Bednar, Jeffers Accept Qualifying Offers

Brad Penner and Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

OK, now we can start free agency.

Of the eight free agents who received a qualifying offer, two — David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers — are returning to their previous teams on one-year, $23.15 million deals. Jake Bauers never formally rejected the Brewers’ qualifying offer, but he signed a four-year contract with the Red Sox last week, which would make it kind of awkward if he tried to go back to Milwaukee now. Randy Arozarena, Brandon Lowe, Adrian Morejon, Trevor Rogers, and Seiya Suzuki will sail into free agency. Best of luck to them.

Since Bednar and Jeffers are de facto free agent signings, let’s explore what it means to the Yankees and Twins, respectively, that they’re getting these major free agents back.

Bednar joined the Yankees at the 2025 trade deadline, and he’s been terrific closing games for them ever since. In 2026, he posted a 2.47 ERA and 2.61 FIP in 64 appearances, winning seven games and converting 35 of 39 save chances. This year, Bednar was 14th among qualified relievers in WAR and fifth in WPA.

Every time I write about Bednar, I go back and link all my old articles, each of which starts more or less the same way: I love this guy to bits. He’s just the closeriest closer you’re going to find these days, a stocky Yinzer who throws hard at eye level and slow in the dirt. In the six years since the pandemic, he’s posted an ERA and FIP between 2.00 and 2.70 five times. The one exception was a brutal hiccup in 2024 that presaged the end of his tenure with the Pirates; otherwise, Bednar’s been as reliable as an old subway car.

A four-seamer that sits at 96 mph isn’t that special for a right-handed one-inning reliever anymore, but Bednar gets a lot of rise on his heater despite a low-three-quarters arm slot. With that pitch as a baseline, he works in a hard splitter and a glacial upper-70s curveball. In 2026, that repertoire got Bednar a 27.1% strikeout rate and a 51.4% groundball rate.

There are a few closers out there — Mason Miller, Jhoan Duran, Louis Varland, Cade Smith — who haunt the first eight innings of the game. They’re so hard to score on that it puts pressure on the offense to get their business done early. Outside that super-elite group, what you want from a closer is just not to screw up. To make things easy. Bednar threw at least one inning and allowed zero earned runs in 48 of his 64 appearances this season. Only 14 relievers with at least 40 appearances had a better ratio. He doesn’t walk a lot of guys and he barely gives up any home runs. There are better closers out there, but few who are less stressful to watch.

Last year, on the open market, the going rate for a reliever like this was about $15 million a year on a multi-year deal. That’s what Robert Suarez got for three seasons. Devin Williams got $16 million per over three seasons, and Raisel Iglesias got $16 million on a one-year deal. Qualifying Bednar was a worthwhile risk for the Yankees, who aren’t going to sweat the odd couple million. Given that Bednar is 32 years old, the Yankees might even prefer a shorter commitment to a three-year pact.

From Bednar’s point of view, I don’t know if there was any reasonable choice other than to take the QO. He’s now the most expensive free agent reliever of the 2020s, on a per-year basis. And on those rare occasions a reliever has merited a qualifying offer, it’s tanked the pitcher’s value. Even in top-end reliever contracts signed over a QO, you walk away wondering where those last few million dollars ran off to: Josh Hader turned down a qualifying offer after the 2023 season and made $95 million over five years. Edwin Díaz got $69 million over three years last winter. Iglesias re-upped with the Angels for $58 million over four years before the 2022 season.

Sometimes, teams will shell out multiple years in the high teens for a premium reliever; rarely are they willing to do that and cough up draft picks and amateur spending money at the same time. If Bednar puts in another season of 30-odd saves with an ERA and FIP in the low 2.00s, being a year older isn’t going to hurt him on next year’s free agent market as much as being unencumbered will help him.

Jeffers is a little more interesting.

On one hand, this is a catcher who doesn’t defend well and will probably be a first baseman or DH pretty soon. He played just 92 games this year, has never qualified for a batting title, and has never posted a three-win season. He’s been on the IL in each of the past two seasons and has a career split of 37 points of wRC+. He doesn’t have elite bat speed or plate discipline; none of those Baseball Savant sliders even hit the 90th percentile for Jeffers across a full season at any point in his career.

Given that description, you’d think the Twins must’ve been insane to give him a qualifying offer in the first place. On the other, if I were running a team, I probably would’ve thrown a grotesque amount of money at him.

