Sunday Notes: For Cubs Southpaw Jordan Wicks, (The) Change Is Good
Jordan Wicks is one of the most promising young pitchers in the Chicago Cubs organization. Drafted 21st overall in 2021 by the North Side club out of Kansas State University, the 24-year-old southpaw is coming off of a season that saw him win four of five decisions and log a 4.41 ERA over his first seven big league starts. Moreover, his minor-league ledger included a 7-0 record and a 3.55 ERA between Double-A Tennessee and Triple-A Iowa. Assigned a 50 FV by our own Eric Longenhagen, Wicks is projected to slot comfortably into new Chicago manager Craig Counsell’s rotation in the coming campaign.
The big lefty — he’s listed at 6-foot-3, 220-pounds — has a diverse arsenal, but one offering stands out above the rest. His changeup, which he began throwing as a Little Leaguer in Conway, Arkansas, is not only the best in the system, it could prove to be one of the best in the National League. As he explained at the tail end of last season, the pitch is his “bread-and-butter, and it has been for awhile.”
Asked for more history on his go-to, Wicks told me that it was his “premium off-speed” growing up, and that he “didn’t really throw a curveball or a slider when [he] was younger.” His repertoire now includes both, as well as a cutter and both two- and four-seam fastballs. Pitchability is another of his assets, and he gets high marks for his competitiveness, but again, it’s the diving circle that earned him his first-round pedigree and has him poised to contribute to a big-league rotation.
“For him it’s always been about the changeup, and it will probably continue to be the changeup,” said a scout who has watched Wicks in recent years. “He showed flashes of his other pitches in college, but he didn’t really need to use much more than his fastball and his changeup. It’s a good combination. While he’s made some tweaks to his repertoire — he’s not just a two-pitch guy — even if a hitter is sitting on it, he can double or triple up on it because it’s a pretty difficult pitch to hit. There have been pitchers who are successful with just a good fastball they can locate and a double-plus changeup.”
Wicks grips and delivers his signature pitch in fairly standard fashion. He described it as a small circle, one in which he hooks a seam with his thumb, his thumb pulling down when he releases the ball. He doesn’t consciously pronate. Having thrown the pitch for as long as he has, that’s “just natural at this point.”
His most-frequently-thrown pitch (29.7% in his seven outings) is most effective when it’s getting more depth and less side-to-side. Wicks feels that it is easier for hitters to pick it up when it runs more than usual, hence his efforts to stay on top of the ball and primarily get downward action. That said, he doesn’t view movement as its most important attribute. Nor does he consider optimal velocity separation from his heater to be paramount to its success.
“I think it’s primarily the ability to sequence it,” opined Wicks. “The changeup is a pitch where you can’t really quantify what makes it good. It has to be how you use it. It has to be the arm-speed. It has to be the command of it. Arm-speed is probably the biggest thing, but you can’t just sit at a computer and tell who has a good changeup and who doesn’t.”
Jordan Wicks has a good changeup.Just ask the hitters.
———
RANDOM HITTER-PITCHER MATCHUPS
Jose Altuve went 17 for 34 against Félix Hernández.
Felix Fermin went 10 for 12 against Mark Guthrie.
Felix Pie went 9 for 14 against Gavin Floyd.
Felix Millan went 6 for 7 against Sammy Ellis.
Junior Felix went 5 for 9 against Hipolito Pichardo.
———
Jon Matlack did a live interview over Zoom for SABR’s Oral History Committee earlier this week, and the entertaining exchange included his memories of a hit he surrendered on September 30, 1972. It was the last of Roberto Clemente’s career, and one whose circumstances caught the then-22-year-old southpaw by surprise.
“I was a wet-behind-the-ears rookie that did not know that the famous Clemente needed one more for 3,000,” admitted Matlack, who was with the New York Mets. “I was having a tough day. I walked too many guys. I’m getting beat [and] was just trying to get another out… I tried a backdoor curveball, and when it [leaves] my hand I know it’s not going to be a strike; I’m mad at myself because of how it came out. Somehow he rifles it one hop off the left-centerfield wall for a double. They present him with the ball at second base and I’m going, ‘Wait a minute, we’ve got a ballgame here to play. Why are you giving him the ball?’ Then I see the 3,000 flashing on the scoreboard. It dawned on me that I was going to be in the history books.”
