first base with time. That versatility will enable him to shuffle around with Tommy Edman and Edmundo Sosa the same way Matt Carpenter and Paul DeJong did, getting Gorman’s bat in the lineup most of the time and taking him off the field to prioritize defense late in games. While flawed, Gorman should get to most of his impact power in games and share time at several infield positions, including one up the middle of the diamond, which will enable him to produce like a good everyday big leaguer.
4. Matthew Liberatore, SP
| Age | 22.7 | Height | 6′ 5″ | Weight | 200 | Bat / Thr | L / L | FV | 50 |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40/45 | 50/55 | 60/60 | 45/55 | 55/70 | 92-95 / 97 |
Liberatore tracked through the minors without experiencing so much as a developmental hiccup, and in fact, he’s accumulated much more big game experience than all but a few pitchers his age. Last year, he struck out a batter per inning as a 21-year-old who spent the entire season at Triple-A Memphis, started the Futures Game for the National League, and pitched for Team USA in the Olympics.
Libby has done all of this amid a shift in his pitch usage. The slider that he learned on the fly as a high school senior might eventually be his most consistent, finishing pitch, and the sinking/tailing fastball shape that seemed like it might hamper his heater’s effectiveness has actually helped set up his changeup, which Liberatore has tremendous feel for locating, especially for a pitcher his age. The gorgeous, high-arcing curveball that made us all swoon while he was an amateur was used less often early in 2022, perhaps as a developmental measure, but as Liberatore was needed at the big league level, he returned to leaning on it. In addition to having enough depth to miss its fair share of bats, the curveball is useful as a way for him to get back into counts, or as a show-me pitch the second or third time through the order. But it’s very slow (73 mph on average) and easy to identify out of his hand, which is why I think the slider might eventually be his two-strike finishing pitch of choice. Libby’s four-pitch package is seasoned with all sorts of crafty, Cueto-esque delivery variations that disrupt hitters’ timing and keep them off of stuff that is more well-rounded than it is dominant. He projects as a mid-rotation starter on a playoff team, he’ll likely pitch in the big leagues for a very long time, and the long-term ceiling on his command is huge since we’re talking about a 22-year-old who already has great feel to pitch.
5. Masyn Winn, SS
| Age | 20.3 | Height | 5′ 10″ | Weight | 180 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 50 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 35/55 | 45/55 | 30/50 | 60/60 | 40/50 | 80 |
While focusing solely on shortstop, Winn (who was a two-way amateur with huge arm strength) dominated High-A for the first month of 2022 and was given a quick promotion to Double-A Springfield, where he continued to rake on the surface. While Winn’s underlying metrics indicate his power output in 2022 has to this point been a mirage, his bat-to-ball skills are advanced, especially for a prospect who was a two-way player not long ago, and who is only 20 and already in the upper levels. His contact rates (in the zone and overall) have been better than the big league average this year and have taken a bit of a leap since 2021. There’s big bat speed and rotational athleticism here, and you can project a little more on Winn’s power output even though he’s already a muscular, tightly wound 20-year-old who doesn’t have a long, projectable frame. While adept at putting the bat on letter-high fastballs, Winn currently struggles to pull ones that have real big league velocity. Fastballs he’s pulled in the air since arriving at Double-A have averaged only 90 mph, while per Synergy Sports, his opposite-field liners and fly balls have come against fastballs averaging 93 mph. Purely based on where his skills and tools are at this moment, Winn isn’t a 50 FV prospect in the same way that most other upper-level prospects are. Instead, he’s more of a high-variance, high-ceiling type with some freaky tools and an impressive early-career track record for someone who was not unanimously considered a hitter as a high school prospect.
6. Gordon Graceffo, SP
| Age | 22.3 | Height | 6′ 4″ | Weight | 210 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 50 |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50/55 | 55/60 | 55/55 | 55/55 | 50/55 | 93-97 / 99 |
Graceffo began to throw harder almost immediately after the Cardinals drafted him, throwing about two ticks harder at Low-A in 2021 than he was throughout the spring leading up to the draft. That trend has continued — Graceffo has added two more ticks, and has gone from sitting 90-93 mph to sitting 93-97 in less than a year. During that time, he’s also developed a second breaking ball, or at least created better separation between the two he was already working with. His slider is harder than his college version, basically experiencing the same four-tick jump his fastball did. His slider bites hard enough that even when it finishes in the zone, hitters are still swinging inside it. There are times when it looks like a generic cutter and others when it’s a nasty, easily plus pitch, but Graceffo’s feel for locating it to the glove side of the plate is reliable and consistent. He tends to want to dump his slower, more vertically oriented curveball into the top of the zone, while his screwball-style changeup is arguably his best pure pitch, though it’s also the one for which his feel is the least consistent. His fastball shape isn’t great for missing bats (get used to reading that), but Graceffo’s command will help keep it out of trouble. He goes right at hitters with four average-or-better pitches, the imaginary arrow that represents his stuff has consistently been pointing up for the last year, and Graceffo is already on the doorstep of the big leagues. He’s a plug-and-play fourth starter in the José Urquidy mold.
45 FV Prospects
7. Brendan Donovan, 2B
| Age | 25.5 | Height | 6′ 1″ | Weight | 195 | Bat / Thr | L / R | FV | 45 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 60/60 | 30/30 | 30/35 | 55/55 | 45/45 | 30 |
Recent rookie graduate Donovan grinds out great at-bats, he is tough to make chase and even more difficult to beat within the strike zone, and his approach and swing are geared for opposite-field spray. He might rack up a few dozen doubles throughout the course of a big league season by slicing pitches down either baseline or by occasionally splitting the center and left fielders, but Donovan’s raw power is skimpy and it’d be surprising if he hit double-digit annual homers; instead, almost all of his offensive output is going to come from his plus bat and on-base skills. While his lack of arm strength should prevent him from seeing extended time at shortstop (and is sometimes a problem when he’s the pivot man on double play attempts), Donovan can basically play all over the rest of the diamond and he’s seen time at all four infield positions and in both outfield corners. While he’s not a spectacular defender at any spot, his versatility on its own is a valuable skill and, in concert with his offensive skill set, is likely to help him crack the lineup on most days as a valuable super-utility type.
40+ FV Prospects
8. Tink Hence, SP
| Age | 19.9 | Height | 5′ 11″ | Weight | 160 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 55/60 | 55/60 | 30/50 | 35/55 | 93-96 / 98 |
Hence has incredible arm speed, he’s a plus on-mound athlete (though his delivery is a little violent) and he’s blowing 94-97 mph fastballs with huge riding life past Low-A hitters right now. As an amateur, Hence presented teams with an exciting vertical fastball/breaking ball foundation, as well as the athleticism and quality fastball strikes to project as a starter. He’s another pitching prospect from this system who enjoyed a healthy post-draft boost in arm strength, though Hence has been deployed for just three innings at a time so far in 2022. One concern from his amateur days was just how slight he was, drawing Triston McKenzie and Deivi García comps from a build and frame standpoint, two guys who have had trouble sustaining apex velo and crisp stuff. It’s fair to say that question hasn’t been answered yet given how light Hence’s workload has been to this point. Evidence of such stamina, more frequent changeup use (mid-90s heat and a good curveball are all you need to pave over a Low-A lineup for three innings at a time) and maybe an eventual second breaking ball are the developmental elements to key on here, as a couple of those things will need to come for Hence to be a mid-rotation stalwart or better. His combination of power and grace generate optimism that stuff will develop.
