The Time Is Not Right to Trade Andrew McCutchen
A few weeks ago, when the Pirates got swept by the Cardinals, while also losing Gerrit Cole and Francisco Cervelli to the DL the same weekend, I noted that the Pirates might have to be a seller this summer, as their playoff odds has dropped down to 14%, and it was looking like this might not be their season. Well, in the two weeks since I wrote that post, their playoff odds have continued their freefall.
As it stands this morning, we’re projecting the Pirates to finish at 80-82, and with the Cubs, Nationals, and Giants all looking like they’ll finish north of 90 wins, that leaves the Mets, Dodgers, Cardinals, and Marlins all looking like Wild Card contenders, each with expected totals between 85-90 wins. To make it into the Wild Card game, the Pirates would have to leapfrog over three of those four teams; that would require them to play at over a .600 clip the rest of the season, most likely, and this doesn’t look like a team that is likely to go on that kind of sustained run.
So barring a miraculous turnaround over the next month, the Pirates are going to be sellers. According to the rumor mill, teams are already kicking the tires on Mark Melancon and Francisco Liriano, and as the deadline draws closer, it’s easy to imagine interest growing in the team’s other contract-year role players like David Freese, Neftali Feliz, and Sean Rodriguez. But with the team looking like a likely seller, attention has turned to a less-likely trade target, with speculation mounting that perhaps now is the time for the Pirates to trade Andrew McCutchen.
On the one hand, I can see why Pirates fans have begun to wonder if this is the time to move their franchise player. McCutchen is in the midst of the worst year of his career, and his struggles are part of the reason for the team’s disappointing first half. There’s also an inevitability to McCutchen’s exit from Pittsburgh, as he’s set to hit the free agent market after the 2018 season, and it’s nearly impossible to imagine the Pirates paying market price for a 32 year old with his track record. Unless he decides to give the Pirates the largest hometown discount in MLB history, they’re going to have to trade him at some point. And with Austin Meadows crushing Double-A pitching as a 21 year old, it’s not impossible to imagine that the team could have McCutchen’s replacement ready by 2017, making an earlier trade than expected more palatable.
But despite having a few arrows pointing in the direction of trading McCutchen, I don’t think this is the right time for the Pirates to move their best player.
Acknowledging the obvious, McCutchen’s current struggles would mean that any mid-season trade of McCutchen would be selling low on a guy who was, before this season started, seen as one of the most valuable assets in all of baseball. If the Pirates put him on the block, it would be taken as a sign that they’re concerned that this rough stretch isn’t just a slump, and that the Pirates would be looking to get off the McCutchen train before his value plummets even further. If the team that watches him everyday isn’t confident that he can turn this around and get back to MVP-levels, then the offers are likely to reflect a similar pessimism, and the Pirates would have to sell McCutchen from a position where both sides were assuming that he was a diminished asset.
There are times when you just have to accept that there probably isn’t a rebound coming and get what you can before the value decreases further. The Rockies got to that point with Troy Tulowitzki last summer, and are likely content that they made the right evaluation in moving their franchise player before his value sunk even more, for instance. But you also don’t want to overreact to every bad half-season of a star player’s career and move him prematurely; players can and do bounce back from similar struggles, and McCutchen’s track record suggests he should have a strong enough second half to rebuild some of his trade value.
To trade him in advance of an expected bounce back, you’d have to be overwhelmed by an offer that values McCutchen as if he’s already rebuilt that value. Looking around the league, though, I don’t know who would make that kind of offer, especially considering that a prospective buyer would likely be interested in talking about an extension in order to give up the kind of talent that they’d have to send to Pittsburgh to make the trade happen.
So what contenders would have the kinds of prospects the Pirates would want, the financial ability to at least try to negotiate an extension with McCutchen, and an opening in center field?
The Astros could be a fit, but they already have a stuggling center fielder with a strong track record who should be expected to bounce back themselves, and Carlos Gomez has hit well enough in June that I’d imagine they’d probably stick with what they have instead of paying a high price to land McCutchen.
The Nationals could use a center field upgrade and have some elite young talents on the farm system, but they also just committed nearly $400 million in future salaries to Max Scherzer and Stephen Strasburg, and probably have to at least look like they’re going to try and make a run at Bryce Harper in a few years; acquiring and extending McCutchen would be a tacit admission that they were out on Harper, and they probably don’t want to do that just yet.
The Giants could use an outfielder, and McCutchen certainly fits the bill as their kind of player, but they probably don’t have the kinds of young talent the Pirates would be looking for. The Dodgers are always seen as a fit for every high-end player who hits the market, but if they resisted paying the price for Cole Hamels last summer, I’m not sure why they’d pivot and overpay for McCutchen this summer. The Red Sox could use a left fielder and certainly have the farm system to land McCutchen, but with Andrew Benintendi on the way, I’m guessing they’re less interested in blocking out left field long-term.