The now-74-year-old West Chester, Pennsylvania native is in the history books for more than just a pitch thrown to a Hall of Famer. Matlack won NL Rookie of the Year with the Mets, and four years later he made three starts for them in the World Series (he was the losing pitcher in Game 7, which saw the Oakland Athletics capture the second of their three consecutive titles). A three-time All-Star who also played for the Texas Rangers, Matlack finished his career with 125 wins and a 114 ERA+.
The video will be archived at SABR.org in the near future.
———
A quiz:
Who has the highest batting average in Texas Rangers franchise history (minimum 2,000 plate appearances)?
The answer can be found below.
———
NEWS NOTES
SABR announced this week that the list of speakers for this summer’s national convention, which will be held in Minneapolis from August 7-11, will include Bert Blyleven, Rod Carew, Jim Kaat, and Tony Oliva. More information can be found here.
SABR also announced a new panel for next month’s analytics conference, which will be held in Phoenix from March 8-10. Moderated by Mark Simon, it will comprise Vince Gennaro, Brian Kenny, Eno Sarris, Bobby Scales, our own Meg Rowley. More information can be found here.
The Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame has inducted former Toronto Blue Jays Jimmy Key and Russell Martin, as well as Howard Birnie, Paul Godfrey, Rod Heisler, and Ashley Stephenson. The induction ceremony will be held on June 15 in St. Marys, Ontario.
Al McBean, a native of the Virgin Islands who pitched primarily for the Pittsburgh Pirates in a career that spanned the 1961-1970 seasons, died on January 31 at age 85. The right-hander went 15-10 as a starter in 1962, then switched to the bullpen and went 27-12 with 51 saves and a 2.29 ERA over the next three campaigns.
John Pregenzer, who made 19 pitching appearances for the San Francisco Giants in 1963-1964, also died on January 31, at age 91. The Burlington, Wisconsin native was on the winning end of both of his career decisions, each coming against the Pirates in games where Al McBean also took the mound.
Yet another former big-leaguer to pass away recently is Brant Alyea, who played for four teams from 1965-1972. Born Garrabrant Ryerson Alyea, in Passaic, New Jersey, the right-handed-hitting outfielder homered for the Washington Senators in his first big-league appearance, then went on to have his best season with the Minnesota Twins, logging a 144 wRC+ and 16 dingers in 1970. Alyea was 83 when he died on February 4.
——-
The answer to the quiz is Al Oliver, who batted .319 with the Rangers from 1978-1981. Will Clark is second, having hit .307 with Texas from 1994-1998.
———
Corey Kluber announced his retirement on Friday after a 13-year, injury-marred career that included three All-Star nods, two Cy Young Awards, and a no-hitter. Those are impressive accomplishments, and they bring to mind those of a contemporary who threw his last pitch in 2016. Tim Lincecum had a 10-year, injury-marred career that included four All-Star nods, two Cy Young Awards, and two no-hitters.
Which of the right-handers was better? I asked that question in a Twitter poll shortly after the retirement news broke, and the results were intriguing. Lincecum received 57% of the 305 votes cast, while Kluber received 43%.
Did the voters get it right? Keeping in mind that “better” is somewhat subjective, here is snapshot of their numbers:
Lincecum: 270 starts, 1,682 IP, 1,736 Ks, 110-89 W-L record, 3.45 FIP. 104 ERA+.
Kluber: 260 starts, 1,641.2 IP, 1,725 Ks, 116-77 W-L record, 3.23 FIP, 122 ERA+.
Does Kluber’s clear edge in ERA hold more weight than an extra All-Star appearances and a second no-hitter? That’s a matter of opinion.