9. Zack Thompson, SP
| Age | 24.7 | Height | 6′ 2″ | Weight | 225 | Bat / Thr | S / L | FV | 40+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Cutter | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 45/45 | 60/60 | 45/50 | 30/35 | 50/55 | 93-96 / 97 |
Arguably the most talented college arm in the 2019 draft, Thompson fell (at least in part) because of injury issues speckled throughout his amateur career. After he signed, he was used pretty conservatively in a bullpen role for workload/health reasons, then was sent straight to Triple-A in 2021, where he struggled some with walks. That continued in a more stark, concerning way during his 2021 Fall League run, when Thompson was throwing about as hard as he ever has, but walked nearly a batter per inning. The Cardinals changed his position on the rubber in 2022 and this simple tweak may have remedied things. While Thompson began the year starting at Memphis, he’s made his big league debut deployed mostly in long relief outings. The headline pitch here is Thompson’s picturesque curveball, a deadly, mid-70s parabola much like Liberatore’s. Like Libby, Thompson’s fastball traits don’t fit perfectly with it, and the curveball pops out of his hand in a noticeable way, which impacts hitters’ propensity to chase it. It limits his curveball’s utility, but it’s a great in-zone offering he can use to get ahead of hitters and generate groundballs. Still sitting 93-94 mph, his fastball can get swings and misses up and to the arm side of the plate. There’s a new-ish cutter/slider here, too, and it’s interesting that even though Thompson has elite curveball spin rates, it hasn’t translated to the spin on the cutter/slider at all. He’s barely thrown the pitch in the big leagues even though it was operating at a 14% clip at Memphis; it looks below-average to the eye. There’s no dominant swing-and-miss offering here, no matter how pretty Thompson’s curveball might be. Assuming the recent strike throwing rebound holds, Thompson still projects to be a lower-impact rotation piece with a shot to pop better than that if his feel for spin can be parlayed into a second good breaking ball down the line.
10. Alec Burleson, RF
| Age | 23.6 | Height | 6′ 2″ | Weight | 214 | Bat / Thr | L / L | FV | 40+ |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 45/55 | 50/50 | 30/40 | 30/30 | 30/45 | 50 |
As the Cardinals are apt to do with their prospects, they pushed Burleson, a former two-way player, to the upper levels very quickly, having him spend most of his first full season at Double-A before a late-season promotion to Memphis, where he began 2022. He has had virtually no issues, slashing .282/.337/.486 so far as a pro, with a whopping .321/.367/.591 line at Triple-A this year. Burleson has above-average raw power and is hitting the ball hard despite utilizing a simple swing, one that becomes even simpler when he has two strikes. He is adept at hitting up-and-in fastballs, though he sometimes strangely inside-outs them to left field, and he also tends to take pitches down and away from him the opposite way, with enough strength to do extra-base damage in that direction.
Burleson is a pretty aggressive hitter whose chase rates have historically been in the 37-40% range, which would put him among the top 25 or so swing-happiest qualified big league hitters. It’s a somewhat scary underlying data point for a guy who doesn’t bring a lot to the table on defense, as he’s a tentative corner outfielder with a surprisingly average arm for a former college pitcher. Burleson has absolutely put himself in the short-term big league conversation with his upper-level performance, but there’s still bust risk here and he’s likely a corner platoon bat who’ll compete with Lars Nootbaar (who has better plate discipline, but a swing less optimized for power) for plate appearances against righties once Corey Dickerson’s one-year deal is up.
11. Andre Pallante, MIRP
| Age | 23.8 | Height | 6′ 0″ | Weight | 203 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Cutter | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50/50 | 60/60 | 55/55 | 45/50 | 93-97 / 98 |
More of the same Cardinals’ draft elements shine through Pallante, who was young for a college draftee (just 20 on draft day) and had a strong two-year track record of starting at Irvine. Again, we see a pitcher whose fastball shape — in Pallante’s case, some with natural cut and some with two-seam sink — makes it so it doesn’t miss bats even though Pallante throws very hard. He complements the heat with a short, more explicit (as in, obvious) mid-80s cutter/slider, and a very explicit (as in, profane) upper-70s 12-to-6 curveball. It’s a weird collection of pitches that generates a heavy dose of groundballs. From a statistical standpoint, Pallante looks like a lock to start: he’s done nothing but throw strikes as an amateur and pro prospect, and sustains his velocity deep into games. Visually, his delivery looks unlike that of any starter in baseball, almost more like a tennis serve than a pitcher’s mechanics, with some violence about the head and neck. Given how thin St. Louis’ rotation feels due to Jack Flaherty’s stubborn injury issues, it’s more likely Pallante gets continued run in the Cardinals rotation for now (he graduated from rookie eligibility earlier this year). It might be ideal for him to be a multi-inning relief weapon who can come in and throw water on a would-be rally by getting a key groundball, then work another frame from start to finish. Either way, Pallante’s bizarre mix should enable him to have a sizable impact on a pitching staff.
12. Michael McGreevy, SP
| Age | 22.0 | Height | 6′ 4″ | Weight | 215 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40/45 | 50/55 | 45/45 | 30/50 | 45/55 | 91-94 / 95 |
A converted infielder with a huge frame, McGreevy’s velocity spiked into the mid-90s during the fall of 2020 and for most of ’21 before falling back into the low-90s at the very end of UC Santa Barbara’s season. It’s been down in that area again in 2022. He utilizes a four-pitch mix that’s heavy on sinkers and sliders. Both his slider and curveball have good-looking movement, but they’re easy to identify out of his hand because they come out of very different arm slots. He’s an athletic, young strike-thrower still somewhat new to pitching, but the fact that McGreevy’s velo hasn’t rebounded is a little discouraging. Barely 22, it feels too early to slide him off his pre-draft grade (which had him as more of a second rounder than a first), but McGreevy currently looks more like a generic backend starter than a burgeoning mid-rotation guy.
13. Jonathan Mejia, SS
| Age | 17.2 | Height | 6′ 0″ | Weight | 160 | Bat / Thr | S / R | FV | 40+ |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25/60 | 30/45 | 20/45 | 55/55 | 40/55 | 50 |
Mejia is a medium-framed, switch-hitting shortstop with advanced feel for contact. He tracks pitches well from both sides of the plate, has a relatively compact swing (his lefty cut is more athletic and powerful right now) and is already pretty strong for a 17-year-old. While we’re not talking about a prospect with huge, overt power projection, Mejia’s feel for contact should enable him to get to whatever raw power he ends up with, and he’s a high-probability long-term shortstop. While a great distance from the big leagues, he’s a potential everyday guy and one of the better prospects signed during the 2022 international period.
40 FV Prospects
14. Juan Yepez, LF
| Age | 24.4 | Height | 6′ 1″ | Weight | 200 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50/55 | 60/60 | 50/55 | 40/40 | 30/30 | 60 |
Yepez has long shown big raw power in BP, enough that he was once acquired via trade (from Atlanta for Matt Adams) and was on prospect lists before the power output really began showing up in games. He struggled to stay healthy early in his career and didn’t slug over .400 at any level until 2019, when he broke camp in the Midwest League for the third straight year. The home runs finally began to pile up in 2021, when Yepez suddenly hit 27 combined between Double-A Springfield and Triple-A Memphis, mostly at the latter. He then went to the Arizona Fall League, where he faced pitchers who were worse on the average than those he had seen throughout the regular season. He homered seven more times in just 23 games in Arizona, creating some perhaps overzealous buzz. While Yepez easily has plus power, the track record for 1B/DH-only types who strike out as much as he does, especially for the swing-happy reasons he has tended to, isn’t great. Yepez had walked at a 5-6% clip in the low-to-mid minors, but showed a year-over-year increase in 2019 (9% in a 72-game sample) and ’21 (12% in 134 games, including the AFL), and he’s has presented some visual evidence that he’s refined his approach (he’s ditching his leg kick with two strikes).
