Why You Should Ignore Off-Season Winner/Loser Recaps

With James Shields finally signing, the off-season is probably closed for business now. Sure, there are a few veteran relievers still out there, and Rickie Weeks still has to find a new home, but most of the money has been spent and the trades have been made. We’ll see a few more deals in Spring Training, but with pitchers and catchers reporting next week, the Hot Stove is now more of a pile of smoldering coals.

And that means you’re about to be inundated with various lists and rankings of off-season moves. You’re going to read about the best and worst individual moves of the winter — I’ll likely have my own posts on those at the end of the week — as well as the always popular “winners” and “losers” of the off-season. In general, I find the winners/losers recaps to be a little bit formulaic, as they could almost always just be rewritten as “teams that made the most win-now moves” and “team that made the fewest transactions”.

For instance, in the linked video above — granted, this is from a month ago, so the list might be different today — Ken Rosenthal lists his off-season “winners” as the San Diego Padres, Chicago White Sox, and Miami Marlins. I’d imagine pretty much every iteration of the topic will contain the Padres and White Sox, as they both made a lot of moves and several high profile acquisitions, propelling themselves from mediocrity into potential Wild Card contenders. The Marlins will show up on a decent amount of lists as well, though their spot could also be absorbed by the Blue Jays, Cubs, or Red Sox, depending on the preferences of the person compiling the list.

In pretty much every one of these cases, the teams exchanged future assets — prospects, draft picks, salary commitments, or a combination of the three — in order to boost their chances of winning in 2015. And with very few exceptions, teams who spend the off-season exchanging future value for present value are lauded for that choice. Teams who intentionally get worse, even if they do so because they were correctly responding to a seller’s market created by so many teams currently demanding win-now upgrades, almost never appear on these lists.

I’m not trying to pick on people who write these columns, because this isn’t a baseball-specific problem. Our culture has a strong positive bias towards borrowing from the future in order to live more comfortably in the moment; note that the American Dream is based around home-ownership, not having a robust 401k. Celebrating a team for signing a major free agent or making a few splashy trades isn’t that different from praising someone for taking out a mortgage. I’m pretty sure I’ve never been invited a party to reward someone for downsizing and putting the savings into a low-cost index fund, however.

But there’s a reason that lending is a highly profitable business to be in, especially when the economy is strong and everyone wants to be a buyer. Baseball’s economy is absolutely booming right now, but because most talent is already distributed throughout the league, teams can’t simply head to the bank and take out a loan to finance their new purchases. Instead, when demand rises as it has this winter, other teams can effectively become banks for their competitors, charging ever higher rates for talent while the strong market exists.

But these winner/loser columns don’t acknowledge that lending is often more profitable than selling in a high-demand market. Instead of focusing on the magnitude of the change in value for a franchise, they often focus solely on the direction. And that’s why I think so often the team that “wins” the off-season ends up as a regular season bust.

Yes, the Padres and White Sox got better this winter, and maybe the Marlins did too, though I’m a little skeptical on that one. The A’s, Rays, and Braves all got worse on purpose, and I’d be happy to wager that none of those three will end up on any off-season winners list. But if you look at the projected standings, OAK and TB both still project as better teams in 2015 than SD and CHW, even though they spent their off-seasons moving in opposite directions. Of course, that doesn’t mean that OAK/TB had better off-seasons — they were starting from much stronger positions to begin with — but we should at least be willing to acknowledge that it is possible to degrade your team in the short-term while adding long-term value and retaining your status as a contender.

If we’re going to celebrate the White Sox and Padres moves towards decency because the consensus is that they didn’t mortgage their futures in order to achieve the upgrades, why not acknowledge that putting a decent potential contender on the field while actually upgrading the organization’s future can also be an admirable pursuit? Why are we only ever rewarding the buyer’s side of the equation, when there’s only something to buy because the market incentivized selling to a degree that lured teams into acting as a lender?

Maybe we’re just not programmed to like bankers, especially after the last five or six years. Maybe our culture will just always value buying over saving for the future, regardless of the wisdom of owning a McMansion versus having a well-funded retirement account. But I don’t know that we have to accept these same ideas when it comes to grading each team’s off-season.

