Cody Bellinger or Christian Yelich for NL MVP?

Anthony Rendon and Ketel Marte have both had very good seasons, but all year long they’ve been a few beats behind Christian Yelich and Cody Bellinger. With only a few days left in the regular season, Marte has already been shut down and Rendon would need a historic week to match the two favorites. While Yelich’s season is unfortunately over, his work already done clearly puts him, along with Bellinger, in the top two for the MVP. With the numbers on offense creating a substantial edge for Yelich, who deserves MVP comes down to a question nobody really likes answering: How much better is Cody Bellinger on defense than Christian Yelich?

It’s possible some voters will ding Yelich for his injuries and playing time lost, though it didn’t stop Mookie Betts and Mike Trout from finishing 1-2 in the AL MVP last year, or keep Josh Hamilton from winning in 2010 when he missed almost all of September. Historically, there haven’t been very many MVPs with around 130 games and 600 PAs, though that likely has less to do with voters being unwilling to vote for players who have missed some of the season and more to do with it just being incredibly difficult to be the best player in the league when other candidates have an extra three weeks to compile numbers.

Since 1931, there have only been 22 position player seasons of at least 7.5 WAR and fewer than 600 plate appearances. Of those 22 seasons, only 10 topped the league in WAR. Six of those 10 players won the MVP that season. In 2009, the under-appreciated Ben Zobrist topped the league in WAR, but Joe Mauer, behind by 0.3 WAR, won the trophy. In 1989, Lonnie Smith played in 134 games and tied Will Clark for the league lead in WAR at 8.1, but it was Clark’s teammate Kevin Mitchell and his 49 homers that took home the MVP. In 1985, Pedro Guerrero topped the NL in WAR at 7.8, but Willie McGee’s 7.1 WAR won him the award thanks in no small part to a .353 batting average. Finally, way back in 1954, Ted Williams topped the AL in WAR, but the Yankees’ Yogi Berra won the vote. Yelich’s situation isn’t unprecedented, but it is fairly rare; players in his position have won MVP around half the time.

As for a tale of the tape, which has been done in the last week at Baseball Prospectus, there’s a seeming consensus that Yelich has been the better offensive player this season, with a small edge at the plate. That gap widens once baserunning is included; here at FanGraphs, Yelich’s edge is 12 runs. At Baseball-Reference, he’s is also up by 12 runs. At Baseball Prospectus, the gap is seven runs with their error bars ranging roughly from Yelich ahead by 1 to 13 runs.

At Baseball Savant, there is no gap between the two players using xwOBA, but that’s prettily easily explainable, as xwOBA doesn’t account for shifts. Bellinger pulls the ball nearly 50% of the time while Yelich is just under 40% on batted balls. Bellinger pulls 70% of his ground balls and nearly 60% of his line drives. The result is that Bellinger fares worse than xwOBA believes he should due to the standard defense against him. Bellinger pulls the ball more to get more hits and home runs overall, and willingly makes the tradeoff to take more outs into the shift. Bellinger’s 75 wRC+ in more than 300 plate appearances against the shift isn’t bad luck on hard hit balls. Yelich has about half the plate appearances, but has a 140 wRC+ against the shift, an indication that shifting against him might not be that useful, and the relative number of plate appearances against the shift opens up more holes for Yelich.

If we chalk up only the difference between xwOBA and wOBA on pulled ground balls and line drives to a more realistic situation, we are back at 12 runs difference between Yelich and Bellinger and in agreement with FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference. Bellinger’s extra playing time nets him two more runs above replacement than Yelich, cutting the deficit to 10 runs. On defense, both players have a positional adjustment of about six runs. So without factoring intangibles or clutch or how much a player meant to a team or where their playoff position would be without them, Bellinger needs to be 10 runs better than Yelich on defense to even the score.

