The Fringe Five: Baseball’s Most Compelling Fringe Prospects

The Fringe Five is a weekly regular-season exercise, introduced a few years ago by the present author, wherein that same author utilizes regressed stats, scouting reports, and also his own fallible intuition to identify and/or continue monitoring the most compelling fringe prospects in all of baseball.

Central to the exercise, of course, is a definition of the word fringe, a term which possesses different connotations for different sorts of readers. For the purposes of the column this year, a fringe prospect (and therefore one eligible for inclusion in the Five) is any rookie-eligible player at High-A or above who (a) received a future value grade of 45 or less from lead prospect analyst Dan Farnsworth during the course of his organizational lists and who (b) was omitted from the preseason prospect lists produced by Baseball America, Baseball Prospectus, and John Sickels, and also who (c) is currently absent from a major-league roster. Players appearing on an updated prospect list or, otherwise, selected in the first round of the current season’s amateur draft will also be excluded from eligibility.

In the final analysis, the basic idea is this: to recognize those prospects who are perhaps receiving less notoriety than their talents or performance might otherwise warrant.

*****

Bruce Caldwell, 2B/3B, St. Louis (Profile)
Last year’s second-overall pick and current member of Double-A Corpus Christi, shortstop Alex Bregman, received considerable attention this past Monday for recording a two-homer game against Cardinals’ Double-A affiliate Springfield. Of note, however, is that another, much less celebrated infielder also produced two home runs during that same contest. Bruce Caldwell, is who. And both those homers were to the opposite field. And, in both cases, Caldwell was facing actual major-leaguer Lance McCullers*. Selected by St. Louis out of Spartanburg Methodist (Junior) College in the 15th round of the 2012 draft, the 24-year-old Caldwell possesses what’s referred to technically as “absolutely no pedigree.” But he also recorded a 5:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio and three home runs over the first 27 plate appearances of the current season. And his professional track record isn’t without signs of offensive promise.

Here’s video footage of Caldwell’s home runs from earlier in the week:

*This, it appears, is a lie. As reader Carlos Baerga notes below only Caldwell’s first homer was off McCullers. The second? Against other right-hander Aaron West.

Junior Guerra, RHP, Milwaukee (Profile)
The right-handed Guerra was a fixture among the Fringe Five last year — and would have been a fixture even harder had he not spent the bulk of June as a member of the Chicago White Sox’ 25-man roster. Used sparingly (just three times) at the major-league level, Guerra was a revelation in the minors, producing a strikeout rate above 30% in 83.1 innings between Double- and Triple-A — this, one notes, after having been signed by Chicago out of the Italian League as a 30-year-old. Guerra possesses a more impressive repertoire than one might expect based on his itinerant career, including a fastball that sat at 94 mph in the majors and a splitter that serves as an out pitch. Given the combination offered by Guerra both of success and also relative anonymity, it’s not surprising that Milwaukee — which club dedicated its offseason to acquiring an array of compelling fringe prospects — emerged to claim him off waivers. Guerra has been promising for Milwaukee’s Triple-A affiliate already, producing strikeout and walk rates of 32.6% and 6.5 %, respectively, across two starts and 13.0 innings.

Here’s some film of Guerra throwing what are probably splitters this past week for what are definitely swinging strikes:

Sherman Johnson, 2B/3B, Los Angeles AL (Profile)
As was the case with a couple players in 2013 — Marcus Semien, for example, and also Mookie Betts — Sherman Johnson emerged in 2015 as more or less a permanent resident of the Fringe Five, appearing within 11 of last year’s 20 installments of this same, dumb weekly exercise and finishing (tied with two others) atop the arbitrarily calculated Scoreboard. Unlike Betts and Semien, however — who both appeared on at least one top-100 list during the following offseason — the 25-year-old Johnson’s name remains woefully absent from those same rankings. Nevertheless, he continues to perform like a player who could become a major-league regular without much trouble. His first week of the 2016 season represents almost a precise facsimile of his career to date. In 22 plate appearances with Angels Double-A affiliate Arkansas, Johnson produced an equal number of walks and strikeouts (4:4) plus also above-average power numbers (.222 ISO) while starting five games at second base.

