Clayton Kershaw’s Big Miss, Matt Adams’ Big Hit

On Tuesday evening, Clayton Kershaw gave up a home run to Matt Adams. It was a big home run. Wanna know how I know it was a big home run? Because Matt Adams did this:

adams

The graphic which appears during that replay is annoying, but also helpful, because it shows the real reason why Adams’ homer was a big homer. It was a big homer because it gave the Cardinals a 3-2 lead late in an playoff game with the opportunity to eliminate a team that had the best pitcher in the world on the mound. The Cardinals went on to win, of course, and the Dodgers’ season is now over.

This was a big home run, and it was an unlikely home run. Basically any homer allowed by Kershaw is unlikely. But this one was especially unlikely. Moments before Kershaw served up the dinger, the FOX broadcasters called to the viewer’s attention some activity in the Dodgers bullpen, but noted the lack of a left-handed reliever. Quickly, however, they added that “the Dodgers already have their left-handed specialist on the mound.” Rarely is there a situation where it makes sense to take Kershaw out to bring in a left-handed reliever, because rarely is there someone available who is better at getting lefties out than Kershaw. He held left-handed batters to a .215 wOBA this season, which was the best mark of any starting pitcher in the National League, and second only to Chris Sale in the MLB. Kershaw gave up nine homers in the regular season, just one of which came off the bat of a left handed hitter.

And for as good as Kershaw has been against left-handed hitters, Adams has been nearly as bad against left-handed pitching. The sample is limited to just 193 plate appearances, but that’s because he isn’t any good against lefties and the Cardinals know that. His career wOBA is just .234 against lefties, and of his 34 career regular seasons dingers, just six have come against lefties.

Then there’s the fact that this homer came off a curveball. Lefties already don’t hit Clayton Kershaw, but when they do, it’s against his fastball. Prior to yesterday’s game, no lefty had ever taken Kershaw’s curveball deep. Phrased differently: Matt Adams is the first left-handed batter to ever hit a home run off Clayton Kershaw’s curveball in the MLB.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

And it was just the second time Adams had ever hit a curveball from a lefty out of the park. The other instance came exactly three months prior, when he took Justin Wilson’s curve deep for a walkoff.

Kershaw’s curve is deadly to lefties. Adams is dreadful against left-handed curves. The Cardinals knew this. The Dodgers knew this. Kershaw and catcher A.J. Ellis certainly knew this. Said Ellis, after the game:

“Give Matt (Adams) credit for making the adjustment. We weren’t going to adjust because (the curveball) has been such an effective pitch to him. It was probably a little higher than we would have liked, but you still have to hit it.”

The Dodgers plan of attack against Adams was the curveball, and it would have worked, had Kershaw executed it. Problem is, he didn’t execute it. Given the circumstances, this obviously wasn’t your ordinary Kershaw curveball. For Matt Adams to take a Clayton Kershaw curveball deep, it’s got to be one of the fatter curves Kershaws has thrown. Ellis alluded to it in that quote. Let’s see for ourselves.

kersh1

Yup. That’s about as fat as they come. It just kind of… floats over the middle of the plate until Adams crushes it. When we think about a fat curveball, we think about location and we think about movement. Of course, there’s other factors, like the sequence within the at-bat and past history between the two players, but location and movement are the most basic, and also the ones with numbers to support them. Everything is better with numbers, so let’s use them!

In Clayton Kershaw’s career – regular season and playoffs included – he has thrown 2,605 curveballs. This one right here was 2.4 inches from the center of the zone, horizontally. Of those 2,605 curveballs, just 664 of them have been within 2.5 inches horizontally from the center of the plate.

But a curve down the middle can still be a good pitch when it breaks into the dirt. This is how Kershaw dominates. It looks like it’s going to be middle-middle until it’s not anymore. As Ellis mentioned, this one didn’t do that. This one was high. This one crossed the plate 2.5 inches above the center of the zone. Of the 664 curves we’re left with, just 84 of them also were within 2.5 inches of the center of the zone, vertically. We’ve pared down Kershaw’s 2,605 career curveballs to just 84 that were dead middle-middle.

But there’s break, too. If you’ve seen a Clayton Kershaw curveball before, you know they don’t usually just float there like this one did. This one had about 10.5 inches of vertical drop, which is actually pretty good for a Kershaw curve, but 12 of our remaining 84 curves had more drop. Now we’re down to 72.

But it wasn’t as much a lack of vertical break that made this pitch so fat as it was a lack of horizontal break. Kershaw’s curve usually sweeps across the strike zone with a little more than three inches of horizontal break. This one broke just two inches. 55 of our 72 hanging Kershaw curves had more horizontal break than this one, leaving us with 17 curveballs.

Just 17 of Clayton Kershaw’s 2,605 curveballs over a seven-year stretch have been as middle-middle as this one with as little movement as this one had. He throws about two curveballs a year this fat. This one was his last pitch of the season. The pitch he’ll have to sit on for an entire offseason.

