Steve Stone Has a Lot of Opinions on Pitching

Steve Stone knows a lot about pitching. A savvy right-hander for four teams from 1971-1981, he hurled 43 complete games, and augmented a 101-93 record with a rock solid 3.97 ERA. Stone was especially stellar in the 1980 season, garnering 25 wins for the Baltimore Orioles and taking home the American League Cy Young Award.

He doesn’t lack for opinions. Given his current job, he’s not supposed to. The 71-year-old has been in the broadcast booth for 30-plus years, the last 10 of them with the White Sox. As fans of Chicago’s South Side team can attest, Stone knows his stuff, and he’s not shy about sharing it. Agree with him or not, he’s rarely boring.

Stone sat down for a wide-ranging interview — one that offered some blunt commentary on players and trends alike — during a visit to Fenway Park midway through the 2018 season.

———

Steve Stone on learning as a young pitcher: “I pitched with Juan Marichal and Gaylord Perry. I pitched with Jim Palmer and Mike Flanagan. I pitched with Wilbur Wood. One thing I learned … I was very young when I was with Marichal and Perry. I didn’t have Hall of Fame talent, so it was hard to assimilate what they had to show me. Plus, Gaylord wasn’t forthcoming about anything that made him the pitcher he was. Marichal probably would have been, had I been able to understand how he did certain things.

“Perry threw a spitter. He wasn’t going to share that. Not unless I brought $3,000 to the park. That’s how much he said he’d charge to teach me the spitter. I was taking home $8,500. I didn’t want to give him 40% of my yearly take-home pay to try to learn a pitch that very few people can master.

“I didn’t learn as much from pitchers as I did from the assorted pitching coaches. One guy I learned a lot from was Ray Miller, with the Orioles. Ray told me a couple of different things. One was to work quickly. I had a tendency to work slow.

“I was in Baltimore — I was their first free-agent signing — and I remember he came running out to the mound with nothing going on. This was in maybe my second game with them. I asked Ray what he was doing out there. He said, ‘I have a message for you.’ I said, ‘From who?’ He said, ‘From your infield. They want you to throw the ball. They’re falling asleep.’

“He threw in a few expletives along the way, so I figured that working quickly was how they liked to do in Baltimore. It worked. When I started to work more quickly, I became more consistent. It was easier for me to repeat my motion, and my fielders were on their toes.”

On setting up hitters: “Ray also mentioned that I had a tendency to throw all of my pitches to every hitter, in every sequence. I was giving away certain things I didn’t have to give away. Ray said to take my fastball and one other pitch — usually my curveball — and establish them first. Then I could slowly integrate my other pitches into the performance. I threw a slider and a cutter, and three speeds of a curveball. I never could throw a straight change.

“Let’s say you have a hitter who has a problem with a low-and-away fastball. Ted Williams used to call it ‘The .240 zone,’ and if he hit .240 on that pitch, you can imagine how difficult it is for mortal hitters. So, let’s say a guy’s soft spot is low and away. If each and every time up, you go low-and-away fastball, then low-and-away slider, you’re tipping your hand. Two outs and nobody on, early in the game, is a non-critical at bat. There’s no reason to give away how you’re going to get him out with runners on base in the late innings.

“Another thing I learned is to always go to my strength until the hitter showed me that he was better than my strength. My strength was inside fastballs to a right-handed hitter, outside to a left-hander, and then breaking balls away to both. All things being equal, I was going to go there before I went to the scouting report. Ideally, my strength is his weakness and then he doesn’t get many hits against me.

“The avocation is called ‘pitching.’ If you’re calling it ‘throwing,’ then you can throw as hard as you can, early, and try to blow everybody away. With ‘pitching,’ you don’t go max effort every pitch. You’re setting guys up for the third time through the order.”

On third time through the order: “Pitchers were actually expected to go deep into games in those days. Now they’re expected to go as hard as they can, as long as they can. They’ll usually come out by the middle of sixth inning, leaving their bullpen to get the rest of the outs. That’s one of the reasons starters don’t have as many wins as they could — they’re not going deep enough into games to do that.