Now in the big leagues (enough that he graduated from rookie status prior to list pub), Yepez has tended to expand the zone. So far in 2022, his chase rates (38% O-Swing) are among the top 25 chasiest in baseball (the big league average is 32%). While all of that is true, his power is huge and Yepez’s feel for contact is actually quite good; when he’s swinging at strikes, he tends to find a way to put the bat on the ball and pull it with power. In addition to developing an actual two-strike approach, Yepez has also slimmed way down even just since the 2021 Fall League, and he’s learning at the wing of Albert Pujols as a big league rookie. These are all reasons for Cardinals fans to hope I’m going to end up being light on Yepez’s projection, and indeed, if he gets regular at-bats, it won’t surprise me if Yepez has several 25-plus homer seasons. But at the 1B/DH end of the defensive spectrum (Yepez has mostly played the outfield corner in the big leagues and hasn’t been good), even amid a big peak year or two, players like this tend to perform close to the 1 annual WAR range as part-time corner role players or low-end options at their position, like Christian Walker, Michael Chavis, and Ryon Healy 힐리. Yepez has better tactile feel to hit than those guys, and maybe the more precise comp is Franmil Reyes. This is a dangerous hitter who I think has a place in a good big league lineup (like the current Cardinals lineup), but I have to factor the approach-related bust risk (and year-to-year volatility) into Yepez’s grade, since that specific trait tends to create highly variable year-to-year performance.
15. Austin Love, SP
| Age | 23.4 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 232 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50/50 | 55/55 | 40/50 | 45/55 | 92-95 / 98 |
Love epitomizes some of the draft trends in this org. He does not have a graceful, picturesque delivery. Instead, it is a plodding, heavy-footed affair, and yet Love’s command is good enough for him to be developed as a starter. In fact, his slider command is really good, another thread that runs throughout this system. He is sitting 92-95 mph as a starter and was up to 98 at UNC. He can create sink action on a firm, upper-80s changeup, and while he’s barely thrown that pitch in 2022 (Love is 90% fastballs and sliders as of list publication), it flashed bat-missing action at North Carolina, where he threw it more often. Love has a huge, innings-eating frame, but his delivery is stiffer than the typical major league starter look. He’s a high-probability big leaguer, with the floor of an ultra-consistent middle reliever and a ceiling toward the back of a rotation.
16. Ian Bedell, SP
| Age | 22.8 | Height | 6′ 2″ | Weight | 198 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40/45 | 55/60 | 40/50 | 35/60 | 88-93 / 94 |
Bedell’s velocity was down during the month-long 2020 college season, which had an impact on his draft stock; he was bumping 95 mph in 2019 but was more 88-92 in February and early March of ’20. Even though he wasn’t throwing as hard, Bedell struck out 35 and walked just four in 24 innings of work because he executes his pitch locations so consistently, especially his curveball, which has above-average depth and plays like a plus pitch because of his command. He needed Tommy John after just two 2021 outings and is about 13 months removed from surgery as of list publication. He’s been throwing in Jupiter but I can’t find anyone who has seen him, just to check on where his arm strength is at this stage. I thought Bedell was a candidate for some mechanical tweaks coming out of Missouri (his delivery was quite cross-bodied and violent), but it’s too early to know if any of that has occurred during the rehab process. Pre-injury Bedell had among the better chances of actually starting in this system and given how St. Louis likes to push guys through the minors quickly, this is a key backfield (and maybe Fall League) evaluation because he will probably be at Double-A and on the big league doorstep quickly if he looks anything like he did at his college prospect peak.
17. Leonardo Bernal, C
| Age | 18.4 | Height | 6′ 0″ | Weight | 200 | Bat / Thr | S / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20/50 | 40/45 | 20/40 | 40/40 | 30/55 | 55 |
Bernal is the Cardinals’ top 2021 international signee, a physical, switch-hitting 17-year-old Panamanian catcher. He’s really short to the ball from the left side of the plate and has a good looking swing from both sides. That, combined with his strong chances of staying behind the plate, gives him an everyday ceiling. Teenage catching is notoriously risky, of course, and Bernal’s career is barely underway, as he was only just assigned to Low-A after essentially skipping the GCL.
18. Freddy Pacheco, SIRP
| Age | 24.2 | Height | 5′ 11″ | Weight | 203 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 70/70 | 55/60 | 30/40 | 94-98 / 99 |
Pacheco has late-inning stuff, with a fastball that sits 96-98 mph with big riding life and a mid-80s slider that has curveball shape and action. Loose fastball command leads to walks and more in-zone contact against his fastball than is typical of someone who throws this hard, so Pacheco is more likely to find himself in lower-leverage roles initially, with a shot to move into a more substantial one through refined command.
19. Lizandro Espinoza, SS
| Age | 19.6 | Height | 5′ 7″ | Weight | 158 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25/60 | 30/40 | 20/35 | 50/50 | 40/50 | 50 |
Espinoza is a compact, contact-oriented middle infield prospect who is stronger and more muscular than you’d guess by just looking at his measurables. He can shorten up and get on top of high fastballs, while Espinoza’s lower half is flexible enough for him to dip and barrel low pitches. He is not a slam dunk shortstop and lacks the physical projection typical of a teenage prospect, but his middle-of-the-road projection is that of a long-term utility piece, and his hit tool gives him a puncher’s chance to be more than that if it turns out to be plus or better.
20. Malcom Nunez, DH
| Age | 21.3 | Height | 5′ 11″ | Weight | 205 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 45/55 | 55/55 | 45/55 | 30/20 | 20/20 | 55 |
Nunez became famous back in 2018 when he posted a god-like .415/.497/.774 line with 31 extra-base hits in 44 DSL games. He was bigger and stronger than most of the kids down there, so the industry was ultra-skeptical of that line. He’s continued to hit through the mid-minors and is a .284/.371/.465 career hitter who is performing at that level as a 21-year-old at Double-A. Much like Yepez, except with even less defensive contribution, Nunez has big strength-driven power and precocious feel to hit. He can make in-flight adjustments to breaking stuff and tailor his bat path to match pitch location, with most all of the slugging coming toward the left field gap. Historically, he’s also been a free-swinging sort, but his walk rate in 2022 (15%) has been much better than his career norms (in the 6-9% range in full-season ball) and some of the under-the-hood, more granular metrics, like his swing and chase rates, corroborate improvement in this area. Awkward and uncoordinated at first base, Nunez is a DH-only athlete and it’s possible his lack of athleticism will start to cause an on-field regression earlier than is typical of a pro athlete, but his hit/power combination will likely be sufficient for him to play a bat-only role like Daniel Vogelbach.
21. Joshua Baez, RF
| Age | 19.0 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 210 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20/40 | 60/70 | 25/60 | 50/40 | 40/50 | 55 |
Baez is a prototypical right field prospect with big present power as well as frame-based projection, a big arm, and strikeouts that threaten to torpedo his profile. Those strikeouts were worse than the industry hoped during his 2021 varsity season, and continued during my in-person looks at the Cardinals during extended spring training. Baez has a long-levered swing that cuts through the middle of the zone. He played both ways as an amateur and is from the Northeast, so it’s possible the feel for contact is still coming, but that demographic of player is also extremely risky. He is a prospect of extreme variance.
