Daily Prospect Notes: 6/28/21
These are notes on prospects from Eric Longenhagen. Read previous installments here.
Nolan Jones, 3B, Cleveland
Level & Affiliate: Triple-A Columbus Age: 23 Org Rank: 2 (66 over) FV: 50
Line: 2-for-4, HR, SB
Notes
Jones got off to a poor start and his overall line hasn’t yet recovered (he’s slugging just .405 on the season, the lowest since his first pro summer back in 2016), but he’s hit .253/.374/.495 over the last month, which is enough to quell overall concerns about him right now. He is a three true outcomes type of player and there may be long stretches where his average is hovering close to the Mendoza line but he’s going to walk a ton and hit for power while playing poor defense at several positions. Jones can be beaten with well-located fastballs at the top of the zone and he’s swung through a lot of them this year, but his swing decisions are typically very good. Per Synergy Sports, he has just a 19% O-Swing% so far this year, which would put him in the top five of qualified big leaguers. There’s real, elite plate discipline here and 70-grade power, but also a clearly exploitable hole in the swing at the top of the strike zone. How those things will interact at the big league level I truly don’t know, though it feels like that hole in the swing is a load-bearing Jenga block against big league pitchers who throw hard and often work at the top of the zone.
Hoy Jun Park, SS, New York Yankees
Level & Affiliate: Triple-A Scranton Age: 25 Org Rank: HM FV: 35
Line: 4-for-5, HR, 2 BB
Notes
Speaking of players with excellent feel for the zone, Park’s chase rates are even lower than Jones’ and Synergy has him offering at just 36 of the 263 out-of-zone pitches he’s seen since promotion to Triple-A, which maths to a 13% rate. Juan Soto’s is 16%. Park has always had good feel for the zone but this year his power output has exploded. He’s slugging a whopping .630 in 30 games at Triple-A and he’s already exceeded his single-season high in home runs. If a viable 2B/SS defender — the Yankees have tried him in center a couple times within the last week; he can make routine plays but is not altogether comfortable there yet — with premium feel for the zone suddenly has power, too, that’s an impact player.
I’m skeptical the power piece of this is real. While I spoke with an analyst to see if Park’s exit velos had shifted northward (they have a little bit), film study of Park shows a player much like the one the industry last saw in 2019. He tracks pitches well and his swing has natural lift but there isn’t big raw power here, definitely not the kind that generates a SLG over .450, let alone .600, across a whole season. His swing has limited in-zone efficacy and Park can really only impact pitches in the bottom two thirds of the zone with any kind of lift. I do think he has some big league utility because he’s a capable middle infielder with great feel for the strike zone and viable bat-to-ball skills, but I don’t think this is suddenly an everyday player.
Jared Jones, RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates
Level & Affiliate: Low-A Bradenton Age: 19 Org Rank: 17 FV: 40+
Line: 4 IP, 2 H, 1 BB, 0 R, 11 K
Notes
Jones was utterly dominant last night, totaling 18 swinging strikes, 14 of which came off his fastball, which sat 93-96 and touched 97 a couple of times. Jones has been working on extended rest, usually a full week, and has only gone three or four innings per outing since he joined Bradenton at the end of May. I think it’s important to view his velocity in that context but the important takeaway as Jones begins his pro career is that he hasn’t had extreme walk issues, which he sometimes battled in high school. There hasn’t been a mechanical adjustment or anything, and it’s not as if Jones has suddenly had a Shane Baz-like strike-throwing development, he just hasn’t melted down. It’s too early to start projecting Jones as a likely starter rather than in relief but based on how his career has begun, the future 35 I currently have on his command will be too low.
John Nogowski, 1B, St. Louis Cardinals
Level & Affiliate: Triple-A Memphis Age: 28 Org Rank: HM FV: 35
Line: 0-for-3, SB
Notes
Nogowski hasn’t been playing well but recall that he was hit by a pitch and sustained a bone bruise to his left hand in April. Hitters can take a while to fully recover from hand injuries. Nogowski looked fantastic during winter ball in the Dominican Republic and even though he has a dreaded “backwards” profile, he’s been a competent upper-level hitter for several years (career .370 OBP) and might be the sort of late-blooming bat that can act as a competent big league band-aid for a couple of years. I think clubs, domestic and international, should stay on him and weigh his late-summer performance more heavily than what we’ve seen so far.
Eric Longenhagen is from Catasauqua, PA and currently lives in Tempe, AZ. He spent four years working for the Phillies Triple-A affiliate, two with Baseball Info Solutions and two contributing to prospect coverage at ESPN.com. Previous work can also be found at Sports On Earth, CrashburnAlley and Prospect Insider.
18 swinging strikes in 4 IP? That had to be demoralizing for the opposing offense. Lmao
He struck out 11 and allowed 2 hits and a walk.