Acting as a buyer is absolutely the right way forward for some franchises in a certain year. It would also be absolutely the wrong way forward for other teams in that same year, and for another swath of franchises, the wisdom of buying or selling can depend upon what the market is demanding at the moment. It’s never as clear cut as short-term upgrades are good and building for the future is bad, or vice versa. The goal should be to maximize value to an organization, and trade-offs always have to be made.

Sometimes, teams should trade future for present. When they do that and do it well, absolutely, let’s celebrate a job well done. I think the Blue Jays did an excellent job of that this winter, for instance, adding Russell Martin, Josh Donaldson, and Michael Saunders to their starting line-up, plus an underrated Devon Travis as a low-key acquisition. They spent some money and traded some real talent in order to make those moves, but overall, I think the Blue Jays organization is in a better place now than they were at the start of the winter.

But I think I could make a case for the Rays having had a nearly equally strong off-season. Their moves weren’t as flashy — the likes of Asdrubal Cabrera, Rene Rivera, John Jaso, and Steven Souza weren’t demanding attention — but as much as I like Toronto’s off-season, I’m not sure they’re significantly better than Tampa Bay for 2015, and yet Tampa built up their future asset base rather than diminishing it. That’s a notable accomplishment, but one that is mostly lost in the process of rewarding teams for making win-now moves.

I think it’s great that so many baseball teams are legitimately trying to win in 2015. That said, I don’t think we should box ourselves into thinking that the only way to have a good off-season is to focus solely on making your team better next year. We shouldn’t pretend that lending is never a good idea, or that a franchise can’t move forward by first taking a small step backwards.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

90 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Anon
11 years ago

“I’m pretty sure I’ve ever been invited a party to reward someone for downsizing and putting the savings into a low-cost index fund, however. ”

Sounds like Fangraphs just found a new February tradition!

Youppi!
11 years ago
Reply to  Anon

{n}ever been…. minor typo but i had to read it twice to catch the meaning of what sounds like a pretty sweet party where hopefully the host reinvests their savings in good hors d’oeuvres.

Paul G.
11 years ago
Reply to  Anon

Buying a house is a bit more complicated than simple borrowing. Typically houses go up in value – save the recent housing bubble crash – so it is both borrowing and investing. Plus buying a house provides tax benefits that renting does not. 401ks are awesome, but you can’t live in them.

Economics
11 years ago
Reply to  Paul G.

“Typically houses go up in value” — because of increasing populations and increasing leverage/lower interest rates on mortgages, house prices have trended upward over time in the United States. However, houses depreciate and incur variable expenses to maintain the property and the leverage incurred adds extra cost.

Long story short, you can be earning interest or paying it — this is Mr. Cameron’s point and this is what is lost on most people.

Paul G.
11 years ago
Reply to  Economics

True, true. Still, you have to live somewhere. The mortgage gives you an asset you own (eventually). Rent does not. Most likely you will have to pay one of those. The analogy to baseball teams is a bit stretched.

Little Mexican Girl
11 years ago
Reply to  Economics

Why not both?

(cue Mexican Hat Dance music)

KK-Swizzle
11 years ago
Reply to  Economics

I think its a great analogy…both are culturally considered to be investments while actually offering little in the way capital growth. Best case scenario, your house rises in value with the market…the thing is, investments do too, and they give interest instead of taking it away.

To extend the analogy: buying a house is like signing a free agent. It can be a great move, if you time it right and have appropriate capital available. In both cases, it usually functions best as a “cherry on top” to a strategy with a sound foundation (i.e. stocks and bonds or player development).

Devil's Advocate
11 years ago
Reply to  Economics

Economics makes a lazy comment with “Long story short, you can be earning interest or paying it”. Hypothetical: I have a 2K mortgage. I have an extra $200 a month. I can send the extra $200 to the mortgage and avoid paying interest on that extra amount. OR I could invest it and hope to earn a greater return that my mortgage rate in the market. The mortgage allows you the opportunity to invest in something else. Economics is wrong. Long story short, a mortgage allows you the opportunity to earn more interest.

KK Swizzle makes a bad analogy as well and he is only correct if talking about investing available capital in raw land vs. investing in the market.

Buying a house is NOT an investment in the majority of cases.

A better analogy would be buying a house is similar to trading a 1 WAR player when you possibly have a 3 WAR player to replace him on your AAA team. Borrowing is about opportunity cost. I borrow at one rate so I can use my money to try to get a higher rate elsewhere.

dave gb
11 years ago
Reply to  Paul G.