Here at FanGraphs, using UZR, Yelich is plus two on defense compared to Bellinger’s plus 9.5, meaning we have Yelich still up by 2.5 runs, which explains how Yelich’s 7.8 WAR is three-tenths better than Bellinger’s 7.5 mark. That’s not true at Baseball-Reference, where Bellinger is plus 24 based on DRS, while Yelich is neutral. Those 24 runs put Bellinger 14 runs ahead of Yelich and explain his 8.6 Baseball-Reference WAR versus Yelich’s 7.1 WAR. So what are we to do? Splitting the difference puts Bellinger up by a handful of runs, but weights DRS more heavily due to its greater spread of results. Taking three-year averages of the pair of metrics would make the players almost even. We could break the tie with Baseball Prospectus, where the 16-run difference between the two players puts Bellinger less than a handful of runs ahead overall. We can consult Statcast data as well.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-Members
✓Full postseason coverage

Both UZR and DRS have Bellinger’s arm worth about five more runs, so if Bellinger’s range and errors are worth five more runs than Yelich, that would put the two players even. Any larger a gap, and Bellinger will have produced more runs than Yelich this season. Jake Mailhot discussed Bellinger’s defensive game earlier this month. According Outs Above Average, Bellinger is plus-seven and Yelich is minus-four. That’s not a lot of help. Even dialing down and noting that Bellinger was two outs better on balls going back and eight outs better on balls going up, assuming two doubles and eight singles, provides a run value of right around eight runs. Using the traditional defensive metrics for his arm and Statcast for range, Bellinger ends up three runs better overall. Over the course of a six-month season, three runs isn’t a lot to hang your hat on when trying to differentiate between players. One season of defensive metrics isn’t a lot to rely on, either.

When weighing a potential choice for MVP, the decision in the NL essentially comes down to whether Cody Bellinger is more than 10 runs better on defense than Yelich this season. Depending on which defensive metrics you’re using and how you’re using them, relying only on this year or taking a three year average, the difference ranges all the way from six runs (three-year UZR average/1000 innings), to eight runs (single-season UZR), to 11 runs (three-year Statcast or three-year DRS/UZR average), to 13 runs (single-season Statcast), to 16 runs (three-year DRS or single-season UZR/DRS average), to 24 runs (single season DRS). Average all of those together, and we end up at 13 runs. We can manipulate our brains and these numbers to shake out any number of ways, but none of that wrangling seems to provide us with confidence in a definitive answer.

We can do the same mental gymnastics with clutch hitting. Yelich came up to the plate 48 times in high leverage situations, and his 287 wRC+ is the best in the game in those situations and much higher than Bellinger’s 133 wRC+ in 57 PA. In medium-leverage and low-leverage situations, the two players were nearly identical (164 wRC+ for Yelich versus 163 wRC+ for Bellinger), but those high-leverage situations helped Yelich to a two-win gap in WPA that would essentially double the 12-run offensive gap between the two players if you look only at results and how much they impacted individual games. While Yelich likely isn’t an inherently more-clutch baseball player than Bellinger, those are the results on the field. If we believe that single-season DRS might not necessarily represent the true defensive talent of the individual players, but does represent what happened on the field this season, wouldn’t we also consider WPA? I’m not sure we should be doing either.

Any number of narratives apply to both players. Bellinger is the best player on the best team and he’s played all year long. His defense makes him the better all-around player. Yelich’s performance was more integral to whether or not the Brewers make the playoffs. He’s the better offensive player and came through more often in the clutch. Ultimately, these are just narratives to help people feel better about their vote or the candidate they support. The race is too close to call. A vote for either candidate is simultaneously justifiable and difficult to justify.





Craig Edwards can be found on twitter @craigjedwards.

68 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Spencer JonesMember since 2020
7 years ago

Criminal that you’re ignoring Rendon here

Monsignor Martinez
7 years ago
Reply to  Spencer Jones

Ignoring Rendon? Did you read the 1st word of the article?

