Congratulations, Doc

28 batters faced. 25 balls. No hits.

That was amazing. Thanks for one of the best games I’ve ever seen. This is why baseball is just so awesome.





Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.

48 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
KC
15 years ago

Hear, hear.

Mike B.
15 years ago

And the Lee and Halladay trades just keep looking better…

philosofool
15 years ago

Yep. It’s moments like these that I know I’m not just a fan of a team, I’m a fan of a sport.

Grammar Police
15 years ago

games*

Punchandpie
15 years ago

Halladay is my idol and watching that was just amazing.

My echo and bunnymen
15 years ago

I pay for postseason.tv and because I couldn’t make a connection in my Economics class, I miss this!!!!!

phoenix
15 years ago

dude… just… wow. that is some luck.

Ivdown
15 years ago

Ron?

AndrewM
15 years ago

I had the same problem in my econ class. But I just “up and left” after the 6th inning.

Dan Pitrowiski
15 years ago

Is Roy Halladay the best pitcher in baseball?

Any debate that was, must be over

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  Dan Pitrowiski

No question he is the best pitcher on earth this year.

Renegade
15 years ago
Reply to  NEPP

Forget Earth and forget this year.
Roy Halladay is the best pitcher in the universe for the past DECADE.

JBV
15 years ago
Reply to  Dan Pitrowiski

The debate is over? No. But this is a crowning point on his resume.

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  JBV

I think its pretty clear he’s the best pitcher in baseball this year. 2 no-hitters and one of them a perfect game along with all his other stats and his ridiculous amount of IP?

Yeah, he’s the best right now.

toronto
15 years ago

Unbelievable

Amazing Doc!!!

NEPP
15 years ago

Historic effort by a master.

Kirsh
15 years ago

Perfect baseball moment. Being a Pirates fan, it’s good to just see something like this and savor it. As a fan of BASEBALL, not any one team.

Steven
15 years ago

It was amazing, I wish I had been able to see the whole thing instead of just part of an inning…

Though I was joking with my friend that anything less than a PG for Doc isn’t worth it =P…stupid walk

Chris
15 years ago

It is one of the best games I’ve ever seen pitched. He was phenomenal!!

Preet
15 years ago

The Blue Jays fan in me, now has me cheering for the Phillies just so Halladay can get the World Series ring he deserves.

exxroxMember since 2016
15 years ago
Reply to  Preet

only now? I’ve been cheering for the Philadelphia Roy freaking Halladays all year

Steven
15 years ago
Reply to  exxrox

True, that’s the only real reason I’d be ok with seeing the Phillies win.

And it’s only when Halladay is pitching that I’d root for the Phillies, otherwise… meh.

bender
15 years ago
Reply to  Preet

That’s an awesome screenname

Not David
15 years ago

Halladay makes it impossible for me to hate the Phillies.

Damn you Roy, damn you!

Megary
15 years ago

I’m not sure what I enjoyed more – watching Halladay pitch a no-hitter or watching my 11 year old Phillies fan son watch Halladay throw a no-hitter. An absolute nervous wreck with 2 outs in the 9th he looked at me and said “Dad, if he gives up a hit now I’m going to cry.”

Look what I’ve done!

B
15 years ago
Reply to  Megary

Lucky kid’s seeing all of the good moments in Phillies history 🙂

Nick
15 years ago

so much for that offensive advantage the Reds had.

Eric
15 years ago

weren’t the Reds giving up on game 1 anyways?

not taking away anything from Hal. Great job. Wish you did it once in TOR.

aw well, i’ll go sulk in the corner over there

Total Dominication
15 years ago

Roy Halladay is amazing to watch. Almost the same feeling you get from seeing Mariano Rivera pitch. Thank god he’s left the AL East, but facing him the the World Series could be really tough.

He's a Relief Pitcher
15 years ago

Almost as exciting as Rivera huh? Yep, one not-hit inning is WAAAAAY cooler to watch than 9.