There just isn’t a natural fit with a team that would want to pay a premium to acquire McCutchen right now, and without a team paying a price that reflects McCutchen’s ability to bounce back, the Pirates would be potentially selling quite low on one of the best players in franchise history. If you’re going to move a guy of that stature, you have to make sure it’s because it makes your team better in the long-term, and moving McCutchen at a time of diminished value makes it less likely that they’d get the kind of return that would make it worthwhile.
At this point, the only real reason to move McCutchen is if you think this isn’t a slump. If this is the beginning of the end, and he’s going to age like Andruw Jones, then yeah, take what you can get this summer. But it seems premature to think that McCutchen can’t bounce back from this, and if the Pirates are reasonably confident that he’s still a star player just going through a rough patch, then keeping him is the better play. Let him rebuild his value in the second half, take stock of the team’s 2017 odds once they have a better idea of what their roster will look like, and listen to offers this winter, moving him only if you get blown away with a great offer.
If he’s going to play better, the team would likely get as much or more for him this winter or next summer as they would by dealing him now, so there shouldn’t be a rush to move him just yet. Unless the Pirates are convinced that he’s going down the Tulowitzki path, they’re better off keeping him around for at least another half season, and then putting him on the blocks after he’s reminded everyone that he’s still one of the best players in the game.
Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.



Agree, though I think that the instant the Pirates decide to be sellers, he should go on the DL to get these nagging injuries fixed, then you bring him back for a month+ to let him reestablish value. That at least gives you a shot at not being asked to sell low over the off season.
It’s also a little of both in terms of ‘bounce back’s or ‘declining’. He’s on a multi-year trajectory of stealing less and striking out more – in the end you are probably never going to get paid for an MVP player, just one who’s better than he’s now
That’d be optimal but with only a little over a month until the deadline that’s just not happening. They could put him on waivers but there’s no doubt somebody would claim him with that contract.
If they put him on waivers, 29 other teams would all claim him.
Yes, hoping for him to make it through waivers would be silly, but I specifically said off season!
Off-the-wall prediction: Cutch plays out his contract in Pittsburgh, and Marte gets traded in the offseason for 100 cents on the dollar (when Cutch would not be 100 cents on the dollar) for a strong #2 SP on a Marte-like contract (Jose Quintana comes to mind, but i havent totally thought about if that’s reasonable).
I also wonder if Josh Bell would be a better player in RF than at 1b. Obviously the offensive value is better in RF, but it’s also sounding like his defense at 1b is struggling more than it would in RF.
Would a Polanco – Meadows – Bell OF play good enough defense if/when Cutch and Marte are gone?
Lots of random thoughts that are only loosely related to the article. Oh well! Well.. i guess it’s related in that i just don’t see the Pirates selling Cutch at 90 cents on the dollar.
Marte isn’t going anywhere, anytime soon. The only move involving Marte will be his eventual move to CF
You’re probably right, as i also labelled it as “off the wall”.
But i just can’t help but think it makes more sense to let Cutch rebound, and cash in on the full-value Marte and let Meadows take *his* spot.
Wouldn’t Marte be the more obvious bet? He’s under control for five more years at only $48M total with the team options. Considering his value couldn’t be higher right now, I have to think he would be a great target. He’s not the “marquee name” but given you will be getting his entire peak for extreme below-market price, he would have to be their #1 value, or at least tied with Melancon.
Why would the Pirates want to trade Marte? You said it yourself, he is controlled through 2021 with an absolute bargain of a contract. He has shown nothing to suggest he can’t be a perennial 4-win player. If you ask me, he is just the type of all-around player that fits well in Pittsburgh, and should definitely be a member of their next contending team.
You don’t do it for a package of prospects. It’d have to be an “old fashioned baseball trade” for a great pitcher that helps the 2017 contending team.
Also, if this really is the beginning of his decline, he’d still be young enough to entertain a pillow contract at a cheap price for 2018. This might be the most graceful way for the Pirates to part with the current face of the franchise, if he’s not back to his old self.
I think it would very, very interesting to see an aging star decline article that shows best and worst case scenarios like Andruw Jones. I had forgotten that he was only 30 when he went down the drain.
For established stars mid-career, I sometimes look at the bbref similarity scores to see what scenarios might look like from the top 10 comps.
