The Keys to the Cardinals’ Resurgence
On a hot afternoon in St. Louis on August 8, in a game that felt meaningless at the time, the Cardinals rallied for three runs in the eighth inning to tie their game with the Royals at 5–5. In the next half inning, a Paul Goldschmidt throwing error and a go-ahead single by Nicky Lopez dropped St. Louis to 55–56, mired in third place in the National League Central. The team was 10.5 games behind Milwaukee for the division lead, 8.5 games behind the Padres for the second wild card spot, and, per our Playoff Odds, had a 1.4% chance of reaching the postseason.
But following that ugly loss, back-to-back sweeps of road series in Pittsburgh and Kansas City put the Cardinals back over the .500 mark for good, and a 10-game winning streak entering Wednesday’s game in Milwaukee has them with a commanding lead for that second Wild Card spot, and the overwhelming favorites to stay that way. Since that loss to the Royals, St. Louis has gone 26–13, but those hot streaks show just how, well, streaky the team has been; those 16 wins wrap around a 10–13 run.
Still, whether the wins come in bunches or not, the Cardinals have been one of the stories of September, and that story feels largely ignored, mostly due to the five-team dogfight that is the AL Wild Card and the back-and-forth NL West battle between the Dodgers and Giants. On last week’s episode of Chin Music, Joe Sheehan and I wondered why everyone was talking about the Blue Jays and not the Cardinals in the battle of surging birds. Our take: the team is boring. The Blue Jays have swag, infectious energy and cool jackets for when somebody hits home runs. The Cardinals, meanwhile, are relative automatons, getting overshadowed by a Toronto club that is just more fun to watch.
That’s not to take anything away from St. Louis. Entertainment value be damned, this is suddenly looking like a postseason team planning to line up a surprising ace for the coin-flip game. Here are five key factors as to how the Cardinals went from under .500 six weeks ago to being in the driver’s seat for that final playoff slot.
Paul Goldschmidt Started Playing Like an MVP
It feels like the Cardinals’ recent highlight reels have been filled with the heroics of Nolan Arenado, who leads the club with 11 home runs during the 39-game return to prominence. But on the whole, the third baseman has been good but not great, with a 105 wRC+ and .231/.290/.497 triple-slash line during the stretch. Instead, the offensive leader has been Goldschmidt, who spent the first half of the season looking like a one-dimensional slugger whose age was beginning to catch up to him.
There’s no obvious and clear reason for Goldschmidt’s late-season explosion, which has him hitting .329/.413/.608 (172 wRC+) since August 10. It feels cheap to say simply that he’s gotten hot, but that’s really the case; there’s no dramatic turnaround in one area as much has there’s been improvement across the board, and in the end, his season line falls in with expectations. Arenado is getting the highlights, but it’s Goldy who put this team on his back offensively.
Tyler O’Neill Started Playing Like an MVP
In O’Neill’s case, there are two things to point out in his impressive second half, which includes a .281/.365/.563 line since the beginning of the August turnaround to go with a 148 wRC+. Certainly, there’s been some luck involved; his BABIP over that span is .377. More sustainable are greatly improved swing decisions. That’s partially a result of pitchers trying to work around his prodigious pop, but O’Neill has clearly shrunk his zone and become a more patient hitter during the second half of the season. Getting into better counts means getting better pitches to hit, and he suddenly looks like a consistent star-level player with his newfound approach at the plate.
An Unexpected New Shortstop
By struggling to stay above the Mendoza line this season, Paul DeJong lost his job in the second half to former utility man Edmundo Sosa. The thought at the time was that if you’re going to play a light bat at the position, you should at least go with the better defender. Sosa is that, but he’s now hitting as well, with a .311/.371/.495 line and 135 wRC+ since August 10. With his raw power increasing by a full grade or more over the last three years, his ability not just to make contact but also to deliver hard contact has completely changed his profile. Now the question is if Sosa’s emergence will keep the Cardinals away from the deep free-agent market at the position this offseason to use their resources elsewhere.