Tim Locastro, 2B/SS, Los Angeles NL (Profile)
Locastro first appeared among the Five last year not merely on the strength of his statistical indicators or physical tools — although both merit attention — but also on the improbability of that performance and those tools within the context of his college pedigree. Regard: the 23-year-old Locastro is a product of Ithaca College, a school most well known for being not Cornell and second-most well known for providing a strong liberal-arts education among the leafy woods of New York state’s Southern Tier. What Ithaca isn’t known for is producing great professional ballplayers. That said, Locastro has exhibited some persuasive credentials. He makes contact, steals bases, and occupies a place towards the most difficult end of the defensive spectrum. And he demonstrated all those same skills during the first week of the season, striking out just three times over his first 27 plate appearances while posting a 1-for-1 stolen-base record and making all his defensive starts at either second base or shortstop.

Aaron Wilkerson, RHP, Boston (Profile)
It’s possible to make rough projections for a player’s career WAR — or his probability of reaching the majors at all — based on the slot within the amateur draft at which he’s selected. A top-five pick produces roughly eight wins over the course of his career, for example; a pick in the 40s, usually fewer than two. Applying this sort of methodology to Aaron Wilkerson’s career is problematic, however — on account, that is, of how he wasn’t drafted at all. A product of NAIA school Cumberland University, Wilkerson has survived a Tommy John procedure and no fewer than three independent leagues en route to his current job with Double-A Portland in the Boston system. The 26-year-old Wilkerson has been excellent in affiliated ball, recording strikeout and walk rates of 26.9% and 6.7%, respectively. He’s been definitively old for his levels, but also hasn’t succeeded merely by polish. Consider: the fastballs in the video below were recorded at 92 and 94 mph. The start to his 2016 campaign has been as good as possible: over two starts and 10.2 innings, Wilkerson has produced a 17:2 strikeout-to-walk ratio against 39 total batters.

Here’s footage from Wilkerson’s season debut at Philadelphia affiliate Reading:

The Next Five
These are players on whom the author might potentially become fixated.

Bubby Derby, RHP, Milwaukee (High-A Florida State League)
Pedro Fernandez, RHP, Kansas City (High-A Carolina League)
Edison Frias, RHP, Houston (Double-A Texas League)
Nathan Orf, 2B/3B, Milwaukee (Double-A Southern League)
Brandon Trinkwon, 2B/3B, Los Angeles NL (Double-A Texas League)

Fringe Five Scoreboard
Here are the top-10 the players to have appeared among either the Fringe Five (FF) or Next Five (NF) so far this season (which is to say, today). For mostly arbitrary reasons, players are assessed three points for each week they’ve appeared among the Fringe Five; a single point, for each week among the Next Five.

Fringe Five Scoreboard, 2016
Name Team POS FF NF PTS
1 Sherman Johnson Angels 2B/3B 2 0 6
2 Edison Frias Astros RHP 1 1 4
Tim Locastro Dodgers 2B/SS 1 1 4
4 Aaron Wilkerson Red Sox RHP 1 0 3
Adam Frazier Pirates SS/CF 1 0 3
Bruce Caldwell Cardinals 2B/3B 1 0 3
Jose Martinez Royals OF 1 0 3
Junior Guerra Brewers RHP 1 0 3
Willians Astudillo Braves C 1 0 3
10 Brandon Trinkwon Dodgers 2B/3B 0 2 2




Carson Cistulli has published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.

24 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
PlatypiMember since 2020
10 years ago

Anyone have any insight into Johnson’s batted ball profile?

free-range turducken
10 years ago
Reply to  Platypi

Looks like he hits a lot of balls off the fringes of the last five inches of the bat. That’s how he has such a low BABIP while also being a regular on this list.