It doesn’t look awful for Cutch. Of the 8 retired players on the list, Gary Sheffield is the best scenario while Vernon Wells is the worst. The other six, however, are skewed more towards the high end than the low end. The key pattern I see is that many of these guys lost their defense/speed but kept up or even slightly improved their hitting (Beltran being a great example).
http://www.baseball-reference.com/friv/scomp_bat.cgi?I=mccutan01:Andrew+McCutchen&st=age&age=-29&compage=28
It would take one hell of an explanation for me to see how Vernon Wells and Andrew McCutchen are even remotely similar in terms of career arc.
So Griffey Jr. Is simultaneously too good to make this similarities list, AND the worst case scenario…
I should point out that I take the bbref lists with a grain of salt. They’re based upon Bill James’s old similarity score formula, which doesn’t fully capture differences in era, ballpark, etc. Wells apparently made the list based upon his counting stats (done in a crazy offensive era) look superficially similar to Cutch’s (done in a pitchers era).
If you look at the OPS+ shown for the comps list, Cutch has the best of the bunch (and Wells clearly the worst), which isn’t surprising. Really, the only similarity between the two worth mentioning is that both may have been overrated defensively as centerfielders.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/friv/scomp_bat.cgi?I=mccutan01:Andrew+McCutchen&st=age&age=29&compage=28
Given the state of the pitching staff, the Pirates will have a hard go to make the WC game. Taillon, Kuhl and Glasnow will likely join Cole and Liriano in the rotation by the end of the season. The time and experience will help each in 2017. But 2016 has become what it appeared to be last January, transition year when a new core replaced the old. Cutch would not be a key part of the new core.
The Pirates need to maximize the value they receive for McCutchen. They are unlikely to maximize the return for him now, as Dave Cameron argued. Time on the DL would help.
Glasnow won’t be up this season. Doesn’t have the control yet.
I”l take that bet.
Glasnow will get a spot start if not a promotion. Kuhl struggled before his promotion. So, the Pirates will promote players when the player is not at his best.
As a Pirates fan I hate to think of it this way, but McCutchen would fit in perfectly at Fenway. His defensive limitations would be minimized in LF at Fenway, and he would probably maximize his offensive value swinging at the Monster instead of PNC’s giant LF. I have to think if the Red Sox offered Andrew Benintendi and some projectable pitchers (Michael Kopech?), the Pirates would have to consider it.
Whom have the Red Sox rolled out in LF this year? Brock Holt, Blake Swihart, Chris Young, Rusney Castillo, and now they have Bryce Brentz out there. I suspect they would make a strong offer for McCutchen.
Then again, who knows?
Yeah, this is my thought as well. If Benintendi is blocked by Andrew McCutcheon, the Sox might want to pull the trigger, since it seems pretty unlikely that he’ll ever develop into what McCutcheon is (he says, ignoring what Mookie Betts and Xander Bogaerts have become from the same development system), so you trade the up-and-comer for the already-here option.
I’m tempted also to suggest that the Tulowitzki deal might be a precedent that would allow the Red Sox to include Pablo or Hanley in the deal, if McCutcheon’s value continues to fall. After all, when the Rockies traded Tulo, they got two serious pitching prospects from the Jays, in Jeff Hoffman and Miguel Castro, but they also had to take on Jose Reyes’ albatross contract, without which the prospect haul wouldn’t have been nearly as good. If Cutch continues looking like a below-average player (or worse), the Pirates might have to take on some dead weight to get much of a prospect haul.
I say ‘I’m tempted’ because upon closer inspection it’s clear that Cutch has way more value now than Tulo did when he was traded (or should have). While Tulo is an above-average shortstop, his hitting was no better than McCutcheon’s is today. Both are coming off 5+ WAR seasons. The difference? McCutcheon is owed $28.5/2 after this season, and Tulo was owed $94/5 after last season. Oh, and McCutcheon is two years younger than Tulo.
So, yeah. The poor play hurts McCutcheon’s value, but earning 30% less than Tulo per year, and less than 1/3 of the long term commitment certainly makes him more valuable. There’s no way the Red Sox could dump a Pablo/Hanley contract off on the Pirates in any such deal, even if they’re giving up Benintendi, who’s a more valuable prospect than Hoffman was, too.
Not that anyone suggested any of this…I guess I’m just arguing with myself at this point. I’ll show myself out now. [down-votes his own comment].
At least spell his name right. There is no way in hades that the Bucs are taking back a bad contract.
Yeah, could be a fit there. One of the issues the Red Sox have, though, is they need pitching more so it remains to be seen where they are after acquiring an SP. But Cutch in Fenway seems like a good option if it can work.