Total Dominication
15 years ago

Not that one game, I meant over his career. Obviously he’s more valuable, but Rivera is something else to waict day in and day out for 15 years.

Brian
15 years ago

For such a mediocre organization, good things really seem to happen for them quite frequently.

CircleChange11
15 years ago

Not to diverge, but watching Hallladay dominate just reminded me of how great Pedro was during his dominant stretch.

Halladay is the “perfect storm” of all aspects of pitching, not the karst of which is durability, efficiency, and endurance.

Rarely has a guy with so many early season CGs racked up such innings year after year.

Hard work + mechanics + genetics + skill = Halladay. U gotta love it when one of the best pitchers in the game is one of the most hard working and humble. That’s not always the case.

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  CircleChange11

I totally get what you’re saying on the Pedro reference. Yeah, Pedro was obviously superior (especially in 1999/2000 when his ERA+ was something like 265 for both years combined) but there is the same level of magic in the air, the dejected, lost looks on the faces of the opposing hitters…the complete confidence that Doc will get it done.

PG
15 years ago

Halladay isn’t Pedro in his prime. But then again nobody is. But Halladay has been the best pitcher in baseball for years. What happened today is amazing. Not at all surprising though. And nobody deserves it more.

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  PG

I think pretty much only Koufax was Pedro in his prime…so there’s that. We will likely never see a pitcher as dominating as Pedro was when he was in his peak years.

That’s probably why everyone can use the name “Pedro” and we all know who they’re talking about instantly.

Jonathan
15 years ago
Reply to  NEPP

We’re talking about Cerrano, right?

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  NEPP

Exactly.

Pedro Cerrano
15 years ago
Reply to  NEPP

Martinez throw da fastball. Me and Joe Boo hit fastball long, long way. I am da best Pedro.

Jonathan
15 years ago
Reply to  PG

Y’know, I’ve never really bothered to look at his BABIP for his prime. I simply don’t understand how a 2.07 ERA and sub-1 WHIP should be possible with a .343 BABIP. The guy was simply a demigod on the mound.

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  Jonathan

Guys almost never made contact. His K/9 rate was something like 13 in 1999 and 11.5 in 2000. No contact for most outs so when they did actually hit it, it had a higher chance of being a hit and thus a higher BABIP. You only got a hit on Pedro when he threw a mistake and mistakes were rare.

Jonathan
15 years ago
Reply to  Jonathan

I should say that I understand the physics behind it. He actually managed to have a FIP lower than his ERA, I’m just further exhibiting the absolute mind boggling quality of his pitching in his prime.

scsiduck
15 years ago

Having watched the last out several times since last night, I’ve been wondering: what are the rules regarding the bat interfering with the ball like that?

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  scsiduck

As long as its not intentional, its a live ball.

Here is the rule:

Rule 6.05 (h)..IF the batter drops his bat and the ballrolls against the bat in fair territory, and in the umps judgement there was no intention to interfere with the course of the ball, the ball is alive and in play.

Mike Gianella
15 years ago

Halladay’s provided some great moments this year. As great as the no-hitter and perfect game were, the game vs. Travis Wood were Wood was perfect for 8 but Roy kept the Phils in the game was one of my favorites. Roy didn’t have quite his A stuff but just kept hanging in there and giving the Phils another shot. That to me is the true mark of an ace.

maqman
15 years ago

I saw Larson pitch his 1956 World Series perfect game and he was not as dominant as Doc was yesterday.

Jamee
15 years ago

I’ve never seen anyone pitch as well as Halladay did last night. Phenomenal. (Imagine if they had Clifford going tonight)

NEPP
15 years ago
Reply to  Jamee

Yeah, they have to settle for that bum Oswalt tomorrow…and then Hamels on Sunday. I think Rube fixed that “mistake” by getting Oswalt for 2 years in place of Clifton for 1.