Everyone makes mistakes, even the best pitcher in the world. Considering the fact that nobody has ever done what Adams did off Kershaw, it’s hard to fault Kershaw for making literally the first mistake of this kind in his entire career. Maybe it had something to do with the fact that he was pitching on three days rest for just the second time and he was already up to 101 pitches. Maybe it was just something that was bound to happen eventually, because nobody is perfect. One thing is for sure: the timing couldn’t have possibly been worse, especially because it came right after two singles that each barely left the infield.

Even when Kershaw throws a curve this fat, it’s not exactly a recipe for disaster. Usually, hitters are so taken aback by it that they watch it go for a called strike. Batters only swung at six of our 17 fattest Kershaw curves. One of those was a whiff. One was a foul ball. Two were popouts, one was a groundout, and one was a dinger. Kershaw made a huge mistake with this pitch, yes, but credit is due to Matt Adams for being the first one in Kershaw’s career to pounce on the mistake the way he did.





August used to cover the Indians for MLB and ohio.com, but now he's here and thinks writing these in the third person is weird. So you can reach me on Twitter @AugustFG_ or e-mail at august.fagerstrom@fangraphs.com.

27 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Ceetar
12 years ago

This is basically the glory of the playoffs in a nutshell. Individual performances of players bucking odds in specific circumstances. We have the regular season to watch Kershaw dominate on a routine basis, to watch the mastery of Andrew McCutchen drive the ball all over the place. In the playoffs..well, it’s about these collection of small events rolled into a battle that create a story out of a baseball series or game. Kershaw makes that pitch and it’s about his dominance. He didn’t, so it’s Adam’s triumph.

But why couldn’t Wainwright have floated his curve 8 years ago?

Fatbot
12 years ago
Reply to  Ceetar

“This is basically the glory of the playoffs in a nutshell. Individual performances of players bucking odds in specific circumstances” … I get that view and indeed it always gets the media love. But too often the other viewpoint is ignored — the one that wants to see baseball’s greatest perform at their greatest on the greatest stage. Sadly, the recent baseball playoffs seem to be more and more about “unlikely heroes” storylines and less about the best talents providing a championship moment to put a stamp on a Hall of Fame career. I’m not a Cards or Dodgers fan, but I would have rather seen a no-hitter by Kershaw than this.

Swfcdan
12 years ago
Reply to  Ceetar

When he struck out Carlos Beltran looking?

Poor Man's Rick Reed
12 years ago

This is awesome (article). This is terrible (reliving that sickening feeling of Kershaw, hands on knees, contemplating the impossibility of what just occurred).

Eephus
12 years ago

This is exactly why fangraphs gives me joy every day. Thank you.

Graves
12 years ago

Aaaaaahhhhh!
I don’t think all this data makes it any less painful.
I will say that if the Dodgers were up 4 – 0 like they could have been, and end up winning 4-3 the “narrative” would have been how great Kershaw Pitched to force a game 5.

Hurtlockertwo
12 years ago

As a devote Dodger hater I’m glad this happened, even though I admire Kershaw as the best pitcher in MLB. This is why we love this game.

chuckb
12 years ago

This is a really great article. Fantastic job.

Also, watch the .gif for Kershaw’s reaction. I’m a Cards fan who was (duh!) ecstatic when Adams hit this ball but Kershaw’s head swings around faster than the ball left Adams’ bat. You can’t help but feel for Kershaw when he saw and knew, instantly — as quickly as Adams did, what just happened.

It was obviously an incredible moment for so many reasons — in a good way for Adams and the Cards, and horrifyingly for the Dodgers and Kershaw.

Duke
12 years ago

A perfect storm of mistake/swing/series timing. The magnitude of this pitch and this result is crazy. A single throw that gives all the talking heads their narratives about Kershaw as a “choking dog.” (Please…)

I had an agenda with my visit to fangraphs today, looking for exactly this, an article about this one pitch. Perfect, thank you.

YEHUDA
12 years ago

The best does not always win and the worst does not always lose.

Z.....
12 years ago

He hung a curveball to Adams earlier in the game, which he popped up

Brooks
12 years ago

The problem with this analysis is that it eliminated from the sample of Kershaw’s fattest curves an even fatter curve Kershaw threw to Grichuk in Game One. That particular curve had absolutely no bite to it and ended up about thigh high and just a bit off the inside corner. Down and in to a Major League hitter is probably just as dangerous as belt high over the middle, because down and in is an easier pitch to pull and generate back spin on the ball, paricularly with a pitch that has top spin like a curveball.

Grichuk’s homer happened on the seventh pitch of the game, on an 0-2 count, with no runners on, and just after Kershaw had fanned Carpenter on four pitches. Not exactly a high-leverage pitch, unless you take the position that every pitch in the postseason is high leverage.

Was Kershaw tired when he hung the curve to Grichuk? He was pitching only on eight days of rest at the time.

je
12 years ago
Reply to  Brooks

but that is also probably not a pitch you would expect a rookie to swing at 0-2

it was in the bottom corner of the zone. righties typically aren’t the down and in hitters like lefties. i dont know..i dont think you can compare the two.

also the fact that leaving pitches up is a side effect of being tired. i dont even know if kershaw was tired in the Adams AB he could have just made a bad pitch.

Brian
12 years ago

It’s like my brain is hard right now.

“Matt Adams is the first left-handed batter to ever hit a home run off Clayton Kershaw’s curveball in the MLB.”

August, amazing article.

Alex Dodd
12 years ago

Comeback Article of the Year? Great post.

joe
12 years ago

What is the more likely explanation here? That a six sigma event just happened? Or these were not normal circumstances and Adams new a curveball was coming?

As you think about the answer to that question, realize how invested everyone here is in the purity of the sport and the cognitive dissonance and mental distress it would cause to contemplate anti-competitive behavior,

red
12 years ago
Reply to  joe

I think it most likely that Kershaw was tipping his pitches. It isn’t hard to believe that St. Louis could look at a ton of video and find something, perhaps when he comes to the stretch position. Not unethical. Very plausible.

Paul Theiss
12 years ago
Reply to  joe

If the Cardinals were stealing signs or had figured out that Kershaw was tipping his pitches, why did they wait until the third batter in the seventh inning to capitalize?

Ruki Motomiya
12 years ago
Reply to  Paul Theiss

Tipping pitches would only mean you know what’s coming, yeah? Just ’cause you know what’s coming doesn’t mean you can hit it (All time example: Mariano Rivera).

Paul
12 years ago
Reply to  Ruki Motomiya

That might be true for an inning or two. But if Kershaw was tipping pitches, it would be highly improbable to miss as badly as the Cards did for about 100 pitches and then suddenly connect on one.

In any event, Grant Brisbee’s piece makes and supports the better point that Kershaw just missed his spots in these games.

Joe
12 years ago
Reply to  Paul Theiss

Maybe it takes that much data. I’d be curious to hear from someone who knows math how much data is required to decode hand and finger signals.

Poor Man's Rick Reed
12 years ago
Reply to  joe

It looked like Adams was sitting curveball, got it, and didn’t miss. I think it’s more likely that he just guessed right on that one pitch than they were stealing signs.

Mark L
12 years ago

I’ve been enjoying the baseball sites and every non-STL journalist basically ignoring the Cardinals side in this (apart from when they’re being accused of cheating by the most biased TV commentary team I’ve ever heard). The idea that the Cardinals just worked on a gameplan and it came together, at the same time Kershaw had a couple of rough innings, just doesn’t seem to enter anyone’s heads.

Even Fangraphs…look at the number of articles on the front page that mention Kershaw specifically, or the Dodgers generally. Then look for mentions of the team that beat them, and beat them fairly comfortably. Aside from an interview with the scouting director and Adams getting second billing in this article, nothing. Actually, that sort of makes it 3-2. Ignore this paragraph.

I’d like some sort of update on the odds that were listed before the beginning of the postseason, where one of the two odds lists had the Cardinals below the As in their chance to win the World Series (and the other table had the Cardinals dead last among the actual division winners in WS winning chance).

I’ve really felt a sea change in the way “general” baseball sites reported on the Cardinals this year. As the Yankees have sucked for years, it’s like everyone needs a boogeyman. How about one of the 11 teams who spends more than the Cardinals? Heck, how about the team that spent more than twice the amount the Cardinals did on payroll – the Dodgers? How about one of the 28 other teams with a lower attendance than the Cardinals? It’s like the Cardinals can’t be faulted for finding players, getting people into the stadium (the more baseball fans, the more sites like this) or success, so there’s either been acres of crap about their obnoxious team philosophy, or the actions of a tiny tiny minority of fans. Or, in the case of quite a lot of sites, just ignoring them, even when reporting on a game they won against the best pitcher in baseball.

How about, rather than another hand-wringing article about how Kershaw lost, we have an article or two about how St. Louis won?

Joel
12 years ago

A pleasure to read. The analysis here added to the emotion of the moment instead of sterilizing it. One small editing issue–it should read ” The Dodgers’ plan of attack” instead of “The Cardinals…”.

Swfcdan
12 years ago

“Prior to yesterday’s game, no lefty had ever taken Kershaw’s curveball deep.”

Holyyyyyyy shit.

Swfcdan
12 years ago
Reply to  Swfcdan

And wow, that was the first time someone took advantage of a fat Kershaw curveball, and they launched it.

Crazy things happen in the playoffs, the feeling of pressure on a pitcher can’t be underestimated too. These aren’t anything like regular season games, Kershaw had the weight of Dodger nation on his back that game, and even the invincibles break sometimes.