———
Sticking with Twitter polls, I ran one a few days ago asking which of four young players will go on to have the best career. There was no runaway winner, but there was a potential superstar garnering a scant amount of support. Tooled-up Cincinnati Reds shortstop Elly De La Cruz received just 8.0% of the 352 votes cast.
As for the three who polled well, NL Rookie of the Year Corbin Carroll came out on top with 37.2%, while AL Rookie of the Year Gunnar Henderson finished third with 23.3%. Sandwiched in between was Bobby Witt Jr. — he of the recently-inked $288.8M contract extension — with 31.5% of support.
Which of the talented group would get my own vote? I’d be inclined to go with Witt. Predicting the future can be a fools’s errand — health or any number of other factors can compromise a career — but the 23-year-old shortstop has a chance to one day be looked upon as one of the best players in Kansas City Royals history. I wouldn’t bet against it.
———
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
Venezuela captured this year’s Caribbean Series, beating the Dominican Republic 3-0 in Friday’s championship game, which was played in front of 36,677 fans in Miami. Ricardo Pinto, who was named series MVP, went five-and-two-thirds innings for the win, while Hernán Pérez plated a run-scoring triple. Panama won the third-place game, edging Curaçao by a count of 5-4.
Scott Radinsky will be managing in the Netherlands this summer. The former Cleveland Indians and Los Angeles Angels pitching coach will be at the helm for UVV Utrecht, which plays in the Hoofdklasse, Holland’s top league.
———
A random obscure former player snapshot:
He was anything but obscure during his playing days, but as his career dates back over century there is a pretty good chance you don’t know about Larry Doyle. A second baseman who played for the New York Giants and (briefly) the Chicago Cubs from 1907-1920, “Laughing Larry” logged a 125 wRC+ and 49.6 WAR. Moreover, he was named NL MVP in 1912 after batting .330… and that wasn’t even his best statistical season. A year earlier, Doyle batted .310 with 25 doubles, 25 triples, 13 home runs, and a 152 wRC+, then in 1915 he had a 143 wRC+ to go along with a league-leading .320 batting average. The Giants played in the World Series each year from 1911-1913, losing all three times.
———
Blake Butera and Michael King were teammates at Boston College for two seasons, and they did more than just compete together on the baseball team. They also went head-to-head on the basketball court, which often didn’t go well for the now Tampa Bay Rays farm director. King, whom the San Diego Padres acquired from the New York Yankees in December as part of the Juan Soto deal, held a distinct height advantage over the athletic-but-undersized middle infielder.
“He was two years behind me, and in the fall we would find time to play pickup basketball at our practice gym,” recalled Butera, who went on to play two professional seasons after graduating from BC. “We would go against each other every chance we got. He was pretty good. I’m also 5-foot-8, so while I always thought I had a chance to beat him… man, I used to get so mad. There were times I left the gym pretty upset with Michael, not wanting to talk to him. ”
Was it mostly as matter of being out-sized by the 6-foot-3 right-hander/hooper?
“That’s all I’m going to give him,” Butera said of his friend. “He could ball a little bit, but when it comes to talent, I think I had him beat.”
———
LINKS YOU’LL LIKE
MLB.com’s Anthony Castrovince told the tragic story of Dobie Moore, a forgotten Negro Leagues phenom who played for the Kansas City Monarchs from 1920-1926 before being shot in the leg by a neighbor.
Sports Info Solutions’s Mark Simons looked at the biggest differences between pitchers’ OPS-against and expected OPS-against.
Jason Kanzler left the Houston Astros organization to become the Director of Player Development for the Chicago Cubs. Sahadez Sharma wrote about it for The Athletic (subscription required).
Also at The Athletic, Brittany Ghiroli talked to Bianca Smith, who made history as the first Black woman coach in professional baseball but has since moved on from the Red Sox.
At The Japan Times, Mai Yoshikawa introduced us to Shiki Nakayama, a Gen Z-er in Japan who is forging a path for girls in baseball.