I prefer a Roth IRA, but I get your point

B N
11 years ago
Reply to  Anon

Also, he clearly has never worked at a mergers and acquisitions firm. Step 1: Buy the company, Step 2: Fire all the workers, Step 3: Increase quarterly profit, Step 4: Re-invest profit in index fund until next acquisition, Step 5: Bonuses and office party.

B N
11 years ago
Reply to  B N

*Step 6: Quietly sell off stock in company where you have reduced its long-term viability)

Mcneildon
11 years ago
Reply to  B N

Most guys I know who work in mergers and acquisitions really don’t like it.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  Anon

You like real estate?

Google: John Powers Middleton Weekly Online

24 pictures of J.P. Middleton’s Hollywood Hills mansion

J.P. Middleton’s kitchen is as big as the first floor of my
house.

I wonder where the $6 BILLION that Comcast gave
John Middleton to buy players went to?

JP Middleton
11 years ago
Reply to  Free_AEC

You mad bro?

Richie
11 years ago

Yeah, a ‘truth in titling’ feature. ‘Teams That Most Mortgaged All Their Future Years In Order To Take A Single Shot This One’

Janet YELLEN
11 years ago

I get the analogy you are making with the mortgage and the 401k, but it is incorrect. Getting a mortgage allows you to have more saved in investment accounts. You either use 300K cash to buy the house or you borrow it and continue to invest it. Don’t worry, I’ll keep rates low enough to make borrowing worth your while.

Ghost of Bernanke
11 years ago
Reply to  Janet YELLEN

Yes…my plan is coming to fruition!

B N
11 years ago

Is the Ghost of Bernanke is like the Christmas spirit, except you buy all your presents on layaway?

Hurtlocker
11 years ago
Reply to  Janet YELLEN

$300K??? Do you live in Alabama Janet??

Janet YELLEN
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

Yes, a mansion in Alabama. Think I should downsize, invest the extra savings into an index fund and throw a party like Mr. Cameron suggests?

Doug Lampert
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

You can get a house in the Huntsville Alabama area for as little as 45K or so. Rural areas or a small fixer-upper are even cheaper.

She lives somewhere expensive. 🙂

B N
11 years ago
Reply to  Doug Lampert

In Memphis they were doing 2-for-1 sales and selling packs of 4 lots for 25k in some cases. I mean, I don’t think I’d want to live in those neighborhoods, but still: four houses!

Dave Cornutt
11 years ago
Reply to  Doug Lampert

Doug, another Huntsville guy checking in. Although there has been some inflation in the market here the past few years.

Paul G.
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

In the NYC metropolitan area, 300K is not a lot of house, not a lot of neighborhood, and/or not a lot of structural integrity, plus the property taxes will range from high to ridiculous. Go out to the KC area and 300K will get you a nice place with modest taxes. Go north to Omaha and 300K will get you very nice place. Depends where you live.

Really low interest rates does make borrowing much more attractive these days.

MG
11 years ago
Reply to  Paul G.

It isn’t low-interest rates and US buyers driving the NYC real estate or several other high-end urban real estate markets either (eg Miami, LA).

It is foreign-buyers who are buying it through LLCs at the high-end for several reasons (eg the are rotating out of paper into physical assets in secure countries or bug out material in case they need to flee from their native countries especially in the cases of place like Venezuela, Russia, and China) and the pass-through effect it is having on the rest of the market in those areas.

Hurtlocker
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

$300k doesn’t even get you a very nice condo in San Diego.

KCDaveInLA
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

$300K could get you an okay house in the Inland Empire of San Bernardino county…which is good, because if you’re going to live there, you’ll probably want to just stay in your house most of the time.

David
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

Regardless of what the map says, Inland Empire is closer to Alabama than it is to San Diego…

Colonel Obvious
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker

You folks don’t mean to imply that real estate prices vary according to location, do you?!

Plucky
11 years ago
Reply to  Hurtlocker
randplaty
11 years ago

I would agree with you that gaining future value is important. But I think you ignore the revenue increases that winning now provides. Winning begets winning because of revenue and then payroll increases as pointed out by Diamond Dollars. Maybe you disagree with this, but I’d like to see an argument against it if you do.