Surprising Bullpen Contributions
The struggles of the Cardinals during the first two-thirds of the season led to many fingers pointing in many directions, but most were pointed at the bullpen — one that couldn’t throw strikes and handed out free passes like perfume samples at a department store. There, it’s a pair of arms who didn’t join the team until early August that have played the biggest role in the relief resurgence of late.
Signed in late July off the Yankees’ scrap heap, 34-year-old journeyman righty Luis Garcia has one really good pitch in a sinker that sits in the upper-90s, and the Cardinals have him throwing said pitch more than ever. Kodi Whitley, meanwhile, came back to St. Louis in late August after a three-month stint in the minors. He doesn’t have huge stuff, but improved pitch shapes — his fastball rises a bit more and his slider drops a bit more — turned him into a more effective pitcher, and a solid changeup for use against left-handed hitters provides assurance that he can navigate a tough inning.
Since August 10, Garcia and Whitley have combined to allow just two runs over 30 innings, with the latter putting up goose eggs in all 11 appearances since his most recent promotion. Once a nightmare for manager Mike Shildt, the bullpen is suddenly a strength, and it’s thanks to a combination of shrewd player development and excellent waiver wire scrounging.
Adam Wainwright Became a Second-Half Ace
Coming out of spring training and having turned 40 in August, it felt like 2021 just might be Wainwright’s swan song. At the same time, he still had that curveball to go with plus command; it felt like he could probably go years as a dependable back-end starter who can deliver five or six innings and keep your team in the game. He’s been much more than that. In his first start after that brutal loss in August that put the Cardinals under .500, he tossed a two-hitter, and in his last eight starts, he’s allowed just ten runs over 56 innings, putting himself in position for some down-ballot Cy Young votes.
It’s a remarkable achievement for Wainwright, who rarely even touches 90 mph these days, instead relying on movement and location and mostly scrapping his straight four-seam fastball for a sinker/cutter mix, while the curveball, as always, remains highly effective and is thrown at any point in count at a variety of locations. Jon Lester, who Jay Jaffe went into more detail on here, has helped as well (as has J.A. Happ, who’s pitched to a similar ERA and FIP as Lester but with less fanfare), but while he is more than a bit over his skis of late, that’s not the case for Wainwright, who already has said that he’s going to pitch next year. At this rate, going beyond that wouldn’t surprise anyone.
Kevin Goldstein is a National Writer at FanGraphs.


FYI Wainwright turned 40 this August, 2021, not 2020 as the article seems to claim
Fixed. Thanks.
As a KC fan I don’t favor the Cards. But I am amazed by their resurgence.
Watching them nightly, I’m very impressed at the overall team defense, especially in the outfield. Bader and O’Neill seem to run down almost everything that doesn’t look like a sure gapper, and they even run down some of those.
Just looked over at the fieldingbible.com site, and the Cardinals are No. 1 in defensive runs saved, with 84, 25% more than the second-place teams (Rays and, uh, the Rangers?).
They are the only team with positive runs-saved totals from all nine positions, and their 34 outfield runs saved also leads MLB.
Like you, I watch them every night, and this doesn’t surprise me. This series against the Brewers — which has featured JBJ and Cain in the OF — has been incredible in the contrast between the two defenses. And the Brewers are one of the better defensive teams in the league.
This Cardinals team is incredibly athletic, and this season has been the continuation of a long maturation process for guys like O’Neill, Bader, Carlson, and Edman. The explosion of Sosa is something of a surprise and may not be sustainable, but the overall shape of his production is roughly what was expected of DeJong.
It’s definitely not a great team. But it is an exciting one if you care to look. If they do make it past the wild card game then they could be very obnoxious in the longer series.
It also hasn’t helped the Brewers than Yelich is LF can barely throw the ball right now, while Urias at 3B has also been a defensive nightmare for them.
Edmundo Sosa’s the new Brandon Guyer.
Man how impressive is the Cardinals franchise? Only one losing season in the past TWENTY years. They just keep plugging along with these same old boring teams year after year. I can’t stand the Cardinals but wow I respect the consistency.
