A Trio of White Sox Injuries Has Made a Bad Team Even Worse

On the heels of a 101-loss season and a trade of Dylan Cease, it was quite apparent that the White Sox would be bad this year. So far, however, they’ve been even worse than that, losing 10 of their first 12 games to become the first AL team whose Playoff Odds have reached zero. Adding to that insult, they’ve already lost Eloy Jiménez, Luis Robert Jr., and Yoán Moncada — the three players who projected to be their most valuable — to injuries, sadly an all-too-common occurrence when it comes to each of them. It’s going to be a long season on the South Side.
The most severe of the injuries is that of Moncada, and woof, it not only looked bad but it may mark the end of his run with the White Sox, one that has certainly contained its share of highs and lows. While running out a grounder in the second inning of Tuesday’s game against the Guardians, he suddenly started limping about halfway down the line, then stumbled and crumpled to the ground before reaching first base, writhing in agony before being tended to by head athletic trainer James Kruk. “When I was running down the line, it felt like something broke. Honestly, that was the worst pain I’ve felt in my career,” Moncada told reporters via an interpreter on Wednesday.
Moncada was diagnosed with a strained left adductor, one of the muscles of the inner thigh, and yes, this will be a recurring theme. You don’t have to believe in jinxes to cringe at the fact that in the pregame media session before Moncada’s injury, manager Pedro Grifol told reporters that the 28-year-old third baseman had been dealing with a nagging hip/adductor injury for three or four days, adding, “He’s doing a really good job maintaining it.” Thus a minor injury has become a major one; the team announced that Moncada’s estimated recovery time is three to six months. In a best-case scenario, that would place his return around the start of the second half, while in a worst-case one, he might not make it back onto the field again this season.
Moncada is already coming off a pair of injury-wracked seasons that took a significant toll on his performance. After hitting for a 120 wRC+ with 3.7 WAR in 144 games in 2021, he slipped to a 76 wRC+ and 0.8 WAR in 104 games in ’22, missing five weeks due to an oblique strain and then 10 days for strains in each hamstring. He rebounded slightly in 2023, hitting .260/.305/.425 (98 wRC+) with 1.1 WAR, but still played just 92 games, missing over 10 weeks due to a pair of IL stints for lower back inflammation. He was off to a good start this season, hitting .282/.364/.410 (127 wRC+) while showing improved plate discipline through his first 44 plate appearances.
He is now in the final guaranteed season of the five-year, $70 million extension he signed in March 2020, making $24 million this year with a $25 million club option and $5 million buyout for 2025. Given the trends of his performance and Chicago’s payroll — which declined from $193 million in 2022 to $177 million to ’23 to $148 million this season as both the old and new regimes have stripped the roster for parts — it’s unlikely the team would have picked up his option. More likely, general manager Chris Getz would have looked to trade him this summer in an effort to fortify a farm system that got a shot in the arm last year, rising from 27th in projected future value in the spring to 12th later in the season.
Grifol said the team will rotate among a trio of players to fill in for Moncada, with 29-year-old lefty Nicky Lopez, 26-year-old lefty Braden Shewmake, and 24-year-old righty Lenyn Sosa all in the mix. None of them has hit a lick at the major league level, with Lopez — who has started eight games at second base and one at shortstop so far this year — the best of the bunch with a career 72 wRC+ across more than 1,900 PA; Sosa owns a 43 wRC+ through 224 PA, while Shewmake has a 50 wRC+, but only 25 PA so far. Each of them is a huge step down from Moncada, to say the least.
Robert isn’t expected to be out as long as Moncada, but his absence is depriving the White Sox of their lone All-Star from last year and their most dynamic player. The 26-year-old center fielder left Chicago’s April 5 game after injuring himself running out a double, and was diagnosed with a Grade-2 flexor strain in his right hip, the same one in which he suffered a Grade-3 strain in 2021. He missed about three and a half months that time, but this time around he’s only anticipated to be out six to eight weeks, with “only” doing a lot of work here.
The shame of it is that Roberts is coming off the closest thing he’s had to a full season in a while. His 145 games played last year was the highest total of his four major league seasons, topping his 98 games from 2022, when he made trips to the IL for COVID-19, blurred vision, and a wrist sprain; the only other time he played at least 100 games in a season was 2019, when he tallied 122 while rocketing through three levels of the minors. Even as the team collapsed around him last season, he put together an outstanding campaign, hitting 38 homers and stealing 20 bases while hitting .264/.315/.542 (128 wRC+) with 4.9 WAR. His slugging percentage and home runs both placed third in the American League, his wRC+ and WAR, eighth.
Robert was hitting just .214/.241/.500 at the time of his injury, with a two-homer, three-hit, four-RBI game against the Tigers on March 30 accounting for the bulk of his contributions. Thus far in Robert’s absence, Grifol has shifted his right field platoon over to center. That pairing — 26-year-old lefty Dominic Fletcher and 35-year-old righty Kevin Pillar — along with various other players in smaller roles placed the White Sox 28th in the right field version of our preseason positional power rankings. Meanwhile, Robert drove their no. 5 ranking among center fielders, but with his playing time reduced, he and his replacements have dropped to 12th in our Depth Charts. Somebody ought to put up a warning sign: “Beware of Falling Projections.”