JLanDC
7 years ago

OK, so maybe a better choice of words would have been ‘Criminal that you’re dismissing Rendon here’. Edwards totally dismisses Rendon but without giving his reasons. That’s bush league.

Hear, hear!

Bryan O'ConnorMember since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  JLanDC

This. Rendon leads Bellinger in OBP and wOBA, and has offered more defensive value and similar baserunning value. Bellinger’s .4-WAR edge comes from power (.020 edge in slugging) and volume (15 PA in 9 extra games).

Would it take a “historic week” for Rendon to close the gap, or just a continuation of what Rendon has done in the second half (.342/.435/.595, 3.7 WAR) vs. Bellinger’s line (.249/.359/.528, 2.0 WAR)?

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  Bryan O'Connor

Rendon would have a lot better chance right now if his September was more like his Apr-Aug months.
wRC+
Mar/Apr 193
May 141
June 142
July 147
August 190
September 114

Obviously Yelich isn’t adding anything in September- and Bellinger has only a 103 in September. But when you are the one who was clearly trailing- to get into the conversation you have to be strong finishing. Rendon hasn’t in September.

RonnieDobbs
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

Belly’s entire second half hasn’t sniffed MVP numbers. To me that is a bit of a problem. Yelich going down was really the only set of circumstances where he still has a case, which he certainly does. Personally I am trying to find other contenders. That gap between first and second half is really something. I completely understand why people would vote for Belly, but its a weird one. Normally you have a big second half…. if you don’t like Rendon’s September, then take a look at June-Sept for Bellinger.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  RonnieDobbs

The problem is that those 1st 2 months Bellinger was by far the best player in the game(and to include Trout- 4.2-3.2). Rendon was only at 2.3. He had a huge hole- and got close. But not close enough to totally make up those 1st 2 months.

Also Bellinger June-Sep has a wRC+ of 132. Rendon in September only 114. If Rendon had copied what he did in August he would have absolutely had a chance. But he didn’t.

SertoriusMember since 2023
7 years ago
Reply to  JLanDC

Probably because Rendon trails both Yelich and Bellinger in fWAR, bWAR, situational hitting, and team success. He’s had an amazing season that should be mentioned more. However, it’s hard to make an argument for him to be MVP over Yelich or Bellinger. He even trails Marte in both fWAR and bWAR.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  Sertorius

Rendon’s actually a tick above both in RE24, which actually does measure situational hitting, unlike WPA.

willl
7 years ago
Reply to  Sertorius

How does one measure “team success”? If by that you mean win percentage, last I check the Nats were ahead of the Brewers in the WC standings, and were significantly better at the moment Yelich went down with an injury.

lilpudgeMember since 2020
7 years ago

If Rendon is “a beat behind” the top 2–using WAR–Bellinger is “a beat behind” Yelich, in more games!

bly
7 years ago
Reply to  lilpudge

As of right now he’s 0.1 WAR ahead of Bellinger and Bellinger is 0.9 WAR behind Yelich, so he’s actually negative nine beats behind.

seasplash
7 years ago
Reply to  bly

Fangraphs said they made a mistake on fWAR calculations and updated the correct fWARs. Bellinger is now at 7.6.

BaseballBreaksYourHeart
7 years ago

In the first paragraph it says:

With the numbers on offense creating a substantial edge for Bellinger, who deserves MVP comes down to a question nobody really likes answering: How much better is Cody Bellinger on defense than Christian Yelich?

Think it say “substantial edge for Yelich”

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

It might not be right, but I think what’s happened since Yelich got hurt is going to hurt his MVP chances.

Also for Yelich think while you bring up Betts/Trout- they did have 6/10 more games than Yelich this year. And the competition is a whole lot stronger for Yelich with Bellinger than Betts/Trout had with Ramirez last year.
last year- fWAR
Betts 10.4/Trout 9.8- next closest Ramirez 8.0
Yelich 7.8- next closest Bellinger 7.4

I think Rendon could have gotten close here- but he’s only batting .188 since Yelich got hurt with a 84 wRC+.