Really gives the lie to the idea that small market teams can’t compete without endless cycles of tanking and rebuilding. St. Louis is roughly the same size as Pittsburgh, and Nielsen ranks them as the #23 and 24 media markets in the US.
I think it’s worth noting that although St. Louis is not a large metro area the franchise is very well-off. They make a lot of money even compared to other teams, and their resources are on par with teams in much larger areas. But of course, the reason for that is because they’ve cultivated a fan base for over 50 years by consistently showing that they’re trying, keeping beloved stars, and winning enough to keep everyone happy.
Yeah they have a very devoted fan base. My view is probably biased some since I live within their “home range” but Cardinals fans really support their team. They’re always wearing Cardinals gear and even people who didn’t live all that close to St. Louis make regular trips to the ballpark. And yeah I think you’re right. The franchise has really cultivated a winning culture. The fans expect to win and the team consistently puts a winning product on the field.
I’m of the mind that fans don’t mind rebuilding, but they do mind if it looks like you aren’t trying to put a winning team on the field to save money. Sometimes, things go wrong and the best course of action is to take a step back. But when you start acting cheap fans do not like that at all. You can see this with the Marlins and Pirates, who have managed to wreck their fanbase by repeatedly signaling they’re worried about costs. The Brewers under Bud Selig were like that too. Probably doesn’t help the A’s or the Clevelands or the Rays either, even though they win a lot more.
The Cardinals have been successful by almost every measure, and very consistent too. Not every team can do that. But every team can, if they work hard enough at it for long enough, make fans think that they want to win as much as the fans do. And the Cardinals have worked at that for a very long time. I think it shows with the fan support.
Even when the Cardinals do have bad years, they never tear it all down. They’ve finished in last place in their league/division just once (1990) over the last century!
Just one last-place finish, and they are one of two teams who have never, in the history of the draft, had an overall #1 or #2 pick. (Trivia question: what’s the other team?)
They get plenty of comp picks though you must agree. Despite dominating the Bible belt with Super torch KMOX. Hillbillies just splooge over the mention of their superior ways.
Pretty sure it’s the Red Sox.
Another fun fact: The Cards used their highest-ever pick, #3 in 1996, on Braden Looper, a RHRP. Two years later, he was part of the package that brought Edgar Renteria to St. Louis.
The Cards’ last single-digit pick was J.D. Drew, #5 in 1998. He’s been out of the game since 2011, but the guy he was traded for is still going strong.
Red Sox it is. The Yankees memorably blew it with Brien Taylor as a #1. Ron Blomberg had been a #1 way back, and did have a major-league career of sorts. Coincidentally, that was the same year that Boston used their only #3 on Mike Garman.
Did you say winning or whining?
He asks, whiningly.
Don’t the Cardinals also have Nashville, Memphis, Little Rock, etc. TV markets as well?
Maybe but it’s impressive that they can get people in those places to care about them, watch on TV and drive to St Louis to games, getting a hotel in the process. Arkansas and Tennessee were thought to be all about football.
In the summer what else are people in Memphis and Nashville going to watch over the summer? Predators, grizzlies, college, and pro football largely doesn’t overlap
Sure, but they don’t have much of Illinois, almost none of the Plains, and not even all of Missouri.
Little Rock has like 2/3 of the population of Durham, NC. It’s not a huge media advantage.
It’s a shame that the Arkansas Travelers aren’t a Cardinals affiliate anymore. They were with them from 1966 to 2000. I feel like that really helped the Cardinals to solidify their presence in Arkansas
Nashville, memphis, little rock, Columbia MO, Springfield MO, and St Louis have a combined 7M+ in their combined metros.
Nashville is mostly Braves in my experience, but Memphis and Little Rock are both mostly Cardinals. I live in Arkansas and the Cardinals have a very loyal fanbase here. I know a number of people who watch most of their games on tv and they make the trip up to St. Louis at last once a season.
Yes,which is why using metros is a dated metric. Their TV market is massive compared to others you might consider similar on the surface.
Lol . Small market team. They get a comp pick every time the president farts . Get out of here with that typical BFIB fake humble brag.
