Why the Cubs and Yankees Should Swap Tyler Chatwood and Sonny Gray

I know what you’re thinking even before you complete the first paragraph of this post: Sheryl’s trade proposal probably sucks.

I don’t blame you. Most trade proposals suck. As we pass the All-Star week contemplating trade value, though, I thought I’d take an opportunity to indulge myself by imagining a deal that makes too much sense (in my head, at least) not to happen. I contend that, before this year’s July 31 trade deadline, the Chicago Cubs should trade Tyler Chatwood to the New York Yankees for Sonny Gray.

One flaw is immediately apparent: contending clubs rarely make trades with other contenders. Why would they? Teams bound for the postseason are typically looking to add present talent while surrendering players with future value. Both the Cubs and Yankees are contenders. Both Chatwood and Gray are major leaguers. So already this is improbable. Because of their struggles, though, Chatwood and Gray actually possess unlocked future value, though — future value that another club, in my opinion, is more likely to unlock.

I’ve written about both pitchers this year. Both have struggled. Let’s start with Chatwood. When I examined his season back on May 22, he had a 3.14 ERA despite an 18.3% walk rate and 102 FIP-, the latter figure mostly on the back of an unsustainable 3% HR/FB. Since then, his walk rate has actually increased; since May 22, he’s recorded an 18.8% walk rate. That’s bad. Not only has Chatwood produced the highest walk rate among pitchers with 30 or more innings this season, but his 18.6% mark would actually represent the second highest among qualifiers* since the integration of baseball.

*The highest mark since integration is 20.3%, produced by Tommy Byrne in 1949. Improbably, Byrne still managed to record a 92 ERA- that year — that is, he prevented runs 8% better than a league-average pitcher. Overall, Byrne made 170 starts in the majors and logged 1362.0 innings, posting a career walk rate of 16.8% but still managing a 103 ERA-.

Chatwood’s continued problems with command have hurt him. When I published that piece, though, he’d managed his league-average ERA by conceding homers on only 3% of his fly balls. Now that mark is up to 11.1%. Regression isn’t pretty sometimes, and combining lots of walks with lots of homers is a quick way out of the major leagues. Chatwood now has a 127 FIP-.

On the other side of this deal, we have Sonny Gray. I wrote about Gray back on April 27, pointing out that Gray’s struggles were directly correlated to a decline in the use of his fastball. The Yankees, after all, throw fastballs less often than any other team, and Gray had never thrown his fastball as scarcely as when he came to New York. On the surface, Gray’s been the recipient of poor fortune — his 129 ERA- is a far cry from his 100 FIP- — but it’s not at all clear that’s the culprit. Statcast thinks Gray deserves the hard contact he’s been surrendering, with a .339 xwOBA and .385 xwOBA on contact, both career highs.

Gray is still not throwing his fastball. Per Pitch Info, he’s using it less than at any time in his Oakland tenure. In 2015, Gray threw his four-seamer (36.5%) nearly three times as often as his curveball (13.7%). In 2018, that script is completely different: Gray is throwing the pitches at 26.6% and 22.0%, respectively. It’s also possible that, by going away from the fastball, Gray has lost his feel for the pitch entirely. Statcast gives Gray’s fastball an .448 xwOBA, also a career high.

So why would anybody trade for Gray or Chatwood on purpose?

Gray is still getting decent or better swinging-strike rates on his primary pitches. His velocity is pretty stable this year — and might actually be up a tick over last year — so there’s no obvious explanation for Gray’s struggles except for the change in approach he adopted when he came to New York. As for Chatwood, we knows he’s pitched poorly — and the pitch-value data suggests he’s struggled with his four-seamer and sinker more than other pitch by far. Yet those pitches also account for close to 60% of his offerings, with his changeup and curveball both in the single digits. The latter two pitches are actually above average on a rate basis, though. The whiff numbers on Chatwood’s secondaries are strong and, interestingly, Statcast suggests that Chatwood’s biggest control problems are on his four-seamer and sinker. He has better command, it seems, of his cutter, changeup, and curve.

Gray, in other words, would benefit by moving away from his secondary pitches, Chatwood by embracing them. Per Pitch Info, those two pitchers are on the worst teams for making those specific changes.