SnowLeopard
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

> I think what’s happened since Yelich got hurt is going to hurt his MVP chances.
> [Rendon]’s only batting .188 since Yelich got hurt

Bellinger’s batted .219 / .306 / .359 in 72 PA since Sept 3.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  SnowLeopard

true, but he was most likely in the lead then- definitely ahead of Rendon. Also, interesting you say since Sept 3. I wonder why you didn’t quote September. Oh, that’s right he goes 3-10 in those first 2 games with 2 homers…. So in September he’s got a 239/.341/.451. 103 wRC+. Not great, but then again going into September- he and Yelich were tied in fWAR and Rendon was 0.6 behind. Rendon has been a smidge better than Bellinger(0.2 fWAR) in September, but not enough to make up how far behind he was.

Do think it’s very possible we see Rendon sit 2-3 games here these last 5 games. Which would put his games total around 145.

OTMHeartBBCMember since 2019
7 years ago

coin flip so ill go with the guy on the better team – belly

and esp since brewers are like 10-1 without yelly

Cave Dameron
7 years ago
Reply to  OTMHeartBBC

The Brewers have had the best pitching in the MLB since Yelich went down (2.27 ERA). That suddenly makes Yelich less valuable?

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  Cave Dameron

like it or not, the Brewers being 20-7 for the season w/o Yelich doesn’t help his case in the least.

The Duke
7 years ago

The brewers have laid waste to the idea that yelich is the straw that stirs the drink, so I will go with Bellinger

CC AFCMember since 2016
7 years ago

I can’t value it with any level of precision, but maybe also a modest bonus to Bellinger for defensive versatility, as well, given that he’s played significant innings in RF, CF, and 1B, which is nice for a team like the dodgers to be able to use with the injuries they’ve had and platooning they like to do.

EltnegMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  CC AFC

Yeah I’ve always wondered this, and it’s come up re: Kris Bryant and Zobrist in the past. I think there’s a case to be made that someone who fields multiple positions well can be significantly undervalued by defensive metrics– at the very least it feels odd that someone who can play a good 3B gets a negative adjustment for moving to LF for a stretch to cover for an injured player.

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago
Reply to  CC AFC

One of the best reasons this statement is nonsense:
“When weighing a potential choice for MVP, the decision in the NL essentially comes down to whether Cody Bellinger is more than 10 runs better on defense than Yelich this season.”
There is a common straw man that the nerds want the MVP to be the highest WAR award. There is room for tons of nuance and consideration of all sorts of factors, small or smaller, when WAR is very close. Don’t give the idiots pushing the straw man some actual flesh for their argument.

Brian McMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  CC AFC

This is a fantastic point. It is incredibly helpful to be able to play multiple defensive positions, and WAR doesn’t capture that (not sure how it can). LeMahieu is in a similar position, even moreso because he plays multiple infield positions. Of course, I’m not arguing for him to be the MVP, just pointing out that WAR isn’t properly capturing his value.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

do know we talked a bit about voter fatigue with the Cy Young votes…. Think it could apply here- Yelich winning last year doesn’t do him any favors this season.

sadtromboneMember since 2020
7 years ago

I’d pick Yelich, but I also think I have better hills to die on, even when it comes to arguing about awards internet.

SertoriusMember since 2023
7 years ago

If there ever was a season there should be co-MVPs, it’s this one. I doubt there’s been a season where two players have been the undisputed but inseparable one and two for so long.

bluerum29
7 years ago

At this point I would say its Bellinger at the top . Yellich or Rendon afterwards is not a problem either. The reality is you can make a solid argument for all 3 of them.

Baron Samedi
7 years ago

Christian Yelich.

Johnston
7 years ago

Bellinger is the best player in the NL and he’s the best player on the best team in the NL. He’s the MVP. Period.

Awarding the MVP to anyone else would be viewed as a travesty in the future.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

I think the games played thing is far more significant than Craig makes it out to be.

In this decade… had 2 pitchers win MVP votes.

The other 16 MVP’s- only 2 didn’t play at least 147 games. Would note that both of these were in the AL.

NL hasn’t had a guy with 130 games win MVP since 2003 Barry Bonds. he led the league in bWAR by 0.5 over Pujols. in fWAR it was 0.7. going to this year- Yelich leads Bellinger by 0.4 fWAR. in bWAR it’s Bellinger up by 1.3.

carterMember since 2020
7 years ago

The only Sportsbook that I can find that is taking bets on MVP as of three days ago when the line closed had it like this:

Rendon -150
Bellinger + 105
Yelich +1000
Acuna +1500

Now I am not saying I agree with it, but a casino willing to take large bets thinks Rendon is favored and Bellinger is the only other likely person who can win. I tend to agree with them. I don’t agree that it is right, but I think that almost certainly is the scenario based on how voters have voted traditionally.

carterMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  carter

Now you would think WAR totals is what matters, but I doubt voters will vote that way. I think Rendon wins. Bellingers second half does him no favors, and Yelich missing time/winning last year I think all but rules him out. Keep in mind I do not agree with the logic, but if I was a betting man, and I certainly am I would bet Rendon wins.

carterMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  carter

The above examples he cites where guys missed X time and still won are primarily because no one else was close. In 2010 Hamilton put up 8.4 WAR and had a historical traditional batting line of .359/411/633. Batting average was a lot more important back then. The next to closest people in WAR were both on the same team (Crawford/Longoria) with far inferior batting lines generating a lot of their value from defense. Crawford was never going to win as guys who steal a lot of bases and play good defense rarely do, and Longoria with a .294 and 22 hrs at a corner position wasn’t going to win either. That is not how voters voted at that time. Matter of fact they pretty much voted straight down batting line (Hamilton, Miggy, Cano, Bautista, Konerko) before including the guys with good D and higher WAR.

Last year there was other people who could of won (Jram, Lindor, Bregman, Chapman) but the WAR lead was pretty huge with both Betts and Trout around 10 depending on whose metric you use and others in the 7 range.

carterMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  carter

The 2019 AL is going to be a pretty interesting one. I think Trout should win, but once again I don’t think he does. Most likely will be Bregman, followed by Trout. NL I think it is a toss up with a slight lead to Rendon. He just fits the “narrative”, and like it or not Bryce Harper is this big name sportswriters are mostly from the east coast, and the team losing him and getting better blah blah. Now I think those are all stupid reasons to vote a certain way, but voters also tend to be stupid.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  carter

In fairness to 2010 voters – Cano’s DRS was 20 points higher than his UZR, putting him a full win ahead of Crawford, and equal to Longo, by rWAR.

Joey Bats was tied with Crawford, as well (and both were behind Brett Gardner).

Hank G.Member since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  carter

Casinos set the line to get the money spread as evenly as possible. If they can do that, they can make a profit with absolutely no risk. If the casino line is accurate, it is only because of the wisdom of the crowd.

JupiterBrandoMember since 2020
7 years ago

It seems weird to write all of this up without mentioning that Bellinger has played RF, CF and 1B. Positional versatility is hard to quantify, but considering who the Dodgers have been able to put in their lineup because of Bellinger it seems strange to exclude that entirely. And with that factored in, which voters will do, I don’t think it’ll be close.

Hank G.Member since 2016
7 years ago
Reply to  JupiterBrando

Is playing the two corner outfield positions and first base really positional “versatility”? The only real difference between left and right is the desire that the right fielder have a good arm, and what corner outfielder could not handle first base with a little practice?

Zobrist in his career has played every position except catcher and pitcher. That is positional versatility.

FermatsLastAccount
7 years ago

It says that Bellinger has a 74 wRC+ against shifts in 300 PAs. Would that mean his wRC+ when they aren’t shifting is astronomical?