If the Nationals did trade for McCutchen, and they are as “out” on Harper in free agency already as you have supposed they are, shouldn’t they just drop the pretense and extend McCutchen if they feel that’s necessary to make the trade work? Or would their front office understand it as they are trading for McCutchen through 2018, even with an extension, and factor that into their calculus in terms of what to give up?
Ultimately, I don’t think those questions are relevant yet, because I agree that right now it’s a sell-too-low situation. Odds seem high that someone not just loses, but gets ripped off in a trade that might reasonably be consummated at this point–the Pirates if McCutchen reverts to form, and the trade partner if he has indeed undergone (ahem) “tulowitzkization.” An extra three months of information is valuable for both the Pirates and the market here–but I suppose it’s possible an extra one month could provide enough information, too.
“Looking around the league, though, I don’t know who would make that kind of offer”
Thankfully for us, Dave Stewart exists. Granted, he probably doesn’t have the prospects to pull it off, by damn it, that’s not going to stop him from trying.
Jake Lamb or A.J. Pollock plus two of Archie Bradley, Patrick Corbin and Robbie Ray should do nicely. We’ll even take the contract of that scrub Shelby Miller off your hands because we’re so nice.
That Goldschmidt guy is still there too, right? Maybe they could throw him in too. Is he still blocking Brett Wallace?
Tulo’s contact rates have returned to normal and he’s been hitting well for over a month. I’ve been really enjoying watching the real Tulo in a Jays uniform, and Mr. Cameron keeps acting like Tulo’s gone full Jeter. His Z-contact rate is back to normal:
Contact rates: http://www.fangraphs.com/graphs.aspx?playerid=3531&legend=1,2,3&stat=&split=base&time=game&ymin=&ymax=&statArr=k,ocon,zcon&start=2014&end=2016&rtype=mult>1=15
Let’s go, Tulo! *clap*clap*clapclapclap*
If by “over a month” you actually mean “the 7 games he has played since coming off the DL” then yeah you are probably right. Because he has only played 7 games in the past 30 days.
http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=ss&stats=bat&lg=all&qual=10&type=8&season=2016&month=3&season1=2016&ind=0&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0&sort=3,a
Might want to hold out for a larger sample size though.
Tulo was starting to rebound a bit before the injury. He had a one month stretch where he had a 116 wRC+, got injured, and has been even better since he returned from the D/L.
I think his overall #s look bad, but there are a lot of positives and he’s not nearly as done as people thought.
Yeah, no I didn’t mean that, I meant the last 30 games.
But then again, from a different point of view the time is exactly right to trade Andrew McCutchen.
It’s also far from a given that Meadows can play center field at the major league level. The scouting reports on his defense aren’t exactly glowing.
Marte would slide to center and Meadows would play left presumably with Polanco staying in right
I don’t think many people realize just how bad Marte has been in center when asked to play there. Go look it up. The sample is still relatively small and perhaps he would improve significantly if the move was permanent, but he’s been much worse than McCutchen.
Not to pile on but yeah not relevant. Cutch wouldn’t even be playing center if not for name recognition. Don’t even really need meadows to succeed, a platoon could be fine as well.
McCutchen has been a below average center fielder defensively, but not nearly as bad as Marte there, and I believe that Meadows would be significantly worse as well.
I dont think anyone agrees with your 390 inning sample stretched over 4 years (that basically says he is league average). Marte has all the tools to be an above average CF.
I already noted the small sample, but the reality is that so far he has been significantly worse than McCutchen. You can suggest that he will get better, but you shouldn’t act as if you know he will be. The only data we have so far has been discouraging.
As a Pirates fan, I’d like to think their days of trading their most popular player are done. That being said I’d rather see them try and move Meadows for a good young SP they can control for a few more years even if it doesn’t look like they can compete this year.
I get paid 85 bucks hourly for freelancing. I never thought I can manage to do it but my good friend is making 10000 dollars each month by doing this job and she recommended me to check it out. Try it out on following website, you have nothing to lose~~
======= ==== incomenews11.cf
This may be a lost year for Pittsburgh, but 2017 and 2018 are still very much within their window to compete. They could extend this window with a good Cutch trade now, but they won’t get a player back who is as good as Cutch will be in over the next two years. Taillon and Glasnow will be in the rotation next year. Marte and Polanco will still be in their primes. This is a win now team. With their limited budget, they will most likely never be able to build this good a of a team for quite a while. So much had to fall in place to be this good. They need to go for it.
as a cards fan, i have to say… Cutch is my favorite ballplayer. Baseball is better when he is playing at his peak… I truly hope he gets out of the funk he’s been in.
And, holy cow would he be a perfect fit for San Fran.
As a cards fan, I have to say… I hope that doesnt happen!