As for Jiménez, he didn’t even make it to April, or to a spot in the outfield, before getting hurt. In the season’s third game, on March 31, the 27-year-old slugger strained an adductor in his left leg while running out an infield grounder and left the game. This marks his fourth straight season with a trip to the IL; in 2021 he missed four months due to a torn pectoral tendon, in ’22 he lost two and a half months to a torn tendon in his right knee, and in ’23 he was shelved 10 days for a left hamstring strain, and then three weeks for an appendectomy. Jiménez still managed to play 120 games last year, his highest total since his 2019 rookie season, but through his first five years, he played in only about 62% of Chicago’s games.
In the wake of last year’s early-season injuries, the White Sox used Jiménez in right field in just 14 games and DHed him 105 times. Keeping him off the grass is probably preferable given not only his fragile state but his defensive metrics (-22 RAA, -18 DRS, -9.8 UZR in 2066.2 career innings). That said, a DH-only role places a lot more pressure on him to hit in order to be valuable, and last year’s .272/.317/.441 (104 wRC+) translated to just 0.5 WAR, which doesn’t cut it. The good news is that Jiménez is on the mend, and could possibly return this weekend. In his absence, Gavin Sheets has gotten hot, batting .333/.455/.704 through 33 PA but [checks notes] none of our projections suggest he can maintain that.
In our preseason projections, Robert (4.0 WAR), Moncada (2.4), and Jiménez (1.9) occupied the team’s top three spots, with Andrew Vaughn (1.6) and Andrew Benintendi (1.5) the only other position players above 1.0. In other words, without this trio the Sox don’t have a single player who projects to be average or better in the lineup. These outages and this miserable start — which includes the lowest-scoring offense in the majors, at 2.42 runs per game — have dropped their already-abysmal win projection from 66.3 as of Opening Day to 60.8. With the possible exception of the days that Garrett Crochet starts — he’s got a 2.00 ERA and 2.50 FIP through three turns — this is going to be an unwatchable team at least until Robert gets back.
Brooklyn-based Jay Jaffe is a senior writer for FanGraphs, the author of The Cooperstown Casebook (Thomas Dunne Books, 2017) and the creator of the JAWS (Jaffe WAR Score) metric for Hall of Fame analysis. He founded the Futility Infielder website (2001), was a columnist for Baseball Prospectus (2005-2012) and a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated (2012-2018). He has been a recurring guest on MLB Network and a member of the BBWAA since 2011, and a Hall of Fame voter since 2021. Follow him on BlueSky @jayjaffe.bsky.social.


We should be relegated to AAA and have to earn our way back up.
Cue Jerry Reinsdorf threatening to move the Sox to Charlotte.
I honestly wish relegation was a thing in US sports.
Well that would be so stupid of an idea. Who are you promoting the triple A team for the Orioles? I assume you don’t know how baseball works.
If MLB was serious about relegation, that’s not how it would work. As I understand it, they’d separate, say, the best 20 teams from the worst 10 teams to play in superior and inferior leagues with no inter-league play. While the inferior league might have a championship series of its own, only the teams in the top league would be eligible to win or play in the World Series. After each season, the best so many teams in the lower league would switch league with the same number of the worst teams in the upper league.
It’s still stupid, but it’s for the reasons I outlined.
No, relegation is one the stupidest ideas in sports history! Nobody wants to see their favorite top league teams shuttled back and forth between two different levels of competition!
Nobody wants to see some of the world’s best players stuck playing against inferior competition just because they happen to be on bad teams! Some Japanese and Korean may not even want to come to MLB if they might spend some years stuck against similar competition to that of their homelands. Analysis of players’ career stats and the associated career records would be ruined! Rivalries wouldn’t be as good if the two teams had to spend some years in different leagues.
Is this when we see Bryan Ramos or Colson Montgomery take over the hot corner?
Montgomery has 52 PA above AA and is hitting .239/.314/.283 with a 38.5% K rate in them. Ramos is hitting .059/.238/.059 with a 38.1% K rate in 21 PA at AA, although last year he hit well at that level. Even if they were hot, bringing them up now would just start the service time clock on a bad team, but both clearly have some development to do.
With Sheets playing very well, and Vaughn being seemingly an automatic double-play. it will be interesting decision to make when Eloy comes back to occupy the DH spot.
I’m not saying they should do this or that they will, but I can’t rule out the idea that they would just cut Jimenez.
I bet they keep him and try to rebuild his trade value, which might be a smarter move but will likely lead to more frustration.
What’s the best use of the ABs?
Is he blocking anybody significantly better?
Sometimes you cut sunk costs but sometimes you just pray for a miracle.
Sheets will probably play RF more than he should, but with Robert out Fletcher is in center so they need somebody there.
If Vaughn keeps playing this bad he might wind up in AAA when Eloy returns. He’s still got options.