———
RANDOM FACTS AND STATS
Zack Greinke has logged 2,979 strikeouts and thrown 101 wild pitches. Clayton Kershaw has logged 2,944 strikeouts and thrown 101 wild pitches. Their WP totals are tied for the most among active pitchers.
In 1932, Washington Senators right-hander Alvin “General” Crowder hurled a big-league best 327 innings and threw nary a wild pitch, nor did he hit a batter or be charged with a balk. He issued 77 free passes and went 26-13 with a 3.33 ERA.
James Karinchak threw 39 innings last year and walked 28 batters. In 1904, Cy Young threw 380 innings and walked 29 batters.
Jerry Reuss, Mickey Lolich, and Rick Reuschel all logged 191 losses. Their respective win totals were 220, 217, and 214.
Félix Hernández threw 2,729-and-two-thirds innings, allowed 2,487 hits, and went 169-136 with a 117 ERA+. Hippo Vaughn threw 2,730 innings, allowed 2,461 hits, and went 178-137 with a 119 ERA+. Hernández had 25 complete games and surrendered 264 home runs. Vaughn had 214 complete games and surrendered 39 home runs.
Walker Cooper, an eight-time All-Star catcher in the 1940s, had seven multiple-home-run games. One was a three-homer game in which he went 6-for-7 with 10 RBIs. Five were two-homer games in which the second came in the eighth inning or later and was a game-winner.
The Washington Nationals signed Adam Dunn to a free-agent contract on today’s date in 2009. The Three True Outcomes legend slugged 38 home runs in each of his two seasons in the nation’s capital, drawing 193 walks and striking out 376 times along the way.
Bill Madlock and Bobby Murcer were the centerpieces of a five-player trade between the Chicago Cubs and the San Francisco Giants on today’s date in 1977. Madlock, who had just won consecutive batting titles, and would later win two more, went west. Murcer, a five-time All-Star who finished his career with a 124 wRC+, became a Cub.
Players born on today’s date include Ben Oglivie, an outfielder who logged a 116 wRC+ and made three All-Star teams in a big-league career that spanned the 1971-1986 seasons. The Colon, Panama native’s best year was 1980 when he slugged 41 home runs and put up a 147 wRC+ with the Milwaukee Brewers.
Also born on today’s date was John Paciorek, whose three hits are the most among modern era (since 1901) players who finished with a 1.000 batting average. The Hamtramck, Michigan native went 3-for-3 with two walks in his only big-league game, with the Houston Colt .45s on September 29, 1963.
David Laurila grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula and now writes about baseball from his home in Cambridge, Mass. He authored the Prospectus Q&A series at Baseball Prospectus from December 2006-May 2011 before being claimed off waivers by FanGraphs. He can be followed on Twitter @DavidLaurilaQA.
Got trivia right this time. remembered Oliver had a 4-5 year run of high BA’s in Texas when I was a kid. I thank Topps for knowing that.
Never even thought of Clark. 2nd choice was Michael Young.
I picked Julio Franco, who is third. I remembered he won a batting title with the Rangers, but I also remembered it was an inexplicably high batting average for him. I hoped it would be enough.
I completely forgot the two guys ahead of him played for the Rangers. The Rangers don’t have much in the way of star players who we associate with the team. Beltre, Ivan Rodriguez, and Michael Young are the big ones. Kenny Rogers, probably. Maybe Nolan Ryan, although he is probably more of an Astro and Angel. After that it’s…Juan Gonzalez? Ruben Sierra? Was Elvis Andrus a big enough star? The leaderboards tell me Rafael Palmeiro should count but I associate him with the Orioles and not any other team.
I had no clue on the quiz. Rangers are like a big black hole to me.
Ryan went into the Hall with a Rangers cap and his association with the team afterwards make him feel more like a Ranger.
