The Early Shift: An Introduction

Hello. I have missed you. I have been on paternity leave for the past two months because — and I’m told this is the most common reason people go on paternity leave — my wife and I had a baby. Mostly, my wife had the baby while I said things like “You’re doing great,” and “I’m so proud of you,” and “Hey look, a baby,” but this is very much a team sport. Our free agent acquisition arrived loaded with tools like spiky hair, world-weary eyes, and a trapezoidal mouth with a cute little dimple just beneath it, but she’s a little short on big league experience. We’ll have to coach her up.
So now we have this baby girl. It’s unclear whether she’s a bouncing baby girl — we haven’t dropped her yet — but she certainly seems healthy enough. I’m looking at her right now. She’s sleeping in her crib all swaddled up like a salami. She is, as babies tend to be, adorable. She is also — and again I’m informed that this is standard — somewhat labor intensive.
While laboring over this novel life-form for the past two months, I have watched precious little baseball. I have done precious little anything other than care for my wife and child (or, as I am still getting used to calling it, my family). As a result, I am wildly underinformed about the latest developments in my field of expertise. The stray missives that reached my ears often left me with more questions than answers. Did somebody Monstars the NL East? Are we sure this is the same Ildemaro Vargas? When did all these bodies get so loose?
Out of the loop as I may be, I am constitutionally incapable of abstaining from making things. I have done some baking. I have mixed down the occasional song. And I have written about baseball, after a fashion. As I fed my daughter, or as I rocked her to sleep, or as she snoozed on the other side of the room, I kept a journal of observations, some about caring for her, some about the small snatches of baseball I’d managed to sneak in the cracks of the day, and some about the intersection of those two worlds. This is the kind of baseball writing I was able to do, and I would like to share it with you.
I tend to think my main job as a baseball writer is noticing. Sure, I have to crunch the numbers, and make the graphs, and hammer out the jokes, and put the actual words on the page (and then, at the very last minute, remember that I also need a headline and frantically try to come up with something that’s not so drab and uninspiring that it’ll make Michael Baumann embarrassed to even know me). That’s the work and it’s rewarding in its own right, but the noticing is the part that keeps giving. A couple years ago, Sam Miller wrote, “The explicit goal of that article, and probably the implicit goal of most of my articles, is to give myself/you a reason to pay attention to things so that we can grow to care for them.”
I have found this to be true over and over again. The act of noticing something and giving it my full attention — even if it’s something as silly as Jacob Wilson’s batting stance or Nick Madrigal’s habit of running halfway across the diamond before throwing the ball to first — rewires my brain. I care about it now. I look for it in the future and get excited when I see it. I’ve just added a small bit of joy to my life. And I think that’s what it’s all about. I think we’re supposed to go through this world looking for things to be passionate about. I think the greater and deeper your enthusiasms, the more connected you will be to the world around you and the more rewarding your life will be. “How intimately related,” wrote Wendell Berry, “how nearly synonymous, are the terms ‘love’ and ‘know,’ how likely impossible is it to know authentically or well what one does not love, and how certainly impossible it is to love what one does not know.”
Well, I have this baby and loving her is now my primary job in life. So I want to make sure I notice as much as I can. As you’ll read many times in the entries that follow, my wife and I wake up every day to a new baby, and we’re so worried that we’ll forget yesterday’s baby. Yesterday’s baby ruled! Our daughter grows so fast, and we want to remember everything we can about this special time in our lives. This journal was the best way I could think of to do that. It’s the story of our rookie season.
I’ll close with a few notes on what you’re about to read. The first entry is dated two weeks after my daughter’s birth, both because that’s the first time I caught any baseball and because I would not wish upon anyone the horror of peeking inside my head during that first feverish fortnight. As you might have noticed, I have not told you my daughter’s name. I think it’d be better to keep that off the internet, at least for a while. I will refer to her as Derek Jr., which is what my wife and I jokingly called her when she was still just a toolsy prospect on the complex. (It did not occur to me during my wife’s pregnancy to refer to my wife’s belly as “the complex,” which I now recognize as a catastrophic oversight.) Likewise, you won’t see her face, but I did my best to take photographs that I could share:

Next, this is presented as a journal and it is a journal — the vast majority of the entries were written in the moment, often in the wee hours of the morning while I was holding Derek Jr. in my arms after feeding her or immediately after I put her to bed — but it’s been polished and edited. It’s still a true story, but I don’t want to give the misleading impression that you’re sneaking a peak at raw diary entries. There were lots of days when I didn’t write anything, or didn’t watch any baseball, or, most frequent, when I wrote a sentence or two and then got interrupted by some baby emergency and never finished saying whatever it was I intended to say. For those days, I came back later and did my best to write what I remembered, or I filled in the gaps with general observations that had been sitting around waiting for a home.
Lastly, I should probably get ahead of something that may have already occurred to readers with keen memories. Around this time last year, I wrote a certain article. In that article, I pulled paternity list data and ran some numbers to test a hypothesis: Ballplayers tend to have babies right around Opening Day, because Opening Day falls roughly nine months after the All-Star break, during which time ballplayers are not getting as much rest as their strength and conditioning coaches might hope. The data bore out that hypothesis, and I had entirely too much fun coming up with euphemisms for those midsummer baby-related activities. As such, I feel honor-bound to point out that my own daughter was very nearly born on Opening Day and allow you to generate your own conclusions (and euphemisms).