This isn’t a new problem. Both Robert and Jimenez have been injured running to first base before and I think there have been others recently too. Grandal definitely pulled a hamstring doing it in 2022 and I seem to remember it happening to Anderson once as well. Maybe they are all just freak injuries, but when a bunch of different players repeatedly suffer similar injuries doing the same very basic baseball activity that thousands of other players manage to do safely, it is reasonable to ask why.
I have no proof, but I am tempted to blame ownership, like with everything else in this franchise. It is well known that they cheap out on minor league development programs, scouting, and analytics. I wouldn’t be surprised if they also pinch pennies in the conditioning department and fail to give players detailed off season routines or in season assistance to maintain their bodies and reduce the risk of injuries.
They are professional athletes that are accountable to be in baseball shape. If they choose not to engage in baseball activities year round to keep them in baseball shape it’s on them.
These three guys look very strong to me so maybe that’s the problem. Lifting weights doesn’t help you run full speed to first base. OR this could just be really bad luck. but a player’s conditioning is not to be blamed on the organization.
Sometimes it is at least partially the org’s fault. The Mets medical staff has always been bad, and the Angels have had problems, especially keeping pitchers healthy and managing symptoms, but also rushing guys back.
I don’t think you can blame Eloy on the Sox; he has had terrible injury problems from the word go. Robert also to a lesser extent, since he missed big chunks of time in his second and third seasons and was playing through injury last year, and had some more minor stuff in the… well, the minors. Moncada just seems like bad luck; he was almost totally healthy his first four seasons in ChiTown.
Not one of these Sox injuries is to a pitcher though. The manager knew Moncada was “sore,” but players play sore all the time. If his soreness was a condition that is widely known is dangerous to play sore with then I would agree you could question that. Once Moncada had back issues he’s struggled to stay on the field.
I haven’t read any questions to the Sox staff re: training regimen so maybe there is more to learn.
I guarantee you that good organizations give players detailed plans for what they want them to do in season and over the winter. The players are not physiatrists, kinesiologists, biomechanists, trainers, or nutritionists.
If players don’t follow those instructions it is on them. If they never get the instructions then the team is trusting them to figure it out without guidance and that would be a bad plan because I don’t expect the players to know any of the science behind it. That’s what the support staff is for. No different than a pitching coach and data guy telling a guy his 4 seamer plays better if he throws it above the belt. Some guys will figure that out on their own, not all will.
They do. Most teams have some internal method to communicate improvement plans & conditioning goals during the winter & track them.
I’d imagine cheap/behind the times orgs are behind in this, too (I know Detroit didn’t have one until Harris took over in early 2023).
As for the White Sox injuries- This sound so basic, but, do they stretch? Again, that’s basic training, but, when guys are dropping like flies with pulled muscles, you wonder if they’re doing enough of that or communicating the need to continue to do it, esp in cold weather.
Injuries can also stem from overexercising and fatigue. Staying in playing condition isn’t as easy as you make it out to be.
The White Sox have a ton of guys who are tools over skills, the sorts of athletes who might be “too strong for their own body.” But it does seem like someone on the training staff needs to go. That is a lot of guys hurt in a short amount of time.
Poster boys for the old baseball axiom about not wanting body builders because they pull muscles.
How the (sort of) mighty have fallen. Look at Benintendi…thought of as a rising star, $66 million and nearly four years left on his contract
Wild that their three “best” guys all get hurt running to first base…
Hey now, Robert had already rounded first when he pulled up lame!
This is karma for how they treated Jason Benetti. I bet he’s happy to be up in Detroit now and away from this mess of an organization.
Agreed. It’s really sucks for the players involved, but reinsdorf deserves absolutely zero success.
I know Crochet is off to a great start, but, how many innings will he realistically pitch?
Missed 2021 due to TJ. He pitched 25 innings last year & barely cleared 90 innings total from 2020-2024..& has always been a reliever, even in college (13 starts in 36 appearances with 12 of the 13 in 2018/19).
He looks like a big part of their future, they would be stupid to have him throw 175 innings in a lost season. Get him to 100-120 & shut him down would be my move.
My son is two months old and I’m wondering if raising him a White Sox fan should be tantamount to child abuse.
For a long time the Sox had one of the better athletic trainer systems. Their ability to keep pitchers healthy especially was unmatched. Their head trainer – Herm Schneider, who might be the only athletic trainer in all of sports whose name I know – retired a few years ago. I would have figured there’d have been a lot of “organizational knowledge” that was passed down, but maybe the succession plan wasn’t as good as I’d have expected. Who really knows.
I will say that when they traded for Eloy and Cease, the biggest knocks against them were the former (already) was hurt a lot and the latter was a skinny, small guy whose arm/body wasn’t going to be able support being a starter. Small sample size, but it’s interesting how those two’s health has played out. Cease hasn’t had any health issues and throws as many sliders as anyone else in the league. I’m not rooting for it, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Cease hits the IL after leaving the Sox.
There was an article about the Sox training staff on FG a couple years ago – maybe 2021 but could’ve been 2019 – per that article, the Sox had less games lost to injury than any other MLB team, and it wasn’t close. Pretty sure it was a projection article saying how that level of team health likely wasn’t sustainable for any team year-to-year and suggested more injuries on the horizon just due to regression to the mean..