Secondary-Pitch Rate by Team, 2018
Rank Team IP Slider% Curve% Change% Split% Secondary%
1 Cubs 849.2 9.5% 10.4% 9.3% 0.2% 29.4%
2 Blue Jays 847.1 11.0% 6.1% 14.8% 1.1% 33.0%
3 Pirates 865.2 13.3% 10.9% 8.7% 0.2% 33.1%
4 Reds 862.0 19.2% 3.8% 10.0% 1.1% 34.1%
5 Twins 849.1 13.0% 12.2% 8.3% 1.9% 35.4%
26 Astros 894.0 18.0% 17.3% 6.7% 1.2% 43.2%
27 Tigers 865.2 24.9% 7.0% 11.3% 0.2% 43.4%
28 Rays 863.2 21.6% 6.6% 13.1% 2.2% 43.5%
29 Angels 866.1 22.3% 9.8% 10.0% 4.4% 46.5%
30 Yankees 857.2 21.0% 13.6% 8.6% 4.2% 47.4%

Cubs pitchers are throwing fewer secondaries than any other staff in the majors, the Yankees more of them. At some level, these figures are reliant on the actual personnel employed by the clubs. When the numbers are so divergent across an entire roster, however, it at least suggests the possibility of an organizational philosophy at work. By these numbers, Gray might benefit most from a move to Chicago, Chatwood from a move to New York.

There is, of course, the problem of money. After this year, Chatwood is owed $12.5 million in 2019 and $13 million in 2020 on the contract he signed with the Cubs before this season. Gray, on the other hand, avoided arbitration this offseason by agreeing to a one-year, $6.5 million deal; he’ll go through arbitration one last time this winter before hitting free agency in 2020. So Chatwood is owed both more money this year and more money overall. On the other hand, Gray’s final trip through arbitration, even with his current struggles, isn’t likely to yield a salary that much less than Chatwood’s $12.5 million paycheck. And given the current price of starting pitching, it’s a pretty easily justifiable bet from both sides: the Cubs get a potential difference-maker at a lower price than Chatwood, whilst the Yankees get two more years of team control of a ground-balling innings-eater at a reasonable price.

There are lots of reasons this won’t happen. Gray and Chatwood may both have more value to the Yankees and Cubs than any other team. There’s the money disparity and the Yankees’ luxury tax plan. There’s fear of being the team that loses out — what if the Cubs fix Gray but the Yankees don’t fix Chatwood, or vice versa? There’s a potential talent disparity: Gray’s been a high-end starter as late as the first half of last year; Chatwood has never been that, although he arguably has better stuff. On the other hand, though, if both pitchers continue in the present direction, Gray could end up a non-tender candidate and Chatwood could be a $38 million long reliever. If things go right, both the Yankees and Cubs end up with useful pitchers. Given where Gray and Chatwood are right now, useful would be an improvement.





Sheryl Ring is a litigation attorney and General Counsel at Open Communities, a non-profit legal aid agency in the Chicago suburbs. You can reach her on twitter at @Ring_Sheryl. The opinions expressed here are solely the author's. This post is intended for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice.

29 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Original Greaser Bob
8 years ago

“So Chatwood is owed both more money this year and more money overall. On the other hand, Gray’s final trip through arbitration, even with his current struggles, isn’t likely to yield a salary that much less than Gray’s $12.5 million paycheck. ”

Huh?

BenZobrist4MVP
8 years ago

I think she meant Chatwood’s $12.5 million paycheck.

ScottyB
8 years ago

Typo. should be “Chatwood’s $12.5 million paycheck”

hebrewMember since 2016
8 years ago

Chatwood = $12.5 + $13
Gray = $6.5 & (Likely close to the $12.5 via arbitration)

TheUncool
8 years ago
Reply to  hebrew

That should be Chatwood = $12.5M (this year) + $12.5M (2019) + $13M (2020)

RenoRhinos
8 years ago

As a Cubs fan, I’d be all for this even if the Cubs had to eat half the remaining money on Chatwood’s contract. Watching Chatwood walk everybody is excruciating. It’s like if Justin Wilson was a starter. Those two walk everybody.

feslenraster
8 years ago

Yankees completely lose that one, Chatwood stinks, never understood obsession over him. Sonny occasionally has moments where he pitches like he once did. He actually has some value as a 5th starter.

cubsker
8 years ago
Reply to  feslenraster

As a cub fan, I dont see the yanks falling for this.

JimMember since 2016
8 years ago
Reply to  cubsker

Don’t forget, Sheryl lives in Chicago. Might even be, you know, a Cubs fan.

Bret
8 years ago
Reply to  feslenraster

Chatwood’s numbers away from Coors Field were attractive.

cjbrassa
8 years ago

Sonny Gray is better than Tyler Chatwood. I don’t think the Yankees should trade Gray for Chatwood.

TJ177
8 years ago

Sonny is fine, he just can’t pitch in Yankee Stadium. He’s been hideous there since they traded for him, and mostly the usual Sonny Gray on the road. This year included.

A reasonable explanation is that when he is being coached to not throw his FB he is having trouble locating his breaking stuff down, and if a RH pitcher leaves the ball up in the zone in Yankee Stadium hard contact goes into the seats.

Free Clay Zavada
8 years ago

Just no. ZIPS shows Gray to be the vastly superior pitcher moving forward, and I believe that projection.