TKDCMember since 2016🏆 MVP
7 years ago

My guess is that this is on balls in play. Otherwise, he’d need to be Barry Bonds in those other situations.

piddy
7 years ago

that’s without 3 true outcomes. His wRC+ against a traditional shift is 74 in 339 at bats vs 300 in 13 at bats against a non traditional shift, and 70 in 43 at bats against no shift.

So contrary to Craig’s implication he’s better against the shift.

MikeD
7 years ago

I do have some issues with the weighting of defense in WAR, believing it overvalues OF defense, particularly CF. That said, both are deserving.

I’d go with Bellinger if I had a vote. Fortunately for Yellich supporters, I do not.

David Ducksworth
7 years ago

I’m surprised that it has not been brought up, but with Marte out, Yelich appears to have a lock on the slash-line Triple Crown for the National League, he’s leading Rendon by 19 points in OBP and Bellinger by 48 in slugging. Batting average is the only place where he might lose it, ahead of Rendon by 7 points, but his odds are looking pretty good.

That is, of course, not really a statistic that captures value better than wRC+, and it does not have the same kind of conventional statistic appeal to voters that the normal Triple Crown would, but it certainly stands out. Is there any history on a player winning the triple slash Triple Crown and not winning MVP? I imagine there are at least a few cases, but I’d think it would be rather rare.

FrancoeursteinMember since 2020
7 years ago

Fred Lynn slashed .333/.423/.637 (!!) in 1979. He came in 4th in the MVP voting.

Dominikk85Member since 2020
7 years ago

I thought first when I read it it was close when yelich got hurt but now it isn’t because yelich is almost missing a full month but then I saw bellinger didn’t do much in September either. Just a 103 wRC+ for the month.

He has been trending downward anyway in the second half

184 wRC+ first half and 125 second half.

Still think he will win it

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  Dominikk85

I think Bellinger had just enough big moments in September since Yelich went out. He had a huge Grand Slam on Sunday. 1 other homer since Yelich went out- a fairly big one vs Tampa if memory serves me right. Those are big for him- especially the Grand Slam obviously.

jtricheyMember since 2021
7 years ago

I’m about to blow some minds:

Did you know that Cody Bellinger hasn’t increased his season batting average week to week since April 21-28? He hit .500 in the first 4 days of the season. If you look at his average after Sunday games every week since then it has gone down every single time except once. On April 21 he was at .424 and on April 28 he was at .427. 2 other times his average stayed the same over a 7 day period, every other time it has gone down, and entering tonight he sits at an even .300. I can’t get over this.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  jtrichey

and the problem with Yelich(and a much bigger one) is that he only has 130 games played. I think we’re going to find to a lot of voters that is a major disqualifier… Being on the field means something.

socalkdgMember since 2020
7 years ago

If it is a tossup between Bellinger and Yelich at the end of the season, does that mean Trout wins over Bregman with Trout being about .5 WAR better when the season ends? Secondly, do you think voters have it in their head when two players are very close to give it to the guy that has never won one?

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  socalkdg

There too- Bregman will wind up with about 20 more games than Trout.

looking-entering tonight
Trout up by 0.7 fWAR, 0.3 bWAR.

Tonight Bregman went 3-4 so far with 2 doubles. Using the live feature here, it’s now only a 0.5 gap for fWAR. With Bregman having 4 more games to make up even more ground. Could get pretty close to a tie.

chrisjacoby
7 years ago

In our ottenou inspired Fantasy league, Bellinger and Bregman overtook Yellich and Trout last week in total fantasy points. The scores are highly correlated w/ wOBA, with bonus points for grand slams, intentional walks and cycles and grounding into double plays and strikeouts reducing season point totals. Bellinger is racking up the counting stats, now having more hits, doubles, home runs, and walks than Yellich. Even though he has more PAs, he also struck out less than Yellich as well.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago

wow reading Jayson Stark’s awards column- he has a very interesting factoid for both MVP races. No player has ever missed his teams final 7 games and won MVP. Dick Allen in ’72 missed last 6 games.

