The Market Was Stacked Against Jason Hammel
Jason Hammel isn’t yet officially a member of the Royals. He still has to pass a physical, and we’ve been burned before when we’ve jumped the gun. Yet the odds are that Hammel will soon officially join the Royals, and he’ll do so on a two-year guarantee worth $16 million. I’ve personally never signed a two-year guarantee worth $16 million, and I can’t imagine I’m going to, unless FanGraphs gets incredibly popular. Hammel is coming out of this with a nice chunk of change.
On the other hand, we’re a week into February, meaning spring training is right around the corner. Hammel got two years where he really wanted three, and this offer might not have even existed were it not for a horrible accident claiming the life of Yordano Ventura. The Royals were more or less forced into this position, and the offseason for Hammel wasn’t what he thought it would be. Looking back, I suppose there’s not much mystery. Hammel’s representatives were fighting something of an uphill battle.
We can start easy. What’s one reason why Hammel might not have been able to draw much of a market? He’s 34 years old. Teams tend to shy away from making significant commitments to players Hammel’s age. There are exceptions, in the cases of really really good players, but Hammel is only really really good relative to you. In the majors, he’s basically average, and 34-year-olds get worse. Sometimes, they stay the same. But then they get worse. Everybody gets worse.
Then there’s the matter of the Cubs declining Hammel’s option. This was sold as a great gesture, and it even probably was. The Cubs were said to be honoring an arrangement where they wouldn’t trade Hammel or limit his future earnings by putting him in the bullpen. But Hammel’s option was for only $12 million, and it came with a $2-million buyout, meaning it would’ve cost the Cubs just $10 million to pick up. Teams were inevitably going to react with skepticism. Hammel ended last season with elbow discomfort, and other teams weren’t sure he was okay.
Tying into that, Hammel leans heavily on his slider. It’s a good slider, and Hammel knows it, and he throws it more than a third of the time. Last season, 181 starters threw at least 50 innings. Hammel had the sixth-highest slider rate among them, and sliders have a negative perception when it comes to a pitcher’s longer-term health. Teams weren’t sure if Hammel’s arm was sound, and the slider rate to some extent justified the concern. Even now, the Royals can’t be totally sure Hammel can hold up.
And there’s one more interesting twist. On the matter of Hammel’s stamina and durability — for his career, he has a 3.99 first-half ERA, and a 5.06 second-half ERA. I’ll grant that ERA isn’t a good statistic. I’ll also grant that season half splits are quick and sloppy. But a lot of people around the league think of Hammel as a pitcher who wears down, and for some evidence, over the past two decades, there are 184 pitchers who have thrown at least 500 innings in each half. Here are the 10 worst splits by OPS allowed.
| Pitcher | 1H OPS | 2H OPS | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chris Sale | 0.588 | 0.682 | 0.094 |
| Nate Robertson | 0.756 | 0.848 | 0.092 |
| Jason Hammel | 0.721 | 0.805 | 0.084 |
| Johnny Cueto | 0.641 | 0.725 | 0.084 |
| Edinson Volquez | 0.709 | 0.787 | 0.078 |
| Edwin Jackson | 0.743 | 0.811 | 0.068 |
| Jered Weaver | 0.662 | 0.729 | 0.067 |
| Brad Penny | 0.733 | 0.791 | 0.058 |
| Josh Fogg | 0.794 | 0.852 | 0.058 |
| Chris Capuano | 0.746 | 0.802 | 0.056 |
There are some good pitchers on that list, like Sale and Cueto. They don’t suffer from the same kind of perception problem. But Hammel’s split is indeed enormous — it’s the third-biggest out of everyone, where the total pitcher pool has an average split of -0.001. Hammel had problems down the stretch last year. He had problems down the stretch the year before, and he lasted just 4.1 innings over two playoff starts. Plenty of teams like the idea of Jason Hammel as a starter, but you just can’t know what you’ll have in September.
I don’t know how much of this is fair, versus how much of this is random noise. Much of Hammel’s ugly split comes down to quality of contact allowed, and that can bounce all over the place. But something we don’t talk about enough is the stretch-run and playoff bonus that gets built into certain contracts. High-leverage relievers get more money, and front-of-the-rotation starters get more money, in part because they’re being compensated for postseason value. Even though no team is guaranteed to make the playoffs, there’s always some chance, and you know which players might become more important in October.
With a guy like Hammel, you very well might not want to use him in October. You might not even trust him in September or August. It’s not that that’s certain, and it’s not that he doesn’t help a team out in the earlier months, but as the games get more and more important, the idea is that Hammel gets less and less reliable. And to an executive, that’s negative value. It means Hammel might not help if your own team makes the playoffs, and it means another team might not want Hammel so bad in the event your team has to sell near the deadline.
In short, Jason Hammel suffers from a perception problem. His age, his stats, his being left off the Cubs’ playoff roster — it all informs a general lack of trust in his ability to keep pitching well as a season wears on. For the Royals, maybe that means this is a buy-low opportunity on a legitimate No. 3 starter. Heaven knows that would help fill a void. But this is a risk, a risk that reminds us to consider just what a team is paying for. The best baseball seasons stretch for seven months, and they don’t all mean the same thing.
Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.


The Royals definitely had a strong need after Ventura, but at the price he ended up going for, I really wish that the Indians had snagged him. Salazar and Carrasco have both had health/consistency issues, and Hammel is definitely better than Tomlin. I would have thought that after the rotation was exposed in the postseason (even though the fill-ins performed well), that the Indians would have been in the market for a mid-rotation arm. Just seems like such a missed opportunity for them.