Funny, I also had Oliver and then Michael Young
Just looked up Michael Young with the Rangers: He hit .301 in over 8K plate appearances, had 6 200-hit seasons, and led the league twice in hits and once in batting average
Both Oliver and Young belong on the All-Underrated team. Along with Vada Pinson and Chet Lemon among others…
I thought of Young first, but went with what I thought was a sneaky pick: Josh Hamilton. Knowing he had that one year with a ridiculous BA and that he didn’t play that long with them. Alas, he hit .302 (one point higher than Young) in 2996 PAs. Would have been even closer (.305) without his last cup of coffee with the Rangers after the Angels gave him away.
I participated in the live SABR Zoom with Jon Matlack and it was wonderful! Jon was personable, intelligent and seemed to enjoy himself. The SABR Zooms have given me a chance to ask questions from people like Jon, Jim Kaat, Sam McDowell, Will Clark and various MLB beat writers. I think anyone who enjoys reading this column would enjoy participating in the SABR Zooms.
Before last year’s baseball season started I participated in a SABR Zoom with David Laurila that the South Michigan chapter put on. I asked David for a Tiger sleeper and he said Tarik Skubal. I was able to pick him up for my Scoresheet Baseball teams. Thanks David!
I knew Cy Young was old but didn’t know that he pitched in the 1094 season.
They didn’t keep great records in the pre Magna Carta era.
Look I’m not a huge fan of ERA as a method of figuring out which pitcher was better. But if you’re trying to decide whether a clear edge in ERA+ is better than an extra all-star appearance then you’ve lost the plot. You shouldn’t be using all-star appearances to determine the value of anyone, at least not compared to an actual indication of how the player performed.
I went with Kluber without looking at any stats. Just a gut feeling. And seeing that he’s +10 WAR vs Lincecum on both bWAR and fWAR confirms my hunch.
When a guy compiles results in a division which was exceptionally weak, does that cloud the numbers? Is it not possible that had he been pitching say for Toronto during that era his numbers would have been a tad worse?
According to Baseball Reference, Kluber’s opponents scored 4.44 runs per game whereas Lincecum’s only scored 4.32 runs per game. Obviously Kluber pitched his whole career against the DH whereas Lincecum didn’t which is part of what accounts for those results. Bottom line: Kluber’s gave up fewer runs per game even though the offenses he faced scored more runs.
Beyond that, Kluber has 74.4% more bWAR and 39.3% more fWAR than Lincecum. JAWS ranks Kluber as the 195th best starting pitcher of all time whereas Lincenum comes in at #446. Those aren’t gaps that can be easily explained away. Those are chasms.
One more thing. Kluber’s peak was 2014-2018. In 2014 and 2015, the AL Central was essentially equivalent to the other 2 AL divisions. In 2016 and 2017, they fell behind the AL East but were essentially equivalent to the AL West. It wasn’t until 2018, the last year of Kluber’s peak that the AL Central fell far behind the other two AL divisions.
I think Kluber was better, but Lincecum’s career averages suffer because the Giants kept putting him out there hoping to recapture the magic. The last 5 years of his career, comprising 654 innings (about a third of his total), his WAR was in negative territory.
After Kluber got hurt he only pitched another 336 innings and still managed to keep post positive values in a couple of those years. This points out the major difference – Lincecum’s time as an effective pitcher was much shorter than Kluber’s, and Kluber’s peaks were just as high.
Another thing that might influence memories is that Lincecum’s best seasons were consecutive near the start of his career, so for a couple of years he got lots of publicity (anyone remember “Let Timmy Smoke”?) while Kluber’s best seasons were spread out and took place in a media backwater.
Some of that is true but Kluber’s best seasons weren’t spread out. They were from 2014-2018.
Beyond that, one of the reasons that Kluber’s teams didn’t keep throwing him out there is that he was hurt. But part of that was age-related. His decline began at age 33, an age at which Lincecum was already out of baseball.
It also helps that Lincecum was a genuine phenomenon early in his career. The dude was legit famous. That memory sticks. Whereas Kluber flew kind of under the radar, even when he was great.
Winning three rings will do that to a guy.
It’s a funny question, because Lincecum was only clearly great for four seasons. His decline was brutal, and even though he won two more titles with the 2012 and 2014 Giants, he was frankly awful for those teams and spent most of his career post-2011 pitching to negative WAR. Whereas Kluber probably had two legitimately great seasons, but five or six productive seasons overall.