Mean Mr. Mustard
7 years ago

“One season of defensive metrics isn’t a lot to rely on, either.”

I daresay that, when discussing deserving MVPs, one season of defensive metrics is *exactly* what you want to rely on since the award is given for the most valuable *that year*. The question isn’t who is the better true-talent fielder; the question is who was more valuable. Three-year averages shouldn’t be a part of the conversation in this particular context.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
7 years ago

If defensive metrics actually told us what happened on the field, rather than what a model using eye-test “data” thinks probably happened on the field, while ignoring factors like positioning, this would be a much stronger argument.

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
7 years ago

Why use WPA to assess their real impact on scoring runs, when it pretends that a bomb in the 1st inning of a 1-0 game is “less valuable” than one hit in the 9th?

RE24 actually measures the effect you’re using WPA as a proxy for, and it has the pair of them in a dead heat, offensively.

I’d still probably go Yelich – his year was more outstanding, even with the injury, and I think he made a bigger difference in the Brewers’ season than Bellinger did in the Dodgers’…but RE24 should absolutely factor into MVP discussions since, y’know, it actually measures the real run value of what happened on the field.

M^3Member since 2016
7 years ago

Not that it really matters, but Mitchell hit 47 HRs in 1989, not 49.

RonnieDobbs
7 years ago

Vote for Yelich here. Baseball overemphasizes quantity over quality far too often.

Thank you for acknowledging that we should not blindly trust defensive metrics.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  RonnieDobbs

Missing 20% of the season is huge though. To survive that in my mind, you have to be way ahead of everyone else. Yelich isn’t.

Spitball McPhee
7 years ago

I don’t put much weight in this; but the Disationals would probly be out of contention without the steady brilliance of Rendon.

NATS FanMember since 2018
7 years ago

Rendon’s my MVP. I believe it’s easy to be Bellinger when your always winning and the guys around are all excellent hitters. Rendon is the best hitter and best fielder on his team. Trust me the NATS can’t win 40% when he is out! I say the dodgers win that division without Bellinger, and the Brewers are winning without Yelich. Rendon should be the vote

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  NATS Fan

The Nats would have won just as much as the Dodgers if their bullpen hadn’t been kerosene for a lot of the season(even worse than the Dodgers at times).

And the Nats lineup is pretty damn good. Since May 24 when the Nats hot streak started- their batters wRC+ is 118. The Dodgers same period? 119.

MRDXolMember since 2021
7 years ago

Yes, Bellinger is the best player on the best team, but I’m not comfortable trusting defensive metrics to decide this, as they’re so finicky and subject to SSS issues over single seasons. I’d vote for Yelich, on the grounds that he’s been more critical to his team’s success than Bellinger, i.e. literally more valuable. The Dodgers have stars everywhere, a team wRC+ of 111, and a rotation that’s been 2nd in fWAR this year. The Brewers’ rotation is below average, 20th, and their team wRC+ is 97; they’ve won by fielding the third-best team defense in baseball. Yelich is such a vital piece of Milwaukee’s offense; imagine what it would look like without him.

stever20Member since 2017
7 years ago
Reply to  MRDXol

That’s absolutely not the question that a Yelich supporter should be asking right now….

Here’s a way of comparing things. Imagine in the NFL someone misses the last 3 weeks. Do you think they should have any chance at the MVP?

Cool Lester SmoothMember since 2020
7 years ago
Reply to  stever20

I do think that Carson Wentz should have won in 2017, when he threw more TDs and fewer picks than Brady in 3 fewer games.

david k
7 years ago

If you had two players exactly the same age, one putting up a career stat line of several identical seasons of Bellinger’s stats, and another putting up a career stat line of several identical Yellich’s stats, and both hit the free agent market at the same time, who would you give more money to?