22. Packy Naughton, MIRP
| Age | 26.2 | Height | 6′ 2″ | Weight | 195 | Bat / Thr | R / L | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40/40 | 45/50 | 60/60 | 55/55 | 87-92 / 94 |
After falling out with the Peaky Blinders, Naughton turned his attention to the mound. A decimated Angels pitching staff and Naughton’s own velo rebound pushed him all the way from Double-A into Los Angeles’ rotation last summer, where he made five starts. He’s a bit of a throwback, relying on a sinker-changeup combination that works because his three-quarters slot helps the movement on both pitches play up. Ultimately though, the southpaw doesn’t throw hard and neither of his breaking balls generate many whiffs (so much that one of them was scrapped and the other was re-shaped since joining St. Louis). He’s had a two-tick bump (averaging 92 mph now) and projects to pitch in a low-leverage, multi-inning or spot start role as pitchability lefties with good changeups tend to do.
23. Inohan Paniagua, SP
| Age | 22.4 | Height | 6′ 1″ | Weight | 160 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 40 |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 35/40 | 55/60 | 40/50 | 35/60 | 89-92 / 94 |
The undersized, athletic Paniagua is leading the org in strikeouts as of list publication, albeit as a 22-year-old at Low-A, a level he is essentially repeating. He only sits 90-92 mph, but Paniagua can vary his fastball’s shape, his low-80s curveball has bat-missing finish and depth, and he repeats a simple, balanced delivery with machine-like precision. While unlikely to ever have an impact fastball, Paniagua has the on-mound athleticism to develop plus command and a better changeup, projecting as a backend starter.
35+ FV Prospects
24. Jake Walsh, SIRP
| Age | 26.9 | Height | 6′ 1″ | Weight | 192 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 60/60 | 50/55 | 30/35 | 35/40 | 94-96 / 98 |
Walsh has a power middle reliever’s two-pitch mix with his carrying mid-90s fastball and hammer low-80s curveball. His feel for location is quite crude, which most often impacts how Walsh’s curveball finishes and plays, while his fastball’s action gives him in-zone margin for error and is easily his best pitch. Walsh has also had some health issues, most recently elbow soreness that lead to a PRP injection. If he can stay healthy and develop more consistent command, then he’ll stick on the roster as a middle reliever. This FV placement has him more as an up/down guy.
25. Gustavo J. Rodriguez, SIRP
| Age | 21.5 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 170 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 55/60 | 45/50 | 30/45 | 20/45 | 94-96 / 98 |
He doesn’t have great feel for release consistency, but Rodriguez has arguably the second-best combination of arm strength and frame projection in this system, after Tink Hence. At a broad-shouldered, high-waisted 6-foot-3, Rodriguez is already bumping 97-98 mph as a 21-year old, and is parked in the 94-96 range. His low-80s curveball lacks consistency but flashes bat-missing depth. There’s interesting raw material here, but Rodriguez is a little behind the developmental curve for a college-aged pitcher.
26. Won-Bin Cho, LF
| Age | 18.9 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 200 | Bat / Thr | L / L | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20/40 | 45/60 | 25/55 | 40/40 | 30/50 | 50 |
Cho’s amateur stock blew up at a power-hitting showcase in Texas, and amid some controversy surrounding whether or not he would be eligible for the KBO Draft, he continued to play at some high school showcase events in the U.S., eventually signing with St. Louis. Cho is a big-framed lefty corner outfield prospect with fair feel to hit. He puts on quite a show during BP but is a less polished in games. There were scouts (both here and in Korea) who considered the public estimation of Cho to be inflated by social media highlight culture, but Cho looks like the high schoolers who command about $1 million in the draft and is a good low-level power projection prospect.
27. Ryan Loutos, SIRP
| Age | 23.4 | Height | 6′ 5″ | Weight | 215 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60/60 | 45/50 | 60/60 | 92-95 / 97 |
Undrafted out of Division-III Washington, Loutos has already reached Double-A and has had success all the way up the ladder thanks mostly to precise, at-the-letters command of his odd-angled mid-90s fastball. Loutos has an over-the-top delivery that creates this angle and action, as well as superficial depth on a curveball that doesn’t really garner many whiffs. He’s quickly put himself in the lower-leverage bullpen mix.
28. Cory Thompson, SIRP
| Age | 27.8 | Height | 5′ 11″ | Weight | 180 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 45/50 | 60/60 | 40/50 | 93-95 / 97 |
A converted shortstop, Thompson was up to at least 94 mph as a two-way player in high school but spent the first half decade of his career as a shortstop in the Reds system before they moved him to the mound. He’s taken a leap in two areas since 2019. One is his velocity (Thompson sat 91 mph in ’19, 94 mph in ’21, and has held in the 94-95 area this season) and the other is via a breakthrough with a screwball action changeup in the upper-80s. Thompson barely threw his changeup in 2021, but it’s easily his best pitch now. He’s out with a vague UCL injury, but he’s an older, late-blooming sleeper reliever, and a very good story.
29. Moisés Gómez, RF
| Age | 23.8 | Height | 5′ 11″ | Weight | 200 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30/35 | 60/60 | 45/50 | 40/40 | 40/40 | 55 |
The Aaron Judge of the Pacific Coast League, Gómez hit 23 homers in 60 games at Double-A Springfield before a recent promotion to Memphis. He was an interesting prospect in the 2017-19 window before approach-related issues caused his offensive performance to fall off a cliff while he was a Ray. He signed with St. Louis as a minor league free agent and slugged a ridiculous .705 with Springfield even though he has swung and missed more often than he’s put balls in play. Make no mistake, Gómez will punish you for yours. Hanging breaking balls and piped fastballs are not safe, and Gómez has so much power that he doesn’t even need to make flush contact to put balls out to any field. He still takes overzealous at-bats and has a ton of in-zone swing-and-miss, especially versus in-zone fastballs against which Gómez tends to be late. It’s fun that he was on pace for 50 Double-A bombs, but it doesn’t feel like Gómez would be able to sustain anything close to that after he gets a two-level bump to the big leagues. Still, there might be enough playable power for a very limited corner role or to consider Gómez an above-replacement depth option because his power is so explosive.
30. Chandler Redmond, 1B
| Age | 25.5 | Height | 6′ 1″ | Weight | 231 | Bat / Thr | L / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Hit | Raw Power | Game Power | Run | Fielding | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20/20 | 70/70 | 50/55 | 30/30 | 30/30 | 40 |
Redmond is a former 32nd round senior sign out of Gardner Webb who owns a .261/.357/.487 career line in pro ball. His peak exit velos in 2021 were in the same ballpark as those of Jordan Walker and Nolan Gorman, and his 30% barrel rate comfortably led the entire system, but Redmond also struck out roughly a third of the time as an old-for-the-level player. While his strikeout rate in 2022 was a very manageable 20% early on, there was no obvious mechanical or approach change to support that shift being sustainable and it’s back up close to 30% as of list publication. Though they’ve tried him at several other positions in the past, including second base, the Cardinals have deployed the 230-pound Redmond exclusively at first base and DH so far this season. There have been 1B/DH types who strike out about a third of the time, hit about .210 and reach base at about a .300 clip, but hit for enough power to be Lucas Duda or Brandon Moss, or even post some of the middle-of-the-road Chris Davis years. More likely, though, Redmond is in a Quad-A limbo and is possibly a candidate for pro ball abroad.
31. Nathanael Heredia, SIRP
| Age | 21.8 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 190 | Bat / Thr | L / L | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 55/55 | 50/55 | 30/40 | 93-95 / 96 |
A funky lefty with a low arm slot, Heredia sits 94-95 mph with tailing action and has a sweeping slider in the low-80s that lives more off his funk and arm slot than it does its own nastiness. He has a lefty-specialist look but also has much worse command than is typical for that sort of reliever.
32. Edwin Nunez, SIRP
| Age | 20.7 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 180 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 55/70 | 45/55 | 20/35 | 92-96 / 99 |
Nunez, who signed for just north of $500,000 after he was suspended for a year due to an age discrepancy, has an explosive mid-90s fastball and has been up to 101 mph, but he has very little idea where it’s going and his command has regressed along with his conditioning. Purely an arm strength flier at this stage, there’s big relief stuff here but low big league probability unless Nunez finds mechanical consistency.
33. Randel Clemente, SIRP
| Age | 20.6 | Height | 6′ 3″ | Weight | 173 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Slider | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50/60 | 45/55 | 30/40 | 94-97 / 98 |
Another young righty with a Division-I QB’s frame and a huge arm, Clemente will show you 94-97 mph and can really spin it. He is just an arm strength flier at this stage and needs both breaking ball and command refinement to even profile as a reliever.
34. Alec Willis, SP
| Age | 19.3 | Height | 6′ 5″ | Weight | 220 | Bat / Thr | R / R | FV | 35+ |
|---|
| Fastball | Curveball | Changeup | Command | Sits/Tops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40/50 | 45/55 | 30/50 | 20/50 | 89-93 / 94 |
Willis is an XXL high school prospect with a much more consistent delivery than most 6-foot-7 prepsters. He sits in the low-90s and has solid curveball feel, projecting as an innings-eating fourth starter. There was a point when Willis was sitting 82-85 mph as an amateur, then came back from ulnar nerve decompression surgery peaking in the mid-90s. He’s currently dealing with an arm issue and hasn’t pitched in 2022, making him a deep projection prospect.
Other Prospects of Note
Grouped by type and listed in order of preference within each category.
Depth Starters
Connor Thomas, LHP
Logan Gragg, RHP
Thomas Parsons, RHP
Thomas is a small, pitchability lefty with four offerings that live off his command, though some pitch metrics like his slider. Gragg, 23, is a 6-foot-5 kitchen sink righty who throws a ton of strikes with five vanilla pitches. He’s still in A-ball, but he could be a two-seam/cutter bulk reliever, if not a spot starter. Parsons, 26, is similar except he’s already at Triple-A.
Bench Role Ceilings
Conner Capel, OF
Nick Dunn, 2B
Osvaldo Tovalin, 3B
Delvin Pérez, SS
Jeremy Rivas, SS
Ryan Holgate, LF
Luken Baker, 1B
Capel is a well-rounded 25-year-old outfielder with above-average bat control and a weird swing. He’s a great upper-level injury replacement type. Dunn, 25, is like a free-swinging Brendan Donovan — same hair and everything. He has good feel for contact but not as good of an approach, and that’s enough to put him on the fringe rather than firmly in the big league mix. Tovalin, 22, is a physical, lefty-hitting infielder with a short swing and doubles power. He’s now at Peoria after clubbing Low-A. Pérez is a capable shortstop defender and a well-rounded defensive infielder who can’t really hit. Rivas, 19, is another light-hitting, glove-first type who is currently in A-ball. Holgate had a good college career at Arizona but has struggled to hit and dealt with injury in pro ball. Baker has stopped hitting after pelting 26 bombs last year, albeit as a 24-year-old in Double-A.
Deep Projection
Yordalin Pena, RF
Carlos Linarez, C
Pena, who signed in January, has arguably the most overt physical projection of that entire group and might come into big power. Linarez, 20, is an advanced defensive catcher with an above-average arm and good timing at the plate.
Relief Depth
Andre Granillo, RHP
Griffin Roberts, RHP
Johan Quezada, RHP
Granillo, a husky closer from UC Riverside, sits 93-95 mph with an above-average slider and 30-grade control. Roberts is rehabbing in the lower levels right now, sitting 90-92 and throwing his trademark breaking ball most of the time. He once looked like a slider monster reliever, but he needs to prove it at this point. Quezada has hopped around to a few orgs now and is still impossible to miss because he’s 6-foot-9 and throws 98 mph with little idea where it’s going.
System Overview
The Cardinals do not mess around. They push the prospects they think are good up the minor league ladder quickly, testing them and integrating them into the big league roster without worrying about service time optimization and manipulation. As such, we have a better idea of who’s a dude and who isn’t pretty quickly, which is part of why this system has little in the way of amorphous profiles or Schrödinger’s Prospects in a “maybe” area. The boom-or-bust high schoolers the Cardinals have found a way to get a little later in the draft have a mixed track record, but it feels like it’s worth it to have used a pick on Tre Fletcher (the only sign I saw of Fletcher on the complex in Jupiter was his sweet matte black car) if the process that landed him is the same one that leads you to Jordan Walker and Masyn Winn, who look like impact players.
I mention in some of the blurbs that St. Louis has a penchant for taking pitchers who have ugly deliveries, but who throw hard (and if not, the org tends to make them throw harder), often work with sink and tail more than rise, and command their breaking balls. That type of guy is all over their big league roster, with Dakota Hudson, Ryan Helsley, Jordan Hicks, and Pallante all applicable examples.
Internationally, St. Louis tends to have a balanced approach. They commit some money at around the same time other teams do, then hold a portion of their pool in reserve for later in the process, which they use to come to agreements with slightly older pitchers who have had a velocity spike (Edwin Nunez and Randel Clemente are examples here), or players who are hitting the market late for whatever reason (as was the case with Cho).
With Graceffo moving into the 50 FV tier, the Cardinals are now tied with several teams for the third-most Top 100-caliber prospects in a single system, with six; their cohort trails only the Guardians and Rays, who each have seven. It’s a top-heavy system with slightly below-average depth due more to graduations than anything else. Elehuris Montero is the only prospect on The Board who originally signed with St. Louis but is now a prospect for another team.
Eric Longenhagen is from Catasauqua, PA and currently lives in Tempe, AZ. He spent four years working for the Phillies Triple-A affiliate, two with Baseball Info Solutions and two contributing to prospect coverage at ESPN.com. Previous work can also be found at Sports On Earth, CrashburnAlley and Prospect Insider.


I think, crazy as it might seem, the best thing for Herrera’s development right now is to be Yadi’s understudy for 2022. The bat is there, he’ll be somewhere around an average glove, but if he can pick Yadi’s brain on how to call a game, he’ll be a plus overall behind the dish.
That’s a good idea, but there’s a problem with that: Knizner is out of options, and the Cardinals would like to keep him to continue being the backup catcher (but for Herrera) next year.
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with just getting rid of him and picking up a generic backup. Knizner is baaaaaad.
The only real reason why any team would want Knizner is if they want to save money. And since he’s going to go through arbitration next year, it’s possible they won’t even save that much.
There is a non-zero chance that if he got DFA’d he’d pass through waivers. Not a high one, but since he can’t hit and can’t catch he isn’t really anyone someone would prioritize.
Why do people keep saying he can’t catch? Defense is where he’s actually pretty good.
Knizner’s errors, passed balls, and caught stealing percentage are all just fine, both this year and for his (limited) career. Baseball-Reference says his defense is passable, at the very least. So B-Ref supports your view, Lanidrac.
Fangraphs’ catcher metrics on the other hand rank him closer to a defensive disaster. I would simply average the two together and say he’s below average but not awful. Then again, I’m lazy and averaging them is easy. (Interesting trend: Knizner’s passed balls have improved from 1 every 10 games in the minors, to just 1 per 30 games in MLB. For context, Dodger uber-prospect Diego Cartaya has averaged an alarming 1 PB every 4 games, both this year and for his career.)
If you look at the components of his DRS and defensive ratings, he is average in most spots but he is a horrible framer. Since he debuted in 2019, he has put up the 6th worst framing value among catchers with a minimum of 500 innings.
That sounds bad, but it’s even worse than that, since he’s only had 906.2 innings. If you standardize it by innings, he leaps ahead of Salvador Perez, Pedro Severino, and Elias Diaz and into third place. The two guys ahead of him are Chance Sisco and Zack Collins. Collins is DH’ing half the time now, and Sisco has been DFA’d twice this year.
Unfortunately, not even roboumps are going to save him, because once they’re in place the bar for offense will be high enough that it’ll squeeze him in a different direction. Guys like Luis Torrens and Zack Collins and Eric Haase will be far more likely to make a roster (Sisco too, if he remembers how to hit). But there will be very few opportunities to play in the majors at catcher unless you’re in the wRC+ range of 80, or you’re an absolute defensive wizard.
I wish I could get eyes on McGreevy. 6′ 4″ and 100 lbs… and you thought Triston McKenzie was thin!
Would be a sight to see! Thanks for spotting that, updated now.
Played against Loutos in college, dude always dominated us. To call his fastball odd angled is an understatement and his delivery is quite wonky which helps add deception. Really excited to see how he progresses!
Stat line scouting warning: it looks like Walker is hitting the ball into the ground a lot. Pretty impressive that he has almost a .200 iso doing that. If he can get the ball off the ground some more without sacrificing a lot of contact, buckle up.
Tip of the cap for the Naughton comment. I LOLed
Agreed on the Naughton reference. Great show, Peaky.
As for the rest, let’s not overthink it. The kid was 19 for the first six weeks of the season, and he’s hitting .300/.400/.500 in Double-A. All told, he’s played 146 pro games, all in full-season ball, all while extremely young for his leagues, and batted .300+ with 45 doubles, 7 trifectas, and 21 homers.
This is like that story The Birthmark. We shouldn’t squint so hard, searching for statcast flaws. Just accept his bat as a thing of beauty.
No for grades Randel Clemente. Are they missing, or simply non-existent?
As a BFIB Minor League dork, this list is very exciting to read over my Friday morning coffee.
It was an HTML goof – updated now! Thanks for spotting that.
Lowkey one of the more exciting farms out there. Gorman’s a stud, the 2020 draft was :chefskiss:, Herrera’s long been underrated, Liberatore seems fine, and this is without noticing any sleepers…the NL Central’s got an interesting Future, all hail the never present always coming Future
This system looks way, way better than it did at the end of last season. Walker and Winn have improved dramatically. Like, 50 -> 60 level improvement, or 40+ -> 50 level improvement. Just super impressive. Graceffo looks better too; Liberatore and Gorman look more ready than they did before (Gorman at least partly because he’s hitting big league pitching). Just a big step forward for a lot of guys.
Thompson was starting to get written off by many and has rebounded in a major way. Graceffo is garnering a lot of attention, but I’m most excited to see Herrera get this level of recognition. I have been watching Nuñez over the past month start to break out of his shell.
There will be interesting decisions ahead for Mozeliak/Girsch.
Wow, I like Graceffo, but I did NOT expect Eric to pump him up this quickly. Fun rising arm to watch!
Thanks Eric! I am always impressed by how much detail you manage to cram into these.
There’s one grade that really baffles me, to the point I think it might be a typo? Burleson has a game power rating of 30/40, despite currently running a .230 ISO in AAA. ZiPS projects him for a .180 ISO in the show, comfortably above league average. I think your write up of Burleson is great and I agree he has his risks/shortcomings. I’m just confused how his current game power is the same as guys like Donovan and Winn, and a full grade lower than Herrera, who had an ISO almost 100 points lower than Burleson on the same Memphis team this year.
As regards the “mixed track record” of high-school draftees, it’s worth remembering that St. Louis hasn’t had a top-ten draft slot in this century, and only one in the upper half (with which they took Brett Wallace). Guys drafted in the lower half of the first round are not odds-on to have significant major-league careers.
Kind of confused by these lines/concerns:
Yepez’s highest MILB K% at any stop from 2017-2022 is 23.8%.
Burleson’s career MILB K% to date:
While both are definitely swing happy, it appears the underlying contact skills have been enough to keep strikeouts well under control so far, no?
Eric, just to spite you and make your blurb outdated after an hour, the Cards promoted Ryan Loutos to Memphis.
Also, I suggest anyone who hasn’t watched some Tink Hence highlights go do so. They are very fun. And watch some Masyn Winn throws.
Eric, what are your thoughts on Mike Antico? He’s old (was a senior signing) but just got called up to AA. Can he keep up the walk rate or will better pitching expose his lack of power?
I am thoroughly convinced that Walker is a 60 after reading this. I read this profile and I get strong Troy Glaus vibes. Walker probably isn’t going to be that good because Glaus was outstanding, but the fact that it’s a realistic possibility is pretty cool.
I got to be honest though, he does not look nearly as good as Gunnar Henderson, and he’s a 55 so far. I was pretty on board with Henderson’s upgraded rating when it came out but the more I read of these the more I think he’s definitely a 60, and possibly on the 60/65 border. It’s nearly impossible to think of him failing entirely at this point, and his upside is on the same level as the best infielders we’ve seen in the last 30 years.
It’s weird that this is what Walker’s profile made me think of, but I totally buy that he’s a 60 and not at all that he’s a better prospect than Henderson which makes me think Henderson is even better than his current grade.
I’m not a prospect guy, but after reading his blurb on the Orioles page, I’m guessing it’s because there’s no standout skill, and he might have issues with MLB velocity. His numbers are hard to ignore, obviously, but Walker has 80 power, which makes up for a lot of possible contact issues. If Henderson does end up having issues with velocity, he becomes a decent infield defender and what, an average bat? Can’t put a 60 on that.
That’s my uninformed opinion, anyway.
Average bat, plus defender at third is probably his floor at this point. That’s incredibly rare, when your floor is a 2.5-win player.
Zips sees him as about 20% above league average with the bat at peak; that would put him around a 4.5 win player, which is near the higher end of the 60 range.
If the defense is better than advertised or–the offense is better than that–then you’re looking at superstar territory. You’re talking Eric Chavez, Troy Tulowitzki, Alex Bregman kinds of stuff. Which you can’t rule out because the list of guys who have done what he’s doing at AAA this young includes guys like Matt Kemp, Mookie Betts, Vlad Jr., Kyle Tucker, and Evan Longoria.
So I feel awfully comfortable with him as a 60, given the floor, the median ZiPs projection, and the historical precedents. The best precedent for a player absolutely destroying AAA this young and not succeeding is Gavin Lux. And he’s been pretty good!
I’m with you 100%, sad one.
Gunnar is baseball’s best prospect right now. I have Walker top 5, but there’s a level of magnitude gap between those two.
Gunnar is the exact same age Bobby Witt Jr. was last year, and is doing the exact same things that rightly made Witt a consensus top 2 or 3 prospect — only Gunnar is amazingly doing them even better than Bobby did. He’s murdering AA/AAA but he’s also walking twice as often as Witt did, and striking out less!
I don’t think Henderson has Witt’s raw power, and he’s a lot less likely to stick at shortstop. But the hit tool is clearly much better than has been assessed in the past. Much, much better.
Among position players who are not in the majors right now (and thus excluding anyone who might exceed rookie thresholds before the year is out), I think he’s on the same level as Corbin Carroll and Francisco Alvarez, with guys like Volpe and Walker and Luciano behind them. Probably all 60s, but if Henderson keeps doing this I think he will probably be a 65 (same goes for Alvarez and Carroll; I think that’s how they’re tracking).
Watching the Cardinals minor league system nearly every day for several years has been humbling. National media outlets have historically struggled to capture the consistency of quality production coming from the Cardinals system.