And that’s about it, I guess. I’m back at work as of today, though I’ll take another few weeks off when my wife returns to her job toward the end of the regular season. I have no idea whether I’ll keep updating this journal now that I’ll be writing real articles every day; it’s hard to imagine I’ll have the time. Then again, it’s also all too easy to imagine the things I might never notice if I stop.
Davy Andrews is a Brooklyn-based musician and a writer at FanGraphs. He can be found on Bluesky @davyandrewsdavy.bsky.social.
Congrats! You have now entered the greatest and most frustrating part of your life! Take care of the Mom. It’s impossible for us men to truly understand what they go through, and the mental health challenges that come with it. Cannot stress enough how important it is to learn about post partum depression.
Yeah this part is a bit of an endurance test for everyone involved, including the baby. By the playoffs hopefully everyone will be in better shape.
Congratulations! May Derek Jr reach the big leagues in whatever form that takes. All the best to you and your growing family!
Congratulations!
Beautifully written. Congrats!
I almost spit out my coffee laughing at the first two paragraphs. And congrats.
Huge congrats, Davy!
Someone Monstar’d the AL East!
(Could make an argument for the whole AL, or the whole east)
Upon some reflection, I think the baby did it.
Congratulations!
Being a dad has been the most amazing part of my life in ways I never expected.
Because pediatricians don’t seem to think it’s important for all new parents to know this, kids can learn sign language far before they can speak. The day your daughter learns to sign “milk” is the day that crying in the house is reduced dramatically. I feel that every parent should know that. 🙂
This! “More” was the sign that we benefited from the most. Best of luck, Davy! Just be patient when you’re up and you’ll be an MVP.
We got the most value out of “milk”, but “more” and “diaper” also provided some value for us.
Diaper could have been great, but my son never cared much that he was running around in a full diaper. It had to get pretty uncomfortable before he’d tell us, and we usually had dealt with it by then.
More is great for solid food. More and then pointing at an empty plate segment is very clear communication. 🙂
Congrats, good luck, and get your sleep when you can.
Congratulations!! I’m sure you’ll be a fantastic dad! And I’m very glad to know that FG provides paternity leave. Yet another good reason to join
Congrats!!! Get sleep whenever you can find it (be creative)
In residency we used to watch as the newborn census would go up and down around 9 months after known blackouts/big storms and valentines days. It’s like Skwisgaard Skwigelf always says, “only one thing to do in a blackout: gets wasted! Wait, no, two things.”
Congratulations on your new teammate! They start off with a smiling grade of 20/80 but by now I bet it’s up to 50.
fangraphs becomes pram-graphs
Amazing news! When people asked me how being a dad/parent has been, I always say: Well it hasn’t gotten any easier, but it’s gotten a little less difficult”. Enjoy these early days. You’ll miss them when she’s toddling around and you can’t keep up.
“my wife and I wake up every day to a new baby, and we’re so worried that we’ll forget yesterday’s baby. Yesterday’s baby ruled! Our daughter grows so fast, and we want to remember everything we can about this special time in our lives.”
This is such a fantastic and succinct and precious way to convey the surprisingly bittersweet feeling watching a kid grow up.
Congratulations, Davy! My child is somehow bordering on adulthood despite the persistent incompetence of my parenting, so I can say with confidence that children are much more resilient than they seem. Don’t sweat small things and enjoy it while you can.
Congrats! Although I would argue she wasn’t a free agent acquisition. I would say it’s of an example of internal prospect development.
Congratulations! I have two, with a similar approach to names and images staying offline, and a similar challenge in adjusting to the reorientation needed for work/life/baseball balance. Best wishes from a fellow-traveler.
Congrats Davy! Just had my first in early October, on the first day of last year’s postseason! As much as it hurt not being able to watch very minute of one of the best World Series of all time, we have enjoyed parenthood so much!
Definitely enjoy it, the baseball will always be here! (We hope… looking at you 2026 CBA….)
Health and happiness and most of all love 🤘
Congratulations Davy, stay healthy and happy!!!
This is the easy part. Just wait until the baby gets mobile….
Davy, congrats, man. I had to stifle laughter at the bouncing baby joke in the office, the Dad humor is alive and well, it looks like.
Welcome back! I have missed your words here.
Oh this is perfect for where I’m at. Excited to follow. I am finding that mlb.tv is great for having something to watch while I rock the baby to sleep — put my phone somewhere she can’t see, put in the AirPods and just hope to have more patience than the screaming lil critter.
Congrats! It was a pleasure reading this….my best to the family!
It was only shortly after our baby was born that I learned the meaning of the word “bittersweet”. Congratulations! Parenthood is all about cherishing the journey.
Welcome to the team, Derek Jr., and swallow as much milk as you can!
Congratulations! So happy for you and glad you had time to soak it in. Also, selfishly, happy to have you back!
Congrats! Hope all three of you stay in good health.
You’re a joy, Davy. Congratulations!
Congrats! Mine just turned 3 months today. I never watched the condensed games on mlb.tv before having a baby and now that’s become our 10 minute morning coffee / father-son / baseball ritual.
Congrats! I’ve got 5(all adults now) and it’s an incredible journey.
Going forward you might want to have Jeter Jr to start working on going to her left….