Assorted Quick Thoughts on Opening Day No. 2
Sunday was the beginning of the 2013 MLB regular season, and it kicked off with a bang, as the Astros bombed the Rangers and we all learned a lesson about the real value of a one-game playoff. Not like the stakes were the same, so the game was managed differently from how it could’ve been, but in any one given game, a team like the Houston Astros can beat a team unlike the Houston Astros. Of course, it should be noted that the difference between the Astros and the best team in baseball might be like the difference between a city’s best restaurant and a city’s 29th or 30th best restaurant. That 29th or 30th best restaurant is probably still a very good restaurant! It’s just outclassed relative to the elite. It still beats the hell out of Hardee’s.
Monday is more of a baseball extravaganza, with several games on the schedule, none of which involve the Astros. Monday feels more like a true opening day, and below, I’ve assembled some quick thoughts based on some of the early games. I didn’t watch a single inning from spring training so, for me personally, baseball couldn’t feel more fresh. It will feel like this for the rest of the day, and then tomorrow, it will feel like baseball as usual. Savor the feeling of today, or tomorrow.
The Red Sox are shifty
Behold, an infield defensive shift:
There was an article some weeks back talking about how the Red Sox are going to utilize a lot more defensive shifts this season, now that they’re under new on-field management. John Farrell, of course, was the manager in Toronto, where he utilized a lot of defensive shifts. So we already knew the Red Sox were going to be shifty, but just in case you thought they were full of crap for some reason, above there is proof they weren’t lying to the media. That’s Will Middlebrooks, essentially playing shortstop. Will Middlebrooks isn’t a shortstop!
Intuitively, shifting is smart. Intuitively, shifting should be obvious. By the numbers, it’s not quite that easy to demonstrate its effectiveness, but it still strikes me as being worthwhile so this is going to be fun to monitor over the course of the season. And then, come season’s end, we can confidently assert that we don’t have a sufficient sample size to draw meaningful conclusions. Baseball!
The Nationals have defense
The Nationals played the Marlins, and the Nationals started Stephen Strasburg. So of course the Marlins got shut out on opening day. The Marlins are terrible and the Nationals are not and Stephen Strasburg is not. But here’s how close the Marlins came to taking a very early lead:
It’s a great diving stop by Ryan Zimmerman, with a runner on third base. Zimmerman then makes a weird throw over to first, where Adam LaRoche digs the ball out of the dirt. Nobody here needs to be told that defense is significant, but in this instance good defense quite literally saved the Nationals at least one run. The Marlins were this close to jumping out in front of Stephen Strasburg.
Bryce Harper’s hot zone
Bryce Harper is a superstar at 20 years old. Before a lively home audience, Harper knocked two dingers on opening day, providing all of the Nationals’ offense. Following the second one, Harper gave a curtain call. The first dinger came against a breaking ball, in this location:
The second dinger came against a breaking ball, in this location:
You don’t ever want to miss your spot against Bryce Harper, if you’re a pitcher. But you especially don’t want to miss your spot there, against Bryce Harper. Harper will beat the crap out of you, or at least out of the baseball you released. Bryce Harper isn’t that kind of abusive.
Kicking off with Chris Denorfia
Early Monday, the Padres played against the Mets. Jon Niese got the start for New York, and leading off for San Diego was Chris Denorfia. Niese’s first pitch was a fastball roughly down the middle, and Denorfia swung and singled into left. As we discussed not long ago, it’s uncommon for a batter to swing at a first pitch, or at a season’s first pitch. Denorfia didn’t care, or he specifically took advantage of that trend, and the maneuver paid immediate dividends. Niese’s second pitch, incidentally, was bunted fair. Both of Jon Niese’s first two pitches of the 2013 season were put in play.
CC Sabathia is to be monitored
Sabathia is coming off elbow surgery, and he didn’t have a full, complete spring. Still, he drew the nod for opening day in The Stadium against the Red Sox, and Sabathia twice threw pitches that PITCHf/x considered to be 92 miles per hour. One was 91.7, and one was 91.5. Those were Sabathia’s fastest pitches, as his fastball hovered around 88-90. A year ago, in the first inning of his first start, Sabathia topped out near 95 miles per hour. It is entirely too early to say it’s time to panic about CC Sabathia. Sabathia, given his track record, has probably earned the benefit of the doubt. But it’s not too early to say Sabathia should be monitored going forward. This is, for the analytical writer, a sort of cop-out line that doesn’t mean anything. It’s the only option in between “worry” and “don’t worry”. With Sabathia, for now, do something in between those two things.
