Sunday Notes: Kyle Harrison’s Repertoire is Coming Along Well
Kyle Harrison was pitching for the Double-A Richmond Flying Squirrels when he was first featured here at FanGraphs in August 2022. Then a fast-rising prospect in the San Francisco Giants system, the now-22-year-old southpaw had broken down the early evolution of his arsenal for me prior to a game at Portland, Maine’s Hadlock Field. Fast forward to this past week, and we were reacquainting at a far-more-fabled venue. Harrison was preparing to take the mound at Fenway Park for his 14th big-league start, his seventh this season.
As I’m wont to do in such scenarios, I asked the dark-horse rookie-of-the-year candidate what’s changed since our 20-months-ago conversation. Not surprisingly, he’s continued to evolve.
“I’ve added a cutter, although I haven’t thrown it as much as I’d like to,” Harrison told me. “Other than that, it’s the same pitches. The slider has been feeling great, and the changeup is something that’s really come along for me; it’s a pitch I’ve been relying on a lot. I really hadn’t thrown it that much in the minors — it felt like I didn’t really have the control for it — but then all of a sudden it clicked. Now I’ve got three weapons, plus the cutter.”
Including his Thursday effort in Boston, Harrison has thrown his new cutter — Baseball Savant categorizes it as a slider — just six times all season. Which brings us to his other breaking ball. When we’d talked in Portland, the lefty called the pitch a sweepy slider. Savant categorizes it as a slurve.
What is it?
“It’s got a two-plane break, so I think slurve is probably the best way to describe it,” Harrison replied to my question. “That’s why I added the cutter, to get more strikes. In Triple-A, I wasn’t able to land that big slurve as much on the ABS [automated ball-strike system] strike zone.”
The movement profile of his breaker differs from his Double-A days, an evolution that was more organic than by design. The bottom line is that two-plane is now the norm.
“I’m getting anywhere from negative-five to probably negative-eight vert on it,” explained Harrison. “It’s kind of getting that depth point, like a curveball, but it’s also keeping the horizontal, anywhere from eight to 16. I haven’t lost any horizontal overall, although I have lost some in a couple of starts. We’ve been talking about it, arm angle and all that. Having ways to fix it in between starts is huge for me. I need to get it more dialed in, get that consistent 13-to-16 sweep.”
His changeup also differs from the one he was throwing in the Eastern League. Harrison still holds the ball with a modified Vulcan grip, but he’s now spreading his fingers wider in order to take off more velocity. Instead of 88-90 mph, the pitch is now coming in 86-87.
“Having a little more split with the fingers allows me to kill a little more speed,” explained Harrison. “In the minors, I was throwing it too hard and not seeing the speed differential. I also wasn’t seeing enough movement differential. Now I have more of a split-finger feel, in a sense, and am able to kill more spin.”
As chance would have it, only 14% of the 95 pitches he threw in Boston were changeups, while 20% were slurves — essentially a flip-flop of his seasonal averages (28.9% changeups and 12.6% slurves). When I asked him about that following the game, he said that he didn’t feel his changeup was as good as usual, in part because the Fenway Park mound felt “a little flatter, per se.” Conversely, he felt that his slurve and fastball were playing well.
Harrison’s heater — the one pitch in his repertoire that has remained unchanged — was indeed good in his five-inning, one-run-allowed effort. Only five of his fastballs were put into play, while 10 elicited a whiff, 11 went for a called strike, and 13 were fouled off. Movement and deception are keys to the 93-mph offering’s effectiveness, as is consistency of arm action.
“I wouldn’t say ride,” Harrison said of his fastball’s movement profile. “I don’t think that’s the right term, because that calls for induced vert, and if my induced vert gets too high, that means my arm slot is creeping up too high and I lose my vertical approach angle. It’s crazy how much I’m learning about all this. In a couple of starts, my heater wasn’t as good as I wanted it to be, because my arm slot was a little lower and I was up-shooting the ball a little. It’s a fine line. You’ve got to stay consistent to get results up here.”
Harrison has a 3.79 ERA, a 3.87 FIP, and a 23.9% strikeout rate in 38 innings this season. Three months shy of his 23rd birthday, he’s one of the youngest pitchers in MLB. The results, and his continuing evolution, are coming along quite well.