“You need to learn how to go through the order multiple times. Let’s say you try to shoot free throws in the NBA without ever practicing free throws. If you’re not expected to make free throws, you’re probably not going to be good at it. You have to convince guys that there’s a benefit to going a third time through, and hopefully a fourth time through, the order. If you yank somebody at the first sign of trouble, he can’t possibly become good at it.

“Third time through the order has a lot to do with how many times you threw the ball the first two times through the order. If you’re at 85-90 pitches, you’re probably not going to be as lively with your arm as you were at 65-70 pitches. If you struggle the first two times, you’re really going to struggle the third time. Plus, pitchers today aren’t used to going through the order a third time. We’ve seen a couple of guys … Reynaldo Lopez has fantastic numbers third time through. He’s a guy whose velocity doesn’t diminish. He’s still throwing 96-95 mph late in games. Extra velocity helps a pitcher get away with a few more mistakes than he would at 93.”

On velocity and max effort: “Earlier in his career, Justin Verlander threw 98-99 mph — but he would throw 93 when the game started. Bob Gibson did the same thing. You might be able to pull the ball against Gibson in the first inning, but he faces that same guy in the ninth inning, maybe with the game on the line, and now he’s throwing 98-99 mph. He had that in the first inning, he just didn’t want to show it. Verlander doesn’t show you his big fastball early unless he’s in trouble. He understands what pitching is all about. He keeps that 98 in his back pocket until he needs it.

“I think one reason we’ve seen (Stephen) Strasburg go through a lot of arm injuries is that he was always max effort on every pitch. Young pitchers with really good arms go through this max-effort phase. If they don’t grow out of it, they end up getting hurt. If they do grow out of it, maybe they can have a long career.

“You’ll see a lot of max effort guys flying off the mound. When you’re flying off the mound to one side or the other, you can’t field your position. Before we saw all these massive shifts, the biggest hole in the infield was back up the middle. It used to behoove pitchers to be able to field. I’ve seen fewer good-fielding pitchers as they’ve gone to the max-effort approach. I prefer the Jim Kaat, Greg Maddux types. You don’t have to win Gold Gloves all the time, but squaring off your delivery keeps you centered and allows you to make plays defensively. It also helps you have a long career, because if you’re not max effort you’re not putting extra strain on your arm.”

On splitters and keeping pitchers healthy: “I think a lot of pitchers will learn the lesson of Ohtani, who is on the shelf and looking at Tommy John surgery. It’s the splitter. A splitter is destructive. There aren’t a lot of guys who can thrive with it over the long haul. Roger Clemens threw it. Jack Morris threw it. There are a few guys in history who have thrown it well. But then you have Roger Craig, who completely decimated the San Francisco organization by teaching everybody splitters. The entire pitching staff broke down. It’s a wonderful pitch to get people out, but it takes velocity away from you and is ultimately destructive. If you want to shorten your career, throw splitters.

“We’ve had a healthy pitching staff here in Chicago. We have a very good pitching coach (Don Cooper) and the scouts place a lot of value on arm action. An exception was made with Chris Sale, and he’s held together outside of an elbow thing earlier on. For the most part the organization has been a pitching organization, and yes, we’ve had fewer guys break down than most. Some of that might be a matter of luck, but it’s also a matter of scouting.”

On Reynaldo Lopez, Carlos Rodon, and Lucas Giolito: “Reynaldo’s ceiling is to be a No. 1 starter on a very good baseball team. His stuff is that good. He’s a very young pitcher with a lot of growth in front of him, but one thing you can’t teach is a great arm. He’s also got a sense of competitiveness that you can’t teach. He does have a tendency to throw flat fastballs, because he’s kind of a short-armer, and occasionally he’ll open up too quickly in his delivery. But he’s got the fastball, a good slider, a really good changeup for a young pitcher. I think Reynaldo’s upside is unlimited.

“Reynaldo doesn’t have the best stuff on the team. That would be Carlos Rodon — when he’s completely healthy. Rodon’s slider is un-hittable. If he and Reynaldo stay healthy, we’re looking at two guys who can pitch of the top of anybody’s rotation.

“(Giolito) can be good, but he dropped three mph in his velocity. I don’t know why. He’s got a very good curveball; he doesn’t like to throw it. I don’t know why. He has a tendency to fall off the mound and yank the ball three feet wide of the plate. I don’t know why. I’m not his pitching coach; I don’t have to know why.”

On strikeouts and sinkers: “Are strikeouts overrated? Tell Nolan Ryan that. Tell Tom Seaver. Tell Don Sutton. If your stuff is good, you’re going to strike out a lot of guys. If it’s not, you generally won’t. Guys who don’t have big fastballs or hard breaking balls … they call that ‘pitching to contact,’ which is a pseudonym for ‘your stuff is marginal, so you better hit your spots.’ There are also sinkerballers. Very few sinkerballers strike out a lot of guys. They live and die with ground balls.

“Is the sinker dying? Maybe, but in baseball everything dies and then it comes back. It’s back to the future. Dylan Covey throws two-seamers that sink and run, and I don’t think he’s going to abandon that any time soon. If a two-seamer is good enough, there’s no reason to go away from it.

“There is an infatuation with four-seam fastballs that stay up in the zone, and this year umpires are calling a higher strike, bringing that pitch back into play. Eventually, what’s going to happen is everybody will throw that same pitch, hitters will adjust to it, and somebody will come along and teach the true sinker — teach it well — and pitchers will throw that again.”

On openers and fifth starters: “Is pitching the same animal it’s always been? To some people it is — to some coaches it is — but more times than not, it’s not. You have organizations like Tampa Bay using a reliever to start the game. Many times it’s the closer, so who is going to close? You need a closer at the end of the game. If starting pitches could close, they probably wouldn’t be starting pitchers — they’d be closers. Let’s see how this experiment goes. I don’t think it’s going to work out very well in the long run.

“The six-man rotation, to me, seems stupid. I believe that some forward-thinking organization is eventually going to go back to a four-man. They haven’t used that since the Mets came up with the five-man in ’69. I think you should.

“I did a breakdown of pitching from 2001-2005, and No. 5 starters had 6.4 wins per season. They had 8.6 losses. Why have a five? If you’re only going to have guys go into the sixth inning, and that’s it, why not go with four starters? Then put another quality reliever in your bullpen. That’s where the game is going anyway. It’s a bullpen game, so why not have one more pen-man and one less starter?

“Of course, what it ultimately comes down to is that you need good pitchers. If you don’t have good pitchers, they’re going to get blown out regardless of what they do. You could have somebody stand on his head and throw nickels over his shoulder, and he’s still going to get hit. You need to have good pitchers who know how to pitch.”





David Laurila grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula and now writes about baseball from his home in Cambridge, Mass. He authored the Prospectus Q&A series at Baseball Prospectus from December 2006-May 2011 before being claimed off waivers by FanGraphs. He can be followed on Twitter @DavidLaurilaQA.

42 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

I’m really curious about the splitter/injury thing. How do we evaluate that? The problem is that if players are getting injured, they’re not throwing anything, so the correlation has to be some sort of lagged variable.

My gut instinct is that the problem isn’t the splitter, it’s the throwing. I’ve now heard that there are problems with injuries with splitters, cutters, fastballs, and curveballs. My gut instinct is that it’s probably just a problem with how many pitches you throw, but again, that’s messy because pitchers who are less likely to get injured are also likely to throw more.

GoNYGoNYGoGo
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Grab a baseball and hold it with a 2-seam grip. Now, spread your fingers wider and you should feel the muscles and tendon in your arm stretch. That strain per pitch is what he is talking about.

rhswanzey
7 years ago
Reply to  sadtrombone

Pitching is a physically unnatural thing to do. Maybe there are biophysicists out there who can isolate muscle/tendon torque and exertion and how usage varies between pitches. But no two pitcher bodies/people are identical, and the same pitch can vary greatly from pitcher to pitcher, just as deliveries can. It seems like something that could become a very data noisy project if you tried to make this an objective science and oversimplify what’s going on when pitchers throw.

https://ericcressey.com/healthy-shoulders-with-terrible-mris

“Miniaci et al. found that 79% of asymptomatic professional pitchers (28/40) had “abnormal labrum” features and noted that “magnetic resonance imaging of the shoulder in asymptomatic high performance throwing athletes reveals abnormalities that may encompass a spectrum of ‘nonclinical’ findings.”

https://deadspin.com/mlb-wants-pitching-prospects-to-submit-to-voluntary-mri-1789839555

Shalesh
7 years ago

Gaylord Perry asking for $3k in the early 70’s to teach Stone his spitter is hilarious. I guess that would be like RA Dickey charging $200k today to teach a rookie his knuckleball.

Interesting how K/9 – BB/9 has tripled from 1.7 (4.8-3.1) in 1980 when Stone won his CYA (even though Mike Norris crushed him in WAR) to 5.3 (8.5 -3.2) in 2018, but the BoSox scored 876 runs this year while the league-leading Tigers scored only 830 in 1980. Guess the emphasis on three-true-outcomes (OBP/walks, Launch Angle) has overwhelmed the improvement in pitching since 1980. It also seems to make “max effort” mandatory for all but the very best pitchers in the game, whose non-max-effort baseline is better than most pitchers’ max effort.

Stone makes a great point about Pitcher defense. Mark Buerhle’s value derived a lot from his defense and historically-great ability to hold/pickoff runners.

John Autin
7 years ago
Reply to  Shalesh

While I don’t dispute your general point about three true outcomes, comparing the league-high Runs figures for those two seasons is meaningless in general, and is downright misleading in this instance. AL scoring was about the same in 1980 (4.51 R/G) and 2018 (4.53); it just happened that 1980 was a year with a very small standard deviation among the good offenses.

By your logic, we might draw a quite different conclusion using a comparison of the 2018 BoSox with the 2000 ChiSox — the latter scored 102 more runs, with almost 300 fewer strikeouts and a a much lower TTO%.

Also, only 4 AL parks of 1980 are still in use, so the raw numbers can’t be fully trusted. Today’s Yankee Stadium is a lot different than the old one.

Chris KMember since 2020
7 years ago

Stone Pony is frustrating. The guy clearly knows pitching, but his views on how pitchers can be used could pejoratively be called antiquated and runs counter to much of what I think we’ve learned about baseball in recent years. I’m not sure why he thinks any starter would be a closer if they could be, save for Chapman. Generally you don’t help your team by throwing 1/3 as many innings, unless your stuff plays up that well in fewer innings.

Still, though, with Benetti around to check some of his “old school” (is that not pejorative?) ways of thinking, the difference in that broadcast booth is night and day, compared to when Hawk would tell a dumb anecdote that left Stone out of the conversation, before three awkward innings of near silence on the back end of the game. Sox went from one of the worst broadcasts in baseball (thankfully the Braves have always been around) to one of the best. Stone factored into the former by failing to challenge Hawk, but I think that Benetti playing up Stone’s encyclopedic knowledge of how pitching works makes for the latter. He’s become a pleasure to listen to.

Jon SealsMember since 2018
7 years ago
Reply to  Chris K

Yeah, I didn’t really understand the closer comment. Every pitcher I’ve ever known or read about wants to be a starter until they can’t.

I was surprised with some of the other seemingly knowledgeable comments. (I don’t know anything about pitching.) I think a lot of these television announcers and producers are hung up on preaching to the dumbest fans.

Jetsy Extrano
7 years ago
Reply to  Chris K

He’s right that starters aren’t being asked to go deep. But does that win more games, or less? That’s not a thing you can just gut through to an answer. He’s got an aesthetic preference (which I can understand) and he’s rolling with that.

PemtlcMember since 2018
7 years ago
Reply to  Chris K

I don’t know about his Sox years, but when he did color for the Cubs, Stone was great. In critical spots, he’d predict what pitch was coming next, where in the zone he was going to throw it, and which defender was going to field the resulting ball-in-play. I’ve heard other commentators do similar from time to time, but there is something about Stone’s tone that makes it more impressive and clinical.

BravoBravo
7 years ago
Reply to  Pemtlc

I vividly remember a Cubs game in the early 90s when Greg Maddux was pitching; in the middle of the at-bat, Steve Stone predicted where the next pitch would be thrown, and he predicted that it would result in an infield popup to the shortstop. That is exactly what happened. It was like sorcery.

rhswanzey
7 years ago

Did Stone’s career end due to injury? His CYA in 1980 was on the back of 37 starts across 250 innings. I was reminded of Laurila’s Bryan Price piece from a couple years back – https://blogs.fangraphs.com/bryan-price-on-developing-but-not-babying-pitchers/ – and I wonder if Stone is a pitcher who would have been able to remain in the league another five years had his workload been managed differently. I think there’s more than nothing to the idea that we’re trying to max a pitcher’s per-inning rates, and possibly at the expense of turning a thrower into a pitcher, etc. Even the comments about pitcher fielding play into that for me.

GoNYGoNYGoGo
7 years ago
Reply to  rhswanzey

Red, yes it did. He had severe shoulder tendinitis, which back then required extensive surgery. He decided to retire as he could barely lift his arm above his head to comb his hair.

mikecws91Member since 2022
7 years ago
Reply to  rhswanzey

He got that Cy Young by selling out and throwing nothing but curveballs for a year. It was his best pitch, but it ultimately wrecked him.

Asmo
7 years ago
Reply to  rhswanzey

I remember him telling a story on air about 20 years ago about how his pitching coach told him he could either keep doing what he was doing and probably end up hurt or make a change that might make him worse but extend his career. He chose to keep going. I can’t remember specifically what the recommended change was, but I think it was to stop throwing his slider as he was feeling pain every time he threw it.

LMOTFOTEMember since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  Asmo

Yes I remember that too– I believe it was to throw more curveballs. He did a Rich Hill before it was a thing.

The Duke
7 years ago
Reply to  Asmo

I remember that. It was heavy reliance on breaking pitches( I think a curveball). He had a good one which led to that big season but he was throwing it 70-80% of the time . Eventually you can’t do that anymore

nprobertsMember since 2021
7 years ago

So we just ignore that he says Reynaldo lopez is fantastic the 3rd time through when is K% drops and xFIP rises each time through the lineup? 20.1 to 17.2 from first time to 3rd time on k rate, xFIP 4.84 to 5.57 first to 3rd. Wouldnt hurt to at least point out when commentators just say things clearly out of line with the facts. This is a stat driven site

MikeSMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  nproberts

His wOBA and OPS against are actually much lower the third time through, so superficially it looks like Stone is correct. But this is probably driven by an (unsustainable) .182 BABIP.

vslykeMember since 2020
7 years ago

I’d hate to be a player and hear my team’s broadcaster say what Stone said about Giolito. Harsh.

Chili Davis Eyes
7 years ago
Reply to  vslyke

If I recall correctly, Dusty Baker’s displeasure with Stone’s “constructive criticism” was a factor in Stone leaving the Cubs’ booth back in 2004.

Eminor3rdMember since 2019
7 years ago
Reply to  vslyke

As a Sox fan, I love it. I’d much rather have a real take than a PR line. It actually gives you something to look for when you watch. Like anyone, Stone is wrong about a TON of stuff — but he’s right about a lot too, and regardless of how correct he is in a given instance, his thoughts are based on careful, actual observation, and provide context to the broadcast that I think enhances the experience.

The Duke
7 years ago
Reply to  vslyke

Sometimes players need to hear that from a 3rd party. I bet in 90% of the cases the coach had asked him to light up a player to get him to listen.

GoNYGoNYGoGo
7 years ago

I remember his 1980 season. Loved this interview. Thank you for posting it here.

khaaan
7 years ago

Fantastic interview.

BryzMember since 2019
7 years ago

I’m a little bothered by the “closers are now opening, so who’s going to close?” argument. Yes, the Rays used Sergio Romo as an opener in between closing stints, but they also had a ton of flamethrowers in their ‘pen that stepped in. Additionally, Ryne Stanek, Diego Castillo, Hunter Wood, et. al racked up multiple opener assignments and none earned a single save this past year. While the idea is enticing, I don’t think anyone is going to send out the Chapmans and Kimbrels to pitch the first inning anytime soon.

I found Stone’s comments on the 5th starter to be spot on, but I doubt any team will return to a 4-man rotation. I think it’s far more likely that the 5th spot becomes a designated bullpen day or opener/primary pitcher.

(I’m mostly complaining, but overall I still enjoyed reading the interview.)