The ratio of Cards’ fans who refer to themselves as the BFIB to the number of other people who accuse them of using that term about themselves is something on the order of 1:1,000. It’s a sure tell you don’t actually know many Cardinals fans.
Maybe now, but having lived in MO most of my life, in the mid 2000s it was rampant.
Fair enough. We must have different crowds, b/c I’ve only heard Cardinals fans use it ironically.
They have massive TV market. Look at one of the color coded blackout maps. Metro markets is a dated metric.
Actually, it’s 21 winning seasons in 22 years and counting with their 82nd win tonight.
Yeeehawww!!! We have discovered how to be completely irrelevant while simultaneously being able to cultivate the maximum dollars from the trump base. MEDIOCRITY FOREVVA!!! LONG LIVE THE BIRDS ON THE BAT!! Stan Musial broke the color barrier…. little known fact.
Sure, if mediocrity means 2 Championships, 4 Pennants, and many other playoff appearances since the turn of the Century.
While they may rarely win 100+ games with their methods (although they even managed to do that in 2004, 2005, and 2015), when you try to just always be an above-average team, it doesn’t take much luck to get to 90+ wins and a likely playoff spot, and then the playoffs are largely a craps shoot, anyway.
This cardinals run has been fun to watch, but Waino has been nothing short of special. The guy seems to pitch off pure will and precision. Football is the game of inches but Waino plays a game of millimeters. Incredible at 40.
If he hadn’t had that bad stretch of injuries and ineffectiveness from 2015-18, people would be campaigning for him to join the Hall of Fame.
Lmfao….no…just no.
The Cardinals are boring because it feels like they’re here every year, not because of the players. It would be easy to have some hype for Wainwright and Molina if they were one team career guys for a host of other teams. It’s the same reason that (despite some FG authors), I just don’t see any third party or casual fans viewing the Giants as plucky upstarts defying the odds this year when they won 3 World Series last decade (3 since the last time the Yankees won), despite the presence of the Dodgers.
I don’t know, I feel like Wainwright and Molina get a lot of hype for being team career guys. There are only a few teams I can think of that you’d hear more about if if they were.
It’s hard because there aren’t many one-career guys anymore but the only one-career guys that we heard about more were Mariano Rivera and David Ortiz, and both of them were legendary postseason / World Series performers across multiple years in two of the biggest and most visible markets in baseball who announced their retirement a full year before they left, when they were still good, and had “farewell tours.” Good luck parsing out the details on which ones were the main factors. Dustin Pedroia, Joe Mauer, Felix Hernandez, Matt Cain, David Wright, Ryan Howard, Alex Gordon, and Ryan Braun were a shell of themselves at the end and their retirements were anti-climactic. The same will likely be true for Votto, although he seems determined to turn back the clock a bit. Is Ryan Zimmerman retired? He sure seems like it, but I don’t even know. Do people talk about Buster Posey still? I think Molina, at least, still gets a ton of love.
Big papi played for the Twins
Technically, yes, but I don’t think anyone knows that unless they are literally looking at his player page.
Ortiz was not a one-team player, he started with the Twins.
> The same will likely be true for Votto, although he seems determined to turn back the clock a bit.
> Do people talk about Buster Posey still?
These sentences made more sense six months ago, not when they are hitting wrc+ 140 with 4 WAR.
Really, though, do people still talk about Posey? I feel like the Giants have been mostly invisible this year, which is remarkable since they’re still one game up on the Dodgers. And Posey has been awesome.
A simple Google search for “Buster Posey MVP” reveals multiple articles written this year. So yes, people still talk about Posey as he always delivers in the clutch.
Pretty good point re Posey and his “clutch” numbers. Just like Molina, Buster Posey has a career OPS nearly 100 points higher with men on base than with the bases empty. (MLB average differential is typically around 40 points.) Over such a large sample, it’s worth praising as more than random fluctuation — for both players.
On the other hand of course, instead of calling them “clutch,” we could instead describe them as two batters who have trouble concentrating when nobody’s on base. But personally I prefer the glass-half-full characterization of clutchiness.