KDL
11 years ago
Reply to  randplaty

Is the whole..”My opinion is right until you prove it wrong” an internet phenomenon? Or do comment sections just make it easier to see how often people interact with others in this way?

randplaty
11 years ago
Reply to  KDL

You have an opinion because you think it’s right. That’s just common sense. If you didn’t think it was right, you wouldn’t have that opinion.

Jaack
11 years ago
Reply to  randplaty

Not necessarily. I think my own opinions are quite often wrong. In fact, I have had as many as 6 incorrect opinions before breakfast.

randplaty
11 years ago
Reply to  randplaty

I think my opinions are wrong too… after someone shows me they’re wrong.

David
11 years ago
Reply to  randplaty

Whether anyone agrees or disagrees with the idea you’ve put forward, it is remarkably unconnected to the central thesis and supporting points of the article you’re commenting in.

randplaty
11 years ago
Reply to  David

Maybe you don’t understand the idea. If you win, you get more money which makes it easier to win in the future. “win-now upgrades” are not necessarily just win now. Therefore teams are not taking out loans to finance purchases. They’re taking out loans to finance investments. Very very different. I wish Dave would have talked about this at least.

chuckb
11 years ago
Reply to  randplaty

Do you really believe that Dave doesn’t understand that winning generates revenues that can be reinvested in the franchise?

If so, you haven’t read many of his articles.

randplaty
11 years ago
Reply to  chuckb

I know he understands it, which is why it’s strange that he doesn’t mention it or acknowledge it at least. It would seem that revenue generation could completely negate his argument.

Maybe it’s because revenue generation hidden in every team’s books and every market is different and therefore we don’t actually know what revenue is generated. Maybe he doesn’t want to talk about what is difficult to quantify. But I would argue that revenue generation is a much more important than any current asset including prospects or players.

Ron Washington
11 years ago
Reply to  randplaty

I think you’re ignoring the fact that the teams he mentioned as selling now and gaining future value, Rays and A’s, will still most likely be winning in 2015.

Hurtlocker
11 years ago

I agree, the winning and losing is on the field, not in the second guessing
of off season moves. The best part of the off season is giving the have nots some hope, it would be great for baseball for the Padres to do very well, or the Cubs finally winning a WS.

tvators
11 years ago

Where would the Mets fall in this? Think most of their improvement would have to be youth developing and or returning and vets health and rebounding outweighing regression and decline… wwhile most met fans complain about lack of spending moves, I’m more upset they could work a deal sending murphy and a SP somewhere, even if they had to pay some salary to get something useful

CrazyPants
11 years ago
Reply to  tvators

Mets FO is still waiting by the phone.

Roger
11 years ago
Reply to  tvators

They’d fall in the “not trying to win the offseason” column, despite the howling of talk radio and fans who want to make moves for the sake of making moves — and thank goodness for that.

sam
11 years ago

I feel like the White Sox did a much better job than the Padres at getting better without sacrificing too much future value.

Alan
11 years ago
Reply to  sam

What future value did the Padres sacrifice?

Buns
11 years ago
Reply to  Alan

Prospects, money, and roster spots. Are you even paying attention?

Alan
11 years ago
Reply to  Buns

B prospects at best, roster spots taken by pretty craptastic players.

Yes to money. But where was that money going over the next couple of years? Kemp is a risk, but Shields was market or under.

People keep looking at the Padres’ moves without looking at the Padres situation, which is a big part of why these moves are getting executed.

They also are strange act like every move here was a Kemp trade, when almost every move has completely different in nature.

The idea that most of these moves sell out the future is strange to me.

There’s a lot of prospect overrating going on here.

Ron Washington
11 years ago
Reply to  Buns

They may have been B prospects like you say, but they were basically the best the Padres had. And the real problem for the Padres is that they still most likely will not make the playoffs in the next few years.

Ted Brogan
11 years ago
Reply to  Buns

That’s not exactly true. Hunter Renfroe, Matt Wisler, and Austin Hedges probably ranked higher than any of the prospects traded, and they managed to keep interesting prospects like Michael Gettys and Tayron Guerrero. Losing Eflin and Turner hurts, and I was a fan of Mallex Smith, but Preller certainly did not clean out the farm.

Baseball Prospectus wrote an interesting article about Preller’s offseason strategy:

http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=25548

Call me crazy, but I still don’t think Preller is done.

Kenny
11 years ago

I have no idea how you can justify the notion the A’s added long-term value this off-season. So far as I can tell they moved around a huge number of bodies, largely treading water whether you look at likely wins, level of spending, years of player control, or value of minor league assets. The one thing they really succeeded in doing though is confusing their fans, who had developed certain allegiances to certain players. That will show up at the box office, especially if they don’t make as much of a run this year.

Joshua_C
11 years ago
Reply to  Kenny

While I don’t agree with the second half of your statement (i.e. the reference to box office performance), I do agree that it’s not exactly clear that the Athletics have acquired a lot of long-term value this offseason.

Indeed, they’ve probably dealt away more prospects than anyone else over the last year (Russell, Robertson, McKinney), they dealt away an Arb1 superstar in Donaldson, they dealt an inexpensive Norris, and they’ve effectively acquired rentals in Zobrist and Clippard. I’m not sure I’d even say that they’ve been less win-now than the Padres, who, interestingly enough, haven’t actually given up that much long-term value.

I agree with the article’s premise–I just don’t think the Athletics qualify. If I were to focus on who had the ‘best’ offseason, I’d go with the Blue Jays, Pirates, and Reds (yup, the Reds).

CrazyPants
11 years ago
Reply to  Joshua_C

Padres added long term value with Myers, Norris, Middlebrooks, Maurer plus stand to gain a draft pick for Upton (or extend him)… and have tons of money coming off the books after 2015.

Ron Washington
11 years ago
Reply to  CrazyPants

I would seriously question any of those 4 bringing legitimate future value. The best bet is Myers and he is far from a sure thing after last year. Norris’s bat profiles decent at catcher, but average at best at 1b. Middlebrooks’s best value was his RH power, and we’ll see how that plays at petco, at&t, etc. At least he’ll get to play 9 or 10 games in Denver i guess.

John
11 years ago
Reply to  CrazyPants

Middlebrooks is not “long-term value” Long-term, yes, value, noooo. Getting someone who is young is only valuable if they are good. Middlebrooks is bad at playing major league baseball.

Well
11 years ago
Reply to  Joshua_C

The net effect of the A’s moves was to get younger and not lose talent. In addition to dealing prospects, they also acquired prospects, including a pretty good one in Barreto, as well as guys who are a little closer to the big leagues: Hahn, Graveman, Nolin, Wendle, Ravelo, etc. Lawrie and Semien are younger and should provide significant value this year. Hahn will be in the rotation. Donaldson might be an “Arb1 superstar” but he’s also 29 and soon to be headed for the standard decline. The A’s will be fine.

Joshua_C
11 years ago
Reply to  Well

My response wasn’t meant to suggest that the Athletics had a poor offseason. I just don’t think they’re the best example of a team who exchanged short-term value for long-term value, given that several of their moves in fact accomplished the opposite.

Whether each of those moves was prescient is an entirely separate subject (I for one loved the Zobrist trade).

John
11 years ago
Reply to  Joshua_C

I agree that the Blue Jays had a great offseason, and the pirates had a solid one too, but I’m curious as to why you think the Reds had one of the best offseasons.

SF
11 years ago

Would that the three Johns in Atlanta could put their heads together and hire Dave Cameron. I mean, they at least had the good sense to get the public to buy them their new suburban McMansion.

Paulie
11 years ago

The White Sox added long term pieces over the last two years. This year they probably don’t go into buy mode without the success of some of those long term pieces, particularly Abreu and Eaton. Now the White Sox have increased fan interest and as a result, season ticket sales.

The White Sox and Rick Hahn particularly have been praised for both approaches in recent years.

Paulie
11 years ago

I forgot to add the following.

From ESPN.com, Jayson Stark, Dec. 13, 2013. “Offseason winners and losers, so Far”

Stark mentions the following winners, Nationals, A’s, White Sox and Angels.

His quote regarding the White Sox
“They needed to transform not just their roster, but their whole aura. And general manager Rick Hahn is off to a tremendous start, with the signing of first-base/DH masher Jose Abreu and the deal this week for hyperactive on-base machine Adam Eaton.

“I’ve always been an Adam Eaton fan,” one scout said. “I love his style of play. I like the energy he gives the White Sox. And they needed that.””

Barneby Jones
11 years ago

So which teams were the big winners and losers this off-season?

Ted Brogan
11 years ago
Reply to  Barneby Jones

Winner: Patriots

Loser: Seahawks

everdiso
11 years ago

The fact that OAK and TB rank ahead of SD and CHW in the projected standings just shows how far this website goes out of its way to rank it’s pet favorites as highly as possible.

I mean does anyone in their right mind think that an OF of Melky, Eaton, and Garcia (baby Miggy) would be worse than Steven Sousa, Desmond Jennings, or Kevin Kermier? I haven’t even heard of Sousa and Kermier before.

Fangraphs too often throws stones at teams that go out and acquire proven players. If it were up to Dave Cameron, every team would be comprised of 25 0.5 WAR rookies.

Food for the Troll
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

“I haven’t even heard of Sousa and Kermier before.”

Yet you feel the need to express an authoritative opinion about them.

everdiso
11 years ago

the fact that I haven’t heard of them says something about the type of player they are. Its a qualitative statement in and of itself

Jorge Fabregas
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

It can be inferred that you think they are “.5 WAR rookies” or something like it. Kiermaier had almost 4 WAR last year.

Only Glove, No Love
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

Ummm… Sousa is going to be kinda good…

James’ Handbook has him in 300AB’s going: .376/.481/.857 w 23 SB and a 6.5 RC/27…

I think the fact that you haven’t heard of him says something about you and not him…

Decent defense as well…

Only Glove, No Love
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

It is triple lulzy that you don’t know who Kiermaier is!

chuckb
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

I can’t help but give you a thumbs-up for “triple lulzy.”

Maybe that just speaks to the kind of day I’ve had.

chuckb
11 years ago

It’s pretty clear he’d never heard of Kiermaier since he can’t even approach spelling the name correctly.

And, of course, if everdiso’s never heard of a player, he must be terrible!

Roger
11 years ago
Reply to  chuckb

I’m just impressed that you guys managed to figure out who “Kermier” even was. At least “Sousa” was obvious (it’s a guy who composed a bunch of marches).

Jorge Fabregas
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

Agh, stop it.

Andrew
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

Fangraphs does not own or run the projection systems. They just post them and use them in analysis. Your accusations of bias are unfounded.

You also may want to improve your arguing technique. Claiming that one set of outfielders is better just because you’ve never heard of the others is admitting ignorance and nobody will take you seriously.

#commentwin
11 years ago
Reply to  Andrew

…

Ron Washington
11 years ago
Reply to  everdiso

Is everyone else purposefully ignoring the fact that he’s deciding which team is better solely by trying to argue about the outfield? Using only 3 of each team’s 25 players?

KDL
11 years ago
Reply to  Ron Washington

I’ve never heard of any other positions, so they’re probably not important.

Plucky
11 years ago

So, the bottom line is that you dislike the genre of “offeason winner/loser” lists, felt like expressing your dislike by invoking a giant strawman better suited to a hack political column, and yet in point of fact you agree with the conventional wisdom that Padres, White Sox, and Marlins/Jays/BoSox/Cubs (depending on taste) won the offseason, with your taste being (quite reasonably) for the Jays and (also reasonably) less so on the Marlins.

Your actual substantive disagreement amounts to wishing for more Beane fanboyism about a highly ambiguous offseason and wanting to substitute TB for MIA in the Jays/BoSox/Cubs tier.

Would it be so hard to admit that sometimes conventional wisdom is reasonably close to correct and that the genre of winners/losers is en entirely legitimate on?

jfree
11 years ago

Seriously – this is not a good sign when the comments of a baseball website are full of housing advice.

Dan
11 years ago

This is why I love Fangraphs. Because of this kind of article right here.

SABRphreak
11 years ago

Any votes for the Phillies as an offseason winner? They finally committed to rebuilding (albeit a couple years late) and refused to trade Hamels and Papelbon on the cheap when other teams were trying to take advantage of their position as sellers (as well as the pitching surplus in the market). The Phillies will do much better trading both players for maximum value in the summer (provided both remain healthy). That seems wise to me. They also got a couple promising pitching prospects (already ranking in the Phillies’ top 10 prospect list per MLB.com) for one year of Rollins from the Dodgers.

chuckb
11 years ago
Reply to  SABRphreak

Refusing to trade Hamels and Papelbon by stubbornly insisting they have value they don’t actually have hardly qualifies them as an off season winner.