Jackie Bradley Jr. is super disciplined, or not
Making his major-league debut in New York against an established southpaw ace, the odds were against Jackie Bradley Jr., but at this writing he’s already drawn two walks. The first included this two-strike pitch, which took some real discipline to lay off:
Bradley laid off another quality slider later in the plate appearance. It was an impressive appearance. Then later on Bradley struck out swinging at this:
What do we know for sure about Jackie Bradley Jr., now? He won’t swing at every pitch out of the zone, and he won’t not swing at any pitches out of the zone. He will chase some percentage of the time, just like every baseball player ever. Bradley, last year, had as many walks as strikeouts in the minors, but then he had 14 more strikeouts than walks in Double-A so this, too, will just have to be monitored. One can be forgiven for chasing against CC Sabathia.
Giancarlo Stanton is to be monitored
We’ve never been able to find much of anything with regard to the effects of lineup protection. We don’t know how it might show up in the numbers. On opening day, in Washington, the Marlins had Giancarlo Stanton batting third, and Placido Polanco batting fourth. We might be able to see something in the numbers, because it’s hard to imagine a hitter being less protected than that. Stanton is elite, and most of the rest of the Marlins are pretty bad, especially with Logan Morrison on the disabled list. It’s going to be interesting to see how Stanton is pitched to for the next while. On the other hand, here’s his first at-bat against Strasburg:
With a runner in scoring position, Stanton was given a mashable fastball, as much as any Strasburg fastball can be a mashable fastball. Based on the Polanco thing, you’d think Stanton would’ve been pitched around. Strasburg came right after him and Stanton nearly took him deep. So one way or another, this will be interesting. It won’t prove anything conclusively, but if Stanton excels with no one behind him, that’s going to be some compelling evidence. Because there won’t be anyone behind him.
Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.







Someone has obviously never had the pleasure of Hardee’s biscuits.
Ryan Zimmerman makes a LOT of weird throws
I was just about to say the same thing… I remember the Nats coaches trying to get Zimmerman to change his throwing style last year, and now I feel like he throws almost sidearm. I’m not sure if they were trying to get him to throw more conventionally and he just keeps doing it like this, or if this is how they wanted him to throw all along. I’ll have to go back and look at some of his throws from a few years ago and see if there’s a difference. It looks goofy and inaccurate, but he’s Ryan Zimmerman and I’m a guy writing about baseball on the Internet, so I’ll leave him to his ways.
He’s always thrown kind of weird, but it got worse last season because he played the whole year with a throwing shoulder kept functional only through several cortisone shots – he’s had to make a lot of adjustments because of that, and made a fair number of throwing errors last year. (Weirdly, pretty much always on plays where he had a minute to gather himself – if he was on the run it usually worked out well.)
In the offseason he had surgery on the shoulder and is still building up strength, I think, so hopefully he can improve over the course of the season.
I was fortunate enough to have tickets to the Nationals’ game today behind home plate, and I’m also very fortunate to see evidence of the crime committed against me! I got up right before Harper’s first home run, leaving my locked security box on the shelf in front of me (above the “C” in “GEICO” in your picture). I didn’t have time to return those very important classified documents to my office safe before the game, so I brought the box with me. When I returned to my seat, right after Harper’s second home run, the box was missing! Now, call me foolish for leaving those nuclear launch codes unattended, but, as I was surrounded by various congress critters, I assumed it was a safe location to leave an unattended box. Curses! Fortunately, you have photographic evidence of the box prior to and after its removal from the shelf. I think the culprit is that shady lady in the white shirt. The FBI or CIA or NSA might be contacting you sometime today.
ps I was not fortunate enough to attend any baseball games today. But I was fortunate to waste 15 minutes of my day fabricating an entirely plausible story. Thanks for that.
If you think the 29th or 30th best restaurant in a city is probably better than Hardees you’ve never lived in Toledo, Ohio.