Molina sure does seem to get a lot of love. Zimmerman still a meh platoon bat. I hear a fair amount about Posey. I for one doubt Votto will be a shell of himself when he retires. He figured out what he could do to adjust, and did it. He doesn’t strike me as a guy who is going to be bad when he retires. Maybe he will have another season that he isn’t great, like a league average bat, but I’d imagine he nearly assuredly gets a farewell tour.
Agreed. I think the narrative the Cardinals are “boring” is lazy, because if you watch the team nightly, they have a lot of fun players to watch. Bader, O’Neill, Sosa are very fun and easy to root for. In the bullpen, despite their bouts with command and some struggles, Reyes and Cabrera have electric stuff. I can get Goldschmidt maybe a little on the boring side, but Nolan Arenado is super exciting to watch. I definitely believe it’s a matter of fatigue people have with seeing the Cardinals consistently be good. With the Bluejays (And Padres before the collapse) they seem more “fun” because they have more young stars, so it feels fresh and different.
^this
Agree. Obviously entertainment value is a matter of taste, so I wouldn’t say Kevin and Joe Sheehan are wrong exactly. I’ll also cop to the Cards putting out some pretty pizzazzless teams (emphasis on zzzz) the past few years, even when they were winning. But this 2021 team has a lot of really fun elements: some serious burners on the base paths (O’Neill, Bader, Sosa, and Edman all among the very fastest players in baseball), some truly acrobatic defense (Bader is like Cirque du Soleil every night), some nice human-interest stories (Waino, Molina, and Lester still chugging along after so many years in the trenches), and some swagger from guys like Arenado, O’Neill, Bader, Sosa, and Cabrera. And of course the narrative of a team stuck in neutral all season suddenly turning on the after-burners down the stretch is inherently not boring. I think a lot of people just lean on an old formula that says Cardinals = buttoned-up Midwest rectitude and stop thinking any further.
apologies for saying similar things absent the use of rectitude.
also, the cards get their cy young quality SP Flaherty back friday night. Hiw many other teams could surge absent their ace?
The boring narrative must have been written by kris bryant. *wink*
the outfield defense of oneill, bader, and carlson is far from boring. molina boring? since when?
Baders baserunning, tagging 2 bases on a deep fly to cain at the track?
the get a “game break” play almost every night. They have veterans, exciting players, and play a speed, power, and defense brand of ball.
I think the “boring” narrative stems from being consistent and being located in the midwest. Theyre not dominant in any offense category, which may be where the boring comes from. but its not accurate.
It’s a classic Cardinals team in that regard. They aren’t incredibly young, or old, or an entire generation of guys who spent a whole career together. It’s a mix of young guys and mid career guys and old guys, with most of them playing at a level individually that you have to be like “Paul Goldschmidt? 4 wins? Eh, sounds about right” and then all of a sudden you’ve got a team in pretty good position without having the best player at any spot
It feels like they are never here. They occupy the endless middle. It never changes. No one out of St Louis notices them.
Yes, no one but you, who’s evidently obsessed by them.
Great analysis. Is there anything about the teams culture that helps them achieve? Or did everything just drop into place with folks getting hot just in time for the playoff push.
I ask about culture because for the last 2 decades StL seems like the quietest successful organization. You never hear about them until you see the. In the playoffs
TJ McFarland is another unsung hero down in that ‘pen.
It seems like every time I tune into a STL game McFarland is either warming up or in the game.
Wade LeBlanc was also another excellent waiver wire pickup in both the bullpen and rotation before he got hurt.
I find it impossible to believe that this surge has nothing to do with John Gant and Carlos Martinez no longer pitching for the Cardinals (and I believe Oviedo’s role has been reduced as well?).
Almost nothing else of this group sounds sustainable…well, Goldschmidt and O’Neill and Wainwright will probably still be good even if they’re not playing out of their minds, so part of their resurgence is probably sustainable. But I still think they’re still going to get that second wild card spot because even if everyone regresses back to their own personal average performance, having actual starting pitchers to roll out there makes a world of difference.