If his “career averages suffer” because the Giants played him more, then there’s no real comparison to be made, Kluber was better for longer. It sounds like you’re saying you get to cherry pick what seasons we use for Lincecum but not for Kluber.
More: no-hitters and perfect games are BABIP dependent. One bad bounce or wind gust can determine the difference between a compete game shutout and a no-hitter. To say nothing of a missed ump call (we’ve seen those, no?) or an early scorer decision, especially on the road.
Note that Kluber, while pitching against AL teams with the DH notched 8 shutouts vs 7 for Lincecum against NL teams without DH.
Go with FIP. It may not eliminate all randomness but at least it tries.
Both had very good peaks but Kluber lasted longer and finished with better rate numbers. And 11 WAR isn’t chopped liver.
I typically like using fWAR and there Kluber has better career numbers, better peak (as long as the peak is 3 years or longer), and better rate stats. And according to Left of Centerfield the gap is bigger with bWAR. I don’t think this is hard.
Brant Alyea was in the set of discs from my second Cadaco All-Star Baseball game. He had a pretty good year in 1970, which is probably why he was included in the 1971 edition. According to Wikipedia, his job post-baseball was supervising craps tables at a casino in Atlantic City.
Take away Felix Pie’s 9 for 14 against Gavin Floyd and his career average falls from .246 to .240.
Fun fact; I believe that among pitchers with multiple Cy Youngs, Kluber and Lincecum have the fewest wins.
Only if you count non-active pitchers. Among all pitchers with 2 or more Cy Youngs, the two lowest are Blake Snell with 71 and Jacob DeGrom with 84.
Odds either surpasses Kluber’s 116?
Interesting question! Snell has averaged only 9 wins per year, so at that pace he would need to play 5 more years. That actually seems doable, since he is only 31 now. Not guaranteed, but doable. It doesn’t account for the fact that he’s likely to be less durable from this age on, though, so I’d say maybe 40% that he passes Kluber.
DeGrom is a much better pitcher but actually averages fewer wins per year (8.4) due to injuries and some of the weirdest lack of run support I’ve ever seen. At that pace, he would need to play 4 more years. He’s already 35, so I find that less likely. Even if he somehow started getting 14 or 15 every year, it would still take 3 years. I’d put him at more like 20%.
Imagine an alternate universe version of DeGrom who doesn’t get injured. How much would you even need to pay a guy like that?
Huh, so Jordan Wicks is from Conway? Spent the better part of a decade there, good baseball area. But mostly I think of it as the stop between Pickles Gap, Arkansas, and Toad Suck, Arkansas.
I’m legit excited for Jordan Wicks as a Cubs fan. He’s my current Top Prospect in the org, one that hangs with the field nationally with an underrated SP profile in today’s bing bow zoom zow burn and turn meta: healthy (one of the big PD wins for the 2023 Cubs was a complete season following 2022 missed time with elbow stuff), command, control, long track record of success with SP workloads (highlights including 28% Ks btw NCAA-MiLB with outstanding control, arguably the most dominant NCAA pitcher during the shortened 2020, strong GBs and batted ball), and high aptitude including adding multiple breaking balls, a cutter, plus reshaping the fastballs in the pros while reaching the MLs in his second full season. He needs more velo
to be a super mega duper ultra alpha ace in today’s league, or even to rank higher in the system this year since many fans and pubs have him in the 6-9 range for the org, but otherwise is well on track to be a long time first division arm. I hate Rebuild 2.0 and what it tells me about The Future of MLB and ‘Merica, somehow worse than it already is for workers, but the homegrown players who will stick for Cubs are going to be badass and Wicks is one
Those league-leading BAs for Larry Doyle seem extremely low for the era.
I picked Josh Hamilton.
Swing and Whiff!
Much like the aforementioned.
Kluber had the better career, but people remember Timmy from the WS teams, so it’s pretty clear there’s some bias there.