Idea might be to use him as the 5th starter, keeps his innings down early. That will get sorted out in ST among Hammel, Karns, and the returning from injury Vargas. Royals were desperate but this might not be bad. Big park should help him.
ned yost isnt really the type of guy to give breaks or cut down on innings. i know salvador perez isnt a pitcher, but yost ALWAYS talks about giving sal a rest…it never happens:
heres yost saying in december 2014 that “i cant catch sal 150 games again. i cant. ill kill the kid.”
http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/mlb-big-league-stew/salvador-perez-needs-more-rest-next-year-and-ned-yost-knows-it-014713546.html
heres a royals review article from may 2015 about how yost is running sal into the ground:
http://www.royalsreview.com/2015/5/14/8600203/ned-yost-is-running-salvador-perez-into-the-ground
heres a fangraphs article discussing how not-serious yost is about this problem from april 2015:
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/monitoring-salvador-perezs-workload/
and my favorite, a semi-serious article on how yost gave perez “an inning off” back in may 2015:
http://www.foxsports.com/kansas-city/story/kansas-city-royals-manager-ned-yost-opts-to-give-banged-up-salvador-perez-an-inning-off-052415
perez has played the most games @ C since 2013. if yost manages hammel to be a second half work horse, it first requires good management in the first half. given his track record of grinding perez behind the plate, i cannot find any proof that suggests yost will do it.
I wouldn’t take his treatment of Perez as indicative of his treatment of everyone. Above all else, Yost likes predictability. Perez is a very different kind of catcher from any backup they’ve had for him, and the catcher’s abilities (as game caller as well as defensively) have a huge impact on how the game proceeds. Switching Perez out makes things unpredictable, and he’s not going to make things unpredictable when they can be predictable.
If you enter the season saying “We’re going to skip Hammel when we can” he can roll with that. If you enter the season saying “If Hammel’s doing okay let him go but if he seems tight skip him to keep his arm fresh” he might never get skipped. That requires interventionist managing, and Yost is famously non-interventionist. He’s said that a lot of the time when he’s tempted to make a move, his next step is to just wait and see, and often the issue works itself out. If you apply the same thing to limiting a pitcher’s innings, you probably won’t do it very well. But a plan is a plan is a plan and he’s pretty good at sticking to a plan, whatever it is.
I have no clue if that’s the right move, but I wouldn’t discount the possibility of it happening.
My thought is that with early off-days and rain outs that Hammel can be fairly easily limited. Not like he would be subbed for, as Salvy would, but that’s also a possibility with Chris Young and later AAA arms rotating up.
Hammel doesn’t go deep in games or deep in seasons. He’s a useful pitcher but you won’t get 180 innings out of him in a calendar year.
Question for Jeff, or anyone else who knows the answer: are the Cubs’ medical records on Hammel disclosed at any point in the free agent signing process?
I haven’t been able to find an answer to that question in a Google search. Team medical records are disclosed as part of due diligence in trade negotiations, and we read all the time about player physicals to finalize free agent signings. But does a team signing a free agent get access to his prior team’s medical records, either as part of the physical or at some earlier point in the process?
This is what I’ve been harping on: Hammel can be a decent 1st half guy, but he’ll be an absolute black hole in the 2nd half. Fans have to realize that he’s a mid-30s non-innings eater 5th starter that was reportedly demanding 3 years and Bartolo money…and that’s not to mention the health concerns on top of it all. There’s a reason this dude has been unsigned for this long, and it’s not so hard to figure out if you look just a teensy bit closer at his peripherals.
And one year later, I still don’t understand why the Tigers panicked and gave Mike Pelfrey 2/$16M.
Or why the Rockies gave Mike Dunn 3/19
They’re the Tigers and Rockies.
Question: Do teams always have insurance policies to cover players prorated salary in case of injury? If so, does it really matter how big an injury risk a 4th or 5th starter is, especially if he’s fringe replacement level by year end anyway?
Short answer: no, teams don’t always insure contracts, and even if they do there are plenty of reasons that they still care about injury risk.
There’s a more complete answer about typical terms of insurance in this article – http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/insuring-prince-fielder/ . The strong implication of it is that insurance, depending on the policy, usually kicks in only after a long absence (something like 90 days to 1 year) and only covers something like 50% to 80% of the salary after that point.
Insurance also isn’t magic: it’s priced based on the insured risk. If a team is asking an insurer to cover Jason Hammel’s against injury, including injury to an elbow with known discomfort last season, then the premium is going to reflect risk.
There also other non-salary reasons for a team to care. Hammel still takes up a 25-man and 40-man roster spot while he’s healthy. It’s true that a player doesn’t take up a roster spot if he’s moved to the 60-day disabled list during the season, but at that point the replacement options are limited to the in-season trade market, a team’s minor leaguers, and released players passing through waivers.
So, Chris Sale in the second half of a season is worse than Jered Weaver in the first half of a season? And a Johnny Cueto second half trails an Edison Volquez first half? Seems like some eye opening (if unfair) comparisons.
I really don’t think there is a perception problem because perception appears to reflect reality. He’s old. Doesn’t have a consistent track record, has never 180+ IP in a season, and had scary elbow soreness to end last season. He’s a 5th starter that a great defense can make look like a #4.
I’m both a Royals and Cub fan so I was and now have a vested interest in Hammel. In short….he’s an NL type pitcher. Except for 2012 he was below average when he was in the AL. His career splits show his ERA is a full run higher in the second half. I don’t call that perception. That being said if healthy I fully expect that with KC’s defense he’ll do well in the first half. I also think as suggested by others he’d be better off as a 5th starter so that he can be skipped early in the season in hopes he can be usefull in the second half.
Hammel murdered the A’s a couple years ago. Terrible trade throw in because he was so much worse than replacement.
Front office just has to know when to pull the plug and bring someone up from AAA who is ready in AUG/SEP, move Hammel to the mop up/long/spot role.