For the most part, throwing strikes is better than throwing balls and the Cards as a team are throwing a lot more strike the past 2 months.
I always see” triple-slash line” and think – ‘but there are only two slashes’.
It’s especially important to not give away free passes when you have the best defense in the league and a very pitcher-friendly ballpark.
Carlos Martinez was never that bad this year. It’s just that he either pitched well or got blown out a similar number of times, and those blow outs really inflated his ratios.
In any case, yes, some of the improvements have been additions by subtraction, and you can add Tyler Webb, Daniel Ponce de Leon, and Junior Fernandez to that list, as well as Justin Miller until he recently from the IL and has so far been much better.
Anyway, Mikolas is now back in form, and Flaherty will be back from the IL on Friday, so the Cardinals could actually have a sneaky good playoff rotation (if they get past the Wild Card game) with Wainwright, Mikolas, Flaherty, and Lester/Happ, depending on how much Flaherty can get built back up in time for the playoffs.
Carlos Martinez was terrible this year, and last year as well. That’s what terrible pitchers do: they pitch effectively sometimes, and are dreadful the rest of the time.
That’s how he ended up with a 7+ ERA over the 2020/21 seasons. The FIP is more like 5.20, but with an excellent defense behind him, you can’t claim he was betrayed by his fielders. He’s lost it, plain & simple.
The question is, which southpaw on the wrong side of 30 will they try to retain for next year’s rotation? Kim, Lester, LeBlanc, or Happ? The latter three are on the wrong side of 35, of course…but hey, lefties pitch forever sometimes. And this team needs much more starting pitcher depth in 2022 than they had coming out of Spring Training this year.
Not just sometimes, he pitched well about half the time this year and almost never had just a mediocre start. That’s a lot more valuable than his surface numbers would indicate. If your starting pitcher gives you a good chance to win the game in half of his starts, that’s not terrible. It’s not that great either, but it’s still acceptable for a back-end starter and why he wasn’t actually dropped from the rotation until he got hurt.
Yes, they do need to pick up starting pitching depth (as well as bullpen help) this offseason, but they actually had great depth at the beginning of this season. It’s just that most of it (Flaherty, Mikolas, Martinez, Gant, Ponce de Leon, Oviedo, at times Kim and Woodford) went sideways for one or more reasons, but they were 7 or 8 deep in what were supposed to be decent starting options early on.
Martinez wasn’t dropped from the rotation despite a tragic ERA well over 6.00 mainly because Mike Shildt is an idiot. After the June 24 shelling in which Martinez allowed 7 walks and 5 runs in 5 innings, his ERA stood at 6.78 and Shildt STILL would not remove him from the rotation. Shildt manages partly by payroll, which is why Carpenter, Fowler, and Carlos Martinez got far more action during his tenure than they should have, and partly by what he remembers a player used to be. Blame it on the front office if you like, but the manager fills out the lineup card, so that’s where the buck stops.
I lean toward optimism when it comes to the Cards and pitchers, but c’mon now. At the start of the year Johan Oviedo was a part of “great depth”? He’s a big unpolished rock who has never had an ERA under 4.20 anywhere, at ANY professional level where he threw 40+ innings. Oviedo was predictably bad in 2021, just as in 2020. And John Gant is a good reliever who never belonged in a rotation, because he lacks viable command of almost all his pitches. (Same with Alex Reyes, by the way, who has zero future as a starting arm.)
Carlos Martinez was coming off a 2020 season with an ERA near 10.00 — he was an interesting longshot, due to his history of success. But he was not a quality depth piece by any stretch. Mikolas was returning from injury, Flaherty was mediocre in 2020. You were and are kidding yourself, fellow Birdfan. In March the rotation was as thin and combustible as flash paper, and it’s just as thin entering the offseason.
Yeah, it is shocking that Carlos Martinez got to pitch 100 innings over the last couple years, and anyone who argues that he was okay is on drugs. I do have a sneaking suspicion that xERA underrates ground ball pitchers like Martinez but even so it’s awfully close to his ERA and he walks more guys than he should considering he doesn’t strike out guys much anymore.
