Why Einhorn Jilted the Mets
Last Thursday, news broke that the prospective deal was dead between Fred Wilpon and David Einhorn for Einhorn to buy $200 million worth of the Mets, a little more than three months after it was first announced. As is often the case with such matters, both sides blamed the other. Einhorn backed out claiming that the Mets changed terms at the last minute; a Mets source told ESPN New York that Einhorn was lying and that he was the one who changed his terms. It seems that the sticking point of the deal was the point that was always most remarkable: the provision that Einhorn would have an option to buy the entire team from Wilpon. The Wilpons clearly didn’t want to lose control of the team, and it seems likely that they simply balked because they were worried at the prospect.
Einhorn is an investor by trade. Unlike the Wilpons, who made their money in real estate, Einhorn spends his career trying to decide whether to invest in people and companies, rather than buildings or land. And he views baseball as an investment, not an act of charity. In a speech to the Ira Sohn Investors Conference earlier this June, he engaged in an extended baseball analogy to explain how Microsoft was like Alex Rodriguez:
I got the analogy wrong. Microsoft is not A-Rod. The better analogy is that the best parts of the Microsoft product portfolio, particularly the dominant Windows Office and Enterprise server franchises, are A-Rod. Put simply, they are some of the most valuable products ever developed in technology. They are record-setters and hall of famers. But they are only part, albeit a large part, of Microsoft. And having A-Rod by himself does not win championships.
Before the 2001 season, the Texas Rangers signed A-Rod to a record 10-year $250M contract. He spent the three years in Texas and did not disappoint, hitting 156 homers and batting over .300, but the team never won more than 73 games, and the Rangers management and overall resource allocation decisions were more Charlie Brown than Sandy Alderson.
That’s not only precluded them from winning despite A-Rod’s heroism, it eventually pushed them into bankruptcy.