———
RANDOM HITTER-PITCHER MATCHUPS
Pedro Guerrero went 11 for 15 against Dennis Rasmussen.
Vladimir Guerrero went 11 for 19 against Chris Young.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is 8 for 10 against Shawn Armstrong.
Wilton Guerrero went 8 for 11 against Mark Clark.
Mario Guerrero went 9 for 13 against Rick Honeycutt.
———
I had a fun exchange with Craig Counsell prior to last Sunday’s game at Fenway Park. The Chicago Cubs manager told reporters that Hayden Wesneski, upon being informed that he was getting the start — Jordan Wicks was scratched due to a forearm strain — responded by saying “My job is to get the first guy out.” Counsell liked Wesneski’s mindset, in part because the young right-hander had faced seven batters in a relief outing three days prior. How long he could be expected to go was an open question.
What prompted my exchange with Counsell was his stating that “Starting provides a different challenge. With relieving, we pick the hitters you face. With starting, they pick the hitters you face.”
I suggested that a caveat was in order. If the starter is an opener, a manager does get to pick the hitters.
“That’s accurate,” said Counsell. “Thanks for that clarification.
“Not really, though,” he then added. “When I name the pitcher, [the opposing manager] gets to react with who he wants the hitters to be. So, that’s actually false, David. Unless I would not tell them who is pitching until I took the lineup card up.”
Point well taken, I proceeded to ask what the normal procedure is.
“That you tell the other team who is pitching,” Counsell replied.
Which brings us to the how and when. This past Wednesday, I asked Bob Melvin about his alerting the Red Sox that Erik Miller would be serving as an opener that evening. The San Francisco manager told me that he’d texted Alex Cora in the morning. Could he have waited until closer to game time? Apparently there is no rule stipulating when the information has to be shared with your opponent.
There is a related rule in place, thanks to Earl Weaver. In 1980, the legendary Baltimore manager began filling out his lineup card with a pitcher he wasn’t planning to use in the DH spot, most often in the six-hole (Steve Stone, who won the Cy Young award that year, had 12 such appearances). Weaver would then pinch-hit for his pitcher/DH at the first opportunity, matching up accordingly. MLB proceeded to ban the phantom DH.
———
A quiz:
Two pitchers in San Diego Padres franchise history have won 20 or more games in a single season. One of them is Randy Jones, who did so twice. Who is the Padres’ other 20-game-winner? (A hint: he was a five-time All-Star who played only two seasons in San Diego.)
The answer can be found below.
———
NEWS NOTES
The Baltimore Orioles announced on Friday that Terry Crowley and Nick Markakis have been inducted into the team’s Hall of Fame. Crowley played parts of 12 seasons with the Orioles, primarily as a DH and a PH, and later spent 16 seasons as the hitting coach. Markakis played nine seasons with the Orioles and ranks among the franchise’s all-time leaders in hits, doubles, and total bases.
Benjamin Cowles was named Eastern League Player of the Month for April after slashing .351/.433/.623 with the Double-A Somerset Patriots. The 24-year-old infield prospect out of the University of Maryland was referred to as “a sleeper in the New York Yankees system” in my February 18, 2024 Sunday Notes column.
Tara Krieger, Todd Lebowitz, Allison Levin, and Roberta J. Newman were elected to serve as SABR’s Board of Directors. More information can be found here.
Joe Shipley, a right-handed pitcher who appeared in 21 games for the San Francisco Giants from 1958-1960, and in three games for the Chicago White Sox in 1963, died earlier this week at age 88. The Morristown, Tennessee native retired Hall of Famers Henry Aaron and Eddie Mathews in his first big-league inning.
A Tribute to the Negro Leagues All-Star Game will take place at Doubleday Field in Cooperstown, New York on May 25. A number of Hall of Famers will participate, including Ken Griffey Jr., Fergie Jenkins, Jim Rice, Ozzie Smith, and Dave Winfield. More information can be found here.
——-
The answer to the quiz is Gaylord Perry, who went 21-6 with the Padres in his 1978 Cy Young season. If you guessed Kevin Brown, he was a six-time All-Star who went 18-7 in 1998, his only season with the Padres.
———
A small plaque on the riverwalk inside PNC Park commemorates the 1935 Pittsburgh Crawfords, who won that year’s Negro National League’s championship series with a dramatic Game 7 come-from-behind win over the New York Cubans. The plaque states the Crawfords are often compared to the 1927 Yankees, and might have been baseball’s best team ever. That statement isn’t a stretch.
Making the quality of the ’35 Crawfords even more amazing is that an in-his-prime Satchel Paige had departed the team in spring training, opting to instead spend the season playing semipro ball in Bismarck, North Dakota (!). Had Paige remained — and he did return the following year — the Crawfords would have had five future Hall of Famers. Oscar Charleston was a player/manger, Judy Johnson was the third baseman, Cool Papa Bell was in the outfield, and Josh Gibson was behind the plate. A left-hander not in the Hall of Fame, Leroy Matlock, was one of the game’s top pitchers throughout the 1930s.
———
FARM NOTES
Chase Meidroth has drawn 26 walks and fanned just 12 times in 115 plate appearances for the Triple-A Worcester Red Sox. The 22-year-old infielder — Boston’s fourth-round pick in the 2022 draft — is slashing .259/.443/.306 with a 119 wRC+.
Tink Hence has 31 strikeouts and has allowed 13 hits and six earned runs in 25-and-two-thirds innings for the Double-A Springfield Cardinals. The 21-year-old right-hander was St. Louis’s second-round pick in the 2020 draft.
Jacob Wilson is slashing .429/.443/.679 with three home runs in 88 plate appearances for the Double-A Midland RockHounds. The 22-year-old shortstop was drafted sixth-overall last year by the Oakland Athletics out of Grand Canyon University.
Blake Mitchell is slashing .244/.417/.449 with three home runs in 103 plate appearances for the Low-A Columbia Fireflies. The 19-year-old, left-handed-hitting catcher was drafted eighth-overall last year by the Kansas City Royals out of Sinton (TX) High School.
Chase Dollander has 33 strikeouts, and has allowed nine hits and five runs in 19-and-a-third innings, with the High-A Spokane Indians. The 22-year-old right-hander was drafted ninth-overall last year by the Colorado Rockies out of the University of Tennessee.
———
Bob Melvin has three decades of big-league experience between his playing and managerial careers, so it’s rare that he finds himself starstruck. One of those moments took place on Thursday at Fenway Park. Giants outfielder Mike Yastrzemski walked into the visiting manager’s office accompanied by his 82-year-old grandfather.
“There aren’t too many things better than that, especially if you’re a fan of baseball and the history,” Melvin said of being introduced to Carl Yastrzemski, who played all 23 of his Hall of Fame seasons with the Red Sox. “You look up there [on the right-field facade] and see his [retired] number. I really didn’t have much to say, because I was kind of in awe. I appreciate Mike bringing him in… There are certain guys who get your attention more than others, and him here at Fenway Park is about as good as it gets.”
How many former players would elicit that type of reaction from the 62-year-old skipper?
“Not too many,” Melvin replied to my question. “I mean, I’ve played with guys like George Brett — you go to Kansas City, and so forth and so on — so I know [them]. But here at Fenway Park, it doesn’t get any better than that… There are some cool days in baseball, and I’ve had a lot of them. This was one of them.”
Carl Yastrzemski’s ledger includes 3,419 hits, 452 home runs, seven Gold Gloves, three batting titles, and 18 All-Star games. His 3,308 games played are second-most in MLB history.
———
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
The Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks have NPB’s best record at 19-9. The Seibu Lions have NPB’s worst record at 11-19.
Shoki Murakami is 2-1 with a 1.06 ERA and 28 strikeouts in 34 innings fir NPB’s Hanshin Tigers. The 25-year-old right-hander captured last year’s Central League MVP award after going 10-6 with a 1.75 ERA.
José Osuna is slashing .285/.333/.488 with six home runs in 132 plate appearances for the Yakult Swallows. The 31-year-old first baseman played for the Pittsburgh Pirates from 2017-2020 before joining the Tokyo-based club in 2021.
Do Yeong Kim is slashing .329/.371/.616 with 11 home runs in 160 plate appearances for the KBO’s Kia Tigers. The 20-year-old third baseman batted .303 with seven home runs a year ago.
Ji Min Choi has appeared in 17 games and allowed just nine hits and one earned run in 16 innings for the Tigers. The 20-year-old southpaw has 11 strikeouts and a pair of saves.
———
A random obscure former player snapshot:
Les Cain had two solid seasons with the Detroit Tigers, then had his career end in controversial fashion at age 24. A left-handed pitcher who had double-digit win totals in 1970 and 1971, Cain made five appearances in 1972 before being shut down with a shoulder injury. From that point forward, his professional career comprised just 11 innings, all of them in the minors. Cain later won a workman’s compensation suit against the Tigers, successfully arguing that Detroit manager Billy Martin had effectively forced him to pitch while he was injured.
———
EARLY-MAY STAT NOTABLES
The Minnesota Twins won their 12th consecutive game yesterday, equalling the second-longest winning streak in team history. The longest is 15 games, by the 1991 Twins, who went on to win the World Series.
The Colorado Rockies have trailed in all 33 of their games this season. They’ve gone on to lose 25 of them.
The Kansas City Royals are 20-14. Last season they were 8-26 through 34 games.
The Oakland Athletics are 17-17. Last season they were 8-26 through 34 games.
The Cleveland Guardians played four consecutive extra-inning games this past week, winning two and losing two. The last time Cleveland played four consecutive extra-inning games was from May 1-5, 1910. The then-named Naps won three and had a 14-inning tie. Cy Young went the distance in the 14-inning affair.
Steven Kwan’s last strikeout (his 11th on the season) came on April 15th. He has recorded 22 hits since he last K’d.
Mike Trout came into this year with a career .346 BAPIP, the highest among qualified hitters since his 2011 debut season. His BABIP this season is .194.
Juan Soto has a .324 BABIP and a .318 BA. Tim Anderson has a .329 BABIP and a .219 BA.
———
LINKS YOU’LL LIKE
Larry Lester was a pioneer in chronicling the history of the Negro Leagues. MLB’s official historian, John Thorn, wrote about Lester at his Our Game blog.
Rintani Sasaki was the top-rated high school player in Japan, but he bypassed the NPB draft and is now enrolled at Stanford University where his prodigious bat has him bound for MLB. Andrew Baggerly spent time with the 19-year-old phenom and has the story at The Athletic (subscription required).
Livan Moinelo is enjoying success as a starter after spending several seasons as one of NPB’s top relievers. Jim Allen talked to the 28-year-old, Cuban-born, Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks southpaw for The Kyodo News.
Pitcher List’s John Foley wrote about how Brady Singer is starting to elevate.
The Score’s Travis Sawchik gave us a statistical breakdown on the importance of first-pitch strikes.
———
RANDOM FACTS AND STATS
Luis Arraez, who turned 27 last month, came into this season with a .328/.379/.427 slash line and a 124 wRC+. Tony Gwynn slashed .326..377/.427 with a 128 wRC+ through his age-26 season.
Smoky Burgess, a catcher known for his pinch-hitting prowess, played for five teams in a career that spanned the 1949-1967 seasons. He batted .294/.362/.446 in home games, and .296/.362/.446 in road games.
Matt Williams had 7,595 PAs, 378 HRs, a .268 BA, a .489 SLG, and 182 GDPs.
Rocky Colavito had 7,559 PAs, 374 HRs, a .266 BA, a .489 SLG, and 182 GDPs.
Red Ruffing went 10-25 with a 104 ERA+ for the Boston Red Sox in 1928. He went 19-11 with a 104 ERA+ for the New York Yankees in 1934.
The first-ever game between the Red Sox and Yankees franchises took place on May 7, 1903 at Boston’s Huntington Avenue Baseball Grounds. The Boston Americans beat the New York Highlanders 6-2 in front of 5,462 fans.
On today’s date in 1950, Hank Sauer hit a game-tying, two-out, three-run homer in the bottom of the ninth inning, then Randy Jackson hit a walk-off solo shot in the 10th, as the Chicago Cubs beat the Brooklyn Dodgers 7-6. Johnny Vander Meer got the win, his first of three wearing a Cubs uniform.
Players born on today’s date include Bruno Haas, who made his MLB debut on June 23, 1915 and walked 16 batters while throwing a complete game for the Philadelphia Athletics in a 15-7 loss to the New York Yankees. Haas took the mound five more times that season — his only one in the big leagues — then spent the next two decades as an outfielder in the minor leagues, playing primarily with the St. Paul Saints.
Also born on today’s date was Tom Gregorio, a catcher whose big-league career comprised 12 games for the Anaheim Angels in 2003. Gregorio stroked singles in each of his first two at-bats, only to finish his brief MLB stint a modest 3-for-19. He went 0-for-9 against the Texas Rangers.
David Laurila grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula and now writes about baseball from his home in Cambridge, Mass. He authored the Prospectus Q&A series at Baseball Prospectus from December 2006-May 2011 before being claimed off waivers by FanGraphs. He can be followed on Twitter @DavidLaurilaQA.


Almost too easy trivia today..at least for a Gen X’ er that remembers Gaylord Perry’s fluke Cy Young season.
Considered Jake Peavy for a second before realizing the 2 year clue eliminated him. Then knew it was Perry. Never even got to Kevin Brown.
I’m a fellow Gen Xer and today’s quiz tool me about 2 seconds. Like you, I knew Perry won a Cy Young with the Padres. And back then you pretty much had to win 20 games to win a Cy Young.
BTW, a couple of notes re: Randy Jones.
1) He lost 22 games the year before his back to back 20+ won seasons.
2) He won the Cy Young in 1976 while striking out (are you ready for this?) a mere 2.7 batters per 9 innings. Even for an era of relatively low strikeouts,that’s pretty incredible.
Whenever someone says “Padres” and “starting pitching” my mind always goes to Jake Peavy and refuses to budge. So I gave up and looked up the answer. Here is what learned: The Padres have not had much in the way of long-term, elite starting pitching in their 55 year history. Peavy is the one with the highest fWAR and he played half his career elsewhere.
Other expansion teams around that time do much better. The Mariners have King Felix and the first chunk of Randy Johnson’s career. The Blue Jays have Halladay and Dave Stieb. The Mets have Seaver, Gooden, and deGrom. The Astros have Oswalt, JR Richard, and a good chunk of Nolan Ryan’s good years. The Royals had Appier, Gubicza, and Saberhagen.
The Brewers are probably ahead of the Padres too, but mostly because they have Ben Sheets. The Rangers are the only team coming out of that wave of expansion who have worse starting pitching. It’s wild, I think of the Padres as a moderately successful franchise, but the only player I could find with more than 30 fWAR was Tony Gwynn. The Rangers have seven players who match that description. The Brewers have five of them.
Yeah, Dave Winfield is 2nd with 29.1..then it’s Peavy at 28.8. Hoffman, Randy Jones & Machado are in the 20’s.
It sort of makes sense. When I think of the Padres franchise it seems like they vacillate between being all-in & selling off every 4-5 years, so players never accumulate enough time with them to get to 30-40 WAR.
Really, only Gwynn & Trevor Hoffman are lifetime Padres players..I’d guess Machado & Tatis will both end up in 2nd/3rd place for franchise WAR.
Just to follow up on this: They have the third-worst winning percentage in MLB among the 30 active teams, just ahead of the Marlins and Rockies. Some of this is because they were exceedingly bad until 1982, but I looked it up and even if you start in 1982 they’re something like 20th in runs allowed and 24th in runs scored out of the 26 teams from 1982 to the present. And they’re 22nd in wins, between the post-machine Reds and the (mostly) post-Weaver Orioles. So perhaps “moderately successful” is overstating things a bit. More successful than the Tigers, Pirates, and Royals over that period
Right, I was going to say that when we look at the total history of franchises, the Padres have been one of the losingest. So it’s not surprising to see lack of historic franchise excellence beyond Gwynn and a handful of others.
The Marlins and Rockies have lower win-loss percentages, but they have the excuse of smaller sample sizes: they’re in their 32nd season whereas the Padres are in their 56th.
Among non-expansion teams, the Phillies had decades of bad play, but in recent decades have been pretty good; over their last 50 seasons they’ve been above .500 in a bit over half of them and have won 6 pennants (and 2 World Series).
The other contender for losingest franchise is the Mariners, who are the only current franchise that has never played in a World Series. They’ve also had decades of futility including setting the modern (division play) record of missing the playoffs for 20 consecutive seasons. But they were actually a good team from 1995-2003, and have been above .500 for 3 straight seasons, 4 if we count this one.
Overall, and looking at each team’s entire history, I’d say it’s between the Padres, Mariners, and Rockies in terms of which franchise has done the worst on the field. Some parts of the Marlins’ history are almost disgusting, but two World Series wins is two World Series wins.
The Padres, Mariners, and Rockies have over 110 years of combined history. Yet only one of those teams has won more than 92 games in a single season – the ’98 Padres who won 98 games. That’s pretty amazing but not in a good way.
The Mariners have indeed had a rather miserable history on the whole – the 1970s/1980s being particularly gruesome – but they did win 93+ games three consecutive seasons beginning with their record setting 116 win 2001 season.
Yeah, I got confused. The comment by mkt42 mentioned the Padres, Mariners, and Rockies but then in the next line he mentioned The Marlins. So my brain switched the Marlins for the Mariners.
Anyway, it’s actually the Padres, Marlins, and Rockies that have 110+ years of combined history with only one season of more than 92 wins.
That’s not right. Off the top of my head I know Seattle had a 116 win season too.
Rockies
& here’s what’s weird & back to the orginal point about lack of stars/long term players. Since 1982, the 4 teams worse than them have the following with more fWAR than Dave Winfield’s 29.1:
Pirates- 4- Bonds, McCutchen, Kendall, Van Slyke
Royals- 5-Brett, Gordon, Appier, Gubicza, Saberhagen
Tigers- 6-Whitaker, Trammell, Miggy, Verlander, Morris,Lemon
Orioles- 6- Mussina, Ripken, Murray, Brady Anderson, Adam Jones, Brian Roberts)
San Diego has 1 guy over 30 fWAR (Gwynn) since 1969. Winfield is 2nd at 29.1 & was gone after 1980. The above teams that are worse than them since 1982 have 4-6 guys with more fWAR than San Diego’s 2nd best player in franchise history…in 13 less years.
Two other franchises have “a good chunk of Nolan Ryan’s good years”.
It’s kind of unbelievable how good he was with the Rangers but he wasn’t with them for that long. At least in comparison with the Astros and Angels.
With 5000+ innings, he can split his tenure across different teams and be a legend in two or three of them.
I seem to remember the White Sox playing that phantom DH trick in the late ’80’s when they were trying to get Jerry Hairston Sr the team record for most pinch hits. This would have been after the rule was changed so maybe they got around it by notifying the other team ahead of time or something? I can’t find any documentation to back up my memory of things that might not have happened 35 years ago.
Tim Anderson’s problem isn’t BABIP, it’s power. He has 3 home runs in the last 730 days and an ISO of about .050. This is a guy who has hit as many as 20 and had double digits in 5 straight years, including the pandemic year.
He had more extra base hits in 2020 (221 PA) than in 2022 (351) and 2023 (524).
Tim Anderson’s main problem is comparing himself to Jackie Robinson.
Pity that there aren’t ballplayers named Smokey, Rocky, and/or Red anymore.
For those interested in the Satchel Paige in Bismarck story, there’s a great book on it – “Color Blind: The Forgotten Team That Broke Baseball’s Color Line” by Tom Dunkel. (It’s better than its title.)
Nice. I grew up in Bismarck and know all about this. The one thing I can’t find is if I played American Legion baseball in the 80s on the same field, obviously modified over the year. I remember Bismarck always only having one really nice big field that could handle that type of baseball.
The Matt Williams-Rocky Colavito similarity is interesting. Colavito fell off a cliff after his age 32 season and was out of baseball by 1968. But he had a five-year stretch where he hit no fewer than 35 homers, with a high of 45 in 1961. He was incredibly durable during an 11-year period as well. And had a very good arm if not particularly rangy in the outfield. On the other hand, Williams had a much more typical career arc, was a plus-plus defensive player at third base (four Gold Gloves) but played 140 or more games only six times. Neither player impressed the Hall of Fame voters, but they’re definitely solid choices for my Hall of Very Good.
Les Cain made 38 starts (plus another 5 relief appearances) and threw 237 innings in the minors when he was 19. And he walked 153 guys too, so not low maintenance innings!