Carlos Martinez might not even get a major league contract once his option gets declined. I’d maybe consider bringing him into camp on a minors contract to compete for a reliever position but he looks so busted right now. Maybe not as much as someone like Shelby Miller, whose career is probably over. But he’s behind Dylan Bundy, Vince Velazquez, and Drew Smyly on the reclamation project list for sure.
Honestly, the Cardinals have NOT been boring at all. They’re elite defensively and their starters all pitch to contact, so you see more good plays than a usual game. They’re also stealing some bases lately (Edman, Sosa, Bader and ONeil are very fast) and it’s been a blast watching a team like that. The Cardinals bumping the meta this season
They even scored 2 runs on a sacrifice fly tonight, and they recently had a runner score from 1st base on a single (without the trail runner slipping or anything like that)!
If this exact roster were on a different team, I think people would genuinely love them. They are the best defensive club in MLB, making flashy plays every game. They also have multiple players with 90+ percentile speed (Bader, O’Neill, Edman, Sosa). What’s more exciting than acrobatic defense and blistering speed? In the pen, they have three relievers who can touch 100 mph, and none of them are even the best reliever on the team!
Bader and Sosa have flair for days, and Arenado obviously has fire. From a purely aesthetic viewpoint, baseball fans should enjoy watching this team. It being the Cardinals dampens the love, but what can you do?
A quick note on Goldy. I believe he hurt his back in spring training, and it didn’t quite heal up for the start of the year. If you look at his wRC+ splits by month, you can almost see him getting healthy:
Mar/Apr 64
May 114
June 129
July 161
August 165
Sept/Oct (as of yesterday) 163
He’s been pretty ridiculous, almost vintage, Goldy since the beginning of July.
Regarding Goldschmidt’s emergence in the second-half, I remember that during that relatively poor first-half he was putting up pretty impressive statcast numbers which seemed to continually expect him to break out soon. Thing was, Matt Carpenter had a similar story the first couple months! But where he dropped off a cliff this summer (not unexpected), Goldschmidt finally started to get results that his peripherals would suggest.
The Jays don’t play a better brand of baseball than the Cardinals, but they do have glamorous new stars like Guerrero and Bichette. Also they’re thought to be a World Series contender whereas the Cardinals are thought to be cannon fodder for the Dodgers in the WC game.
You can never call any team cannon fodder for a single game. The issue is that they (or whoever wins the 2nd NL Wild Card) have to beat either the Dodgers or Giants in that one game, and then they have to beat the other one in a best-of-5 series just to get to the NLCS.
Yes, Sosa is technically a better defender, but DeJong is also a really good defender. The main reason for the switch is that Sosa has been outhitting Dejong ever since he was called up back in late April, not just recently.
It wasn’t just an early small sample size, either, as Sosa got a lot of playing time while DeJong was on the IL, and aside from the occasional homer Dejong has failed to hit decently both before and after his injury this year.
the rest of baseball not paying attention to the cards is nothing new. last night they saved the win in the 8th with a walk by rookie lars nootbaar, a stolen base, and a single by tommy edman who surprise leads the NL in doubles… classic cardinal baseball. red and whitey would be proud. hopefully we’ll meet up with tony in the fall classic. c u there.
Respectfully, I think you’re missing the biggest reason. The Cardinals excel at three things that baseball players can control: pitchers throwing strikes and limiting free passes, batters not giving away any bats, and – perhaps most importantly – not giving up many of your 27 precious outs per game on the bases. Watching the Cardinals / Mets series was a constant reminder of how fundamentally poor the Mets are.
The biggest market inefficiency in baseball right now seems to be the fundamentals of baseball. The Cardinals are one of the few teams that seem to coach and play like they understand it.