Or in a city for which finally getting a Hardees means you are now a hot spot for people traveling through to/from smaller cities. (Or alternatively, a Dairy Queen or Pizza Hut, those are really the only 3 “destination” eateries.)
Waco, Texas
He said city, not truck stop.
Hey Waco has more than that! There are heavily fortified cult compounds, too!
Scratch that…they don’t have those anymore.
Perhaps there should have been the modifier “Major League Baseball” city. Obviously there are small towns that barely have one restaurant, let alone 29 or 30.
At what population does a village or town become a city, anyway? There must to be some government standard. Because, bureaucracy.
There is no standard in the US. Cities and towns (except in New England where a town is like a mini-county) are incorporated places, village in most places is an informal term if its used at all. There are unincoporated places containing tens of thousands that aren’t cities and there are incorporated cities and towns of a dozen or less people.
The U.S. Census standard for a city is 1,000 pop. By which definition, Iowa has the most cities of any state.
In my state, Ohio, 5,000 is the minimum pop to incorporate as a city. The entity next to mine, Anderson, has well over 5,000 but prefers to remain a township, rather than a city.
I’m sure other states have equally odd oddities.
At what population does a village or town become a city, anyway?
As noted above, it’s the DQ, Hardees or Pizza Hut test.
I have always lived in Toledo. And we’ve got some pretty great restaurants; your information is out of date.
Can one truly LIVE in Toledo?
Edit the popup on your FIP descriptions on the player pages. If I see “independant” one more time I’m going to send a strongly worded email to someone not responsible for them.
Had the Dodgers not scored 3 additional runs afterwards, Clayton Kershaw would have accomplished a one-man victory over the Giants, by throwing a complete-game shutout and hitting a solo homerun. I would think such a performance would give him a WPA of 1 for that game alone, but I know that’s not exactly how it works.
I’d be in support of this if Kershaw also accumulated all of the putouts and assists himself as well.
would be pretty impressive if a pitcher generated 27 Ks or popups/grounders to the mound in a game.
Sullivan you must be feeling extra frisky today. This article was stocked with whimsy and witticisms. Secretly the start of the baseball season is, like, your Christmas, isn’t it? Mine too! Ho, Ho, Hochevar! Merry Chamberlain!
On a semi more serious note, what WAS the deal with Denorfia leading off for the Padres today? Do they have so little respect for Maybin and Cabrera’s ability to get on base? Or the Marlins off season moves have threatened their strangle hold on 2014’s first overall draft pick.
Padre’s season opener: it is never too early to start tanking, boys!
Jeff: Good to see you here and at USS Mariner as I’ve really enjoyed your writing over the last few years.
Is it possible to have Felix start all the games in a series? The Mariners #2 – #5 starters are the Hardee’s comparative equivalent to a burger, a steak, a shake, and cocktail. Tuesday brings reality like an STD to Mariner land.
I don’t know if it’s just Opening Day or what, but this grab-bag was one of my favorite FanGraphs articles ever.
Agreed – I now expect 161 more grab bags like this one. #setting_the_bar_too_high
Giancarlo should bat leadoff.
Not sure if this was mentioned, but it’s probably not Farrell shifting; In his tenure with Toronto, including last year, Brian Butterfield, Boston’s 3B Coach, was responsible for designing all the shifts.
That’s right. And since no article was cited, I can recommend Tim Britton’s piece for the Providence Journal: http://blogs.providencejournal.com/sports/red-sox/2013/03/the-red-sox-shift-how-and-why-bostons-infield-defense-will-be-different-in.html
Question: don’t almost all breaking balls that get hit (at least if they are in the zone) seem like hanging breaking balls? They get hit during their break. If the batter misses it continues on with its break. Not sure if this makes sense, but does pitch fx or whatever just assume that where it gets hit, that’s where the break stops? Admittedly, Nolasco’s look like particular meatballs.
What happened on that Stanton swing in the GIF? If you wouldn’t have said anything, I would have assumed it was a home run. Did it go foul or was it a flyout? It looked beautiful anyway.
Its hard to tell from the GIF but he gets under it quite a bit andit actually is a simple popout to Center. In fact it was a little right of center, maybe 15 feet from the warning track.
Stanton did not nearly take SS out on that swing. That was a flyout though, not a pop up.