I’ll encourage any fans who enjoy reading about the Cardinals minor league system to engage BigJawnMize at VEB (VivaElBirdos comments section), check out work on The Cardinals Nation, and follow Kyle Reis on Twitter. Big thank you to Fangraphs and Eric on sharing feedback on the Cardinals system. Loved following the now retired AE Schafer for nearly a decade. Shout out to all who put effort in to writing about our sports we’re following.
– Baseball Fanatic
I will echo the support to writers dedicated to the Cardinals’ prospects. They are able to provide updates more often and follow the system more closely.
Eric does great work and to me, system overviews found at places like Fangraphs, Baseball America, etc provide perspective that we don’t get as fans of the team.
To sum this up:
-Thanks Eric, great work as always
-Support your local blogger
Yeah, it’s only sites like this where the term “devil magic” gets thrown around with regards to the Cardinals’ player development system, or there’s similar praise coming from local media. I’ve never heard the national media talk about it.
Are these the beginning of 2023 rankings?
Biiiiiiiiiiiitch, please.
Also it’s crazy that the Cardinals basically have three first basemen right now (Goldschmidt, Yepez, and Gorman) and in a couple of years they’ll have two third basemen (Arenado, Walker). I suppose you just hold on to Walker and figure out the position later. Who knows, maybe Arenado gets himself hurt and he struggles to recover his form and they need a third baseman anyway? It would be a shame if Walker has to slide to first base or DH, but it also might not work out that way?
Walker comes across as more of a left fielder with his above average speed and his timeline is aligned well with Tyler O’Neill (either hitting free agency or the Cardinals cashing in on a trade). Having the ability to play COF and CIF will help as injuries are bound to happen over the next several years. Positional versatility is great and Walker is a gifted athlete who can easily make the transition.
Well said, Redneck.
Walker is currently an above-average runner (one of the reasons he’s 15-for-18 stealing this year, and 29-for-34 across 146 career games) and I can’t see him anywhere as a major leaguer but the outfield — at least for the next 8-10 years. His hot corner defense is quite poor, so even if Arenado opts out after this season, it’ll be Gorman who takes over 3rd base.
One odd thing re his tool grades. Don’t know why Walker is perceived at only an eventual 50 for the hit tool. He’s a hard-hitting kid who was still 19 on Opening Day, has now run uniformly high BABIPs at all three full-season ball levels (.377, .382, .419) and is batting .300+ in Double-A with solid plate discipline markers (12% BB and 21% K).
Given his extreme youth, that screams 60 or even 65 hit tool to me.
I mean, a 50 is really solid. A 50 Hit and 80 Game Power is an incredible outcome for a back of the 1st round guy. He’s a 50 because he has exploitable holes that MLB pitchers can use against him and MiLB pitchers cannot. Trust the scouts who are seeing his swings in games.
When it comes to pitching, I’ll trust scouts.
When it comes to hitting — especially when talking about highly successful & very young hitters — I’ll always place the greatest trust in the sum total of all minor and major league hitters who’ve come before. I see a Matt Holliday skillset at the plate.
Again, it’s not the batting averages he’s posted per se. It’s everything: the youth, the consistently exceptional BABIPS, and the fine plate discipline markers. That’s a recipe for conspicuous success, not mediocrity. I’m not looking at the hit tool relative to draft position or power. Don’t know why anyone would.
Most surprised about Graceffo’s helium. With those evaluations on his stuff and command, he should probably be in the majors, bumping Pallante to long relief and Wittgren to free agency. I bet we see him in 2022.
Is the Winn pitching dream dead? I mean, you’ll take a 50 FV SS whenever you can get it, but he currently makes throws from short that are harder than any other professional player, MLB included. He is one of the few guys who could possibly make a two-way approach work, though I guess you don’t want him making throws from short a day after pitching, right? I don’t know.
I don’t care if Herrera’s defense never improves — he’s gotta be playing over Knizner, who simply can’t play the position. I think evaluators probably shouldn’t have put Knizner on any lists until he either proved a bat that can overcome league- worst defense, or improved defense, because his current play is so, so bad.
Graceffo is only in AA. If he’s getting a promotion soon, it will only be to AAA as long as Pallante and Liberatore don’t suddenly decline or get injured and probably not even then.
Pitchers come up from AA all of the time. Hicks came up from A+. STL has no qualms with jumping levels. If a pitcher is ready, he’s an option to be called up.
No, they don’t, and when they do they’re usually only an injury-related callup who gets optioned back to the minors before long. Hicks is an extreme exception.
In any case, he’s still behind both Pallante and Liberatore on the depth chart, along with Hicks returning from the IL any day now and Woodford available in long relief or a spot start as needed, so the Cardinals have no place to use him even if they did call him up.
It will then only get more crowded once Matz returns before long and eventually Flaherty and (hopefully) Reyes. Ver Hagen as another long relief option, too, if he doesn’t get DFAed soon after he returns.
Can someone explain the difference between raw power and game power?
From Eric’s “The BOARD tutorial”:
“Raw” power is graded via a combination of visual evaluation during batting practice (How far can you hit the ball?) and the max exit velocities I source from teams. As I’ve sourced max exit velocities, I’ve found that there are a couple different ways teams keep track of this data. Several of them wipe away the top couple exit velos to eliminate the possibility of outliers. Keep this in mind as you look at the “Max Exit Velocities” on The Board. It’s a big part of why the visual evaluation piece is still very important in this space.
“Game” power is a grade describing power output. While raw power is “How far/hard can they hit the ball?”, game power is “What is their power production like in actual games?” These two are often different for any number of reasons (often augmented by swing plane, approach, or hit tool quality). The present game power grades are derived the same way present hit tool grades are. If a player’s approach and/or swing currently enable power in games, they’ll be a present 25 or 35 depending on their age. If they lack present strength, or have a contact-oriented approach, or need a swing change to get there, it’ll be a 20 or 30 depending on their age. Once again, I try to put a present grade on the game power in a traditional sense only once the player is in the upper levels of the minors.
How To Use The Board: A Tutorial | FanGraphs Baseball
I still don’t get it. If the point of observing their “non-game” power is to identify future game power potential, then simply show the “power” category as 20/80.
Raw is what you show in BP. Game power is how much of your raw power you can access in games, and can be a function of approach, bat speed, in-game swing and barrel ability.
On a related note, having watched both for years, I’m not buying Walker as two standard deviations better in game power than Gorman, even conceding Walker has the better approach and hit tool. Gorman has shown strength, bat speed, barrel ability and natural launch angle since he was 14.
I’m not crazy about Gorman’s hit tool, but yeah, the power is true elite. Assuming robust health, he’ll contend for a home run title or three before he’s done.
But this other thing:
“Gorman is being shoehorned in at second base, where he isn’t very good; his range, hands, and actions around the bag are all below average…he’s a 30-grade defender at the position.”
At the risk of being impertinent, that is simply dead wrong. That description fits Brendan Donovan, not Nolan Gorman. Just directly comparing those two, over their minor league careers Clay Davenport’s website has Gorman’s glove worth 12 runs more per 150 games than Donovan’s, and Baseball Prospectus has Gorman a whopping 18 runs better/150. The ZiPS model loves Gorman’s glove as well.
And in case all of that is colored by Gorman’s third base defense, well, we can compare Gorman’s numbers head-to-head with Tommy Edman this year. (Aside: Edman got a 45 fielding grade at Fangraphs as a prospect, so maybe his elite MLB defense is an illusion. But I doubt it.) Per 1,000 innings at 2nd base this year,
Edman: 535 chances, 193 putouts, 337 assists, 5 errors, 79 double plays turned.
Gorman: 593 chances, 229 putouts, 373 assists, 10 errors, 115 double plays.
