Stick It in Your Ear: How Rebellion Makes Baseball Occasionally Cool
Cheating, if you haven’t heard, is extremely cool. To look at the rules as listed, tilt your sunglasses down and, while loudly chewing gum, announce that nah, the rules are not for you, is the absolute peak of baditude. Why do you think teams have been doing it for generations? To weaken the integrity of the game and remind people that it’s nothing but a useless novelty and none of it really matters? Of course not. They’ve done it because rules are just the box society wants to keep us in. Our job as cool people is to continuously break out of it.
So it makes sense that Astros fans are leaning into their new persona as people desperate to be victims of an unclear injustice, “turning heel” to the rest of the league, as if they had at any point throughout this cheating scandal been considered heroes.
Is it “cool” to break the sport and get fans across baseball to wonder why they even bother watching? I mean, sort of. It’s at least been a more talkative offseason for baseball, with more going on than simply waiting for top free agents to sign somewhere. The violent spasms going on as baseball fights with a modern version of itself are unbecoming, but they are certainly more interesting than waiting out the late winter hellscape with a list of top ten spring training hairdos.
It’s an interesting exercise to look back through baseball and determine what has been “cool” through the years. You’re reading FanGraphs, so obviously you live at the intersection of “baseball” and “coolness.” But there was a time when coolness in this sport wasn’t defined by colorful charts or $30 t-shirts that warn people the wearer is despised among their peers. In fact, it was this day 20 years ago when we were reminded that baseball’s coolest players were identified by the bejeweling of their ear lobes.
In February of 2000, Ken Griffey Jr. wanted to come home, and he took a huge pay cut to get there. Traded to Cincinnati from Seattle after becoming the best player in the league, he signed a nine-year extension with the Reds worth $116.5 million to play in his hometown. A good $57.5 million of that total was deferred with interest; he is still getting paid for it and will be through 2025. The deal was such an act of charity by Griffey that Bud Selig was practically crying when he heard about it, repeatedly saying “Thank you!” according to Sports Illustrated.
But there were still some kinks to work out. For instance, the Reds had held fast to a rule for anyone on their roster: No facial hair, and no earrings. These were signs of unkempt rebellion, and no true ball player could display them without starting a small riot.
Griffey famously wore a diamond stud in his left ear at a time when doing so caused arm-flailing speculation and deep self-reflection on the part of older fans. A Baltimore Sun columnist who had commented in 1994 that Griffey’s earring was “the size of the Sears Tower” wrote that “I don’t stick pins in any parts of my body any more than I voluntarily drop blocks of cement on my head or read books written by Tom Clancy.”
That same year, Reds owner Marge Schott was famously less verbose on the topic when she said that “Only fruits wear earrings.” Claiming that the comment had been “misconstrued,” which seems difficult to believe seeing as it’s only four words long, she was grateful that her team appeared to stand behind her during the brief fallout of her remark.
According to the Chicago Tribune:
“I’m very proud of what the team members said. They know where I’m coming from,” [Schott] said, noting that some Reds agreed that players with earrings aren’t good role models.
Schott’s head full of racist steam is well known (interesting fact from this SI feature on her; did you know that Schott had five family members who fought for Germany in World War II?), but there was a presiding societal concern appearing in weekly columns and snarky remarks that a small piece of jewelry, when worn by a man, would lead to the collapse of the natural order.
It would appear then that the Reds had a problem on their hands, as the greatest player of a generation, and apparently a poor role model for Cincinnati-area children, Ken Griffey Jr., was headed straight for the Queen City with a twinkle in his ear.
There’d been a similar wrinkle in 1999, the year prior. The Reds had swung a trade for Padres slugger Greg Vaughn, startling the 33-year-old not just because of his sudden relocation to a small market, but because the Reds, a team whose mascot is famously mustachioed, had a long-standing ban on facial hair. Pete Rose had once asked A’s hurler Rollie Fingers if he wanted to come play for Cincinnati, and Fingers told him no.
“I wasn’t going to shave my mustache to play for the Reds,” Fingers said years later.
The Vaughn trade had gone down in the late nineties, remember – a time that repeatedly taught us that when a man made a promise to his goatee, he kept it, no matter how many times his employer waved a razor at him. Though he said he would ignore the policy, or even file a grievance against the team, Vaughn still called Reds shortstop Barry Larkin for reassurance.
“I told him to go to the boss on that one,” Larkin told reporters. (Tampa Bay Times, April 3, 1999)
So Vaughn did. And two weeks after the trade, the 32-year-old rule was wiped from the books. But the ban on earrings had remained. Until now, obviously.
Reds GM Jim Bowden and COO John Allen had, according to Bowden, determined earlier in the offseason that the ban on earrings, which allowed players to wear them in the locker room but not on the field, was “archaic.” Just like the facial hair ban, which had been destroyed by Vaughn the year before, it was “outdated,” Bowden said to the Cincinnati Enquirer, “as long as it’s a stud and doesn’t go below the earlobe.”
What a happy coincidence, it seemed, that the exact kind of earring Griffey wore was the exact kind of earring the Reds would now allow! Truly it was joyous news for the state of Ohio as it welcomed back its wayward son.
Griffey the player was elite, but Griffey the fashion icon changed everything. From the moment he touched the warehouse at Camden Yards with a home run derby shot while wearing his hat backwards, he made the front of his baseball card as impactful as the back. That little diamond stud that gave columnists night terrors helped close a meaningless chapter in Reds history and usher in a new era for both the Reds franchise and coolness.
And so once more, coolness caught up to baseball, shook things up, and went away for a while. These days it’s back in the form of embracing the hate you receive for rampant cheating at the game’s highest level. How will baseball get even cooler in the days ahead? We’ll just have to wait and see what rule they break next.
Justin has contributed to FanGraphs and is a contributor to Baseball Prospectus. He is known in his family for jamming free hot dogs in his pockets during an off-season tour of Veterans Stadium and eating them on the car ride home.


I was recently rewatching the Ken Burns series & a bunch of the interviewees are making the point that in baseball, some of the fun is that breaking the rules is part of the game as long as you avoid detection (even mentioning an 1800s guy that would occasionally skip 2nd base when the ump wasn’t looking – oh 1800s, never change).
I was watching that & wondering how different this opinion would be after steroids & sign stealing. I wonder if that aspect of baseball has changed or if there were always lines to be crossed…
I think the response from players around the league is a pretty clear sign that attitudes have changed. Even in 1899, when the Phillies were using binoculars and a buzzer system to transmit signs to batters, there was a stir. At that time there wasn’t a commissioner to do anything about it (and gambling was a bigger threat to the integrity of the game, anyway).
The Phillies came up with some laughably transparent bunch of baloney to try and explain why there was a transmitter in the ground by the third-base coach and the third-base coach had a buzzer strapped to his leg, and nothing happened to them. It was a completely different time. Today, we have a commissioner who came down very hard on the Astros, punished the players, and stripped the team of its ill-gotten title. The Astros were completely honest and candid about their sign-stealing and its impact on the game. Oh, wait. Maybe things haven’t changed that much.
“So it makes sense that Astros fans are leaning into their new persona as people desperate to be victims of an unclear injustice, “turning heel” to the rest of the league, as if they had at any point throughout this cheating scandal been considered heroes.”
It has to be tough being in an Astros fan’s position (and yes, I realize they just won a WS recently). It would bug the hell out of me if the Tigers won a WS and got caught in this cheating issue…I want my teams to win with integrity (knowing everyone tries to bend the rules as much as possible to gain an edge…the trash can and buzzer things just went too far).
If you’re an Astros fan and you still support the team and use this recent issue as a means to feel the world is against you, hey….you go right ahead. I get it. It’s your team, you’re still going to root for them regardless. It wasn’t your fault this happened, so I don’t look down at you. I’m still going to root against you (heaven help me if/when the Yanks face you in the ALCS and I’ll actually be on their side for once), but it’s nothing personal.
Stick it in your ear?
Did you do it all for the Mookie?
Yet again, Fangraphs climbs on their moral soapbox to shoehorn social oppression into their baseball analysis.
Former Reds owner doesn’t want Griffey to wear an earring – yeah that team policy is pretty lame, good for KGJ that he still donned the stud in Cincinnati.
Former Reds owner who doesn’t want Griffey to wear an earring IS THEREFORE A RACIST INDIVIDUAL AND IT WILL BE REPORTED AS SUCH – Wtf? Too quick a trigger to shout racist.
And the line about Schott’s ancestors fighting for Germany in WWII? Unnecessary and irrelevant information; lazy and pseudomoralistic journalism. Also, *Jordan Peterson voice* what *exactly* makes you so certain that if you were placed in 1940s Germany and encouraged to be an Auschwitz campguard that you wouldn’t succumb to it? Something to think about.
A left (or right) leaning publication is fine, however when it reaches an extreme it can be dangerous. Fangraphs is approaching this extreme.
First of all, if you think of Fangraphs as an “extreme” publication, well, then, lucky you I guess, because you clearly haven’t been subjected to the actual extremes of the internet. More to the point, it is well established that Marge Schott was racist; in fact it’s what caused her to sell the team, following a long ban from MLB for her repeated racist comments, including some in support of Hitler. In this context, the stuff included above is definitely fair game.
My comment was “approaching extreme.”
I’m also speaking strictly in the context of accredited journalism, as opposed to, as you say, the actual extremes of the internet.
Amongst publications, and not these actual extremes of the internet, I think Fangraphs has demonstrated sufficient evidence to be labeled as firmly left-leaning.
I can’t tell if you’re a troll or just a right-wing #$*!nugget. Either way, it’s time to go.
I’m fine where I’m at
Yet you said leaning was fine, so long as it wasn’t extreme. Which is it? You’re trying to thread a small needle if leaning is fine, extremes are not, and of course you mean only extremes relative to serious journalism, not propaganda, and of course Fangraphs in only “approaching” such an extreme…. All of that clarifies absolutely nothing.
Regardless, none of that is really the important point. The article did not conclude she was racist on the basis of one incident about jewelry. The article mentioned in passing her well known racism, linked to an article that went int greater detail, and then cited the earring as one example in a much larger tapestry. Again, where exactly is the problem?
Right I would say a left/right bias, in any context I suppose, is fine – extremes can be sketchy. I’m unsure how that was miscommunicated? Or how there’s an issue with that?
Wow, friend. You should Google Marge Schott.
This clearly isn’t baseball “analysis”. It’s more commentary on baseball culture than anything else. And Marge Schott wasn’t a racist because of the Reds’ policy about earrings. She was a racist because of the countless racist things she said publicly over the years. She was a racist because everyone that ever knew her thought she was a racist. Take your “fake news” word vomit somewhere else.
what
sure, fangraphs absolutely has/has had some writers who obviously lean a certain way politically and have, at times, let those opinions shine through on their takes on stuff. and thats fine! for the most part, they are well thought out and well articulated. which, even in the cases that i dont 100% agree, i can respect and find quite refreshing given the current state our beloved country is in when it comes to that stuff. but to even try to act like fangraphs is even remotely of the same ilk as the truly awful deadspin and barstool is wild. and uh, yea, you should probably learn about who marge schott is and the absolutely bonkers beliefs she had about things
I like how this comment was written and looked up Marge Schott… yep doesn’t seem like she had the best morals. I prematurely submitted my reaction to the article with ignorance on my end. Apologies to the author.
I still feel comfortable saying that Fangraphs is quite liberal, and maintain that they’re at risk of alienating readership *if* it reaches an extreme bias. This particular article doesn’t get placed in the heavily-leftist bin.
Please stop policing how the people who write for this site choose to do so.
I do agree that the earring ban doesn’t make Marge Schott racist (although it is a pretty effective dog whistle). Her calling Eric Davis and Dave Parker her million dollar n—-s does though.
https://www.nytimes.com/1992/11/29/sports/baseball-marge-schott-baseball-s-big-red-headache.html
Sorry to post something from such a failing and extreme publication.
Man I need a cup of coffee after reading a FanGraphs article that boarders on such an extreme. Putting kids in cages, grabbing women, calling for retribution against journalists: all that’s well and good. Writing about earrings… that’s approaching dangerous.
Also if you are keeping score: kneeling during the national anthem means you hate our troops. Fighting for Hitler in WWII means you deserve empathy and compassion.
Nobody expressed either of those opinions.
ZMP-Thanks for the reasonable response and for doing more research . I truly think that’s admirable. I’ll try to be as open minded as you the next time I’m challenged by people on the net.
Take care – from the other side of the aisle 🙂
But Marge Schott was a racist. Why do you not want an article about her to point this out?
I couldn’t remember if Marge Schott had died. She died in 2004. Good.
“Is it “cool” to break the sport and get fans across baseball to wonder why they even bother watching?”
This is excessive. If any fan is thinking this because of a little trash can banging, they are taking this way too much to heart. Even Fangraphs’ own research shows that the benefit the Astros got out of this, while ill-gotten, was certainly not determinitive enough of outcomes to make a rational fan wonder ‘why bother watching?’
Let’s take this scandal for what it is: MLB is cashing in on keeping itself in the news, and the ‘heel turn’ by Houston is going to be a hugely profitable one for the league in the same way the NFL has been able to milk the Patriots’ similar evolution. Sour grapes competitors are cashing in on muddying the waters on their own poor performances (looking at you Aroldis). Media is cashing in on having what is effectively a dead horse to beat during the offseason (this article even almost acknowledges as much). But what is this scandal, really? Couple teams did something against the rules, it gave them an occasionally marginal competitive edge, and they got caught and punished for it. Move on, in my book.
p.s. not an Astros fan, before that comes up.
oh, this is the good stuff