Phillies113
11 years ago
Reply to  SABRphreak

“(provided both remain healthy)”

Boy oh boy, that is a big gamble they’re taking! Here’s hoping they do stay healthy; the return on both players would be fantastic, assuming they’re still playing at a high level. Don’t forget how the Phillies waited on Cliff Lee because the offers were “too cheap,” and he immediately blew out his elbow, destroying his trade value through at least this upcoming spring training.

I agree, though, the best time to move Hamels is more towards the deadline at this point; the Phillies have allowed his market to dry up, so there’s only one viable suitor left. Had they traded him at LAST year’s deadline, they could’ve gotten maximum value for him. Unfortunately, the Phils’ version of max value seems to differ from that of reality’s.

Free_AEC
11 years ago
Reply to  Phillies113

If Cliff Lee shows he’s healthy the Phillies will get as much for
Lee as they would have trading Lee in July 2013.

That’s why Lee is still in Philly.

That’s why Hamels is still in Philly.

No one will make a trade for them. The interested teams
want them for nothing.

How does getting nothing for them help the Phillies?

JOHN MIDDLETON
SOLD

CURT SCHILLING -Three Rings

HUNTER PENCE – Two Rings

SCOTT ROLEN – One Ring

SHANE VICTORINO -One Ring

BOBBY ABREU
CLIFF LEE

for

VICENTE PADILLA

That’s SEVEN Rings in 14 years while the Phillies have won two World Series in 125 years.

KK-Swizzle
11 years ago

This article demonstrates nearly everything I aspire to be as a writer: analytical yet nuanced, respectfully countercultural, and founded on insightful big picture ideas. Thanks so much for the free (and quality) content, Dave!

circlechange11
11 years ago

I dont buy the winner-loser lists BC we’ve seen teams, like well, the blue jays and marlins make a bunch of moves in an off season and not do that well.

This year we’ve seen the cubs be lauded, etc when the best move in the division may have been StL getting Heyward. The moves that get the most attention are bad teams trying to get better in a hurry, rather than just good teams staying good or teams not making bad moves trying to aggressive.

pft
11 years ago

If payrolls are going up 5% per year and your revenues are going up 10% per year is investing in human resources really mortgaging the future?

Put another way, if you put 40% of your increased revenue into payroll, thats hardly mortgaging the future.

MLB reportedly increased revenues almost 1 billion last year. That’s 30 million a team. Every team could have increased payroll for 2015 by 12-15 million and not even felt it. More than half of teams probably did not.

With teams now spending almost 10% less of revenues on payroll than they did at the turn of the century, their poor mouthing and those who enable them grow wearisome. Look at the Yankees, brand new stadium takes revenues sky high yet in revenue adjusted dollars they spend 50 million less in payroll in recent years than they did from 2003-2009 years

Professor Ross Eforp
11 years ago

I happen to agree with Dave, but he did write this during the KC run last year…

http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/where-i-was-wrong-about-the-royals/

In other sports, where the value of a top draft pick is so much higher than it is in MLB, the correct decision is often to either be great or terrible, with mediocrity as the awful middle ground. Perhaps too much of that sentiment crept into my own thinking about the upside of building an 85 win team, because in today’s baseball world, 85 wins and a little bit of luck can turn a franchise around. I’ve argued against losing on purpose, but perhaps I’ve argued too strongly for wins in the 88-95 range and not strongly enough for wins in the 80-88 range. The win curve is a real thing, and some wins are more valuable than others, but that doesn’t mean that I’ve correctly evaluated the marginal benefit of pushing yourself from 82 to 86 wins.

I think we can all agree that building an 80-88 win team for a long time is better than building one in the short-term, but perhaps Chicago and San Diego plan to continually sink the resources into their teams to build 80-88 win teams.

Stank Asten
11 years ago

Or we could simply treat these recaps as reports on what teams got better for the present? I don’t see the point of introducing polemics into such reports, which are obviously written for light consumption, or to see them as condemnations of investment or banking.

Natman
11 years ago

As Master Oogway said, “Yesterday is history, tomorrow is a mystery, but today is a gift. That’s why they call it the present.”