Time to turn our attention to center field, the eighth position we’ve tackled since Dave Cameron kicked off the series with an
informative introduction.
Used to be, you put a fly catcher in center and didn’t worry too much about offense, even if he batted leadoff because he was fast. Willie McGee and Otis Nixon come to mind, though their on-base percentages were decent enough, maybe. They didn’t have power, though. Those years, the position’s isolated power was around 10% worse than league average.
These days, it seems the position has evolved. There are center fielders now who don’t count fielding as their best strength, and their collective power is now closer to average than it used to be. Even Kevin Kiermaier — in some ways a throwback, defense-first burner — has decent power. Maybe down table, around two thirds down the list, you’ll find some guys that would have fit on any 80s squad in center.
But Leonys Martin, Billy Hamilton, and Odubel Herrera are today’s maybes instead of yesterday’s sure things, it seems. Today we wonder if Odubel’s defense is as good as his tools, or if Martin will ever hit lefties, or if Hamilton will ever hit righties. In any case, they provide diversity where some other positions have lacked it. There’s a long way from Yoenis Cespedes to Billy Hamilton.
Let’s separate the burners from the bombers among today’s center fielders!

Looks like two or three stars, a couple clearly above-average guys after that, and then a big bucket of decent. They won’t all get there the same way, but today’s center fielders can swing the stick a bit.
#1 Angels
Name |
PA |
AVG |
OBP |
SLG |
wOBA |
Bat |
BsR |
Fld |
WAR |
Mike Trout |
658 |
.300 |
.405 |
.580 |
.414 |
54.4 |
3.1 |
0.6 |
8.7 |
Craig Gentry |
35 |
.234 |
.291 |
.306 |
.266 |
-1.2 |
0.2 |
0.5 |
0.1 |
Rafael Ortega |
7 |
.237 |
.299 |
.318 |
.275 |
-0.2 |
0.0 |
0.1 |
0.0 |
Total |
700 |
.296 |
.398 |
.562 |
.405 |
53.0 |
3.3 |
1.2 |
8.8 |
This ranking is not built on depth. Should (perish the thought) Mike Trout go down with a season-ending injury, the Angels’ center-field situation would drop down to the bottom of the heap. That may sound like a knock on Craig Gentry — a decent defense-first center fielder when his legs are right — but more it’s just another way to fawn about Trout.
There are so many ways to fawn, though. As August Fagerstrom pointed out in his player cap, he’s already accrued more wins than any player in the history of baseball through their age-23 season. Only Ted Williams, Joe Jackson, Stan Musial, and Ty Cobb were any better with the bat alone, and Trout adds legs and glove to the package. Or you can go the route of Tony Blengino, who found that Trout was better than Micky Mantle through the same age. Or Jeff Sullivan it up, and chronicle the way that Trout has adjusted to every single wrinkle that the league has thrown at him, like handling the high pitch, and now including now taking inside pitches yard to the opposite field.
Or you can just be succinct, as Fagerstrom was when he summed up his player cap on Trout: the best in the world.
Read the rest of this entry »