I’m of course not arguing that these numbers prove Gorman is as good as Edman at the keystone. That’s not the point. I am saying that when we combine them with all of the other above evidence (ZiPS, BPro, Davenport) they confirm to my satisfaction that Gorman is at least *average* at the position. The fact that he had an errorless June is just one more small data point in his favor. I am aware of zero objective evidence that Gorman is a 30 defender, or 40 or 45 at 2nd base.
I would argue vehemently that like Edman and DeJong before him, Nolan Gorman’s defense is vastly superior to the pre-MLB perceptions of some skeptics.
His OAA is not good. Small sample but it backs up the scouting reports.
Ah, but which scouting reports? This notion that Gorman is a terrible “30” defender at the keystone may be a misleading outlier for all we know.
For a counterexample, prior to this season the substantially less despondent Pipeline overview was:
“The biggest news of Gorman’s 2021 was his full-time move to second base, which kicked into gear at Triple-A, following the acquisition of Nolan Arenado. He worked hard with infield coordinator Jose Oquendo to improve his footwork and range, particularly on balls to his right, and he could be average there in time.”
So perhaps now is the time, and he’s already average. I’m half-joking, but he’s certainly looked good turning a LOT of double plays — good transfer, footwork, accurate arm to first. And it’s been nearly 5 weeks since his last fielding miscue.
…and this, courtesy of Baseball America in November, 2021:
“Gorman drew solid reviews for his defense at third base in previous years, but second base was a question mark given his physical, muscular build. He proved surehanded with only seven errors in his first year at the position and rapidly improved his footwork turning double plays.”
“By the end of the year, even opposing scouts opined he would be able to play second base in the major leagues. With Gorman’s defense at the keystone drawing better than expected reviews, there is now a strong possibility his time will come sooner rather than later in St. Louis.”
So the notion that Nolan Gorman is a very poor “30” grade defender at 2nd appears to be a Fangraphs opinion, not a scouting one. I suspect the same was likely true of the “45” fielding grade that Tommy Edman received when a prospect.
Gorman’s primary position is now 2B, and Pallante’s ETA is now 2022. (I’ll accept Herrera’s ETA as still 2023, since he’s only up this season until Molina returns and possibly September.)
Also, I don’t buy Donovan as a 45 FV when that could very well be his current value or more.
In particular, I don’t get how Donovan has already maxed out his hit tool as a rookie. The only good contact hitters I know who’ve arguably even come close to doing that are Joe DiMaggio, Ted Williams, and Albert Pujols. Well, and Jackie Robinson and Ichiro Suzuki, but they had extenuating circumstances.
He got a 60 for Hit. For a non-prospect, that’s amazing, and a 60 Hit is pretty rare in general. A lot of his current success is BABIP-related — let’s see what his numbers look like once the BABIP normalizes and pitchers adjust to him. Because he has well below-average power, pitchers will start challenging him more. The average and OBP are going to drop — it’s just a matter of how much.
And I’m a huge Donovan hawk — I watched a ton of Memphis games last year just to watch him. He hit a sweet home run off the left field foul pole that gives me hope there’s some more power in him, but it’s not something I’m expecting.
Also, hitters arrive maxed out all of the time. Plenty of players have their best years at the beginning of their careers then settle in at a lower level, whether that’s due to not adjusting or not having a skillset conducive to sustained success.
I’m not arguing against his current 60 rating. I’m arguing about his futute hit rating also being a 60. As good as his hitting already is as a rookie, he should get even better to a 70+ mark in the future. Most of his current success is due to his hard contact line drives legitimately giving him a high BABIP, not much from luck.
Lesser hitters can arrive already maxed, but good ones do not save for the rare exceptions I already mentioned. Position players hgaving their best years at the beginning of your career is very rare, and most of those who do are power hitters who are average or worse contact hitters like Paul DeJong.
Donovan is 25 1/2 years old. There’s a non-trivial chance he’s already done developing in every way, save power perhaps.
But I do agree that a 45 grade is too light. A 45 would make him something like a top 180-200 prospect with a projected career WAR in the 2-4 range. He’ll reach that by Labor Day at his current pace. A strong 45+, i.e., top 125-135 overall prospect, makes sense for an elite bench guy. (His glove isn’t good enough to start at any position, in my opinion. And the bat is good but not nearly as good as he’s shown in MLB thus far.)
Once his numbers drop into the average or slightly below-average area, as his Statcast data suggests will happen, where is the excess value gonna come from? His main issue is he can’t play any position at an average clip. He’s been pretty abysmal in the outfield and clearly can’t play short or third base for more than emergencies.
He’s a utility guy that will have great value for his team, filling in here and there, but he won’t be racking up WAR. He seems like a 1-2 WAR a season guy, probably closer to the 1 until he improves defensively. His current WAR numbers are set to stagnate or even drop, not increase, so there’s no guarantee he reaches 2 WAR this season.
“His (Brendan Donovan) current WAR numbers are set to stagnate or even drop, not increase, so there’s no guarantee he reaches 2 WAR this season.”
I should have clarified that when I made that remark about Donovan “getting to (2 WAR) by Labor Day” I was simply extrapolating from the three Rest-Of-Season projections on his Fangraphs page. Those three models had him adding between 0.8 and 1.0 WAR over the remainder of the season, in 200-240 plate appearances. Pro-rated, that would theoretically be 0.6-0.7 additional WAR by Labor Day, which would put him over the top.
Anyway, I agree he’s a 1-1.5 WAR per season guy if he gets 350-400 plate appearances — and that’s a reeeal good bench player. There are much worse things than being a poor man’s Tommy Edman.
At 25, it’s reasonable to think he’s more of a finished product than someone with significant room for growth. The commenter above also describes how his current line likely isn’t close to sustainable.
But a 60 hit tool is really good! He doesn’t need to have room to grow from there
I don’t think that’s necessarily true in the COVID era. Young players today missed some serious baseball and may have different growth trajectories than what we’re used to.
Perhaps, but the point remains that an older prospect can absolutely debut as a finished product.
Moreover, in this individual case Donovan had plenty of minor league reps before debuting
A 70 FV? Very few hitters in MLB have a 70 grade hit tool. For example, in an article earlier this year, MLB.com listed their top tools among prospects and who had them. For hit tool, they had Julio Rodriguez and gave him a 70 FV. Donovan isn’t the top hitting prospect in MLB, nor will he project to hit .310+ consistently. He’d be a top prospect in baseball if a 70 hit tool was in his future, let alone a 70+.
I have no idea where you are getting hard contact about Donovan. His Statcast page is significantly underpowered — he’s in the bottom 11% in avg exit velo, bottom 18% in max avg exit velo, bottom 3% in Barrel%, bottom 7% in xSLG…hard contact is far from his game. Also of note — his xBA is only slightly above average, at 55%. An xBA of .265 is much worse than his current numbers and isn’t indicative of a possible future 70 grade tool.
Comparing him to inner circle hall of famers? Yeah, you won’t be disappointed by his career at all!
The thumbnail for this article gave me some Chuck Carr flashbacks.
This is awesome content. Tre Fletcher showing not everyone can be Ryan Flaherty aka a Maine product who makes it to the majors
Fletcher is 0-fer-16 on the season… with a 100% K rate. 16K in 16PA. Wow.
Wow is right.
That “perfect” K rate by the way was in Low-A. He has mercifully been sent down to rookieball, where he’s 1-for-15 with 11 strikeouts and a suspension.
All told, across the two levels he fanned in each of his first 22 plate appearances. Difficult to believe, really. Should have announced his retirement effective immediately. Would have been a legend.
Can’t win ’em all…although if you’re Tre Fletcher, apparently you can lose ’em all.
Just want to say thanks to Eric (and Tess) for the hard work putting these together!