Eric, how does Jones’ batting profile compare to Max Muncy’s?
It doesn’t? It compares more closely to someone like Miguel Sano (probably more like 2021 Sano than 2019 Sano, but that’s the sort of profile you’re looking at). Proponents look at Jones and think he compares to someone like Jack Cust but Jack Cust was a bit of an anomaly–nobody walks that much unless they’re absolutely terrifying hitters (think Mike Trout, Jim Thome, peak Jose Bautista).
I think the big unknown about Jones is if/when he’ll start hitting homeruns. People seem to expect Jones to hit a lot of homeruns but so far that hasn’t happened. Heck this season, he has more steals than homeruns!
So my big question for Jones is this: will he be a guy who hits .220-250 with 10-20 homeruns and lots of walks? Or will he be that same guy with 30+ homeruns, The latter plays. The former, I’m not sure.
I just looked and yes, he is not hitting home runs this year. I think there were reasons to think he was going to hit more home runs back in 2019 but with this backtracking he probably has to get back to where he was before before hitting more dingers.
A different comp for him that I almost made was Domingo Santana. It’s bit unfair because Santana was one of the most inexplicably inefficient defenders I have ever seen but he usually only hit about 20 homers a year, instead running really high BABIPs because he hit lasers all over and walking a lot. I think that if he gets back to where he was before Domingo Santana with better defense is plausible. That’s a functional ballplayer although not a star.
If he doesn’t get back to where he was before then there’s probably no good comparison for him. Jabari Blash, maybe? It’s the kind of profile that gets you DFA’d when you run out of options.
Domingo Santana is a really good offensive comp for Jones. Their plate disciple and batted ball profile are almost identical. They’re at very different points in their career but if you look at their 3 year ZIPS projections, they’re very similar. Ironically Jones’ below average defense nets him an extra 1.5 wins per year.
I think Jones’ biggest issue is he’s just hitting the ball on the ground way too much. A .330 BABIP for a 30 grade runner who hit’s the ball on the ground 48%+ of the time suggests he’s probably rocking some high exit velos but that’s probably not going to cut it at the major league level. Right now he’s playing like the 2020 version of Kyle Schwarber…which isn’t great. If he could get the ball in the air more often though, he could be dangerous.
Yeah, that’s a good point. I remember noticing that about Jones a few years ago. Unfortuantely, since he’s always hit a lot of ground balls, not sure if he can change that.
Are you going to stop doing the video segment along with Monday’s prospect notes?
I was enjoying that
Hmm, Eric wrote the following about Jared Jones:
“There hasn’t been a mechanical adjustment or anything, and it’s not as if Jones has suddenly had a Shane Baz-like strike-throwing development, he just hasn’t melted down.”
So, Baz throws strikes and that counts as a strike throwing development. Jones throws strikes but it doesn’t count as a strike throwing development. He does walk too many, but….his current BB rate bests Baz’s rate at a comparable age.
You’re mixing up your past, present, and future tense. Baz has walked something like 1 batter per nine innings so far this year, after regularly doing 5 per nine innings in previous years. That’s strike throwing development!
I’m not confusing tenses. The claim was Jones’ control improvements do not provide evidence that his control improved, that he’ll meltdown sometime in the future, returning to what some expect of him. Jones’ BB rate remains higher than one would like. But his BB rate is not a cause for concern at this time and will not be a cause for concern unless he regresses to a lesser level of performance.
To put the matter in different terms, Jones has yet to show the control problems imputed to him. Until disaster strikes, if it strikes, we should follow the evidence which suggests that Jones may not have plus control, but his control of his pitches today is not a problem. Also, he has not had a difficult time in -A ball, the level at which he started his professional career.
Thanks for all of the coverage. Can’t wait for the Brewers and Cubs lists. I do a project on MLB The Show where I create a roster with all 40 FV+ prospects and re-rated MLB players based on advanced stats. Your analysis coupled with statistics is my basis for rating prospects’ current skills and future potential.
Can you post that roster in the vault so I can download it? Please
Definitely! I have to finish up the Brewers and Cubs lists after Eric is through with them so it’ll be a while. Project is 300+ hours in total lol lots of late nights. Pitchers are rated insanely high right now with the way this year has gone… It’ll be under xKobeBean24x on PSN when it’s done.
Will you be adding players from this year’s draft class as well?
Feels like Hoy Jun Park sorta came out of nowhere. He wasn’t highly touted as a prospect (the Yankee prospect list has his ceiling as “bench guy”) and yet due to his improvements but also circumstance, it seems like a callup (or trade) for him is imminent.
How much of this is just luck and how much is development over the past year without eyes on him? Maybe he figured something out in quarantine?