Broken BatMember since 2020
8 years ago

Interesting idea, but there is zero reason for Yanks to even consider Chatwood. I get they may want to trade Gray for another starter but difficult to imagine Chatwood even got a Yankee sniff. I also get the Cubs need another starter. I just think they will need to pay higher than turning over Chatwood with the note, “ maybe you can fix him”. The Cubs have not been able to fix Justin Wilson either. Maybe see if packaging them both to get someone like Happ from Jays makes any sense. Wilson used to be good in AL. Someone should want to gamble. How about considering Duffy from KC to Cubs for that package?

Krisco
8 years ago
Reply to  Broken Bat

Justin Wilson is showing a 3.56 xFIP this year, and a 0.4 WAR—not bad at all for a pitcher in his role. I would argue he doesn’t need fixing. He’s not an All-Star, but he never really was.

Uwashington
8 years ago
Reply to  Broken Bat

“The Cubs have not been able to fix Justin Wilson either”
Yeah, not sure about that one.

jrutree
8 years ago

The Yankees might be starting to try this exact approach with Gray. His last start, granted it was the Orioles, was possibly his best of the year. In it he threw almost exclusively 2 seamers and curves. If this was a plan that they plan to try going forward then the Yanks definitely won’t want to trade and will want to see if a different approach will work.

TheUncool
8 years ago
Reply to  jrutree

This just makes much more sense than trying that swap, especially given Chatwood’s contract could become essentially dead weight while Gray could just be non-tendered.

Not like Chatwood had ever proven himself to be a solid SP to justify the gamble at this point…

stonepie
8 years ago
Reply to  TheUncool

right, much easier to have him revert to his old ways. ntm, if chatwood has the worst walk % in the league, do you really want him to start throwing significantly more secondary pitches?

CONservative governMENt
8 years ago

Gray is better and cheaper. Cubs could add Alzolay and their leftover international pool money to even it out.

RoyalsFan#14321
8 years ago

The reason so many trade proposals stink (or /suck/ as you put it) is that like 90% of them are the result online trade machines or are created by a team’s particular fans with no interest in fairness. As far as I can tell you aren’t a Yankees/Cubs fan, and didn’t float this through ESPN’s NBA Trade Machine.

It stinks because Chatwood is terrible and Gray is so obviously fixable.

roadrider
8 years ago

I don’t like the trade but neither do I think that Fredo (not good enough to be Sonny) is “obviously fixable”.

OneearMember since 2018
8 years ago

I don’t think this article is about the trade as it is about how team pitching philosophies can produce interesting results.

mewhitenoise
8 years ago

This is a really interesting premise, and I agree with one commenter who said it’s more about the effects of team pitching philosophies than an argument that this trade would actually ever work.

One minor qualm (as a Cubs fan who has watched way too many hours of Chatwood that I’ll never get back): I’m not sure Chatwood qualifies as an innings eater. He rarely goes beyond the fifth inning, and his starts have continually put a burden on the Cubs’ pen. Calling him that feels like a stretch in order to make the trade more plausible (since Gray obviously has more value than Chatwood).

Just my thoughts, but like I said, I do think it’s a cool way of demonstrating how certain pitchers just don’t “fit” into certain organizational philosophies regarding pitch mix.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
8 years ago

Everyone said this better than I did…Sonny Gray could still pretty good, while Chatwood was always a longshot to be good. BUT, what if the Cubs sent something else of value to the Yankees? I can’t imagine what that would be, given that both teams are trying to contend, but while I do agree with everyone here that the trade is totally lopsided, I also like Sheryl’s logic that both would benefit from a change of scenery and the other spot is the ideal location for them.

Deacon DrakeMember since 2017
8 years ago

Gray > Chatwood… Chatwood also has the contract. Gray will yield a draft pick. Cubs would have to throw another log on the fire, but other than that, Gray looked like a real candidate for the Cubs closer job not to long ago. They clearly know his talent and limitations… and considering that Yankee fans have taken to an easy and unflattering nickname for him, Sonny could be moved.

martyvan90Member since 2017
8 years ago

Sheryl in the 80’s the Boss would’ve bit after a 5 runs, 8 hits, 2 walks in 3 and 1/3 pitching line.

TheomyheroMember since 2024
8 years ago

If I were the Yankees I would stay as far away from Chatwood as I possibly could. This coming from a Cubs fan. The dirty secret of the Chicago Cubs is that there pitching is continually bailed out by their defense, which has been one of the best in the league over the past couple of years, this helps out their pitchers numbers a lot and probably allows them a greater selection of spots to throw since they can have confidence of the defense to work behind them. Chatwood would also have to deal with going from a semi-pitcher friendly NL Central, to the NL East. That not an easy move to make. Chatwood has also had two tommy johns.

I’ll be honest, I would love this trade. But it ain’t going to happen, unless the Yankees feel like they owe the Cubs for the Gybler Torres trade.