My longstanding belief about free agency is that the safest place to fish is at the most expensive end of the lake. Elite talent might be expensive, and the back half of a 10-year contract for Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani might look a little squirrely, but at the end of the day, you’re walking away with a star player.

Teams get in trouble when they try to talk themselves into second-tier free agents, attempting to get 80% of the production for 50% of the cost. It’s like the Terry Pratchett boots theory — if you’re rich enough to afford good boots, you’ll pay more up front, but the boots will last a long time. A poor man who can only afford cheap boots will have to replace them every winter, ultimately spending more in the long run than the rich man did on his expensive boots.

This year’s free agent class is Tarik Skubal and then nothing but cheap boots. A team that sets out to fill a need on the open market this winter can realistically only hope to break even. Not only is there a lack of elite talent available, it’s such a seller’s market teams are going to be climbing over each other for the privilege of hoping Seiya Suzuki or Brandon Lowe defies the aging curve.

In an environment like this, you have to take risks.

Jeffers is very much a modern hitter. He makes a lot of contact, chases very infrequently, and has optimized his swing to get the ball in the air and to the pull side. He hasn’t hit an opposite-field home run in more than three years.

The market for free agent bats usually trends older; Jeffers is 29 years and five months old, which makes him either the sixth- or seventh-youngest hitter in this free agent class and the third-youngest free agent hitter you’d go out of your way to acquire. (Jeffers and Luis Urías were both born on June 3, 1997. I could call the respective hospitals they were born in and see which one is older; instead, I’ll note that Jeffers is the far superior hitter.)

In 2026, there were five hitters with at least 350 plate appearances who met the following criteria: walk rate of 10% or more, strikeout rate of 20% or less, isolated power of .200 or more. Those five players: Yordan Alvarez, Junior Caminero, Miguel Vargas, Juan Soto, and Jeffers.

It’s good company to keep. And remember, Jeffers is (at least theoretically and for the time being) a catcher. No one’s ever going to confuse him with Patrick Bailey, but he caught 80 games this year. He can put on the gear and stop the ball from hitting the screen.

Jeffers still kills lefties, but in 2026, he narrowed his platoon split to almost even. And insofar as he’s had injury troubles, they’re not of the sort I’d worry about. Every IL stint he’s taken in his career has been the result of an impact injury — one concussion, a couple broken bones in his hands — so there’s no degenerative knee injury or chronic back problem to worry about.

All that looks pretty promising to me. In a free agent class where the best available bat is Suzuki, Jeffers looks like one of the few opportunities for real impact upside without having to do the full “I can fix him” routine about, say, Luis Robert Jr. Our crowdsourced contract estimate for Jeffers was $48 million over three years; I’d have gone to four years at $20 million per without batting an eye.

I see a hand up in the back of the class.

“Seeing you get excited about a part-time former Twins catcher with an iffy glove but a great approach and exciting rate stats reminds me of how you said Mitch Garver was a top-10 free agent in a much stronger class in the 2023-24 offseason. How did that work out for the Mariners?”

Not awesome, I’ll concede. Over parts of three seasons in Seattle, Garver hit .185/.292/.333, with a 30.1% strikeout rate. He was literally below replacement level. But consider that Garver was older then than Jeffers is now, and also that I’m determined not to learn anything from that experience.

That said, the Garver precedent would probably have influenced Jeffers’ market. Jeffers would’ve only needed to convince one GM in order to cash in, but this admittedly risky free agent only becomes more so when signing him costs draft picks and a massive chunk of international pool money. That, of course, assumes the qualifying offer system survives the lockout. But I don’t think an GM, or agent, would want to bet the farm on what’s in the next CBA.

Therefore, I don’t blame Jeffers for taking the big payday up front and running it back next year. He can keep taking walks and socking pull-side dingers, and if he keeps building a track record of performance, he can go into the 2027-28 offseason with a better sales pitch to potential employers. That surely seems to be what Jeffers is thinking; before he accepted the QO, Jeffers turned down a multi-year offer from Minnesota with as-yet-undisclosed financial terms.

In the meantime, Minnesota’s a lovely place to be during baseball season, and if the Twins stink, Jeffers could catch on with a contender at next year’s trade deadline.

Pity that I don’t run a team, though. I’d have made Jeffers preposterously rich.





Michael is a writer at FanGraphs. Previously, he was a staff writer at The Ringer and D1Baseball, and his work has appeared at Grantland, Baseball Prospectus, The Atlantic, ESPN.com, and various ill-remembered Phillies blogs. Follow him on Twitter, if you must, @MichaelBaumann.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted