During the Sportscenter running before the start of yesterday’s World Series game, ESPN did a segment on some trends associated with cold weather* baseball. The numbers discussed ranged from biometric data (your grip strength and reaction time ability both decrease dramatically in cold weather) and some of the resulting baseball numbers such as that batting average drops and errors increase in cold weather.
*Link goes to one produced about football, but the same biometric data applies.
I do not think any of the above should surprise you. I found it fairly intuitive. I can recall with great clarity that my fingers do not seem as dexterous when suffering from cold. What I hadn’t done before though was make the explicit connection between the biological nuisances of cold and the dynamics of a baseball game. Think about how reduced grip strength can impact a pitcher. Some of his control is going to be diminished, but probably not evenly so as offspeed pitches require more of a grip than a fastball does. And writing of fastballs, think about how an increase in reaction time affects a hitter trying to distinguish between pitches and then make contact with a 90+mph pitch.
Intrigued, I turned to the holy Retrosheet and its temperature data for games. The 2011 dataset is not out yet, so I poked around recent years and then got distracted by something else and then another something else and then eventually came back and plotted the average temperature for the 2010 season on a map.
Oakland checked in with the lowest average temperature and Miami the highest. Most parks are where you’d expect, but surprises do exist. As not someone relying on a few visits and the stereotype, I never would have thought San Diego would be so low. Perhaps that’s an aberration, I’m not sure where Retrosheet gets their temperature data, but perhaps it reflects the reality of a coastal city.
A game played in 40-degree weather is different from a game played in 80-degree weather just as a game played in Arlington is different from a game played in Seattle. Obviously, but also the two are connected. Part of what makes Arlington such a hitter’s park is the higher temperature. Part of what makes Safeco such a pitcher’s park is the lower temperature. The effects get roped into and considered “park factors”, but they’re more factors of the environment than the park itself. The two are related, but worth remembering. Parks and their location have clear and subtle effects on the game. Where the sun sets, what the hitters’ eye looks like, where the wind blows in from, the height and configuration of the fences both in fair and foul territory are all examples. Temperature is another. Consider that decrease in reaction speed the next time somebody asks you how a park can impact strikeout rate.
Matthew Carruth is a software engineer who has been fascinated with baseball statistics since age five. When not dissecting baseball, he is watching hockey or playing soccer.