Mario MendozaMember since 2017
10 years ago

Re: Sherman, you lost me at 25 years old in AA. 🙁

TwinPeaks
10 years ago
Reply to  Mario Mendoza

I think Sherman Johnson, as well as Krol, were jokes. He hit .204 last year at AA with little power. Yeah, he has some underrated skills, but he’s 25 (and he hit .204)

Dooduh
10 years ago

I nominate Sherman Johnson for the Robert Kral Award.

grandbranyanMember since 2017
10 years ago

Bubba Derby may be on the fringes of the fringe five in terms of prospectdom, but is a clear 80 grade name. I also like the brevity of Nate Orf, doesn’t inspire the imagination quite like Bubba Derby, but then little does.

John Elway
10 years ago
Reply to  grandbranyan

If nothing else, Bubby Derby should be made part of the Triple Crown.

Just neighing.

ZonkMember since 2016
10 years ago

Question on this series: Who is the most recognizable current major leaguer that appeared on “Fringe Five” prospects?

Pirates HurdlesMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  Zonk

Mookie Betts

Jorge FabregasMember since 2016
10 years ago

Ah, yes. Definitely Mookie.

Dooduh
10 years ago
Reply to  Jorge Fabregas

Why, is he good or something..?

Jorge FabregasMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Zonk

Marcus Semien, maybe?

baltic wolfMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Zonk

Over the last 2-3 years, I could name you several players who have appeared on The Fringe Five, made it to the majors and are recognizable names: Joc Pederson of the Dodgers first appeared in his column (2013?), Maikel Franco of the Phillies (pretty sure it was the same year as Pederson), Salazar of the Indians first caught my attention reading this column and of course Betts.

Kepler, whom he profiled last summer, may be a pretty recognizable name soon. He has been promoted to the Twins though his role has mainly been as a late inning replacement.

troz
10 years ago
Reply to  Zonk

Besides Mookie and Semien, Danny Salazar and Maikel Franco were prominent successes of this series.

JoserMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  Zonk

And yet whenever I see the title, I adopt an Inigo Montoya accent and proclaim “Compelling! You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”

BipMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Zonk

And let us not forget the Corey Kluber Society.

DKH
10 years ago
Reply to  Bip

I don’t think he was Fringe Five, though. I think Corey Kluber was that unexpected pitcher who had a compelling NERD score of 10.

Psy Jung
10 years ago
Reply to  DKH

I think Kluber did come out of the Fringe Five – it makes sense, as he was an old pitcher for his level putting up good numbers.

Carlos Baerga
10 years ago

One small nit to pick: Bruce Caldwell’s second homer was off #14 Aaron West, not #28 Lance McCullers. They look almost identical in that video though, I had to watch it five times to see the difference.

senor_mike
10 years ago

Hey Carson, a couple of Mets to keep an eye on:

– Robert Gsellman, 22, AA: according to multiple reports was sitting at 93mph with his fastball and touching 98 (in the bitter cold of Binghamton NY). Last year he was topping out at 93 if I recall correctly, and posted fairly awesome groundball rates with crappy K%.

– Jeff McNeil, 24, AA: A bean-pole that added somewhere between 25-35 lbs of muscle in the off-season depending on which report you read. Always known for his quality bat/approach and positional versatility, if that added muscle actually converts to in-game power he is suddenly a very interesting dude.

zoddie
10 years ago
Reply to  senor_mike

And Mickey Jannis!

28 year old who throws a hard knuckleball. He had a no hitter into the 7th inning yesterday.

PeterJMoss
10 years ago

Most interesting thing about Locastro when he was a Jays prospect was how often he managed to get hit by pitches – which led to a great OBP. Not sure if that’s continued with the Dodgers.

formerly matt wMember since 2025
10 years ago

“he also recorded a 5:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio”

This should be a 5:1 walk-to-strikeout ratio, as a 5:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio would not be a positive sign for a position player, and is also not what happened. Though the use of the word “ratio” is a bit misleading as it is in fact 5 walks and 1 strikeout.