Sorry, but the first at least isn’t supported by the data. STL is 2nd worst in the league in BB/9 and bottom 5 in CSW. Not sure what you base #2 on, but their BB/9 as hitters isn’t special either, nor CSW as hitters. I guess they’re in Top 5 by BsR, but that doesn’t have a ton of weight in WAR models…
CSW is a measure of a pitcher’s true skill. That’s not the same thing as what I said; if anything, it makes what they’re doing even MORE impressive because CSW would suggest that the Cardinals are in the bottom 20% of the league in pitching talent. Meanwhile, you’re looking at full-season stats and we’re talking about a couple dozen games (i.e., “The Cardinals Resurgence,” the title of the article).
Re: #2, how is hitter BB/9 a proxy for “batters not giving away any at bats”? I didn’t say they excelled at drawing walks. All of your batting references are to stats that will naturally be dragged down by their middle-of-the-pack standing in extra base hits… but I never said that doubles or homers was their forte.
So, you’ve created a strawman.
Well, if we’re being real, I think all of what you wrote is gobbleygook nonsense, but I was just pointing out that even if you tried to frame data around it, it wouldn’t tell the story you’re trying to tell. Its a baseball analytics website, you should expected to be challenged on your assertions when they have zero basis in analytics…
Also, the stats I listed are pretty much the same looking at 2nd half splits.
Well, (s)he’s talking about more recently after the Cardinals essentially remade their pitching staff mid-season. Yes, they gave up a ton of walks in the first half of the season, and although I still don’t think they’re currently that good at avoiding free passes, the pitchers they have now are overall a lot better at throwing strikes than they were before.
“STL is 2nd worst in the league in BB/9” That means they’ve made massive improvements during this streak because for basically the entire season they’ve been worst in that category by an enormous margin.
They have indeed, based on the way they remade their staff in August.
I mean, the title of the article is about the recent resurgence. That’s what we’re talking about.
I think you misspelled “Cardinals devil magic”…
cardinal devil magic is usually reserved for when they obtain a player thats either underperformed, been injured, is aging, etc and they play very well in their time in StL … cesar cedeno, will clark, ryan ludwick, allen craig, joel pineiro, suppan/williams, berkman, beltran, freeze, etc.
im hoping flaherty comes back friday and gets to top form, throw him into this mix and theres our devil magic for 2021
I wouldn’t count Flaherty; he was a first-round draft choice (and one that they made a cost-saving choice earlier in the round to free up money for), pretty well devastated the minors, and was anointed a future ace more or less on arrival in the Show. Pretty normal stuff, relatively speaking.
Craig is also unlike the others you name, having been a Cardinals draftee, but taken low enough (8th round I think) that nobody saw him coming. That is another manifestation of CDM: high value out of low draft choices — like, say, their 13th round pick in 1999, who has had a bit of a career playing for them, the Angels and the Dodgers.
Cards Devil Magic can mean a few different things, but to the extent that it’s about magically transforming journeymen into useful players (I’d add Lester, Luis Garcia, and TJ McFarland to your list, rbemont), the past couple years have been very much about REVERSE Cards Devil Magic. Think of all the players traded or let go by the Cards who have gone on to shine elsewhere: Wisdom, Voit, Ozuna, Arozarena, Alcantara, Lynn, Gallen, Carson Kelly, Rafael Ortega, Lane Thomas, etc. Which is to say there’s some confirmation bias going on with the whole Cards Devil Magic idea – people remember the reclamation projects who succeed on the Cardinals’ watch, but not the ones who don’t.
They’re just not that good…clearly some kind of devil-magic.
The Yankees have won the most World Series’ since the World Series started, but the Cardinals are a strong #2. They have essentially always been decent, good, or great! If you win year in and year out for decades you cultivate a fan base that cares through generations. Then as your city goes through good and bad times it doesn’t matter cause the fans will come to games regardless. The problem with most other franchises is that they care far more for immediate wins and immediate profit than the Cardinals. The cardinals have always played the long term profit game and thus they get the long term profit success we are seeing now. If only all businesses worked this way our economy would rarely suffer.
The key? A portrait of Yadier Molina and Adam Wainwright that grows uglier each season, while the Cardinals’ battery continues leading them to playoff berth after playoff berth. The portrait is in La Russa’s house, but he forgot to show up to the painting session.