The Crazy Probabilities in the Nationals Five-Homer Inning

Bryce Harper got a little help from his friends. (Photo: Keith Allison)


The Nationals just exploded offensively against the Brewers, winning 15-2. It might be hard to believe, but it could have been worse as all 15 Nationals runs were scored in the first four innings. One inning in particular stands out as the Nationals hit five home runs in the third inning on their way to a seven-run inning. It might be hard to believe, but the inning didn’t appear to be a particularly promising one from the beginning as Max Scherzer and his .185/.215/.200 slash line led off. Here’s how the inning went down, per the FanGraphs play log.

Nationals Wild Third Inning
Pitcher Player Inn. Outs Base Score Play
M Blazek M Scherzer 3 0 ___ 2-0 Max Scherzer walked.
M Blazek B Goodwin 3 0 1__ 4-0 Brian Goodwin homered (Fly). Max Scherzer scored.
M Blazek W Difo 3 0 ___ 5-0 Wilmer Difo homered (Fly).
M Blazek B Harper 3 0 ___ 6-0 Bryce Harper homered (Fliner (Fly)).
M Blazek R Zimmerman 3 0 ___ 7-0 Ryan Zimmerman homered (Fliner (Fly)).
M Blazek D Murphy 3 0 ___ 7-0 Daniel Murphy flied out to center (Fly).
M Blazek A Rendon 3 1 ___ 8-0 Anthony Rendon homered (Fly).
W Peralta A Lind 3 1 ___ 8-0 Adam Lind singled to center (Grounder).
W Peralta A Lind 3 1 1__ 8-0 Adam Lind advanced on a stolen base to 2B.
W Peralta J Lobaton 3 1 _2_ 9-0 Jose Lobaton doubled to center (Fliner (Liner)). Adam Lind scored.
W Peralta M Scherzer 3 1 _2_ 9-0 Max Scherzer singled to shortstop (Grounder). Jose Lobaton advanced to 3B.
W Peralta B Goodwin 3 1 1_3 9-0 Brian Goodwin lined out to third (Liner). Max Scherzer out at second.

Before we get to these probabilities, lets talk some other odds. Let’s say I told you four Washington Nationals hitters in a row hit homers, and you had to name the four hitters, how many guesses would it take. Bryce Harper would certainly be a good guess. So it would Ryan Zimmerman, but how many names would you have to cycle through before you named both Wilmer Difo and Brian Goodwin. I can understand Goodwin, as he’s popped ten in just over 200 plate appearances, but Difo had hit two homers this season and just 14 at any level since leaving low-A at the end of the 2014 campaign.

Jon Tayler took a rough stab at the probability here:


There are a lot of wild probabilities to cover, but let’s start with the four homers in a row.

Four homers in a row


  • 0.00000115744
  • Roughly one in 864,000

According to our projections, Goodwin is likely to hit a home run in 2.9%, Difo in 1.5%, Harper in 5.5%, and Zimmerman in 4.6% of plate appearances. The odds of them going back to back to back to back is about one in 864,000. If you divide by 18 chances per game, 81 games per home team and 30 teams in baseball, we are talking about a one in 20-year occurrence. For four good home run hitters, say 4% chance of a homer, that number is once in nine years.

If you want to play the what-if game, Daniel Murphy had a shot to make it five homers in a row. The odds of those five players each hitting homers in a row is one in 26 million, or once in 604 seasons. It’s possible that’s why it hasn’t ever happened before.

That’s not the only homer probability from the inning though, as after Daniel Murphy flied out, Anthony Rendon hit a homer.

Five homers in six batters


  • .0000002914
  • Roughly one in 3.4 million

I got a little bit lazy here and instead of taking the individual players’ homer percentages, I averaged out the six players and used 3.6% chances of each getting a homer to determine the chances of six players getting five homers. This is a once in 78 seasons occurrence. Of course, just getting five homers in an innings is slightly easier as you have three outs to work with and other players can get hits in between. For example, in 2006 the Milwaukee Brewers hit five home runs in an inning when Bill Hall, Damian Miller, Brady Clark, J.J. Hardy, and Prince Fielder all teed off, they hit four homers among six batters and five homers among nine batters, which is a one-in-two year and one-in-six year phenomenon at the Nationals’ homer rates.

Max Scherzer


  • .0000124305
  • Roughly one in 80,000

In the third inning, Max Scherzer did three things that do not normally happen to Max Scherzer. First, he drew a walk, which happens about once in 30 plate appearances. Then he batted again, which required eight teammates not to make three outs, which at a .330 OBP clip, which is about a one in 70 shot, and then he got an infield single, which is about one in 40 tries. Put it all together and that thing would happen about once in 80,000 tries. Scherzer has come to the plate 304 times.

Adam Lind steals a base


  • .0011892857
  • Roughly one in 840

Adam Lind gets on base via the walk or single about one in three times and according to Baseball-Reference, Lind has stolen six bases in 1,680 opportunities. Put it together and the odds aren’t high of seeing this, and it is possible I am understating things quite a bit as Lind hasn’t stolen a base since 2013 and has only attempted two in the last six seasons. It’s probably a bit more rare than I’m making it out to be.

As for Tayler’s question in the tweet above, I plugged all the information into my calculator and it told me to get outside more. Feel free to question my math or challenge any assumptions I made. I promise I won’t mind.


Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
4 years ago

So the Nats are up 8-0 in the third with Scherzer pitching and Adam Lind decides to steal a base. Seems like there are unwritten rules about that.

4 years ago
Reply to  Smacc

It’s the third inning and let’s just say the Nationals bullpen lags behind their lineup slightly.

Also, Adam Lind isn’t going to get a lot of those in his career, why not let him have it.

The Ghost of Johnny Dickshot
4 years ago
Reply to  Smacc

Unwritten rules in baseball are idiotic.