LHPSU
7 years ago
Reply to  Bryz

I don’t know – what’s the difference between making 30 starts a year with the expectation to go 6 innings, and making 35 starts a year with the expectation to go 5? Would pitchers be more or less prone to injury and fatigue without a bullpen day between starts? Hard to say how much we take for granted as common sense or best practice are actually founded upon empirical evidence.

BryzMember since 2019
7 years ago
Reply to  LHPSU

I wonder if having a 4-man rotation make 35 starts apiece with 5 innings per start would put too much strain on the bullpen.

Mike
7 years ago

Stone and Benetti are fantastic together. Its a nice combo of the old school baseball experience mixed with a statcast nerd. They argue like two generations in the same family. I’m terrified Benetti is going to get poached by ESPN or something.

He’s spot on with the White Sox pitching staff from what I saw last year. Should have asked him about Kopech as well.

deltaclownMember since 2023
7 years ago
Reply to  Mike

Benetti worked for ESPN when the Sox hired him and still calls college football for them full time; I think he saw the White Sox job as an upgrade, so I don’t think there’s much poaching to be done.

MikeSMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Mike

It’s fun when he says things like “If you throw him a slider down and in here, he’ll probably foul it off his foot,” and then it happens.

Kevbot034
7 years ago

So 5 man rotations are alright, 6 man is stupid, 4 man is smart? But opening is stupid, and yet a 4 man with an extra reliever isn’t? I’m confused.

Alex
7 years ago
Reply to  Kevbot034

Every time I hear Stone call a game I leave with that same impression. He doesn’t really connect his arguments he just likes to argue

BipMember since 2016
7 years ago

If starting pitches could close, they probably wouldn’t be starting pitchers — they’d be closers.

I’d be curious to what extent he actually believes that. Was he a closer but for the fact he couldn’t close?

david k
7 years ago

BTW, Stone did NOT deserve the Cy Young award he got. Mike Norris had MUCH better stats that year, Stone just benefitted from old school “wow, he has 25 wins!” which was pretty much the only stat he surpassed Norris in that year.

LMOTFOTEMember since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  david k

You might be right but it was 1980– we were all looking at wins then unless you were Bill James. It wasn’t “old school” in 1980. No way Mike Norris goes all Old Hoss Radbourn either– I think OAK’s bullpen pitched maybe 10 innings in Norris starts for the whole year. I’m glad I got to see me some old time baseball once upon a time.

david k
7 years ago
Reply to  LMOTFOTE

I guess we weren’t ALL looking at wins. I was a 15-year-old kid back then and I knew that wins was a horrible way to judge a pitcher. I guess I figured that out real fast playing Strat-O-Matic baseball, when I go tan understanding of what stats really mattered. I basically came up with something similar to OPS by looking at a player card and giving point values to each entry based on probability of rolling that number, weighted for single/walk, double, triple, and homerun. Then I drafted my teams based on that. I guess I was Bill James before anyone knew who he was.

wcarlson49
7 years ago
Reply to  david k

Britt Burns WAR was 7.0. Norris’ was 5.9.

Alex
7 years ago
Reply to  wcarlson49

So do we base the award on one single number now?

The Duke
7 years ago

Steve stone is fun. You could post an interview with him every month and I wouldn’t mind. Make it like billy Joel playing the garden.

mrknutson
7 years ago

Can’t say I’m a statistical nut like some of you but a lot of what he says about pitching is correct and was overlooked in the comments. Know your strengths, pitch to that first, and hit your spots. Don’t show them everything in the first AB. Throw your curveball three different speeds and when your behind take some velo off. You’ll get outs and lots of them with fewer pitches. Worked for Greg Maddux in the juice area.

When there’s no fix to blowing up arms people will migrate back to pitching at 90% and lasting versus max effort and Tommy John. Nothing is working for arm injuries.

Thizzle13
7 years ago
Reply to  mrknutson

Even though I hope your theory will eventually become true, I think it will never happen. There are a lot of pitchers in the minor leagues who at max effort will be better than a starting pitcher 3rd time through order at 90%. Ofcourse there will be a few exceptions, but that is probably only limited to the aces.

shaq_diesel
7 years ago

My dyslexia caused me to believe I was going to read Stone Cold Steve Austin’s pitching philosophy. Extremely disappointed.